The Upside of Loss Aversion: Evidence From Financial Reporting Loss Avoidance
Corresponding Author
Michael Neel
G. Brint Ryan College of Business, University of North Texas, Denton, Texas, USA
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Michael Neel
G. Brint Ryan College of Business, University of North Texas, Denton, Texas, USA
Search for more papers by this authorFunding: The author received no specific funding for this work.
ABSTRACT
This study provides evidence that managerial loss avoidance is one cause of the zero-earnings discontinuity and that investor loss aversion is a plausible explanation for diversity in the appearance of that discontinuity. de la Rosa and Lambertsen in 2022 theoretically show that when investors are loss averse, the earnings discontinuities proposed by Guttman et al. in 2006 emerge at investor reference points and are an increasing function of loss aversion. In this study, I test these propositions using a sample drawn from 49 countries in which cross-country differences in loss aversion are measurable. Net income distributions exhibit significant discontinuity at zero earnings only among countries ranked high in loss aversion. Multivariate analysis corroborates that the firm-level likelihood of loss avoidance is also an increasing function of loss aversion. Consistent with loss aversion plausibly impacting loss avoidance through a pricing effect, the market penalty for missing the zero-earnings threshold is also an increasing function of loss aversion. Additional analyses test competing theories on whether managers’ loss aversion facilitates loss avoidance through stronger performance or opportunistic reporting. These results suggest that performance (opportunistic reporting) plays a more extensive role in loss avoidance in more loss-averse (less loss-averse) countries.
Conflicts of Interest
The author declares no conflicts of interest.
Open Research
Data Availability Statement
The data that support the findings of this study are openly available from public sources.
Supporting Information
Filename | Description |
---|---|
jbfa12880-sup-0001-SuppMat.docx37.7 KB | Table OA1: Individual Loss Aversion Measures and the Likelihood of Reporting Small Positive Earnings Table OA2: Additional Robustness Tests Table OA3: Prior Year Net Income as the Loss Threshold |
Please note: The publisher is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.
References
- Abeler, J., A. Falk, L. Goette, and D. Huffman. 2011. “Reference Points and Effort Provision.” American Economic Review 101: 470–492.
- Ahmed, A., M. Neel, and D. Wang. 2013. “Does Mandatory Adoption of IFRS Improve Accounting Quality? Preliminary Evidence.” Contemporary Accounting Research 30, no. 4: 1344–1372.
- Allen, E., C. Larson, and R. Sloan. 2013. “Accrual Reversals, Earnings and Stock Returns.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 56: 113–129.
- Armantier, O., and A. Boly. 2015. “Framing of Incentives and Effort Provision.” International Economic Review 56: 917–938.
- Athanasakou, V., N. C. Strong, and M. Walker. 2011. “The Market Reward for Achieving Analyst Earnings Expectations: Does Managing Expectations or Earnings Matter?” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 38: 58–94.
- Ayers, B., J. Jiang, and P. E. Yeung. 2006. “Discretionary Accruals and Earnings Management: An Analysis of Pseudo Earnings Targets.” Accounting Review 81: 617–652.
- Ball, R., and P. Brown. 1968. “An Empirical Evaluation of Accounting Income Numbers.” Journal of Accounting Research 6: 159–178.
- Barth, M., W. Landsman, and M. Lang. 2008. “International Accounting Standards and Accounting Quality.” Journal of Accounting Research 46, no. 3: 467–498.
- Bartov, E., D. Givoly, and C. Hayn. 2002. “The Rewards to Meeting or Beating Earnings Expectations.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 33: 173–204.
- Beatty, A., B. Ke, and K. Petroni. 2002. “Earnings Management to Avoid Earnings Declines Across Publicly and Privately Held Banks.” Accounting Review 77: 547–570.
- Beaver, W. 1968. “The Information Content of Annual Earnings Announcements.” Journal of Accounting Research 6: 67–92.
- Beaver, W., R. Clarke, and W. Wright. 1979. “The Association Between Unsystematic Security Returns and the Magnitude of Earnings Forecast Errors.” Journal of Accounting Research 17: 316–340.
- Beaver, W., M. McNichols, and K. Nelson. 2007. “An Alternative Interpretation of the Discontinuity in Earnings Distributions.” Review of Accounting Studies 12: 525–556.
- Bjornsen, M., C. Do, and T. Omer. 2019. “The Influence of Country-Level Religiosity on Accounting Conservatism.” Journal of International Accounting Research 18: 1–26.
10.2308/jiar-52270 Google Scholar
- Brown, L., and M. Caylor. 2005. “A Temporal Analysis of Quarterly Earnings Thresholds: Propensities and Valuation Consequences.” Accounting Review 80: 423–440.
- Burgstahler, D. 2014. “Discussion of “the shapes of scaled earnings histograms are not due to scaling and sample selection: Evidence from distributions of reported earnings per share”.” Contemporary Accounting Research 31, no. 2: 522–530.
- Burgstahler, D., and E. Chuk. 2015. “Do scaling and selection explain earnings discontinuities?.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 60, no. 1: 168–186.
- Burgstahler, D., and E. Chuk. 2017. “What Have We Learned About Earnings Management? Integrating Discontinuity Evidence.” Contemporary Accounting Research 34: 726–749.
- Burgstahler, D., and I. Dichev. 1997. “Earnings Management to Avoid Reporting Earnings Decreases and Losses.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 24: 99–126.
10.1016/S0165-4101(97)00017-7 Google Scholar
- Burgstahler, D., and M. Eames. 2006. “Management of Earnings and Analysts' Forecasts to Achieve Zero and Small Positive Earnings Surprises.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 33: 633–652.
- Byun, S., and K. C. Roland. 2022. “Quarterly Earnings Thresholds: Making the Case for Prior Quarter Earnings.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 49: 690–716.
- Cannito, L., R. Palumbo, and P. Sacco. 2023. “Measure for Measure: Effects of Money Exposure, Reward Size and Loss Aversion on Cheating.” Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 4: 100110.
- Cedergren, M., and V. Li. 2023. “Round Number Reference Points and Irregular Patterns in Reported Gross Margin.” Review of Accounting Studies 29: 3293–3327.
10.1007/s11142-023-09780-x Google Scholar
- Cerdin, J.-L., M. A. Diné, and C. Brewster. 2014. “Qualified Immigrants' Success: Exploring the Motivation to Migrate and to Integrate.” Journal of International Business Studies 45: 151–168.
- Chartrand, T., and R. van Baaren. 2009. “Chapter 5 Human Mimicry.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 41: 219–274.
- Chen, H., H. Huang, G. Lobo, and C. Wang. 2016. “Religiosity and the Cost of Debt.” Journal of Banking and Finance 70: 70–85.
- Cheng, C., and T. Chartrand. 2003. “Self-Monitoring Without Awareness: Using Mimicry as a Nonconscious Affiliation Strategy.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 85: 1170–1179.
- Daske, R., G. Gebhardt, and S. McLeay. 2006. “The Distribution of Earnings Relative to Targets in the European Union.” Accounting and Business Research 36: 137–167.
10.1080/00014788.2006.9730019 Google Scholar
- Dechow, P., S. Richardson, and I. Tuna. 2003. “Why Are Earnings Kinky? An Examination of the Earnings Management Explanation.” Review of Accounting Studies 8: 355–384.
- Dechow, P., R. Sloan, and A. Sweeney. 1995. “Detecting Earnings Management.” Accounting Review 70: 193–225.
- de Dreu, C. K. W., P. J. D. Carnevale, B. J. M. Emans, and E. van de Vliert. 1994. “Effects of Gain-Loss Frames in Negotiation: Loss Aversion, Mismatching, and Frame Adoption.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 60: 90–107.
- Degeorge, F., J. Patel, and R. Zeckhauser. 1999. “Earnings Management to Exceed Thresholds.” Journal of Business 72: 1–33.
- Degiannakis, S., G. Giannopoulos, S. Ibrahim, and B N. Jørgensen. 2023. “An Alternative Approach to Detect Earnings Management to Meet or Beat Benchmarks.” Journal of Accounting Literature 45: 64–99.
- de La Rosa, L. E., and N. N. Lambertsen. 2022. “Loss Aversion and Financial Reporting: A Possible Explanation for the Prevalence of Discontinuities in Reported Earnings.” Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 41: 106992.
10.1016/j.jaccpubpol.2022.106992 Google Scholar
- Donelson, D., J. McInnis, and R. Mergenthaler. 2013. “Discontinuities and Earnings Management: Evidence From Restatements Related to Securities Litigation.” Contemporary Accounting Research 30: 242–268.
- Durtschi, C., and P. Easton. 2005. “Earnings Management? The Shapes of the Frequency Distributions of Earnings Metrics Are Not Evidence Ipso Facto.” Journal of Accounting Research 43: 557–592.
- Durtschi, C., and P. Easton. 2009. “Earnings Management? Erroneous Inferences Based on Earnings Frequency Distributions.” Journal of Accounting Research 47: 1249–1281.
- Enomoto, M., and T. Yamaguchi. 2017. “Discontinuities in Earnings and Earnings Change Distributions After J-SOX Implementation: Empirical Evidence From Japan.” Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 36: 82–98.
- Ewert, R., and A. Wagenhofer. 2005. “Economic Effects of Tightening Accounting Standards to Restrict Earnings Management.” Accounting Review 80: 1101–1124.
- Fama, E., and K. French. 1997. “Industry Costs of Equity.” Journal of Financial Economics 43: 153–193.
- Farinha, A., and T. Maia. 2021. “People Exert More Effort to Avoid Losses Than to Obtain Gains.” Journal of Experimental Psychology 150: 1837–1853.
10.1037/xge0001021 Google Scholar
- Fischer, P. E., and R. E. Verrecchia. 2000. “Reporting Bias.” Accounting Review 75: 229–245.
- Foellmi, R., A. Jaeggi, and R. Rosenblatt-Wisch. 2019. “Loss Aversion at the Aggregate Level Across Countries and Its Relation to Economic Fundamentals.” Journal of Macroeconomics 61: 103–136.
- Gandelman, N., and R. Hernandez-Murillo. 2015. Risk Aversion at the Country Level. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.
- Garbarino, E., R. Slonim, and M. Villeval. 2019. “Loss Aversion and Lying Behavior.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 158: 379–393.
- Gilliam, T., F. Heflin, and J. Paterson. 2015. “Evidence That the Zero-Earnings Discontinuity Has Disappeared.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 60: 117–132.
- Goldsmith, K., and R. Dhar. 2013. “Negativity Bias and Task Motivation: Testing the Effectiveness of Positively Versus Negatively Framed Incentives.” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied 19: 358–366.
- Grolleau, G., M. Kocher, and A. Sutan. 2016. “Cheating and Loss Aversion: Do People Cheat More to Avoid a Loss?” Management Science 62: 3428–3438.
- Gunny, K., and T. C. Zhang. 2014. “Do Managers Use Meeting Analyst Forecasts to Signal Private Information? Evidence From Patent Citations.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 41: 950–973.
- Guttman, I., O. Kadan, and E. Kandel. 2006. “A Rational Expectations Theory of Kinks in Financial Reporting.” Accounting Review 81: 811–848.
- Haga, J., F. Huhtamäki, and D. Sundvik. 2019. “Long-Term Orientation and Earnings Management Strategies.” Journal of International Accounting Research 18: 97–119.
- Hannan, R., V. Hoffman, and D. Moser. 2005. “ Bonus Versus Penalty: Does Contract Frame Affect Employee Effort.” In Experimental Business Research. Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/0-387-24243-0_8.
10.1007/0-387-24243-0_8 Google Scholar
- Haw, I.-M., D. Qi, D. Wu, and W. Wu. 2005. “Market Consequences of Earnings Management in Response to Security Regulations in China.” Contemporary Accounting Research 22: 95–140.
- Hayn, C. 1995. “The Information Content of Losses.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 20: 125–153.
- Hemmer, T., and E. Labro. 2019. “Management by the Numbers: A Formal Approach to Deriving Informational and Distributional Properties of “Unmanaged” Earnings.” Journal of Accounting Research 57: 5–51.
- Herrmann, D., O.-K. Hope, J. L. Payne, and W. B. Thomas. 2011. “The Market's Reaction to Unexpected Earnings Thresholds.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 38: 34–57.
- Hofstede, G. 2001. Culture's Consequences: Comparing Values, Behaviors, Institutions, and Organizations Across Nations. Sage Publications.
- Holland, D., and A. Ramsay. 2003. “Do Australian Companies Manage Earnings to Meet Simple Earnings Benchmarks?” Accounting and Finance 43: 41–62.
- Hong, F., T. Hossain, and J. List. 2015. “Framing Manipulations in Contests: A Natural Field Experiment.” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 118: 372–382.
- Hossain, T., and J. List. 2012. “The Behavioralist Visits the Factory: Increasing Productivity Using Simple Framing Manipulations.” Management Science 58: 2151–2167.
- Imas, A., S. Sadoff, and A. Samek. 2017. “Do People Anticipate Loss Aversion?” Management Science 63: 1271–1284.
- Jeanjean, T., and H. Stolowy. 2008. “Do Accounting Standards Matter? An Exploratory Analysis of Earnings Management Before and After IFRS Adoption.” Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 27: 480–494.
- Jia, Y. 2013. “Meeting or Missing Earnings Benchmarks: The Role of CEO Integrity.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 40: 373–398.
- Jorgensen, B., Y. Lee, and S. Rock. 2014. “The Shapes of Scaled Earnings Histograms Are Not Due to Scaling and Sample Selection: Evidence From Distributions of Reported Earnings Per Share.” Contemporary Accounting Research 31: 498–521.
- Kahneman, D., and A. Tversky. 1979. “Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision Under Risk.” Econometrica 47: 263–292.
- Kanagaretnam, K., C. Lim, and G. Lobo. 2011. “Effects of National Culture on Earnings Quality of Banks.” Journal of International Business Studies 42: 853–874.
- Kasznik, R., and M. McNichols. 2002. “Does Meeting Earnings Expectations Matter? Evidence From Analyst Forecast Revisions and Share Prices.” Journal of Accounting Research 40: 727–759.
- Leuz, C., D. Nanda, and P. Wysocki. 2003. “Earnings Management and Investor Protection: An International Comparison.” Journal of Financial Economics 69: 505–527.
- Lim, N. 2010. “Social Loss Aversion and Optimal Contest Design.” Journal of Marketing Research 47: 777–787.
- Lopez, T., and L. Rees. 2002. “The Effect of Beating and Missing Analysts' forecasts on the Information Content of Unexpected Earnings.” Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance 17: 155–184.
10.1177/0148558X0201700204 Google Scholar
- Makarem, N., F. Liu, and L. Chen. 2023. “Evidence That Financing Decisions Contribute to the Zero‑Earnings Discontinuity.” Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting 60: 231–257.
- Markiewicz, I., and K. Gawryluk. 2020. “Cheating Among Children: Temptation, Loss Framing, and Previous Cheating.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 33: 151–165.
- McNichols, M. 2002. “The Quality of Accruals and Earnings: The Role of Accrual Estimation Errors: Discussion.” Accounting Review 77: 61–69.
- Nagel, J., K. Patel, E. Rothstein, and L. Watts. 2021. “Unintended Consequences of Performance Incentives: Impacts of Framing and Structure on Performance and Cheating.” Ethics and Behavior 7: 498–515.
10.1080/10508422.2020.1813143 Google Scholar
- Neel, M. 2024. “Country-Level Loss Aversion and the Market Response to Earnings News.” International Journal of Accounting 60, no. 1. https://doi.org/10.1142/S1094406024500215.
10.1142/S1094406024500215 Google Scholar
- Nguyen, V. T., and L. Xu. 2010. “The Impact of Dual Class Structure on Earnings Management Activities.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 37: 456–485.
- Pennings, J., and A. Smidts. 2003. “The Shape of Utility Functions and Organizational Behavior.” Management Science 49: 1121–1273.
- Petrishcheva, V., G. Riener, and H. Schildberg-Hörisch. 2023. “Loss Aversion in Social Image Concerns.” Experimental Economics 26: 622–645.
- Phillips, J., M. Pincus, and S. O. Rego. 2003. “Earnings Management: New Evidence Based on Deferred Tax Expense.” Accounting Review 78: 491–521.
- Pinello, A. 2008. “Investors' differential Reaction to Positive Versus Negative Earnings Surprises.” Contemporary Accounting Research 25: 891–920.
- Rabin, M. 2000. Diminishing Marginal Utility of Wealth Cannot Explain Risk Aversion. University of California, Berkeley. Institute of Business and Economic Research.
10.1017/CBO9780511803475.012 Google Scholar
- Riley, J. G. 1979. “Informational Equilibrium.” Econometrica 47: 331–359.
- Rosokha, Y., and K. Younge. 2020. “Motivating Innovation: The Effect of Loss Aversion on the Willingness to Persist.” Review of Economics and Statistics 102: 569–582.
- Sánchez-Ballesta, J. P., and J. Yagüe. 2021. “Financial Reporting Incentives, Earnings Management, and Tax Avoidance in SMEs.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 48: 1404–1433.
- Schindler, S., and S. Pfattheicher. 2017. “The Frame of the Game: Loss-Framing Increases Dishonest Behavior.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 69: 172–177.
- Shuto, A., and T. Iwasaki. 2015. “The Effect of Institutional Factors on Earnings Discontinuities in Earnings Distributions: Public Versus Private Firms in Japan.” Journal of Accounting, Auditing, and Finance 30: 283–317.
10.1177/0148558X14544504 Google Scholar
- Stein, J. 1989. “Efficient Capital Markets, Inefficient Firms: A Model of Myopic Corporate Behavior.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 104: 655–669.
- Talha, M., M. Mohamad, and A. Sallehhuddin. 2008. “Avoiding Losses and Earnings Decrease by Malaysian Companies Before and After Major Corporate Governance Initiatives.” International Journal of Managerial and Financial Accounting 1: 45–63.
10.1504/IJMFA.2008.020461 Google Scholar
- Trimble, M. 2018. “A Reinvestigation Into Accounting Quality Following Global IFRS Adoption: Evidence via Earnings Distributions.” Journal of International Accounting, Auditing, and Taxation 33: 18–39.
10.1016/j.intaccaudtax.2018.09.001 Google Scholar
- Ullmann, R., and C. Watrin. 2017. “Detecting Target-Driven Earnings Management Based on the Distribution of Digits.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 44: 63–93.
- Wallmeier, M., and P. Chardonnens. 2021. “Kinked Accounting? Loss Avoidance in Europe and (not) the US.” Working paper. (February 8, 2024). Available at SSRN:. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3882901 or. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3882901.
10.2139/ssrn.3882901 Google Scholar
- Wang, M., M. Rieger, and T. Hens. 2017. “The Impact of Culture on Loss Aversion.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 30: 270–281.
- Xie, Y., S. Hwang, and A. Pantelous. 2018. “Loss Aversion Around the World: Empirical Evidence From Pension Funds.” Journal of Banking and Finance 88: 52–62.
- Xu, K., M. Hitt, and S. Miller. 2019. “The Ownership Structure Contingency in the Sequential International Entry Mode Decision Process: Family Owners and Institutional Investors in Family-Dominant Versus Family-Influenced Firms.” Journal of International Business Studies 51: 151–171.
- Xu, W. 2016. “Accruals Management to Avoid Losses.” Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 43: 1095–1120.