What Influenced Early Secularization? A Statistical Analysis of the Results of the 1923 Referendum in Estonia
Corresponding Author
Mark Gortfelder
Estonian Institute for Population Studies, Tallinn University
Correspondence should be addressed to Mark Gortfelder, Estonian Institute for Population Studies, Tallinn University, Estonia, Tallinn, 10120. E-Mail: [email protected]
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Mark Gortfelder
Estonian Institute for Population Studies, Tallinn University
Correspondence should be addressed to Mark Gortfelder, Estonian Institute for Population Studies, Tallinn University, Estonia, Tallinn, 10120. E-Mail: [email protected]
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
In 1923, the first referendum of Estonia—one of the most secular countries in the world—was held. It came about as a public initiative to reinstate religious studies as a subject in public elementary schools after it had been banned by left-dominated parliaments. The referendum underlined the schism between the political elite and the wider population regarding the societal role of religion, with only 28.8 percent of votes cast in opposition to the proposal. This article uses opposition to religious studies as a proxy for secularization, and asks which political, cultural, demographic, and economic factors influenced people to become secularized in an early phase of the process. The analysis is done using municipal-level results of the referendum and standard linear, as well as two spatial models. It is shown that left-wing political preference and male sex are the most important predictors of secularization.
Supporting Information
Filename | Description |
---|---|
jssr12745-sup-0001-AppendixS1.docx15.9 KB | The effect of individual variables on explanatory power Table S1: AIC's of the full model and models without one variable |
jssr12745-sup-0002-AppendixS2.docx16.9 KB | Was there a difference between the voting of old and new smallholders? Table S2: The effect of the share of old farms on the referendum result |
jssr12745-sup-0003-AppendixS3.docx18.3 KB | Results for the historical Estonian territory Table S3. Regression results for the linear, spatial lag and spatial error models without the new municipalities |
Please note: The publisher is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.
REFERENCES
- Aarma, Liivi. 1990. Kirjaoskus Eestis 18. sajandi lõpust 1880. aastateni (nekrutinimekirjade andmeil): Dissertatsioon [Literacy in Estonia from the late 18th century to the 1880s (based on lists of recruits]. Tallinn: Eesti Teaduste Akadeemia.
- Altnurme, Lea. 2013. Kristluse tähenduse ja tähtsuse muutus eestlaste seas 1857–2010 [On the meaning and importance of Christanity among Estonians 1857–2010]. Tuna : Ajalookultuuri ajakiri 16(4): 36–55.
- Andresen, Lembit. 2003. Eesti kooli ajalugu: Algusest kuni 1940. aastani [The history of the Estonian schools: From the beginning to 1940]. Tallinn: Avita.
- Atlas of European Values. 2021. European Values Studies. Available at: https://www.atlasofeuropeanvalues.eu/maptool.html (accessed May 18, 2021).
- Aunver, Jakob. 1961. Aastate kestes: Kiriku- ja kultuuriloolisi vaatlusi 1924–1959 [During the years: Observations on church and culture 1924–1959]. Stockholm: Eesti Vaimulik Raamat.
- Becker, Sascha O., Markus Nagler, and Ludger Woessmann. 2017. Education and religious participation: City-level evidence from Germany's secularization period 1890–1930. Journal of Economic Growth 22(3): 273–311.
- Becker, Sascha O. and Ludger Woessmann. 2013. Not the opium of the people: Income and secularization in a panel of Prussian counties. American Economic Review 103(3): 539–44.
- Bivand, Roger S., Edzer Pebesma, and Virgilio Gomez-Rubio. 2013. Applied spatial data analysis with R. New York: Springer. http://www.asdar-book.org/.
10.1007/978-1-4614-7618-4 Google Scholar
- Fischer, Manfred M. and Jinfeng Wang. 2011. Spatial data analysis: Models, methods and techniques. SpringerBriefs in Regional Science. Berlin Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.
- Graf, Mati. 2000. Parteid Eesti Vabariigis 1918–1934 [Parties in the Republic of Estonia 1917–1934]. Tallinn: TRÜ Kirjastus.
- Gortfelder, Mark. 2020. Fertility modernisation in Estonia: An analysis of individual-level data for women born 1850–1899. Ph.D. Dissertation, Tallinn University.
- Gortfelder, Mark. 2021. Usuõpetuse rahvahääletuse tulemusi mõjutanud tegurid [The factors influencing the results of the referendum on religious studies]. Tuna: Ajalookultuuri ajakiri 23(1): 66–81.
- Hering, Rainer. 2011. Die Kirchen als Schlüssel zur politischen Macht? Archiv für Sozialgeschichte 51: 237–66.
- Iannaccone, Laurence R. 1998. Introduction to the economics of religion. Journal of Economic Literature 36(3): 1465–92.
- Jansen, Ea. 2007. Eestlane muutuvas ajas: Seisusühiskonnast kodanikuühiskonda [The Estonian in a changing era: From estate society to civil society. ]. Tartu: Eesti Ajalooarhiiv.
- Katus, Kalev. 1989. Eesti demograafiline areng läbi sajandite [Demographic development of Estonia throughout the centuries]. Tallinn: Eesti Kõrgkoolidevaheline Demouuringute Keskus.
- Karjahärm, Toomas. 2013. 1905. aasta Eestis: Massiliikumine ja vägivald maal [1905 in Estonia: Mass movement and violence in the countryside]. Tallinn: Argo.
- Karjahärm, Toomas and Väino Sirk. 1997. Eesti haritlaskonna kujunemine ja ideed, 1850–1917 [The development and ideas of the Estonian intelligentsia, 1850–1917]. Tallinn: Eesti Entsüklopeediakirjastus.
- Kasekamp, Andres. 2010. A history of the Baltic countries. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
10.1007/978-0-230-36450-9 Google Scholar
- Kruus, Hans. 1930. Talurahva käärimine Lõuna-Eestis XIX sajandi 40-ndail aastail [The ferment in South-Estonia in the 1840s]. Tartu: Eesti Kirjanduse Selts.
- Laar, Anton. 1923. Usuõpetuse rahvahääletus ja vähemuskirikud [The referendum on religious studies and minority churches]. Uus Elu 5(2): 4.
- Lust, Kersti. 2020. How permanent were farms in the manorial system? Changes of farm occupancy in the nineteenth-century Russian Baltic provinces of Estland and Livland. Continuity and Change 35(2): 215–43.
- Marradi, Alberto. 1976. Italy's referendum on divorce: Survey and ecological evidence analyzed. European Journal of Political Research 4(1): 115–39.
- Mcleod, Hugh. 2015. Christianity and nationalism in nineteenth-century Europe. International Journal for the Study of the Christian Church 15(1): 7–22.
- Mihkelson, Marko. 1992. Punane terror ja kirik Eestis 1918–1919 [The Red Terror and the church in Estonia 1918–1919]. Looming 94(11): 1545–52.
- Norkus, Zenonas and Jurgita Markevičiūtė. 2020. New estimation of the gross domestic product in Baltic countries in 1913–1938. Cliometrica Published online.
- Pace, Roderick. 2012. Growing secularisation in a catholic society: The divorce referendum of 28 May 2011 in Malta. South European Society and Politics 17(4): 573–89.
- Pew Research Center. 2018. The age gap in religion around the world. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center.
- Protocols of the Voting Stations. 1920. Eesti Rahvusarhiiv, Estonia, 27–30 May [ Elections to the I Riigikogu, Folders 12–21]. Tallinn, Estonia: Estonian National Archives.
- Qvostrup, Matt. ed. 2014. Referendums around the world: The continued growth of direct democracy. Basingstoke: Palgrace Macmillan.
- Radkey, Oliver H. 1990. Russia goes to the polls: The election to the All-Russian Constituent Assembly, 1917. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
- Raun, Toivo U. 1979. The development of Estonian literacy in the 18th and 19th centuries. Journal of Baltic Studies 10(2): 115–26.
10.1080/01629777900000151 Google Scholar
- ———. 2002. Estonia and the Estonians. Stanford: Hoover Press.
- Reiman, H. 1935. Rahvastiku tööharud ja ühiskondlik kihistus Eestis [The employment fields and the societal strata of the population in Estonia]. Statistika Kuukiri 13(6): 286–90.
- Riigi Statistika Keskbüroo. ed. 1923a. Esimene rahvahääletus Eestis [The first referendum in Estonia]. Statistika Kuukiri 2(3): 58–76.
- ———. 1923b. II Riigikogu valimised: 5.-7. mail 1923 [The election of the II Riigikogu: 5th to 7th of May. Tallinn, Riigi Statistika Keskbüroo.
- ———. 1924a. 1922 a. üldrahvalugemise andmed, Vihk 1: Rahva demograafiline koosseis ja korteriolud Eestis [The results of the 1922 census, Volume 1: The demographic composition of the population and living conditions in Estonia]. Tallinn: Riigi Statistika Keskbüroo.
- ———. 1924b. 1922. a üldrahvalugemise andmed (vihud IV–XI): Maakondade tulemused [The results of the 1922 census, Volumes 4–11: The results of the counties]. Tallinn: Riigi Statistika Keskbüroo.
- ———. 1934. Valdade rahvastik [The population of rural municipalities]. Tallinn: Riigi Statistika Keskbüroo
- Robinson, William. 1950. Ecological correlations and the behavior of individuals. American Sociological Review 15(3): 351–57.
- Rohtmets, Priit. 2016. Kirikuelu Eestis Esimese maailmasõja ajal [Religious life in Estonia during the First World War]. In Esimene maailmasõda ja Eesti II, edited by Tõnu Tannberg. Tartu: Eesti Rahvusarhiiv.
- ———. 2018. Riik ja usulised ühendused [The state and religious associations. ]. Tallinn: Siseministeerium.
- Rosenberg, Tiit. 2013. Eesti 1919. aasta maareform: Võrdlusjooni Ida- ja Kesk-Euroopa maadega [The 1919 land reform of Estonia: Comparisons with the countries of Central and Eastern Europe]. Künnivaod: Uurimusi Eesti 18.–20. sajandi agraarajaloost 401–17.
- Saard, Riho. 2007. Eestlane luterluse ja õigeusu vahel [The Estonian between Lutheranism and Orthodoxy]. Usk ja elu 4: 117–34.
- ———. 2008. Eesti Apostlik-Õigeusu Kiriku algusaastad [The first years of Estonian Apostelic-Orthodox Church]. Akadeemia 20(7): 1543–82.
- ———. 2010.Eesti evangeelse luterliku kiriku sünniloost [On the birth of the Estonian Evangelical Lutheran Church]. Akadeemia 22(12): 2177−202.
- ———. 2016. Kiriku, usu ja ateismi küsimus Eduard Vilde elus [The question of Church, faith and atheism in the life of Eduard Vilde]. Looming 118(6): 856−72.
- ———. 2018. Ristitud eestlane: Kristluse ajalugu Eestis keskajast tänapäevani [Christined Estonian: The history of Christianity in Estonia from middle ages to the present]. Tallinn: Argo.
- ———. 2020. Härraskirikust rahvakirikuks: Eesti rahvusest luterliku vaimulikkonna kujunemine ja Eesti Evangeelse Luterliku Kiriku sünd [From master's church to people's church: The development of the Estonian clergy and the birth of the Estonian Evangelical Lutheran Church. ]. Tallinn: Argo.
- Siilivask, Karl. 1990. Socio-economic development of the Baltic countries at the beginning of the 20th century. In The Baltic countries 1900–1914, edited by Aleksander Loit, pp. 229–44. Stockholm.
- Swiss votes. 2020. https://swissvotes.ch/page/home (accessed December 11, 2020).
- Vahtre, Lauri. 2020a. Eesti vabadussõja ajalugu. I [The history of the Estonian War of Independence: I]. Tallinn: Varrak.
- ———. 2020b. Eesti vabadussõja ajalugu. II. [The history of the Estonian War of Independence: II]. Tallinn: Varrak.
- Valge, Jaak. 2006. Breaking away from Russia: Economic stabilization in Estonia, 1918–1924. Stockholm: Stockholm Universitet.
- ———. 2014. Punased. I. [The Reds. I.]. Tallinn: Rahvusarhiiv.
- ———. 2016. Tee esimese rahvahääletuseni [The road to the first referendum]. Tuna: ajalookultuuri ajakiri 18(4): 60–77.
- Valk, Pille. 1997. Ühest heledast laigust Eesti kooli ajaloos: Usuõpetus Eesti koolides aastatel 1918–1940 [On an untouched topic in the history of Estonian schools: Religious studies on Estonian schools in 1918–1940]. Tallinn: Logos.