Air Transport Liberalization and Its Impacts on Airline Competition and Air Passenger Traffic
Xiaowen Fu
Search for more papers by this authorTae Hoon Oum
Search for more papers by this authorAnming Zhang
Search for more papers by this authorXiaowen Fu
Search for more papers by this authorTae Hoon Oum
Search for more papers by this authorAnming Zhang
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
This study examines the impacts of air transport liberalization policies on economic growth, traffic volume, and traffic flow patterns, and investigates the mechanisms leading to those changes. Our investigation concludes that (1) liberalization has led to substantial economic and traffic growth. Such positive effects are mainly due to increased competition and efficiency gains in the airline industry, as well as positive externalities to the overall economy; (2) liberalization allows airlines to optimize their networks within and across continental markets. As a result, traffic flow patterns will change accordingly. Strategic alliance is a second-best solution and will have a reduced role when foreign ownership restrictions are relaxed; (3) there is a two-way relationship between the expansion of low-cost carriers (LCCs) and liberalization. The rapid growth of LCCs leads to increased competition and stimulated traffic, calling for the removal of restrictions on capacity, frequency, pricing and entry. In addition, development of LCCs in domestic markets can promote liberalization policy for international aviation by increasing the competitiveness of the national aviation industry. On the other hand, the existing regulations hindered the growth of LCCs. Further liberalization is needed for the full realization of associated benefits.
References
- Airbus (2007), Global Market Forecast, 2007-2026.
- AirNeth (2005), “Strategies of Multi-Hub Airlines and the Implications for National Aviation Policies,” AirNeth Workshop Report, 2005.
- Aizenman, J. (2004), “Endogneous Pricing to Market and Financing Cost,” Journal of Monetary Economics, 51(4), pp. 691-712.
- Asia Times (2008), “Prying Open ASEAN' s Skies,” Asia Times, July 6.
- Air Transport Research Society (2005), The ATRS Airport Performance Benchmarking Report: Global Standards for Airport Excellence, Report, Vancouver, British Columbia: the Centre for Transportation Studies, University of British Columbia, www.atrsworld.org.
- Berechman, J., and O. Shy (1998), “The Structure of Airline Equilibrium Networks,” Recent Advances in Spatial Equilibrium Modeling, edited by J.C.J.M. Bergh, P. Nijkamp and P. Rietveld. Springer, Berlin.
- Berry, S. (1992), “Estimation of a Model of Entry in the Airline Industry,” Econometrica, 60(4), pp. 889-917.
- Bittlingmayer, G. (1990), “Efficiency and Entry in a Simple Airline Network,” International Journal of Industrial Organization, 8, pp. 245-57.
- Boeing Commercial Aircrafts (2008), Review of Boeing Commercial Airplanes Long-term Airplane Market Forecast Methodology and Airlines' Underlying Requirement for Economic Profits, public distribution version.
- Borenstein, S. (1989), “Hubs and High Fares: Dominance and Market Power in the U.S. Airline Industry,” RAND Journal of Economics, 20, pp. 344-365.
- Borenstein, S. and N.L. Rose (2007), “How Airline Markets Work… or Do They? Regulatory Reform in the Airline Industry,” NBER Working Paper 13452.
10.3386/w13452 Google Scholar
- Brueckner, J. K. and P.T. Spiller (1991), “Competition and Mergers in Airline Networks,” International Journal of Industrial Organization, 9, pp. 323-342.
- Brueckner, J. K. and P.T. Spiller (1994), “Economies of Traffic Density in the Deregulated Airline Industry,” Journal of Law and Economics, 37, pp. 379-415.
- Brueckner, J. K., N.J. Dyer, and P.T. Spiller (1992), “Fare Determination in Airline Hub-and-Spoke Networks,” Rand Journal of Economics, 23, pp. 309-333.
- Brueckner, J.K. and W.T. Whelen (2000), “The Price Effect of International Airline Alliances,” Journal of Law and Economics, 43, pp. 503-545.
- Brueckner, J. K. and Y. Zhang (2001), “A Model of Scheduling in Airline Networks: How a Hub-and-Spoke System Affects Flight Frequency, Fares and Welfare,” Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 35, pp. 195-222.
- Brueckner, J.K. (2004), “Network Structure and Airline Scheduling,” Journal of Industrial Economics, LII, pp. 291-312.
10.1111/j.0022-1821.2004.00227.x Google Scholar
- Button, K. (1998), “Opening U.S. Skies to Global Airline Competition, Trade Policy Analysis,” Trade Policy Analysis, November 24.
- Button, K., S. Lall, R. Stough, and M. Trice (1999), “High Technology Employment and Hub Airports,” Journal of Air Transport Management, 5, pp. 53-59.
10.1016/S0969-6997(98)00038-6 Google Scholar
- Button, K. (2006), “Airports and International Economic Integration,” ECMT-OECD working paper, presented at the 1 7th International Symposium on Theory and Practice in Transport Economics and Policy, Berlin, October 25-27, 2006.
- Caves, R. (1962), Air Transport and Its Regulators: An Industry Study, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
- Caves, D. W., L. R. Christensen, and M. W. Tretheway (1984), “Economies of Density versus Economies of Scale: Why Trunk and Local Service Costs Differ,” Rand Journal of Economics, 15, pp. 471^89.
- Clougherty, J.A. (2002), “U.S. Domestic Airline Mergers: The Neglected International Determinants,” International Journal of Industrial Organization, 20, pp. 557-576.
- Clougherty, J.A. (2006), “The International Drivers of Domestic Airline Mergers in Twenty Nations: Integrating Industrial Organization and International Business,” Managerial and Decision Economics, 27, pp. 75-93.
10.1002/mde.1248 Google Scholar
- Clougherty, J.A. and A. Zhang (2009), “Domestic Rivalry and Export Performance: Theory and Evidence from International Airline Markets,” Canadian Journal of Economics, 42(2), pp. 440-468.
- Datamonitor (2005), “Express Logistics in the Netherlands: Industry Profile,” Reference Code: 0176- 2331. www.datamonitor.com.
- Djankov, S., E. Miguel, Y. Qian, G. Roland, and E. Zhuravskaya (2005), “Who Are Russia's Entrepreneurs?” Journal of European Economic Association, 3(2-3), pp. 587-597.
- Dobruszkes, F. (2009), “Does Liberalization of Air Transport Imply Increasing Competition? Lessons from the European Case,” Transport Policy, 16, pp. 29-39.
- Douglas, G.W., and J.C. Miller (1974), “Quality Competition, Industry Equilibrium and Efficiency in the Price Constrained Airline Market,” American Economic Review, 64, pp. 657-669.
- Dresner, M., J. Lin, and R. Windle (1996), “The Impact of Low-Cost Carriers on Airport and Route Competition,” Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 30, pp. 309-328.
- Fethi, M.D., P.M. Jackson, and T.G. Wayman-Jones (2000), “Measuring Efficiency of European Airlines: An Application of DEA and Tobit Analysis,” discussion paper, Efficiency and Productivity Research Unit, University of Leicester, UK.
- Franke, M. (2004), “Competition between Network Carriers -Retreat Battle or Breakthrough to a New Level of Efficiency?” Journal of Air Transport Management, 10, pp. 15-21.
- General Accounting Office (1989), Barriers to Competition in the Airline Industry.
- General Accounting Office (1990), Airline Competition: Industry Operating and Marketing Practices Limit Market Entry.
- Government Accountability Office (2006), “Airline Deregulation,” GAO-06-630, June.
- Government Accountability Office (2008), “Airline Industry: Potential Mergers and Acquisitions Driven by Financial and Competitive Pressures,” GAO-08-845, July 31.
- Harrigan, J. (2005) “Airplanes and Comparative Advantage,” NBER Working Paper No. 11688.
- Hausman, W.H., L.L. Lee, and U. Subramanian (2005), “Global Logistics Services, Supply Chain Metrics and Bilateral Trade Patterns,” Mimeograph, World Bank, October.
10.1596/1813-9450-3773 Google Scholar
- Hendricks, K., M. Piccione, and G. Tan (1995) “The Economics of Hubs: The Case of Monopoly,” Review of Economic Studies, 62, pp. 83-99.
- Hendricks K., M. Piccione, and G. Tan (1997), “Entry and Exit in Hub-spoke Networks,” Rand Journal of Economics, 28, pp. 291-303.
- Hendricks, K., M. Piccione, and G. Tan (1999), “Equilibria in Networks,” Econometrica, 67, pp. 1407-1434.
- Hummels, D. (2006), “Global Trends in Trade and Transportation,” ECMT-OECD Paper, presented in the 17th International Symposium on Theory and Practice in Transport Economics and Policy, Berlin, October, 25-27 2006.
- ICAO (2007), Outlook for Air Transport to the Year 2025, International Civil Aviation Organization, Montreal.
- ICAO Secretariat (2007), Overview of Trends and Developments in International Air Transport, http://www.icao.int/icao/en/atb/epm/Ecp/OverviewTrends.pdf.
- Intervistas (2006), The Economic Impact of Air Service Liberalisation. http://www.intervistas.eom/4/reports/2006-06-07_EconomicImpactOfAirServiceLiberalization_FinalReport.pdf.
- Irwin, M. D. and J.D. Kasarda (1991), “Air Passenger Linkages and Employment Growth among U.S. Metropolitan Areas,” American Sociological Review, 56(4), pp. 524-537.
- Jordan, W. A. (1970), Airline Regulation in America: Effects and Imperfections, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press.
- Keeler, T. E. (1972), “Airline Regulation and Market Performance,” Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science, 3, pp. 399-424.
- Lee, D. and M.J. Prado (2005), “The Impact of Passenger Mix on Reported “Hub Premiums” in the U.S. Airline Industry,” Southern Economic Journal, 72, pp. 372-396.
- Levine, M. E. (1965), “Is Regulation Necessary? California Air Transportation and National Regulatory Policy,” The Yale Law Journal, 74, pp. 1416-1447.
- Levine, M. E. (1987), “Airline Competition in Deregulated Markets: Theory, Firm Strategies and Public Policy,” Yale Journal on Regulation, 4, pp. 283-344.
- Lijesen M., P. Rietveld, and P. Nijkamp (2001), “Hub Premiums in European Civil Aviation,” Transport Policy, 8(3), pp. 193-199.
10.1016/S0967-070X(01)00013-0 Google Scholar
- Limao, and Venables (2001), “Infrastructure, Geographical Disadvantage, Transport Costs, and Trade,” The World Bank Economic Review, 15(3), pp. 451-479.
- Maillebiau, E., and M. Hansen (1995), “Demand and Consumer Welfare Impacts of International Airline Liberalization: the Case of the North Atlantic,” Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 29 (2), pp. 115-136.
- Morrison, S. A. and C. Winston (1986), “Empirical Implications and Tests of the Contestability Hypotheses,” Journal of Law and Economics, 30, pp. 53-66.
- Morrison, S. A. and C. Winston (1995), The Evolution of the Airline Industry, Washington, DC, The Brookings Institution.
- Morrison, S. A. (2001), “Actual, Adjacent, and Potential Competition: Estimating the Full Effect of Southwest Airlines,” Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 35, pp. 239-256.
- Murakami, H. (2007), “ An Empirical Analysis of Inter- Firm Rivalry between Japanese LCC and Legacy Carriers and its Welfare Effects,” paper presented at the 2007 ATRS Conference, Berkeley, June 2007.
- Oum, T.H., and M.W. Tretheway (1990), “Airline Hub and Spoke System,” Journal of Transportation Research Forum, 30, pp. 380-393.
- Oum, T.H., A.J. Taylor, and A. Zhang (1993), “Strategic Airline Policy in the Globalizing Airline Networks,” Transportation Journal, 32(3), pp. 14-30.
- Oum, T.H., A. Zhang, and Y. Zhang (1995), “Airline Network Rivalry,” Canadian Journal of Economics, 28, pp. 836-857.
10.2307/135934 Google Scholar
- Oum, T.H. and C. Yu (1998), Winning Airlines: Productivity and Cost Competitiveness of the World's Major Airlines, New York, London: Kluwer Academic Press. http://www.wkap.nl/prodto/0-7923-8010-X.
10.1007/978-1-4615-5481-3 Google Scholar
- Oum, T.H., J.H. Park, and A. Zhang (2000), Globalization and Strategic Alliances: The Case of the Airline Industry, Elsevier Science, http://www.elsevier.nl.
- Oum, T.H, X. Fu, and C. Yu (2005), “New Evidences on Airline Efficiency and Yields: A Comparative Analysis of Major North American Air Carriers and Its Implications, “ Transport Policy, 1 2, pp. 153-164.
10.1016/j.tranpol.2005.01.002 Google Scholar
- Oum, T.H. and J.H. Park (2004), “Multinational Firms' Location Preference for Regional Distribution Centers: Focus on the Northeast Asian Region,” Transportation Research E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 40, pp. 101-121.
- Piermartini, R. and L. Rousova (2008), “Liberalization of Air Transport Services and Passenger Traffic,” Staff Working Paper ERSD-2008-06, World Trade Organization, Economic Research and Statistics Division.
- Richards, K. (1996), “The Effect of Southwest Airlines on U.S. Airline Markets,” Research in Transportation Economics, 4, pp. 33-47.
10.1016/S0739-8859(96)80004-7 Google Scholar
- Schaur, G. (2006), “Airplanes and Price Volatility,” Mimeograph, Purdue University.
- Spiller, P. T. (1989), “Pricing of Hub-and-Spoke Networks,” Economics Letters, 30, pp. 165-169.
- Swan, W. (2007), “Misunderstandings about Airline Growth,” Journal of Air Transport Management, 13, pp. 3-8.
- The Straits Times (2008), “Tiger Airways Korea Venture Off,” December 31, Singapore.
- Transportation Research Board, National Research Council (1999), Entry and Competition in the U.S. Airline Industry: Issues and Opportunities, Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
- Tretheway, M. W. and I.S. Kincaid (2005), “The Effect of Market Structure on Airline Prices: A Review of Empirical Results,” Journal of Air Law and Commerce, 70, pp. 467-498.
- U.S. Department of Transportation (2001), “Dominated Hub Fares,” Domestic Aviation Competition Series.
- U.S. Department of Transportation (1993), The Airline Deregulation Evolution Continues: The Southwest Effect, Office of Aviation Analysis, U.S. Department of Transportation.
- Warren, T. and C. Findlay (1998), “Competition Policy and International Trade in Air Transport and Telecommunications Services,” World Economy, 21, pp. 445-456.
- Windle, R. and M. Dresner (1995), “The Short and Long Run Effects of Entry on U.S. Domestic Air routes,” Transportation Journal, 35, pp. 14-25.
- World Trade Organisation (2006), “Second Review of the Air Transport Annex: Developments in the Air Transport Sector (Part Two) Quantitative Air Services Agreements Review (QUASAR),” Volumes I and II Note by the Secretariat, document S/C/W/270/Add. 1.
- Zhang, A. and X. Wei (1993), “Competition in Airline Networks: The Case of Constant Elasticity Demands,” Economics Letters, 42, pp. 253-259.
- Zhang, A. (1996), “An Analysis of Fortress Hubs in Airline Networks,” Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 30, pp. 293-308.
- Zhang, A., S. Hanaoka, H. Inamura, and T. Ishikura (2008), “Low Cost Carriers in Asia: Deregulation, Regional Liberalization and Secondary Airports,” Research in Transport Economics, 24(1), pp. 36-50.