The Polarization of Personal Saving
Corresponding Author
Marina Gindelsky
US Bureau of Economic Analysis, Washington, DC, USA
Correspondence:
Marina Gindelsky ([email protected])
Search for more papers by this authorRobert Martin
US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Washington, DC, USA
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Marina Gindelsky
US Bureau of Economic Analysis, Washington, DC, USA
Correspondence:
Marina Gindelsky ([email protected])
Search for more papers by this authorRobert Martin
US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Washington, DC, USA
Search for more papers by this authorABSTRACT
The Bureau of Economic Analysis and Bureau of Labor Statistics have constructed the first complete distribution of personal saving (2004–2022) for the U.S. by estimating the joint distribution of disposable personal income and personal consumption expenditures. We start with household surveys, augmented with administrative sources, to correct for suspected underreporting in the distribution tails. We then scale household values to national accounts totals and calculate the resulting distribution of personal saving, extending existing distributional national accounts for the U.S. While aggregate saving is 3% of personal income in 2022, it is negative for the bottom half of the distribution. In fact, consumption expenditures are more than double income for the bottom 10%, but almost six times less than income for the top 1%. Despite a temporary increase in saving during the COVID pandemic, the polarization is large and persistent, and robust to modifying the definitions and sample composition.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Supporting Information
Filename | Description |
---|---|
roiw70004-sup-0001-Supinfo.docapplication/doc, 251.7 KB | Data S1. Supporting Information. |
Please note: The publisher is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.
References
- Aguiar, M., and M. Bils. 2015. “Has Consumption Inequality Mirrored Income Inequality.” American Economic Review 105: 2725–2756.
- Armstrong, G., C. Cho, T. I. Garner, B. Matsumoto, J. Munoz, and J. Schild. 2022. “Building a Consumption Poverty Measure: Initial Results Following Recommendations of a Federal Interagency Working Group.” AEA Papers and Proceedings, 112, May.
- Atkinson, A., and F. Bourguignon. 2016. Handbook of Income Distribution. Elsevier.
- Attanasio, O., and L. Pistaferri. 2014. “Consumption Inequality Over the Last Half Century: Some Evidence Using the New PSID Consumption Measure.” American Economic Review 104: 122–126.
- Balestra, C., and F. Oehler. 2023. “ Measuring the Joint Distribution of Household Income, Consumption and Wealth at the Micro Level.” In OECD Papers on Well-Being and Inequalities, vol. 11, 1–109. OECD Publishing.
- Bee, A., and J. Mitchell. 2017. “Do Older Americans Have More Income Than we Think?” Proceedings of Annual Conference on Taxation and Minutes of the Annual Meeting of the National Tax Association 110: 1–85.
- Bhutta, N., A. C. Chang, L. J. Dettling, and J. W. Hsu. 2020. “ Disparities in Wealth by Race and Ethnicity in the 2019 Survey of Consumer Finances.” In FEDS Notes, September 28. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. https://doi.org/10.17016/2380-7172.2797.
10.17016/2380-7172.2797 Google Scholar
- Blundell, R., L. Pistaferri, and I. Preston. 2008. “Consumption Inequality and Partial Insurance.” American Economic Review 98: 1887–1892.
- Bruil, A. 2023. “Distributional National Accounts for The Netherlands and a Comparison With 12 Other Countries.” Review of Income and Wealth 69: 886–906.
- Carranza, R., M. Morgan, and B. Nolan. 2023. “Top Income Adjustments and Inequality: An Investigation of the EU-SILC.” Review of Income and Wealth 69: 725–754.
- Chiang, Y-T., and M. Dueholm. 2024. “Which U.S. Households Have Credit Card Debt?” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis on the Economy Blog. June, 27.
- DeBacker, J., B. Heim, A. Tran, and A. Yuskavage. 2020. “Tax Noncompliance and Measures of Income Inequality.” Tax Notes 166, no. 7: 1103–1118.
- Dynan, K., J. Skinner, and S. P. Zeldes. 2004. “Do the Rich Save More?” Journal of Political Economy 112, no. 2: 397–444.
- Feenberg, D., and E. Coutts. 1993. “An Introduction to the TAXSIM Model.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 12, no. 1: 189–194.
- Feiveson, L., and J. Sabelhaus. 2019. Lifecycle Patterns of Saving and Wealth Accumulation, Finance and Economics Discussion Series 2019–010. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System.
- Fisher, J., D. Johnson, J. Latner, T. Smeeding, and J. Thompson. 2016. “Inequality and Mobility Using Income, Consumption, and Wealth for the Same Individuals.” RSF Journal of the Social Sciences 2: 44–58.
- Fisher, J., D. Johnson, and T. Smeeding. 2015. “Inequality of Income and Consumption in the US: Measuring the Trends in Inequality From 1984 to 2011 for the Same Individuals.” Review of Income and Wealth 61: 630–650.
- Fisher, J., D. Johnson, T. Smeeding, and J. Thompson. 2018. “The Demography of Inequality: Income, Consumption, and Wealth, 1989–2013.” PSC Research Report No. 18–890, July.
- Fisher, J., D. Johnson, T. Smeeding, and J. Thompson. 2020. “Estimating the Marginal Propensity to Consume Using the Distributions of Income, Consumption, and Wealth.” Journal of Macroeconomics 65: 103218.
- Fisher, J., D. Johnson, T. Smeeding, and J. Thompson. 2022. “Inequality in 3-D: Income, Consumption, and Wealth.” Review of Income and Wealth 68, no. 1: 16–42.
- Gaillard, A., C. Hellwig, P. Wagner, and N. Werquin. 2023. “Consumption, Wealth, and Income Inequality: A Tale of Tails.” Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago Working Paper, December.
- Garner, T. 1993. “Consumer Expenditures and Inequality: An Analysis Based on Decomposition of the Gini Coefficient.” Review of Economics and Statistics 75, no. 1: 134–138.
- Garner, T., R. Martin, B. Matsumoto, and S. Curtin. 2022. “Distribution of US Personal Consumption Expenditures for 2019: A Prototype Based on Consumer Expenditure Survey Data.” BLS Working Paper 557, August.
- Garner, T., R. Martin, B. Matsumoto, and S. Curtin. 2024. “A Distributional Approach to US Personal Consumption Expenditures: An Overview.” Business Economics 59: 166–173.
10.1057/s11369-024-00358-2 Google Scholar
- Garner, T., B. Matsumoto, and J. Schild. 2024. “Consumption Inequality During and After the COVID-19 Pandemic.” BLS Working Paper, March.
- Garner, T., B. Matsumoto, J. Schild, S. Curtin, and A. Safir. 2023. “Developing a Consumption Measure, With Example of Use for Poverty and Inequality Analysis: A New Research Product From BLS.” Monthly Labor Review, April.
- Garner, T., J. Ruiz-Castillo, and S. Mercedes. 2003. “The Influence of Demographics and Household-Specific Price Indices on Consumption-Based Inequality and Welfare: A Comparison of Spain and the United States.” Southern Economic Journal 70, no. 1: 22–48.
- Garner, T., and K. S. Short. 2013. “ A Multi-Dimensional Measure of Economic Well-Being for the US.” In The Material Condition Index in Joint Statistical Meetings Proceedings August 2013, 294–308. American Statistical Association (Link to BLS Working Paper Version).
- Gindelsky, M. 2022. “Do Transfers Lower Inequality Between Households? Demographic Evidence From Distributional National Accounts.” Economic Inquiry 60, no. 3: 1233–1257.
- Gindelsky, M. 2023. “Technical Document: An Updated Methodology for Distributing Personal Income. BEA Technical Paper.” December 15, 2023.
- Hong, A., B. Meyer, C. Murphy, J. Sullivan, and D. Wu. 2023. “Economic Well-Being and the Effects of Transfer Programs Using Linked Expenditure and Administrative Data.” Working Paper.
- Johnson, D. S., and T. M. Smeeding. 2015. “ Income Distribution and Inequality: Measurement Issues.” In International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences, edited by J. D. Wright, vol. 11, 2nd ed., 732–738. Elsevier.
10.1016/B978-0-08-097086-8.71044-0 Google Scholar
- Krueger, D., and F. Perri. 2006. “Does Income Inequality Lead to Consumption Inequality? Evidence and Theory.” Review of Economic Studies 73, no. 1: 163–193.
- Meyer, B., and J. X. Sullivan. 2023. “Consumption and Income Inequality in the US Since the 1960s.” Journal of Political Economy 131: 247–284.
10.1086/721702 Google Scholar
- Moriarty, C., and F. Scheuren. 2003. “A Note on Rubin's Statistical Matching Using File Concatenation With Adjusted Weights and Multiple Imputations.” Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 21, no. 1: 65–73.
10.1198/073500102288618766 Google Scholar
- National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2024. Creating an Integrated System of Data and Statistics on Household Income, Consumption, and Wealth: Time to Build. National Academies Press.
- Passero, W. 2009. “The Impact of Income Imputation in the Consumer Expenditure Survey.” Monthly Labor Review 132, no. 8: 25–42.
- Passero, W., T. I. Garner, and C. McCully. 2014. “ Understanding the Relationship: CE Survey and PCE.” In Improving the Measurement of Consumer Expenditures, 181–203. University of Chicago Press.
- Rothbaum, J. 2015. “Comparing Income Aggregates: How do the CPS and ACS Match the National Income and Product Accounts, 2007–2012. SEHSD Working Paper 2015–01.” Census Bureau Working Papers, January.
- Rubin, D. 1986. “Statistical Matching Using File Concatenation With Adjusted Weights and Multiple Imputations.” Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 4, no. 1: 87–94.
- Ruiz, N. 2011. “Measuring the Joint Distribution of Household's Income, Consumption, and Wealth Using Nested Atkinson Measures.” OECD Statistics Working Paper. No. 2011/05. Paris: OECD.
- Sabelhaus, J., and J. Groen. 2000. “Can Permanent-Income Theory Explain Cross-Sectional Consumption Patterns?” Review of Economics and Statistics 82, no. 3: 431–438.
- Sabelhaus, J., D. Johnson, S. Ash, et al. 2015. “ Is the Consumer Expenditure Survey Representative by Income?” In Improving the Measurement of Consumer Expenditures, 241–262. University of Chicago Press.
10.7208/chicago/9780226194714.003.0009 Google Scholar
- Semega, J. L., and E. Welniak. 2015. “The Effects of the Changes to the Current Population Survey Annual Social and Economic Supplement on Estimates of Income.” Census Bureau Working Paper, January.
- Stiglitz, J. E., A. Sen, and J. Fitoussi. 2009. Report by the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress. United Nations Press.
- Stone, C., D. Trisi, A. Sherman, and J. Beltran. 2020. “A Guide to Statistics on Historical Trends in Income Inequality.” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.” https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-inequality/a-guide-to-statistics-on-historical-trends-in-income-inequality.
- US Bureau of Labor Statistics. 2018. “Table 1110. Deciles of Income Before Taxes: Annual Expenditure Means, Shares, Standard Errors, and Coefficients of Variation.” https://www.bls.gov/cex/tables/calendar-year/mean-item-share-average-standard-error/cu-income-deciles-before-taxes-2017.pdf.
- US Census Bureau. 2018. “Annual Social and Economic Supplements.” https://www.census.gov/data/datasets/time-series/demo/cps/cps-asec.html.
- Zwijnenburg, J., J. Grilli, and P. Engelbrecht. 2022. “Pareto Tail Estimation in the Presence of Missing Rich in Compiling Distributional National Accounts.” Paper Prepared for the 37th IARIW General Conference, August 22–26, 2022.