Ethics Instruction in Engineering Education: A (Mini) Meta-Analysis
David R. Haws,
David R. Haws
Department of Civil Engineering Boise State University
Search for more papers by this authorDavid R. Haws,
David R. Haws
Department of Civil Engineering Boise State University
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
What are the objectives of engineering ethics? How is it being taught and how might instruction be more effective? The American Society for Engineering Education (ASEE) annual conference proceedings (1996–1999) contain 42 papers that treat engineering ethics as a coherent educational objective. Some of these papers disclose small components that seem to be part of a larger ethics curriculum. Other papers discuss engineering courses that are clearly the department's major ethics commitment. While it would be inappropriate to assume that the 42 papers represent the only means by which engineering students receive ethics instruction, these papers do present a variety of more-or-less defensible approaches and certainly the major intentional approaches of engineering curricula. This paper will develop an analysis of the 42 articles, including a discussion of where ethics is being taught (from both a chronological, and disciplinary perspective), and the six pedagogical approaches used to transfer an understanding of ethics to the student. These approaches include professional codes, humanist readings, theoretical grounding, ethical heuristics, case studies, and service learning. These six approaches will also be analyzed in terms of their promise to develop the ethical competencies needed by engineers.
References
- 1 Chin, S.H., M. Reed, and A. Hassler, “An Outreach Effort: The Connection Program,” Proceedings, 1996, ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 2 Hesketh, R., et al., “Outreach and Recruitment to Attract Students to Chemical Engineering: Fermenting Students' Interest in Engineering,” Proceedings, 1999 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1999.
- 3 Vodrazaka, W.C., “A Course on Professional Engineering Practice,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 4 Stenger, J.B., and K.E. Schmahl, “Miami University's Alumni Teaching Scholars Program: A Model of a Teaching Enhancement Program,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 5 Baker, M., “Reengineering Ph.D. Programs,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 6 Baker, M., “Redirecting Engineering Ph.D. Programs to Meet Job Demands,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 7 Case, E.D., “Integrating Professional Ethics into Technical Courses in Material Science,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 8 Raman, D.R., and R.E. Yoder, “Relevant Design Experiences for Agricultural and Biosystems Engineers: Team Focus through Competition,” Proceedings, 1997 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1997.
- 9 Reising, J.A., “Senior Design Project Course Sequence: Electrical and Computer Engineering,” Proceedings, 1997 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1997.
- 10 Whiting, W.B., et al., “Fitting the Essentials into the ChE Curriculum: Ethics, Professionalism, Environmental Health and Safety,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 11 Tooley, M.S., and K.D. Hall, “Using a Capstone Design Course to Facilitate ABET 2000 Program Outcomes,” Proceedings, 1999 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1999.
- 12 Vader, D., C.A. Erikson, and J.W. Eby, “Cross-cultural Service Learning for Responsible Engineering Graduates,” Proceedings, 1999 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1999.
- 13 Krishnamurthi, M., “Integrating Ethics into Modeling Courses in Engineering,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 14 Lau, A.S., “Design for Society: An Innovative Multidisciplinary Course for Engineering Technology,” Proceedings, 1997 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1997.
- 15 Crofton, F.S., and C.A. Mitchell, “Role Models and Environmental Education: The Good, the Bad, and the MIA,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 16 Soudek, I.H., “Teaching Ethics to Undergraduate Engineering Students: Understanding Professional Responsibility Through Examples,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 17 Soudek, I.H., “Turning Belief into Action: Aims of Teaching Engineering Ethics,” Proceedings, 1999 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1999.
- 18 Neeley, K.A., “The Engineer in the Museum,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 19 Herkert, J.R., “A Multidisciplinary Course on Technological Catastrophes,” Proceedings, 1997 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1977.
- 20 Atkinson, D., “Getting Professionally Cool with Hot Media,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 21 Brown, A., and D.F. Ollis, “Team Teaching: A Freshman Engineering Rhetoric and Laboratory,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 22 Pfaffenberger, B., et al., “Teaching Professional Development in the First-year Writing Course,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 23 Rubino, F.J., “Project Based Freshman Introduction to Engineering Technology Course,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 24 Yokomoto, C.F., and R. Ware, “Using Small Groups to Promote Active Learning and Student Satisfaction in a Required Engineering Ethics Course,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 25 Alford, E., and T. Ward, “Integrating Ethics into the Freshman Curriculum: An Interdisciplinary Approach,” Proceedings, 1999 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1999.
- 26 Alenskis, B.A., “Integrating Ethics into an Engineering Technology Course: An Interspersed Component Approach,” Proceedings, 1997 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1997.
- 27 Bordman, S., and I. Hasan, “An Integrated Model for Management and Economics Instruction for Engineers,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 28 Soudek, I.H., “Teaching Gender Issues to Undergraduate Engineering Students,” Proceedings, 1997 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1997.
- 29 Leydens, J.A., “To Not Lose Them at the Beginning: Nature and Human Values as a Writing-intensive Course,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 30 Tsang, E., C.D. Martin, and R. Decker, “Service Learning as a Strategy for Engineering Education for the 21st Century,” Proceedings, 1997 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1997.
- 31 Clemence, S.P., and D. J. McGinley, “Issues in Professional Practice and Their Implementation in Engineering Curricula,” Proceedings, 1997 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1997.
- 32 Kohlberg, L., “Moral Stages and Moralization: The Cognitive Developmental Approach,” in T. Lickona, ed., Moral Development and Behavior: Theory, Research and Social Issues, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York, 1976.
- 33 da Brito, Rocha C., and M.M.C.T. Rocha da Brito, “The Forming Humanistic in Engineering Education,” Proceedings, 1999 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1999.
- 34 Wiedenhoeft, R.V., “Historic Background for CSM's Nature and Human Values,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 35 Gorman, M.E., and M.N. Mehalik, “Putting Environmental Ethics at the Center of Design: A Case-study Approach,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 36 Russell, E.P., and J.M. Stocker, “Hands-on Ethics: Experiences with Cases in the Classroom,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 37 Dyrud, M.A., “Ethics Education for the Third Millennium,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 38 Arnaldo, S.G., “Teaching Moral Reasoning Skills within Standard Civil Engineering Courses,” Proceedings, 1999 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1999.
- 39 Martin, M.W., and R. Schinzinger, Ethics in Engineering, 3rd Edition, The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., New York, 1996, p. 58.
- 40 Rawls, J., John Rawls: Collected Papers, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1999, p. 366.
- 41 Baier, A., Moral Prejudices: Essays on Ethics, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1995, p. 114.
- 42 Arora, V.K., “Integration of Liberal Arts, Management, and Technical Skills for Professional Development,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 43
Gilligan, C., In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women's Development, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1993.
10.4159/9780674037618 Google Scholar
- 44 Rabins, M.J., C.E. Harris, and J.E. Hanzlik, “An NSF/Bovay Endowment Supported Workshop to Develop Numerical Problems Associated with Ethics Cases for Use in Required Undergraduate Engineering Courses,” Proceedings, 1996 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1996.
- 45 Gorman, M.E., “Ethics, Invention and Design: Creating Cross-disciplinary Collaboration,” Proceedings, 1998 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1998.
- 46 Freckleton, J.E., “Case Studies in Engineering Ethics,” Proceedings, 1997 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1997.
- 47 Gorman, M.E., J.M. Stocker, and M.M. Mehalik, “Using Detailed, Multimedia Cases to Teach Engineering Ethics,” Proceedings, 1997 ASEE Annual Conference, ASEE, (CD), 1997.
- 48 Aristotle, The Nicomachean Ethics, Translated by J.E.C. Welldon, Amherst, New York: Prometheus Books, 1987, p. 12.
