Placing poverty on the agenda of a primary health care team: an evaluation of an action research project
Meg Bond MACQSW
Department of Continuing Education, University of Warwick, UK
Search for more papers by this authorMeg Bond MACQSW
Department of Continuing Education, University of Warwick, UK
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
The period of the last Government in the UK was marked by increases in poverty and social exclusion, with the gap widening between rich and poor, and differentials being associated with, and further entrenched by, inequalities in health. In 1994, the Audit Commission pointed to the potential contribution which proactive and well coordinated health and welfare services could make to meeting the needs of vulnerable families, and suggested the setting up of local demonstration projects. This paper reports on the achievements and limitations of Nottingham’s 2-year Strategies for Practice in Disadvantaged Areas (SPIDA) Project which tested a model of team learning about poverty in relation to those registered with an inner-city doctor’s practice. Members of a primary health care team engaged in a self-directed development programme which, despite numerous staff changes, enabled them to learn how to learn together, enhanced their understandings of what it means to live in poverty, and facilitated the establishment of collaborative and productive interagency working relationships at a neighbourhood level. It is suggested that staff in health and welfare organizations wishing to implement anti-poverty strategies could usefully consider adopting this model of team learning to promote collective action and change.
References
- 1 Alcock P. (1994) Welfare Rights in Primary Health Care. Centre for Regional Economic and Social Research: Sheffield Hallam University, Sheffield.
- 2 Audit Commission (1994) Seen But Not Heard: Co-ordinating Community Child Health and Social Services for Children in Need: Detailed Evidence and Guidelines for Managers and Practitioners. HMSO, London.
- 3 Balarajan R. (1993) Ethnicity and Health. Department of Health, London.
- 4 Beattie A. (1991) The evaluation of community development initiatives in health promotion: a review of current strategies. In: Roots and Branches: Papers from the Open University/Health Education Authority 1990 Winter School on Community Development and Health. Health Education Unit, Department of Community Education, Open University, Milton Keynes.
- 5 Benzeval M., Judge K., Whitehead M. (1995) Tackling Inequalities in Health: an Agenda for Action. King’s Fund, London.
- 6 Blackburn C. (1991) Poverty and Health: Working with Families. Open University Press, Milton Keynes.
- 7 Blackburn C. (1992a) Improving Health and Welfare Work with Families in Poverty: a Handbook. Open University Press, Buckingham.
- 8 Blackburn C. (1992b) Poverty Profiling: a Guide for Community Nurses. Health Visitors’ Association, London.
- 9 Bloch A. (1997) Ethnic inequality and social security policy. In: A. Walker and C. Walker (Eds) Britain Divided: the Growth of Social Exclusion in the 1980s and 1990s. CPAG, London.
- 10
Bond M. (1997) A learning team in the making: a case study of the Strategies for Practice in Disadvantaged Areas Project.
Journal of Interprofessional Care
7 (1), 89–98.
10.3109/13561829709040247 Google Scholar
- 11
Boot N. (1985) Community health action: challenge for the health education officer.
Health Education Journal
7(1), 203–207.
10.1177/001789698504400414 Google Scholar
- 12 Boyd M. (1993) Health visitors rôle out. Nursing Standard 7 (1), 45–47.
- 13 Burchell B. (1997) The unequal distribution of job insecurity. International Review of Applied Economics (in press).
- 14 Charlton J. (1996) Which areas are healthiest? Population Trends 7, 17–24.
- 15 CPAG (1997a) Britain bottom of league within Europe for levels of poverty. Poverty97, 20.
- 16 CPAG (1997b) Health visitors’ survey. Poverty 7, 20–21.
- 17 Dawson P. & Heyman B. (1997) Evaluating community health services: conflict and controversy. Health and Social Care in the Community 7 (1), 255–260.
- 18
Dechant K.,
Marsick V.J.,
Kasl E. (1993) Towards a model of team learning.
Studies in Continuing Education
7 (1), 1–14.
10.1080/0158037930150101 Google Scholar
- 19
Delaney F. (1994) Making connections: research into intersectoral collaboration.
Health Education Journal
7, 474–585.
10.1177/001789699405300411 Google Scholar
- 20 Department of Social Security (1997) Households Below Average Income – a Statistical Analysis 1979–94/95 (8th Edn). The Stationery Office, London.
- 21
Dickinson R. &
Bhatt A. (1994) Ethnicity, health and control: results from an exploratory study of ethnic minority communities’ attitudes to health.
Health Education Journal
7, 421–429.
10.1177/001789699405300406 Google Scholar
- 22 Disability Rights Bulletin. (1995) Take-up campaigns. Disability Rights Bulletin Summer 17–20.
- 23
Doyle Y. &
Thomas P. (1996) Promoting health through primary care: challenges in taking a strategic approach.
Health Education Journal
7, 3–10.
10.1177/001789699605500102 Google Scholar
- 24 Filakti H. & Fox J. (1995) Differences in mortality by housing tenure and by car access from the OPCS Longitudinal Study. Population Trends 7, 27–30.
- 25 Flanagan H. & Robinson C. (1997) Measuring Deprivation in the West Midlands Region. West Midlands Low Pay Unit, Birmingham.
- 26 Gordon D. & Pantazis C. (1997) Breadline Britain: the Full Report of a Major National Survey on Poverty. Ashgate, Aldershot.
- 27 Graham H. (1993) When Life’s a Drag: Women, Smoking and Disadvantage. HMSO, London.
- 28 Gregg P. (1997) Jobs, Wages and Poverty. Centre for Economic Performance, LSE, London.
- 29
Gunning-Schepers L.J. &
Gepkens A. (1996) Review of interventions to reduce social inequalities in health: research and policy implications.
Health Education Journal
7, 226–238.
10.1177/001789699605500210 Google Scholar
- 30 Hart E. & Bond M. (1995) Action Research for Health and Social Care: a Guide to Practice. Open University Press, Buckingham.
- 31 Hart E. & Bond M. (1996) Final Evaluation of the Strategies for Practice in Disadvantaged Areas (SPIDA) Project. Department of Nursing and Midwifery Studies, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Nottingham, Nottingham.
- 32 Health Visitors’ Association (1996) HVA Centenary Survey: return of diseases and social conditions of 19th century. HVA Press Release, 27 November.
- 33 Hill M. & Aldgate J. (1996) Child Welfare Services: Developments in Policy, Practice and Research. Jessica Kingsley, London.
- 34
Johnson P. (1997) Moving in and out of poverty.
New Economy
7 (1), 7–11.
10.1111/j.1468-0041.1997.tb00161.x Google Scholar
- 35 Kosmidou C. & Usher R. (1991) Facilitation in action research. Interchange 7 (1), 24–40.
- 36 Kumar V. (1993) Poverty and Inequality in the UK: the Effects on Children. National Children’s Bureau, London.
- 37 Laughlin S. & Black D. (1995) Poverty and Health: Tools for Change. Public Health Alliance, Birmingham.
- 38
McLoone P. &
Boddy F. (1994) Deprivation and mortality in Scotland 1981 and 1991.
British Medical Journal
7, 1465–1470.
10.1136/bmj.309.6967.1465 Google Scholar
- 39 MORI Health Research Unit (1995) The Black and Ethnic Minority Groups’ Health and Lifestyles Survey. Health Education Authority, London.
- 40
Murray S.A. &
Graham L.J.C. (1995) Practice-based health needs assessment: use of four methods in a small neighbourhood.
British Medical Journal
7, 1443–1448.
10.1136/bmj.310.6992.1443 Google Scholar
- 41 Nazroo J. (1997) The Health of Britain’s Ethnic Minorities. Policy Studies Institute, London.
- 42 NCH Action for Children & The Maternity Alliance. (1995) Poor Expectations: Poverty and Under-Nourishment in Pregnancy. NCH Action for Children/The Maternity Alliance, London.
- 43 Oppenheim C. (1993) Poverty, the Facts. CPAG, London.
- 44 Payne S. (1991) Women, Health and Poverty: an Introduction. Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead.
- 45 Perkins E.R. (1988) The Nottingham Community Health Project Final Report. Nottingham Health Education and Promotion Unit, Nottingham Health Authority, Nottingham.
- 46 Poulton B.C. & West M.A. (1994) Primary health care team effectiveness: developing a constituency approach. Health and Social Care in the Community 7, 77–84.
- 47
Reeves J.,
Kendrick D.,
Denman S.,
Roberts H. (1994) Lone mothers: their health and lifestyle.
Health Education Journal
7, 291–299.
10.1177/001789699405300307 Google Scholar
- 48 Regel S. & Dessaur-Furr G. (1995) Hyson Green Poverty Profile. Nottingham Community Health NHS Trust SPIDA Project, Nottingham.
- 49 Regel S. & Dessaur-Furr G. (1996) SPIDA Project Final Report. Nottingham Community Health NHS Trust SPIDA Project, Nottingham.
- 50 Rowe A. & Miles M. (1994) Coping strategy. Nursing Times 7 (1), 32–34.
- 51 Save the Children (1997) Out of the Frying Pan: the True Cost of Feeding a Family on a Low Income. Save the Children, London.
- 52 Simmons M. (1994) Poor men at the Gate. Guardian Society 6July p. 11.
- 53 Tipton Challenge Partnership (1995) Challenge Report 18. Tipton Challenge Partnership, Sandwell.
- 54 Walker A. & Walker C. (1997) Britain Divided: the Growth of Social Exclusion in the 1980s and 1990s. CPAG, London.
- 55 Wilkinson R.G. (1996) Unhealthy Societies: the Afflictions of Inequality. Routledge, London.
- 56 Willis J. (1997) Inner city decay. Nursing Times93 (9), 17.