Monitoring to Learn, Learning to Monitor: A Critical Analysis of Opportunities for Indigenous Community-Based Monitoring of Environmental Change in Australian Rangelands
Corresponding Author
Nathanael D. Wiseman
Geography, Environment and Population, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, 5005 Australia
Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorDouglas K. Bardsley
Geography, Environment and Population, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, 5005 Australia
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Nathanael D. Wiseman
Geography, Environment and Population, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, 5005 Australia
Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorDouglas K. Bardsley
Geography, Environment and Population, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, 5005 Australia
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Indigenous community-based monitoring has been a central feature in many international attempts to improve monitoring of and local adaptation to environmental change. Despite offering much promise, Indigenous community-based monitoring has been underutilised in natural resource management in Australia, particularly within the remote, semi-arid rangelands. This paper discusses contextual social and environmental factors that may help to explain this apparent deficiency, before critically analysing key stakeholder perceptions of the roles for, and challenges of monitoring in the Alinytjara Wilurara Natural Resources Management region in the north-west of South Australia. The analysis guides a discussion of responses to better integrate monitoring in general, and Indigenous community-based monitoring in particular, into regional environmental management approaches. We argue that community-based monitoring offers a range of benefits, including: better coordination between stakeholders; a heightened ability to detect and respond to climatic trends and impacts; the effective utilisation of Indigenous knowledge; employment opportunities for managing and monitoring natural resources; and improved learning and understanding of rangeland socio-ecological systems. Identified opportunities for spatial and temporal community monitoring designed for the Alinytjara Wilurara region could be of value to other remote rangeland and Indigenous institutions charged with the difficult task of monitoring, learning from, and responding to environmental change.
References
- Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), 2011: Census 2011. Retrieved: 8 January 2014 from <http://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/censushome.nsf/home/data>.
- J.C. Altman and S. Kerins (eds), 2012: People on Country: Vital Landscapes, Indigenous Futures. Federation Press, Sydney.
- Ara Irititja, 2014: Ara Irititja digital archive. Retrieved: 6 February 2014 from <http://www.irititja.com/index.html>.
- Argent, R.M., 2009: Components of adaptive management. In C. Allan and G.H. Stankey (eds) Adaptive Environmental Management: A Practitioner's Guide. Springer Science + Business Media B.V., Dordrecht and CSIRO Publishing, Collingwood, 11–32.
10.1007/978-1-4020-9632-7_2 Google Scholar
- Australian Government, 2014: Indigenous Protected Area webpage. Retrieved: 3 December 2014 from <http://www.environment.gov.au/indigenous/ipa/index.html>.
- AW NRM Board (Alinytjara Wilurara Natural Resources Management Board), 2011: Alinytjara Wilurara Regional NRM Plan. Government of South Australia, Adelaide.
- AW NRM Board (Alinytjara Wilurara Natural Resources Management Board), 2013: Amendments to the Regional Natural Resources Management Plan of the Alinytjara Wilurara, Natural Resources Management Board. Government of South Australia, Adelaide.
- AW NRM Board (Alinytjara Wilurara Natural Resources Management Board), 2014: Dreamweaver: rockhole maintenance. Retrieved: 30 November 2014 from <http://www.naturalresources.sa.gov.au/alinytjara-wilurara/projects/dreamweaver-rockhole>.
- Baland, J. and Platteau, J., 1996: Halting Degradation of Natural Resources: Is there a Role for Rural Communities? Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome.
- Bardsley, D.K., 2015: Navigating the roles of the social learning researcher: a critical analysis of a learning approach to guide climate change adaptation. Australian Geographer 46, 33–50.
- Bardsley, D.K. and Rogers, G.P., 2011: Prioritizing engagement for sustainable adaptation to climate change: an example from natural resource management in South Australia. Society and Natural Resources 24, 1–17.
- Bardsley, D.K., Weber, D., Robinson, G.M., Moskwa, E. and Bardsley, A.M., 2015: Wildfire risk, biodiversity and peri-urban planning in the Mt Lofty Ranges, South Australia. Applied Geography 63, 155–165.
- Bardsley, D.K. and Wiseman, N.D., 2012a: Climate change vulnerability and social development for remote Indigenous communities of South Australia. Global Environmental Change 22, 713–723.
- Bardsley, D.K. and Wiseman, N.D., 2012b: It depends which way the wind blows: an integrated assessment of projected climate change impacts and adaptation options for the Alinytjara Wilurara Natural Resources Management region. AW NRM Board/Government of SA, Government of Australia, Adelaide.
- Bastin, G. and the Australian Collaborative Rangelands Information System Management Committee (ACRIS-MC), 2008: Rangelands 2008 – Taking the Pulse. National Land & Water Resources Audit, Canberra.
- Berkes, F., 2012: Sacred Ecology, third edn. Routledge, New York.
10.4324/9780203123843 Google Scholar
- Berkes, F., 2009: Indigenous ways of knowing and the study of environmental change. Journal of the Royal Society of New Zealand 39, 151–156.
- Berkes, F., Berkes, M.K. and Fast, H., 2007: Collaborative integrated management in Canada's North: the role of local and traditional knowledge and community-based monitoring. Coastal Management 35, 143–162.
- Box, J.B., Duguid, A., Read, R.E., Kimber, R.G., Knapton, A., Davis, J. and Bowland, A.E., 2008: Central Australian waterbodies: the importance of permanence in a desert landscape. Journal of Arid Environments 72, 1395–1413.
- Burgess, C.P., Johnston, F.H., Bowman, D.M.J.S. and Whitehead, P.J., 2005: Healthy country: healthy people? Exploring the health benefits of Indigenous natural resource management. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 29, 117–122.
- Commonwealth of Australia, 2014a: Working on Country. Retrieved: 30 November 2014 from <http://www.environment.gov.au/indigenous/workingoncountry/>.
- Commonwealth of Australia, 2014b: Carbon Farming Initiative Amendment Bill 2014. Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
- Coombes, B., Johnson, J.T. and Howitt, R., 2014: Indigenous geographies III: methodological innovation and the unsettling of participatory research. Progress in Human Geography 38, 845–854.
- COAG (Council of Australian Governments), 2008: National Indigenous Reform Agreement (Closing the Gap). Retrieved: 30 November 2014 from <https://www.coag.gov.au/closing_the_gap_in_Indigenous_disadvantage>.
- CyberTacker, 2014: CyberTracker website. Retrieved: 15 November 2014 from <http://www.cybertracker.org/>.
- Danielsen, F., Burgess, N.D. and Balmford, A., 2005: Monitoring matters: examining the potential of locally-based approaches. Biodiversity and Conservation 14, 2507–2542.
- Danielsen, F., Burgess, N.D., Balmford, A., Donald, P., Jones, J., Alviola, P., Balete, D., Blomley, T., Brashares, J., Child, B., Enghoff, M., Fjelds, J., Holt, S., Hubertz, H., Jensen, A., Jensen, P., Massao, J., Mendoza, M., Ngaga, Y., Poulsen, M., Rueda, R., Sam, M., Skielboe, T., Stuart-Hill, G., Topp-Jorgensen, E. and Yonten, D., 2009: Local participation in natural resource monitoring: a characterization of approaches. Conservation Biology 23, 31–42.
- Danielsen, F., Pirhofer-Walz, K., Adrian, T.P., Kapijimpanga, D.R., Burgess, N.D., Jensen, P.M., Bonney, R., Funder, M., Landa, A., Levermann, N. and Madsen, J., 2014: Linking public participation in scientific research to the indicators and needs of international environmental agreements. Conservation Letters 7, 12–24.
- Davies, J., White, J., Wright, A., Maru, Y. and LaFlamme, M., 2008: Applying the sustainable livelihoods approach in Australian desert Aboriginal development. The Rangeland Journal 30, 55–65.
- Davies, J., Hill, R., Walsh, F.J., Sandford, M., Smyth, D. and Holmes, M.C., 2013: Innovation in management plans for community conserved areas: experiences from Australian Indigenous protected areas. Ecology and Society 18, 14.
- Ens, E.J., 2012: Monitoring outcomes of environmental service provision in low socio-economic Indigenous Australia using innovative CyberTracker Technology. Conservation and Society 10, 42–52.
10.4103/0972-4923.92194 Google Scholar
- Ens, E.J., Finlayson, M., Preuss, K., Jackson, S. and Holcombe, S., 2012a: Australian approaches for managing ‘country’ using Indigenous and non-Indigenous knowledge. Ecological Management & Restoration 13, 100–107.
10.1111/j.1442-8903.2011.00634.x Google Scholar
- Ens, E.J., Towler, G.M., Daniels, C. and
the Yugul Mangi Rangers and the Manwurrk Rangers, 2012b: Looking back to move forward: collaborative ecological monitoring in remote Arnhem Land. Ecological Management & Restoration 13, 26–35.
10.1111/j.1442-8903.2011.00627.x Google Scholar
- EPA (Environmental Protection Authority), 2013: State of the Environment South Australia 2013. Government of South Australia, Adelaide.
- Eyre, T.J., Fisher, A., Hunt, L.P. and Kutt, A.S., 2011: Measure it to better manage it: a biodiversity monitoring framework for the Australian rangelands. The Rangeland Journal 33, 239–253.
- Gearheard, S., Aporta, C., Aipellee, G. and O'Keefe, K., 2011: The Igliniit project: inuit hunters document life on the trail to map and monitor arctic change. The Canadian Geographer 55, 42–55.
- Goddard, C., 2006: Pitjatjantjara/Yakunytjatjara to English dictionary. Institute for Aboriginal Development Press, Alice Springs, NT.
- Gómez-Baggethun, E., Corbera, E. and Reyes-García, V., 2013: Traditional ecological knowledge and global environmental change: research findings and policy implications. Ecology and Society 18, 72.
- Gorman, J. and Vemuri, S., 2012: Social implications of bridging the gap through ‘caring for country’ in remote Indigenous communities of the Northern Territory, Australia. The Rangeland Journal 34, 63–73.
- Gorman, J., Person, D. and Whitehead, P., 2008: Assisting Australian Indigenous resource management and sustainable utilization of species through the use of GIS and environmental modeling techniques. Journal of Environmental Management 86, 104–113.
- Graham, B., Ashworth, G.J. and Tunbridge, J.E., 2000: A Geography of Heritage: Power, Culture and Economy. Arnold, London.
- Green, D. and Minchin, L., 2014: Living on climate-changed country: indigenous health, well-being and climate change in remote Australian communities. Ecohealth Jan 2014.
- Green, D., Niall, S. and Morrison, J., 2012: Bridging the gap between theory and practice in climate change vulnerability assessments for remote Indigenous communities in northern Australia. Local Environment 17, 295–315.
10.1080/13549839.2012.665857 Google Scholar
- Harmsworth, G.R., Young, R.G., Walker, D., Clapcott, J.E. and James, T., 2011: Linkages between cultural and scientific indicators of river and stream health. New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 45, 423–436.
- HORSCATSIA (House of Representatives Standing Committee on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs), 2004: Many Ways Forward: Report of the Inquiry into Capacity Building and Service Delivery in Indigenous Communities. Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
- Hughey, K.F.D. and Booth, K.L., 2012: Monitoring the state of New Zealand rivers: how the River Values Assessment System can help. New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 46, 545–556.
- Jollands, N. and Harmsworth, G., 2007: Participation of Indigenous groups in sustainable development monitoring: rationale and examples from New Zealand. Ecological Economics 62, 716–726.
- Lawley, E.F., Lewis, M.M. and Ostendorf, B., 2014: Evaluating MODIS soil fractional cover for arid regions, using albedo from high-spatial resolution satellite imagery. International Journal of Remote Sensing 35, 2028–2046.
- Leonard, S., Parsons, M., Olawsky, K. and Kofod, F., 2013: The role of culture and traditional knowledge in climate change adaptation: insights from East Kimberley, Australia. Global Environmental Change 23, 623–632.
- Ludwig, J.A. and Tongway, D.J., 1996: Rehabilitation of Semiarid Landscapes in Australia. II. Restoring vegetation patches. Restoration Ecology 4, 398–406.
- Ludwig, J.A. and Tongway, D.J., 1997: A landscape approach to rangeland ecology. Chapter 1. In J. Ludwig, D. Tongway, D. Freudenberger, J. Noble and K. Hodgkinson (eds) Landscape Ecology, Function and Management: Principles from Australia's Rangelands. CSIRO Publishing, Melbourne, 1–12.
- Lynam, T.J.P. and Stafford Smith, M., 2004: Monitoring in a complex world – seeking slow variables, a scaled focus, and speedier learning. African Journal of Range & Forage Science 21, 69–78.
10.2989/10220110409485837 Google Scholar
- Maffi, L. and Woodley, E., 2012: Biocultural Diversity Conservation: A Global Sourcebook. Routledge, London.
10.4324/9781849774697 Google Scholar
- Maru, Y.T., Chewings, V. and Sparrow, A., 2012: Climate change adaptation, energy futures and carbon economies in remote Australia: a review of the current literature, research and policy. CRC-REP Working Paper CW005. Ninti One Limited, Alice Springs.
- Masters, P., Dickman, C.R. and Crowther, M., 2003: Effects of cover reduction on mulgara Dasycercus cristicauda (Marsupialia: Dasyuridae), rodent and invertebrate populations in central Australia: implications for land management. Austral Ecology 28, 658–665.
- Moorcroft, H. and Adams, M., 2014: Emerging geographies of conservation and indigenous Land in Australia. Australian Geographer 45, 485–504.
- Morton, S.R., Stafford Smith, D.M., Dickman, C.R., Dunkerley, D.L., Friedel, M.H., McAllister, R.R.J., Reid, J.R.W., Roshier, D.A., Smith, M.A., Walsh, F.J., Wardle, G.M., Watson, I.W. and Westoby, M., 2011: A fresh framework for the ecology of arid Australia. Journal of Arid Environments 75, 313–329.
- Muller, S., 2012: ‘Two ways’: bringing indigenous and non-indigenous knowledges together. In J. Weir (ed.) Country, Native Title and Ecology. ANU ePress, Canberra, 59–79.
10.22459/CNTE.03.2012.04 Google Scholar
- Muller, S., 2014: Co-motion: making space to care for country. Geoforum; Journal of Physical, Human, and Regional Geosciences 54, 132–141.
- Olsson, P., Folke, C. and Berkes, F., 2004: Adaptive comanagement for building resilience in socio-ecological systems. Environmental Management 34, 75–90.
- Parlee, B.L., Geertsema, K. and Willier, A., 2012: Social-ecological thresholds in a changing boreal landscape: insights from Cree knowledge of the Lesser Slave Lake Region of Alberta, Canada. Ecology and Society 17, 20.
- Pelling, M. and High, C., 2005: Understanding adaptation: what can social capital offer assessments of adaptive capacity? Global Environmental Change 15, 308–319.
- Pert, P.L., Hill, R., Maclean, K., Dale, A., Rist, P., Schmider, J., Talbot, L. and Tawake, L., 2015: Mapping cultural ecosystem services with Rainforest Aboriginal peoples: integrating biocultural diversity, governance and social variation. Ecosystem Services 13, 41–56.
- Petheram, L., Zander, K.K., Campbell, B.M., High, C. and Stacey, N., 2010: Strange changes': indigenous perspectives of climate change and adaptation in NE Arnhem Land (Australia). Global Environmental Change 20, 681–692.
- Pretty, J. and Ward, H., 2001: Social capital and the environment. World Development 29, 209–227.
- Pringle, H., Watson, I. and Tinley, K., 2006: Landscape improvement, or ongoing degradation – reconciling apparent contradictions from the arid rangelands of Western Australia. Landscape Ecology 21, 1267–1279.
- Prober, S.M., O'Connor, M.H. and Walsh, F.J., 2011: Australian Aboriginal peoples' seasonal knowledge: a potential basis for shared understanding in environmental management. Ecology and Society 16, 12.
10.5751/ES-04023-160212 Google Scholar
- Reynolds, J.F., Smith, D.M.S., Lambin, E.F., Turner, B.L., Mortimore, M., Batterbury, S.P.J., Downing, T.E., Dowlatabadi, H., Fernández, R.J., Herrick, J.E., Huber-Sannwald, E., Jiang, H., Leemans, R., Lynam, T., Maestre, F.T., Ayarza, M. and Walker, B., 2007: Global desertification: building a science for dryland development. Science 316, 847–851.
- Robbins, J., 2010: A nation within? Indigenous peoples, representation and sovereignty in Australia. Ethnicities 10, 257–274.
- Robins, L. and Dovers, S., 2007: NRM Regions in Australia: the ‘Haves’ and the ‘Have Nots’. Geographical Research 45, 273–290.
- Robinson, A.C., Copley, P.B., Canty, P.D., Baker, L.M. and Nesbitt, B.J., 2003: A Biological Survey of the Anangu Pitjantjatjara Lands, South Australia, 1991–2001. Department for Environment and Heritage, South Australia.
- Robinson, C.J. and Wallington, T.J., 2012: Boundary work: engaging knowledge systems in co-management of feral animals on Indigenous lands. Ecology and Society 17, 16.
- Robinson, C.J., Smyth, D. and Whitehead, P.J., 2005: Bush tucker, bush pets, and bush threats: cooperative management of feral animals in Australia's Kakadu National Park. Conservation Biology 19, 1385–1391.
- Sallenave, J., 1994: Giving traditional ecological knowledge its rightful place in environmental impact assessment. Northern Perspectives 22, 16–19.
- Scheffer, M., 2009: Critical Transitions in Nature and Society. Princeton University Press, Princeton.
10.1515/9781400833276 Google Scholar
- SCRGSP (Steering Committee for the Review of Government Service Provision), 2014: Overcoming Indigenous Disadvantage: Key Indicators 2014. Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
- Staddon, S.C., Nightingale, A. and Shrestha, S.K., 2014: The social nature of participatory ecological monitoring. Society and Natural Resources 27, 899–914.
- Stafford-Smith, D.M., 2008: The‘desert syndrome’ – causally-linked factors that characterise outback Australia. The Rangeland Journal 30, 3–14.
- Stafford-Smith, D.M., Abel, N., Walker, B. and Chapin, F.S., 2009: Drylands: coping with uncertainty, thresholds, and changes in state. In C. Folke, G.P. Kofinas and F.S. Chapin (eds) Principles of Ecosystem Stewardship: Resilience-Based Natural Resource Management in a Changing World. Springer, New York, 171–195.
10.1007/978-0-387-73033-2_8 Google Scholar
- Sutton, P., 2001: The politics of suffering: indigenous policy in Australia since the 1970s. Anthropological Forum 11, 125–173.
10.1080/00664670125674 Google Scholar
- Svenning, J. and Sandel, B., 2013: Disequilibrium vegetation dynamics under future climate change. American Journal of Botany 100, 1266–1286.
- Tengö, M., Brondizio, E.S., Elmqvist, T., Malmer, P. and Spierenburg, M., 2014: Connecting diverse knowledge systems for enhanced ecosystem governance: the multiple evidence base approach. Ambio 43, 579–591.
- Tremblay, M., Furgal, C., Larrivee, C., Annanack, T., Tookalook, P., Qiisik, M., Angiyou, E., Swappie, N., Savard, J. and Barrett, M., 2008: Climate change in northern Quebec: adaptation strategies from community-based research. Arctic 61, 27–34.
- URBIS, 2012: Assessment of the social outcomes of the working on country program: report 2012. Retrieved: 30 November 2014 from <https://www.environment.gov.au/indigenous/workingoncountry/publications/woc-social.html>.
- Veland, S., Howitt, R., Dominey-Howes, D., Thomalla, F. and Houston, D., 2013: Procedural vulnerability: understanding environmental change in a remote Indigenous community. Global Environmental Change 23, 314–326.
- Walker, B. and Abel, N., 2002: Resilient rangelands: adaptation in complex systems. In L.H. Gunderson and C.S. Holling (eds) Panarchy: Understanding Transformations in Human and Natural Systems. Island Press, Washington., 293–314.
- Waudby, H.P., Petit, S. and Robinson, G., 2013: Pastoralists' knowledge of plant palatability and grazing indicators in an arid region of South Australia. The Rangeland Journal 35, 445–454.
- White, A., Foulkes, J.N., Sparrow, B.D. and Lowe, A.J., 2012: Biodiversity monitoring in the rangelands. In D. Lindemayer and P. Gibbons (eds) Biodiversity Monitoring in Australia. CSIRO publishing, Canberra, 179–190.
- Wiseman, N.D. and Bardsley, D.K., 2013: Climate change and indigenous natural resource management: a review of socio-ecological interactions in the Alinytjara Wilurara NRM region. Local Environment 18, 1024–1045.
10.1080/13549839.2012.752799 Google Scholar
- Wiseman, N.D. and Bardsley, D.K., 2015: Adapting to Climate Change on Country. Climate Change Addendum – Technical Report for the Alinytjara Wilurara Regional Management Plan. Government of South Australia/Australian Government, Adelaide.
- Woodward, E.L., Jackson, S., Finn, M. and Marrfurra McTaggart, P., 2012: Utilising Indigenous seasonal knowledge to understand aquatic resource use and inform water resource management in northern Australia. Ecological Management & Restoration 13, 58–64.
10.1111/j.1442-8903.2011.00622.x Google Scholar
- Zander, K.K., Austin, B.J. and Garnett, S.T., 2014: Indigenous peoples' interest in wildlife-based enterprises in the Northern Territory, Australia. Human Ecology 42, 115–126.