The Strategic Role of Circular Economy Innovations and Stakeholder Engagement in Advancing Responsible Production and Consumption
Li KaoDui
School of Finance and Economics, Jiangsu University, Zhenjiang, China
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Maxwell Kongkuah
Department of Economics, Faculty of Political Sciences, Çanakkale Onsekiz Mart University, Çanakkale, Turkey
Correspondence:
Maxwell Kongkuah ([email protected])
Search for more papers by this authorLi KaoDui
School of Finance and Economics, Jiangsu University, Zhenjiang, China
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Maxwell Kongkuah
Department of Economics, Faculty of Political Sciences, Çanakkale Onsekiz Mart University, Çanakkale, Turkey
Correspondence:
Maxwell Kongkuah ([email protected])
Search for more papers by this authorFunding: This research is supported by the National Social Science Foundation of China (No. 24BGL276), China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (No. 2024M752437), Philosophy and Social Sciences Major Project of Jiangsu Universities (No. 2024SJZD059), Basic Research in Natural Sciences Major Project of Jiangsu Universities (No. 23KJB630005), Zhenjiang Science and Technology Project (No. RK2024010).
ABSTRACT
As the urgency of global sustainability goals intensifies, achieving responsible production and consumption (RPC) has become a critical priority, especially in emerging markets where economic growth must be balanced with environmental stewardship. Businesses play a pivotal role in advancing sustainability, and understanding how governance practices influence RPC is essential for aligning corporate strategies with global objectives. This study investigates how circular economy innovations and stakeholder engagement moderate the link between indigenous directors and RPC. Using secondary data from 439 manufacturing firms across MENA countries between 2012 and 2022, we employed the method of moments quantile regression (MMQR) and fixed effects estimations, addressing endogeneity through GMM modeling and propensity score matching techniques. Our findings demonstrate that indigenous directors significantly enhance RPC across all quantiles. Additionally, circular economy innovations not only advance RPC but also amplify the positive effects of indigenous directors on sustainable practices. Stakeholder engagement further strengthens this relationship, particularly in higher quantiles, underscoring the importance of inclusive governance for achieving sustainability goals. These insights provide actionable implications for business leaders and policymakers, particularly in the MENA region, by emphasizing the strategic integration of Indigenous leadership and circular economy innovations into corporate governance. This study offers a framework for aligning business strategies with global sustainability objectives, notably SDG 12 while also contributing to the literature on strategic management and sustainability. By highlighting the role of Indigenous leadership in driving sustainable practices, this research provides valuable guidance for firms and policymakers seeking to advance environmental sustainability in emerging market economies.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
References
- Aguilera, R. V., J. A. Aragón-Correa, V. Marano, and P. A. Tashman. 2021. “The Corporate Governance of Environmental Sustainability: A Review and Proposal for More Integrated Research.” Journal of Management 47, no. 6: 1468–1497.
- Agyemang, A., K. Yusheng, M. Kongkuah, A. Musah, and M. Musah. 2023. “Assessing the Impact of Environmental Accounting Disclosure on Corporate Performance in China.” Environmental Engineering & Management Journal (EEMJ) 22, no. 2: 389–397.
- Agyemang, A. O., K. Yusheng, and A. Osei. 2025. “Addressing Sustainability Footprint Disclosure for High Pollutant Firms in China and the US: The Roles of Firms Governance Structure, Financing Decisions, and Eco-Technology.” Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management 32: 2835–2858.
- Agyemang, A. O., K. Yusheng, A. K. Twum, E. C. Ayamba, M. Kongkuah, and M. Musah. 2021. “Trend and Relationship Between Environmental Accounting Disclosure and Environmental Performance for Mining Companies Listed in China.” Environment, Development and Sustainability 23: 12192–12216.
- Al Amosh, H., and S. F. Khatib. 2021. “Corporate Governance and Voluntary Disclosure of Sustainability Performance: The Case of Jordan.” SN Business & Economics 1, no. 12: 165.
10.1007/s43546-021-00167-1 Google Scholar
- Albitar, K., T. Abdoush, and K. Hussainey. 2023. “Do Corporate Governance Mechanisms and ESG Disclosure Drive CSR Narrative Tones?” International Journal of Finance and Economics 28, no. 4: 3876–3890.
- Almagtome, A., M. Khaghaany, and S. Önce. 2020. “Corporate Governance Quality, Stakeholders' Pressure, and Sustainable Development: An Integrated Approach.” International Journal of Mathematical, Engineering and Management Sciences 5, no. 6: 1077–1090.
- Alonso-Almeida, M.d., J. M. Rodríguez-Antón, L. Bagur-Femenías, and J. Perramon. 2020. “Sustainable Development and Circular Economy: The Role of Institutional Promotion on Circular Consumption and Market Competitiveness From a Multistakeholder Engagement Approach.” Business Strategy and the Environment 29, no. 6: 2803–2814.
- Alvarez, J., and M. Arellano. 2022. “Robust Likelihood Estimation of Dynamic Panel Data Models.” Journal of Econometrics 226, no. 1: 21–61.
- Ao, X., T. Ong, R. Aprile, and A. Di Vaio. 2023. “Environmental Uncertainty and Digital Technologies Corporate in Shaping Corporate Green Behavior and Tax Avoidance.” Scientific Reports 13, no. 1: 22170.
- Attanasio, G., N. Preghenella, A. F. De Toni, and C. Battistella. 2022. “Stakeholder Engagement in Business Models for Sustainability: The Stakeholder Value Flow Model for Sustainable Development.” Business Strategy and the Environment 31, no. 3: 860–874.
- Ben Hassen, T., and H. EI Bilali. 2024. “ Sustainable Development Goals in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) Region: Policy and Governance.” In SDGs in Africa and the Middle East Region, 283–298. Springer.
10.1007/978-3-031-17465-0_20 Google Scholar
- Bernstein, J. M., and R. O. Vos. 2021. “ Moving Toward a Circular Economy in Support of SDG12.” In SDG12–Sustainable Consumption and Production: A Revolutionary Challenge for the 21st Century, 73–105. Emerald Publishing Limited.
10.1108/978-1-78973-099-920211006 Google Scholar
- Blundell, R., and S. Bond. 2023. “Initial conditions and Blundell–Bond estimators.” Journal of Econometrics 234: 101–110.
- Bohinc, R. 2024. “ Corporate Directors' Sustainability due Diligence: A Groundbreaking Step to Sustainable Corporate Governance.” In Corporate Governance and CSR Strategies for Sustainability, 179–205. IGI Global.
10.4018/979-8-3693-5863-4.ch008 Google Scholar
- Cardoso de Oliveira, M. C., M. C. Machado, C. J. Chiappetta Jabbour, L. de Sousa, and A. B. Jabbour. 2019. “Paving the Way for the Circular Economy and More Sustainable Supply Chains: Shedding Light on Formal and Informal Governance Instruments Used to Induce Green Networks.” Management of Environmental Quality: An International Journal 30, no. 5: 1095–1113.
10.1108/MEQ-01-2019-0005 Google Scholar
- Chang, G., A. O. Agyemang, U. F. Saeed, and I. Adam. 2024. “Assessing the Impact of Financing Decisions and Ownership Structure on Green Accounting Disclosure: Evidence From Developing Economies.” Heliyon 10, no. 5: e26672.
- Chang, G., I. Wiredu, P. K. Boadu, and A. O. Agyemang. 2024. “Navigating Sustainable Development: Exploring the nexus of Board Attributes and Environmental Accounting Information Disclosure in China's Construction Industry.” Environment, Development and Sustainability: 1–26.
- Correa-Garcia, J. A., M. A. Garcia-Benau, and E. Garcia-Meca. 2020. “Corporate Governance and Its Implications for Sustainability Reporting Quality in Latin American Business Groups.” Journal of Cleaner Production 260: 121142.
- Cramer, J. 2022. “Effective Governance of Circular Economies: An International Comparison.” Journal of Cleaner Production 343: 130874.
10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.130874 Google Scholar
- Di Vaio, A., A. Zaffar, M. Chhabra, and D. Balsalobre-Lorente. 2024. “Carbon Accounting and Integrated Reporting for Net-Zero Business Models Towards Sustainable Development: A Systematic Literature Review.” Business Strategy and the Environment 33, no. 7: 7216–7240.
- Diaz, A., T. Reyes, and R. J. Baumgartner. 2022. “Implementing Circular Economy Strategies During Product Development.” Resources, Conservation and Recycling 184: 106344.
- Doni, F., A. Corvino, and S. Bianchi Martini. 2022. “Corporate Governance Model, Stakeholder Engagement and Social Issues Evidence From European Oil and Gas Industry.” Social Responsibility Journal 18, no. 3: 636–662.
- Erin, O., A. Adegboye, and O. A. Bamigboye. 2022. “Corporate Governance and Sustainability Reporting Quality: Evidence From Nigeria.” Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal 13, no. 3: 680–707.
- Eriqat, I. O., M. Tahir, and A. H. Zulkafli. 2024. “The Impact of Corporate Social Responsibility Disclosure on Corporate Reputation: The Moderating Role of National Culture in Financial Industries of MENA Region.” Cogent Business & Management 11, no. 1: 2391120.
- Esposito, B., N. Raimo, O. Malandrino, and F. Vitolla. 2023. “Circular Economy Disclosure and Integrated Reporting: The Role of Corporate Governance Mechanisms.” Business Strategy and the Environment 32, no. 8: 5403–5419.
- Freeman, R. E., S. D. Dmytriyev, and R. A. Phillips. 2021. “Stakeholder Theory and the Resource-Based View of the Firm.” Journal of Management 47, no. 7: 1757–1770.
- Gull, A. A., M. Carvajal, M. Atif, and M. Nadeem. 2024. “The Presence and Composition of Sustainability Committee and Waste Management Practices.” International Review of Financial Analysis 93: 103111.
- Gunawan, J., P. Permatasari, and C. Tilt. 2020. “Sustainable Development Goal Disclosures: Do They Support Responsible Consumption and Production?” Journal of Cleaner Production 246: 118989.
- Gündoğdu, H. G., and A. Aytekin. 2022. “Effects of Sustainable Governance to Sustainable Development.” Operational Research in Engineering Sciences: Theory and Applications 5: 117–151.
10.31181/oresta060722090g Google Scholar
- Hristov, I., and A. Appolloni. 2022. “Stakeholders' Engagement in the Business Strategy as a Key Driver to Increase Companies' Performance: Evidence From Managerial and Stakeholders' Practices.” Business Strategy and the Environment 31, no. 4: 1488–1503.
- Jabbour, C. J. C., A. B. L. de Sousa Jabbour, J. Sarkis, and M. Godinho Filho. 2019. “Unlocking the Circular Economy Through new Business Models Based on Large-Scale Data: An Integrative Framework and Research Agenda.” Technological Forecasting and Social Change 144: 546–552.
- Jacob-John, J., C. D'Souza, T. Marjoribanks, and S. Singaraju. 2021. “Synergistic Interactions of SDGs in Food Supply Chains: A Review of Responsible Consumption and Production.” Sustainability 13, no. 16: 8809.
- Jibril, R. S., M. A. Isa, Z. S. Maigoshi, and K. T. Hamid. 2024. “Audit Committee Attributes, Board of Director's Independence and Energy Disclosure for Environmental Sustainability in Nigeria.” International Journal of Innovation Science 16, no. 2: 391–419.
- Kamil, R., U. F. Saeed, F. K. Essel, and T. M. Nagriwum. 2024. “Net-Zero Transition Pathways in Belt and Road Economies: Insights From Threshold Effects and Heterogeneous Analysis.” Environmental Quality Management 34, no. 2: e22335.
- Kar, D., and B. Patro. 2024. “Unravelling the Impact of Financial Literacy on the Intention of Indian Retail Investors to Adopt Socially Responsible Investments: The Interplay of Social Self-Efficacy as a Mediating Mechanism.” Global Business Review: 09721509231223571.
- Kateb, I., and W. M. Alahdal. 2024. “Tracing the Path to Sustainable Governance: CSR Committees as Mediators of Board Impact on ESG Performance in the MENA Region.” Corporate Governance: The international journal of business in society.
- Kavadis, N., and S. Thomsen. 2023. “Sustainable Corporate Governance: A Review of Research on Long-Term Corporate Ownership and Sustainability.” Corporate Governance: An International Review 31, no. 1: 198–226.
- Khan, N., S. Karim, L. F. Chan, and L. She. 2024. “Green Horizons: Overcoming Political Risks With Strategic Environmental Management and Financial Innovation.” Journal of Environmental Management 368: 122224.
- Kilincarslan, E., M. H. Elmagrhi, and Z. Li. 2020. “Impact of Governance Structures on Environmental Disclosures in the Middle East and Africa.” Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society 20, no. 4: 739–763.
- Kiran, M., S. Chughtai, M. R. Rabbani, and A. F. Aysan. 2024. “ESG Disclosure and Cost of Finance: The Moderating Role of Managerial Ownership.” Journal of Financial Reporting and Accounting.
- Kong, Y., A. Agyemang, N. Alessa, and M. Kongkuah. 2023. “The Moderating Role of Technological Innovation on Environment, Social, and Governance (ESG) Performance and Firm Value: Evidence From Developing and Least-Developed Countries.” Sustainability 15, no. 19: 14240.
- Lestari, K. C., and N. Soewarno. 2024. “Do Female Directors Influence Firm Value? The Mediating Role of Green Innovation.” Gender in Management: An International Journal 39, no. 2: 255–273.
10.1108/GM-08-2022-0281 Google Scholar
- Li, X., and X. Tong. 2024. “Fostering Green Growth in Asian Developing Economies: The Role of Good Governance in Mitigating the Resource Curse.” Resources Policy 90: 104724.
- Ludwig, P., and R. Sassen. 2022. “Which Internal Corporate Governance Mechanisms Drive Corporate Sustainability?” Journal of Environmental Management 301: 113780.
- Ma, W., and J. L. Hao. 2024. “Enhancing a Circular Economy for Construction and Demolition Waste Management in China: A Stakeholder Engagement and Key Strategy Approach.” Journal of Cleaner Production 450: 141763.
- Mahajan, R., S. Kumar, W. M. Lim, and M. Sareen. 2024. “The Role of Business and Management in Driving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): Current Insights and Future Directions From a Systematic Review.” Business Strategy and the Environment 33: 4493–4529.
- Manes-Rossi, F., G. Nicolò, A. Tiron Tudor, and G. Zanellato. 2021. “Drivers of Integrated Reporting by State-Owned Enterprises in Europe: A Longitudinal Analysis.” Meditari Accountancy Research 29, no. 3: 586–616.
- Naciti, V., F. Cesaroni, and L. Pulejo. 2022. “Corporate Governance and Sustainability: A Review of the Existing Literature.” Journal of Management and Governance 26: 1–20.
- Nazir, S., and F. Doni. 2024. “Nexus of Circular Economy R0 to R9 Principles in Integrated Reporting: Insights From a Multiple Case Study Comparison.” Business Strategy and the Environment 33: 4058–4085.
- Nguyen, N. P., and S. Adomako. 2022. “Stakeholder Pressure for Eco-Friendly Practices, International Orientation, and Eco-Innovation: A Study of Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises in Vietnam.” Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management 29, no. 1: 79–88.
- Nong, D., P. Simshauser, and D. B. Nguyen. 2021. “Greenhouse Gas Emissions vs CO2 Emissions: Comparative Analysis of a Global Carbon Tax.” Applied Energy 298: 117223.
- Omri, A., and N. B. Mabrouk. 2020. “Good Governance for Sustainable Development Goals: Getting Ahead of the Pack or Falling Behind?” Environmental Impact Assessment Review 83: 106388.
- Palombi, G., V. Schiaroli, L. Fraccascia, and F. Nonino. 2024. “Identifying Barriers and Good Practices for Implementing Circular Economy Principles in Small and Medium Enterprises.” Business Strategy and the Environment 33, no. 7: 6773–6794.
- Papagiannakis, G., I. Voudouris, S. Lioukas, and G. Kassinis. 2019. “Environmental Management Systems and Environmental Product Innovation: The Role of Stakeholder Engagement.” Business Strategy and the Environment 28, no. 6: 939–950.
- Perotti, F. A., A. Bargoni, P. De Bernardi, and Z. Rozsa. 2024. “Fostering Circular Economy Through Open Innovation: Insights From Multiple Case Study.” Business Ethics, the Environment & Responsibility 34, no. 2: 390–408.
10.1111/beer.12657 Google Scholar
- Pesaran, M. H., and T. Yamagata. 2008. “Testing Slope Homogeneity in Large Panels.” Journal of Econometrics 142, no. 1: 50–93.
- Petruzzella, F., A. Giakoumelou, V. L'Abate, N. Raimo, and F. Vitolla. 2024. “Fostering Firm Value: Unpacking the Effect of Circular Economy Disclosure via Social Media.” Business Strategy and the Environment 33, no. 8: 7960–7971.
- Pla-Julián, I., and S. Guevara. 2019. “Is Circular Economy the Key to Transitioning Towards Sustainable Development? Challenges From the Perspective of Care Ethics.” Futures 105: 67–77.
- Pozzoli, M., R. Nastari, S. Pisano, and M. Venuti. 2023. “How Circular Economy Disclosure Responds to Institutional Determinants Empirical Evidences in Non-Financial European Firms.” Sustainability 15, no. 22: 16069.
- Purvis, B., D. Celebi, and M. Pansera. 2023. “A Framework for a Responsible Circular Economy.” Journal of Cleaner Production 400: 136679.
- Rabbani, M. R., M. Kiran, A. B. Bhuiyan, and A. Al-Hiyari. 2024. “Does Diversity in Top Management and Boards Affect ESG Performance? Evidence From Islamic and Conventional Banks in the MENA Region.” International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management 17, no. 6: 1244–1266.
10.1108/IMEFM-06-2024-0281 Google Scholar
- Salvioni, D. M., and A. Almici. 2020. “Transitioning Toward a Circular Economy: The Impact of Stakeholder Engagement on Sustainability Culture.” Sustainability 12, no. 20: 8641.
- Senadjki, A., M. J. Bashir, H. N. AuYong, I. M. Awal, and J. H. Chan. 2024. “Pathways to Sustainability: How China's Belt and Road Initiative Is Shaping Responsible Production and Consumption in Africa.” Environmental Science and Pollution Research 31, no. 1: 1468–1487.
- Suchek, N., C. I. Fernandes, S. Kraus, M. Filser, and H. Sjögrén. 2021. “Innovation and the Circular Economy: A Systematic Literature Review.” Business Strategy and the Environment 30, no. 8: 3686–3702.
- Sulemana, I., L. Cheng, A. O. Agyemang, A. Osei, and T. M. Nagriwum. 2025. “Stakeholders and Sustainability Disclosure: Evidence From An Emerging Market.” Sustainable Futures 9: 100445.
- Tawiah, V., E. Gyapong, and M. Usman. 2024. “Returnee Directors and Green Innovation.” Journal of Business Research 174: 114369.
- Tawiah, V. K., E. Gyapong, and Y. Wang. 2024. “Does Board Ethnic Diversity Affect IFRS Disclosures?” Journal of Accounting Literature.
10.1108/JAL-03-2024-0043 Google Scholar
- Tawiah, V., N. Samson, and U. Jatau. 2024. “Local Directors and Corporate Social Responsibility Activities of Multinational Companies in Africa.” Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management 32: 1688–1697.
- Tawiah, V., R. Matemane, B. Oyewo, and T. T. Lemma. 2024. “Saving the Environment With Indigenous Directors: Evidence From Africa.” Business Strategy and the Environment 33, no. 3: 2445–2461.
- Tibiletti, V., P. L. Marchini, K. Furlotti, and A. Medioli. 2021. “Does Corporate Governance Matter in Corporate Social Responsibility Disclosure? Evidence From Italy in the “Era of Sustainability”.” Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management 28, no. 2: 896–907.
- Tjahjadi, B., N. Soewarno, and F. Mustikaningtiyas. 2021. “Good Corporate Governance and Corporate Sustainability Performance in Indonesia: A Triple Bottom Line Approach.” Heliyon 7, no. 3: e06453.
- Tuboalabo, A., U. Buinwi, C. G. Okatta, E. Johnson, and J. A. Buinwi. 2024. “Circular Economy Integration in Traditional Business Models: Strategies and Outcomes.” Finance & Accounting Research Journal 6, no. 6: 1105–1123.
10.51594/farj.v6i6.1245 Google Scholar
- Veeravel, V., E. Sadharma, and B. Kamaiah. 2024. “Do ESG Disclosures Lead to Superior Firm Performance? A Method of Moments Panel Quantile Regression Approach.” Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management 31, no. 1: 741–754.
10.1002/csr.2598 Google Scholar
- Vitolla, F., V. L'Abate, F. Petruzzella, N. Raimo, and A. Salvi. 2023. “Circular Economy Disclosure in Sustainability Reporting: The Effect of Firm Characteristics.” Sustainability 15, no. 3: 2200.
- Yang, Z., J. Na, and X. Dong. 2024. “Corporate Governance for Sustainable Development: A Study on Mechanism Configuration.” Journal of Cleaner Production 458: 142509.
- Zaman, R., T. Jain, G. Samara, and D. Jamali. 2022. “Corporate Governance Meets Corporate Social Responsibility: Mapping the Interface.” Business & Society 61, no. 3: 690–752.
- Zhou, D., U. F. Saeed, and A. O. Agyemang. 2024. “Assessing the Role of Sustainability Disclosure on Firms' Financial Performance: Evidence From the Energy Sector of Belt and Road Initiative Countries.” Sustainability 16, no. 2: 930.
- Zhou, D., U. F. Saeed, M. Kongkuah, and I. Wiredu. 2024. “Examining the Moderating Role of Environmental Regulations on Financial Development and Ecological Footprint in the MENA Region.” Environment, Development and Sustainability: 1–28.
- Zhu, N., E. N. T. Aryee, A. O. Agyemang, I. Wiredu, A. Zakari, and S. Y. Agbadzidah. 2024. “Addressing Environment, Social and Governance (ESG) Investment in China: Does Board Composition and Financing Decision Matter?” Heliyon 10, no. 10: e30783.
- Zhu, N., A. Osei, and A. O. Agyemang. 2024. “Do Board Attributes Influence Environmental Sustainability Disclosure in Manufacturing Firms? Evidence From Sub-Saharan Africa.” Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management 31, no. 5: 4759–4771.
10.1002/csr.2822 Google Scholar
- Zhu, N., I. Wiredu, A. O. Agyemang, and A. Osei. 2024. “Addressing Corporate Governance and Carbon Accounting Disclosure Gaps: A Path Toward Firms Commitment to Sustainable Development Goal 13.” Sustainable Development 32: 5421–5436.