Short-Selling Threats and Corporate Tax Avoidance: Evidence From Regulation SHO
Corresponding Author
Johan Maharjan
Lally School of Management, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, New York, USA
Correspondence: Johan Maharjan ([email protected])
Search for more papers by this authorThomas Omer
School of Accountancy, University of Nebraska at Lincoln, Lincoln, Nebraska, USA
Search for more papers by this authorYijiang Zhao
Kogod School of Business, American University, Washington, District of Columbia, USA
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Johan Maharjan
Lally School of Management, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, New York, USA
Correspondence: Johan Maharjan ([email protected])
Search for more papers by this authorThomas Omer
School of Accountancy, University of Nebraska at Lincoln, Lincoln, Nebraska, USA
Search for more papers by this authorYijiang Zhao
Kogod School of Business, American University, Washington, District of Columbia, USA
Search for more papers by this authorFunding: The authors received no specific funding for this work.
ABSTRACT
We examine the effect of short-selling threats on tax avoidance. To establish causality, we exploit a quasi-experimental setting where the US Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC's) Regulation SHO (Reg SHO) pilot program relaxed an essential short-selling constraint for a sample of NYSE-listed pilot stocks, thus causing an exogenous increase in short-selling threats in these stocks. Using quantile regression, we find that the relation between tax avoidance and short-selling threats is significantly negative (positive) when tax avoidance is very high (low). This effect is observable for more opaque firms, firms whose managers have more job security concerns, and firms whose managers’ equity portfolios are more sensitive to share prices. Our results suggest that short sellers’ scrutiny of hidden agency problems underlying extreme tax avoidance would dampen stock price inflation and reduce managers’ welfare, thus motivating managers to reduce extreme tax avoidance in the first place.
Open Research
Data Availability Statement
Data are available on request from the authors.
References
- Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP. 2004. "SEC Revises Short-Sale Rules With Adoption of Regulation SHO." Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP. https://www.akingump.com/a/web/1058/692.pdf.
- Alexander, G. J., and M. A. Peterson. 1999. “Short Selling on the New York Stock Exchange and the Effects of the Uptick Rule.” Journal of Financial Intermediation 8, no. 1–2: 90–116.
- Alexander, G. J., and M. A. Peterson. 2008. “The Effect of Price Tests on Trader Behavior and Market Quality: An Analysis of Reg SHO.” Journal of Financial Markets 11, no. 1: 84–111.
- Ali, A., and W. Zhang. 2015. “CEO Tenure and Earnings Management.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 59, no. 1: 60–79.
- Anderson, R. C., A. Duru, and D. M. Reeb. 2009. “Founders, Heirs, and Corporate Opacity in the United States.” Journal of Financial Economics 92, no. 2: 205–222.
- Armstrong, C. S., J. L. Blouin, A. D. Jagolinzer, and D. F. Larcker. 2015. “Corporate Governance, Incentives, and Tax Avoidance.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 60, no. 1: 1–17.
- Asquith, P., P. A. Pathak, and J. R. Ritter. 2005. “Short Interest, Institutional Ownership, and Stock Returns.” Journal of Financial Economics 78, no. 2: 243–276.
- Badertscher, B. A., S. P. Katz, and S. O. Rego. 2013. “The Separation of Ownership and Control and Corporate Tax Avoidance.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 56, no. 2–3: 228–250.
- Baginski, S. P., J. L. Campbell, L. A. Hinson, and D. S. Koo. 2018. “Do Career Concerns Affect the Delay of Bad News Disclosure?” Accounting Review 93, no. 2: 61–95.
- Balakrishnan, K., J. L. Blouin, and W. R. Guay. 2019. “Tax Aggressiveness and Corporate Transparency.” Accounting Review 94, no. 1: 45–69.
- Bebchuk, L., A. Cohen, and A. Ferrell. 2009. “What Matters in Corporate Governance?” Review of Financial Studies 22, no. 2: 783–827.
- Beber, A., and M. Pagano. 2013. “Short-Selling Bans Around the World: Evidence From the 2007–09 Crisis.” Journal of Finance 68, no. 1: 343–381.
- Black, B. S., H. Desai, K. Litvak, W. Yoo, and J. J. Yu. 2019. “ The Reg SHO Reanalysis Project: Reconsidering of Fang, Huang and Karpoff (2016) on Reg SHO and Earnings Management.” Working paper, Northwestern University.
- Black, B. S., H. Desai, K. Litvak, W. Yoo, and J. J. Yu. 2020. “ Specification Choice in Randomized and Natural Experiments: Lessons From the Regulation SHO Experiment.” Working paper, Northwestern University.
- Blouin, J. 2014. “Defining and Measuring Tax Planning Aggressiveness.” National Tax Journal 67, no. 4: 875–899.
- Boehmer, E., C. M. Jones, and X. Zhang. 2020. “Potential Pilot Problems: Treatment Spillovers in Financial Regulatory Experiments.” Journal of Financial Economics 135, no. 1: 68–87.
- Boehmer, E., and J. Wu. 2013. “Short Selling and the Price Discovery Process.” Review of Financial Studies 26, no. 2: 287–322.
- Bris, A., W. N. Goetzmann, and N. Zhu. 2007. “Efficiency and the Bear: Short Sales and Markets Around the World.” Journal of Finance 62, no. 3: 1029–1079.
- Chang, E. C., J. W. Cheng, and Y. Yu. 2007. “Short-Sales Constraints and Price Discovery: Evidence From the Hong Kong Market.” Journal of Finance 62, no. 5: 2097–2121.
- Chang, E. C., T. C. Lin, and X. Ma. 2019. “Does Short-Selling Threat Discipline Managers in Mergers and Acquisitions Decisions?” Journal of Accounting and Economics 68, no. 1: 101223.
- Chang, Y. C., M. Huang, Y. S. Su, and K. Tseng. 2021. “Short-Termist CEO Compensation in Speculative Markets: A Controlled Experiment.” Contemporary Accounting Research 38, no. 3: 2105–2156.
- Chen, S., X. Chen, Q. Cheng, and T. Shevlin. 2010. “Are Family Firms More Tax Aggressive Than Non-Family Firms?” Journal of Financial Economics 95, no. 1: 41–61.
- Chen, J., H. Hong, and J. C. Stein. 2002. “Breadth of Ownership and Stock Returns.” Journal of Financial Economics 66, no. 2–3: 171–205.
- Chen, T., and C. Lin. 2017. “Does Information Asymmetry Affect Corporate Tax Aggressiveness?” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 52, no. 5: 2053–2081.
- Chen, S., Y. Huang, N. Li, and T. Shevlin. 2019. “How Does Quasi-Indexer Ownership Affect Corporate Tax Planning?” Journal of Accounting and Economics 67, no. 2–3: 278–296.
- Chen, Y., R. Ge, H. Louis, and L. Zolotoy. 2019. “Stock Liquidity and Corporate Tax Avoidance.” Review of Accounting Studies 24, no. 1: 309–340.
- Chen, X., Q. Cheng, T. Luo, and H. Yue. 2020. “Short Sellers and Long-Run Management Forecasts.” Contemporary Accounting Research 37, no. 2: 802–828.
- Chen, H., D. Yang, X. Zhang, and N. Zhou. 2020. “The Moderating Role of Internal Control in Tax Avoidance: Evidence From a COSO-Based Internal Control Index in China.” Journal of the American Taxation Association 42, no. 1: 23–55.
- Chen, R., S. El Ghoul, O. Guedhami, H. Wang, and Y. Yang. 2022. “Corporate Governance and Tax Avoidance: Evidence From US Cross-Listing.” Accounting Review 97, no. 7: 49–78.
- Cheng, C. A., H. H. Huang, Y. Li, and J. Stanfield. 2012. “The Effect of Hedge Fund Activism on Corporate Tax Avoidance.” Accounting Review 87, no. 5: 1493–1526.
- Christophe, S. E., M. G. Ferri, and J. J. Angel. 2004. “Short-Selling Prior to Earnings Announcements.” Journal of Finance 59, no. 4: 1845–1876.
- Christophe, S. E., M. G. Ferri, and J. Hsieh. 2010. “Informed Trading Before Analyst Downgrades: Evidence From Short Sellers.” Journal of Financial Economics 95, no. 1: 85–106.
- Chu, Y., D. Hirshleifer, and L. Ma. 2020. “The Causal Effect of Limits to Arbitrage on Asset Pricing Anomalies.” Journal of Finance 75, no. 5: 2631–2672.
- Chung, S. G., B. W. Goh, J. Lee, and T. Shevlin. 2019. “Corporate Tax Aggressiveness and Insider Trading.” Contemporary Accounting Research 36, no. 1: 230–258.
- Chyz, J. A., and F. B. Gaertner. 2018. “Can Paying “Too Much” or “Too Little” Tax Contribute to Forced CEO Turnover?” Accounting Review 93, no. 1: 103–130.
- Coles, J. L., N. D. Daniel, and L. Naveen. 2006. “Managerial Incentives and Risk-Taking.” Journal of Financial Economics 79, no. 2: 431–468.
- Cook, K. A., W. J. Moser, and T. C. Omer. 2017. “Tax Avoidance and Ex Ante Cost of Capital.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 44, no. 7–8: 1109–1136.
- Cox, C. 2007. "Speech by SEC Chairman: Address to the 2007 Corporate Council Institute." https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/2007/spch030807cc.htm.
- De Angelis, D., G. Grullon, and S. Michenaud. 2017. “The Effects of Short-Selling Threats on Incentive Contracts: Evidence From an Experiment.” Review of Financial Studies 30, no. 5: 1627–1659.
- Dechow, P., A. P. Hutton, L. Meulbroek, and R. G. Sloan. 2001. “Short-Sellers, Fundamental Analysis, and Stock Returns.” Journal of Financial Economics 61, no. 1: 77–106.
- DeMott, D. A. 2005. “The Discrete Roles of General Counsel.” Fordham Law Review 74: 955–988.
- Desai, H., S. Krishnamurthy, and K. Venkataraman. 2006. “Do Short Sellers Target Firms With Poor Earnings Quality? Evidence From Earnings Restatements.” Review of Accounting Studies 11, no. 1: 71–90.
- Desai, H., K. Ramesh, S. R. Thiagarajan, and B. V. Balachandran. 2002. “An Investigation of the Informational Role of Short Interest in the NASDAQ Market.” Journal of Finance 57, no. 5: 2263–2287.
- Desai, M. A. 2005. “The Degradation of Reported Corporate Profits.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 19, no. 4: 171–192.
- Desai, M. A., and D. Dharmapala. 2006. “Corporate Tax Avoidance and High-Powered Incentives.” Journal of Financial Economics 79, no. 1: 145–179.
- Diamond, D. W., and R. E. Verrecchia. 1987. “Constraints on Short-Selling and Asset Price Adjustment to Private Information.” Journal of Financial Economics 18, no. 2: 277–311.
- Diether, K. B., K. H. Lee, and I. M. Werner. 2009a. “It's SHO Time! Short-Sale Price Tests and Market Quality.” Journal of Finance 64, no. 1: 37–73.
- Diether, K. B., K. H. Lee, and I. M. Werner. 2009b. “Short-Sale Strategies and Return Predictability.” Review of Financial Studies 22, no. 2: 575–607.
- Dorsey & Whitney LLP. 2004. SEC Adopts New Short Sale Rules. Minneapolis: Dorsey & Whitney LLP. https://www.martindale.com/matter/asr-79914.pdf.
- Drake, M. S., J. N. Myers, L. A. Myers, and M. D. Stuart. 2015. “Short Sellers and the Informativeness of Stock Prices With Respect to Future Earnings.” Review of Accounting Studies 20, no. 2: 747–774.
- Drake, M. S., L. Rees, and E. P. Swanson. 2011. “Should Investors Follow the Prophets or the Bears? Evidence on the Use of Public Information by Analysts and Short Sellers.” Accounting Review 86, no. 1: 101–130.
- Dyreng, S. D., B. P. Lindsey, and J. R. Thornock. 2013. “Exploring the Role Delaware Plays as a Domestic Tax Haven.” Journal of Financial Economics 108, no. 3: 751–772.
- Dyreng, S. D., M. Hanlon, and E. L. Maydew. 2019. “When Does Tax Avoidance Result in Tax Uncertainty?” Accounting Review 94, no. 2: 179–203.
- Edmans, A., and G. Manso. 2011. “Governance Through Trading and Intervention: A Theory of Multiple Blockholders.” Review of Financial Studies 24, no. 7: 2395–2428.
- Edwards, A., C. Schwab, and T. Shevlin. 2016. “Financial Constraints and Cash Tax Savings.” Accounting Review 91, no. 3: 859–881.
- Fang, V. W., A. H. Huang, and J. M. Karpoff. 2016. “Short Selling and Earnings Management: A Controlled Experiment.” Journal of Finance 71, no. 3: 1251–1294.
- Fang, V. W., A. H. Huang, and J. M. Karpoff. 2019. “ Reply to “the Reg SHO Reanalysis Project: Reconsidering Fang, Huang and Karpoff (2016) on Reg SHO and Earnings Management” by Black et al.” Working paper, SSRN.
- Figlewski, S. 1981. “The Informational Effects of Restrictions on Short Sales: Some Empirical Evidence.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 16, no. 4: 463–476.
- Gibbons, R., and K. J. Murphy. 1992. “Optimal Incentive Contracts in the Presence of Career Concerns: Theory and Evidence.” Journal of Political Economy 100, no. 3: 468–505.
- Gillan, S. L., J. C. Hartzell, and R. Parrino. 2009. “Explicit Versus Implicit Contracts: Evidence From CEO Employment Agreements.” Journal of Finance 64, no. 4: 1629–1655.
- Glaeser, S., and W. R. Guay. 2017. “Identification and Generalizability in Accounting Research: A Discussion of Christensen, Floyd, Liu, and Maffett (2017).” Journal of Accounting and Economics 64: 305–312.
- Goh, B. W., J. Lee, C. Y. Lim, and T. Shevlin. 2016. “The Effect of Corporate Tax Avoidance on the Cost of Equity.” Accounting Review 91, no. 6: 1647–1670.
- Graham, J. R., M. Hanlon, T. Shevlin, and N. Shroff. 2014. “Incentives for Tax Planning and Avoidance: Evidence From the Field.” Accounting Review 89, no. 3: 991–1023.
- Grullon, G., S. Michenaud, and J. P. Weston. 2015. “The Real Effects of Short-Selling Constraints.” Review of Financial Studies 28, no. 6: 1737–1767.
- Guo, S. Y., S. Chi, and K. A. Cook. 2018. “Short Selling and Corporate Tax Avoidance.” Advances in Taxation 25: 1–28.
- Hanlon, M., and S. Heitzman. 2010. “A Review of Tax Research.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 50, no. 2–3: 127–178.
- Hanlon, M., and J. Slemrod. 2009. “What Does Tax Aggressiveness Signal? Evidence From Stock Price Reactions to News About Tax Shelter Involvement.” Journal of Public Economics 93, no. 1–2: 126–141.
- Heath, D., M. C. Ringgenberg, M. Samadi, and I. M. Werner. 2023. “Reusing Natural Experiments.” Journal of Finance 78, no. 4: 2329–2364.
- Holmström, B., and J. Tirole. 1993. “Market Liquidity and Performance Monitoring.” Journal of Political Economy 101, no. 4: 678–709.
- Hoopes, J. L., D. Mescall, and J. A. Pittman. 2012. “Do IRS Audits Deter Corporate Tax Avoidance?” Accounting Review 87, no. 5: 1603–1639.
- Hope, O. K., D. Hu, and W. Zhao. 2017. “Third-Party Consequences of Short-Selling Threats: The Case of Auditor Behavior.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 63, no. 2–3: 479–498.
- Hung, M., and K. R. Subramanyam. 2007. “Financial Statement Effects of Adopting International Accounting Standards: The Case of Germany.” Review of Accounting Studies 12: 623–657.
- Jain, A., P. K. Jain, T. H. McInish, and M. McKenzie. 2013. “Worldwide Reach of Short Selling Regulations.” Journal of Financial Economics 109, no. 1: 177–197.
- Jin, Z., B. Lin, X. Yang, and T. Zhang. 2018. “Accounting Conservatism and Short Selling: Evidence From China.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 45, no. 3–4: 352–394.
- Karpoff, J. M., and X. Lou. 2010. “Short Sellers and Financial Misconduct.” Journal of Finance 65, no. 5: 1879–1913.
- Khan, M., S. Srinivasan, and L. Tan. 2017. “Institutional Ownership and Corporate Tax Avoidance: New Evidence.” Accounting Review 92, no. 2: 101–122.
- Khan, S., S. J. Park, S. Veliotis, and J. K. Wald. 2023. “Director and Officer Liability and Corporate Tax Avoidance.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 50, no. 7–8: 1338–1371.
- Kim, J. B., Y. Li, and L. Zhang. 2011. “Corporate Tax Avoidance and Stock Price Crash Risk: Firm-Level Analysis.” Journal of Financial Economics 100, no. 3: 639–662.
- Kubick, T. R., D. P. Lynch, M. A. Mayberry, and T. C. Omer. 2016. “The Effects of Regulatory Scrutiny on Tax Avoidance: An Examination of SEC Comment Letters.” Accounting Review 91, no. 6: 1751–1780.
- La Porta, R. L., F. Lopez-de-Silanes, A. Shleifer, and R. W. Vishny. 1998. “Law and Finance.” Journal of Political Economy 106, no. 6: 1113–1155.
- La Porta, R., F. Lopez-de-Silanes, A. Shleifer, and R. Vishny. 2000. “Investor Protection and Corporate Governance.” Journal of Financial Economics 58, no. 1–2: 3–27.
- Li, Y., and L. Zhang. 2015. “Short Selling Pressure, Stock Price Behavior, and Management Forecast Precision: Evidence From a Natural Experiment.” Journal of Accounting Research 53, no. 1: 79–117.
- Li, Q., E. L. Maydew, R. H. Willis, and L. Xu. 2023. “Taxes and Director Independence: Evidence From Board Reforms Worldwide.” Review of Accounting Studies 28, no. 2: 910–957.
- Liggio, C. D. 1997. “The Changing Role of Corporate Counsel.” Emory Law Journal 46: 1201–1222.
- Litvak, K., B. S. Black, and W. Yoo. 2019. “ The SEC's Busted Randomized Experiment: What Can and Cannot be Learned.” Working paper, Northwestern University.
- Luo, J., X. Ni, and G. G. Tian. 2020. “Short Selling and Corporate Tax Avoidance: Insights From a Financial Constraint View.” Pacific-Basin Finance Journal 61: 101323.
- Macey, J. R., M. Mitchell, and J. Netter. 1989. “Restrictions on Short Sales: An Analysis of the Uptick Rule and Its Role in View of the October 1987 Stock Market Crash.” Cornell Law Review 74: 799–835.
- Massa, M., B. Zhang, and H. Zhang. 2015. “The Invisible Hand of Short Selling: Does Short Selling Discipline Earnings Management?” Review of Financial Studies 28, no. 6: 1701–1736.
- McGuire, S. T., D. Wang, and R. J. Wilson. 2014. “Dual Class Ownership and Tax Avoidance.” Accounting Review 89, no. 4: 1487–1516.
- Miller, E. M. 1977. “Risk, Uncertainty, and Divergence of Opinion.” Journal of Finance 32, no. 4: 1151–1168.
- Mills, L. F. 1996. “Corporate Tax Compliance and Financial Reporting.” National Tax Journal 49, no. 3: 421–435.
- Mills, L. F. 1998. “Book-Tax Differences and Internal Revenue Service Adjustments.” Journal of Accounting Research 36, no. 2: 343–356.
- Pae, S., C. J. Song, and A. C. Yi. 2016. “Career Concerns and Management Earnings Guidance.” Contemporary Accounting Research 33, no. 3: 1172–1198.
- Park, K. 2017. “Earnings Quality and Short Selling: Evidence From Real Earnings Management in the United States.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 44, no. 9–10: 1214–1240.
- Phillips, J. D. 2003. “Corporate Tax-Planning Effectiveness: the Role of Compensation-Based Incentives.” Accounting Review 78, no. 3: 847–874.
- Saporito, B. 2008. "Are Short Sellers to Blame for the Financial Crisis?" http://content.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1842499,00.html.
- SEC. 1999. "SEC Concept Release: Short Sales." SEC. https://www.sec.gov/rules/concept/34-42037.htm.
- SEC. 2007. “ Economic Analysis of the Short Sale Price Restrictions Under the Regulation SHO Pilot.” Office of Economic Analysis, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
- Wang, K., R. Wang, K. J. Wei, B. Zhang, and Y. Zhou. 2022. “Insider Sales Under the Threat of Short Sellers: New Hypothesis and New Tests.” Accounting Review 97, no. 2: 427–451.
- Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP. 2004. "Regulation SHO: SEC Rewrites Short Sale Locate and Delivery Requirements and Suspends Price Test for Pilot Program Securities." Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP. https://www.wilmerhale.com/-/media/files/wilmerhale_shared_content/files/editorial/publication/securities-08-09-04.pdf.
- Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP. 2004. "SEC Adopts Regulation SHO Governing Short Sales." Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP. https://www.willkie.com/-/media/files/publications/2004/08/sec-adopts-regulation-sho-governing-short-sales/files/regulationshopdf/fileattachment/regulation_sho.pdf.