The rights of blood recipients should supersede any asserted rights of blood donors
J. P. Brooks,
Corresponding Author
J. P. Brooks
University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, OK, USA
Correspondence: Jay P. Brooks, Director of Transfusion Medicine, 940 Stanton l. Young Blvd., Room 451, University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73104, USA E-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorJ. P. Brooks,
Corresponding Author
J. P. Brooks
University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, OK, USA
Correspondence: Jay P. Brooks, Director of Transfusion Medicine, 940 Stanton l. Young Blvd., Room 451, University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73104, USA E-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Some gay men have argued that the laboratory testing of blood is so accurate that continued deferrals based upon sexual activity are unnecessary and unjust. They also assert that they have a right to donate blood. There has been much debate over altering the rule barring donation from men who have had sex with other men since 1977, with blood organizations disagreeing over the best course of action. Two studies have indicated that changing the rule would increase the risk of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) transmission. This dilemma is part of a broader issue, namely: what are the responsibilities of blood services to blood donors and recipients? Blood services should base decisions regarding donor suitability on science rather than on their donors’ desires. Blood services must recognize that the rights of blood recipients should supersede any asserted rights of blood donors.
References
- 1 Silts RS: And the Band Played On, edn 1. New York, St Martin's Press, 1987
- 2 Roehr B: The gift of life: gay men and US blood donation policy. [Article on the Internet] 2000 [cited 2003 June 3 [about 7 p.]. Available from: http://www.libertyeducationforum.org/downloads/2004/1h_whtpa_pbl00.pdf
- 3 Matthews CZ: Gay man denied right to give blood [letter]. The Current Online. [Online Weekly Newspaper of the University of Missouri at Saint Louis] 2003 September 22 [cited 2004 May 24 [about 4 p.]. Available from .http://www.thecurrentonline.com/news/2003/09/22/Opinions/Discriminating. For Charity-473356.shtml
- 4 Jennelle B: Bleeding for a change. The Harvard Crimson Online. 2002 December 4 [2004 May 23]. [about 2 p.]. Available from: http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=255627
- 5 Tatchell P: Gay blood ban is homophobic. [article on homepage on the Internet] 1996 [cited 2004 May 24 [about 3 p.]. Available from: http://www.petertatchell.net/
- 6 Garza E: Blood shortages lead some to question ban on gay donors. The Daily Texan [ online edition] 2001 July 25 [cited 2004 May 23 [about 2 p.]. Available from: http://tspweb02.tsp.utexas.edu/webarchive/07-2501/PF2001072501_s03_Excluding.html
- 7 Tatchell P: Bloody homophobia – drop the ban on gay blood donors. Outrage [serial on the Internet]. 1996 May 28 [cited 2004 April 4]. Available from: http://outrage.nabumedia.com/pressrelease.asp?ID=99
- 8 Hilts PJ: Transfusions infect two in Florida with HIV. The New York Times [ online edition]. 2002 July 20 [cited 2004 June 3. Available from: http://newyorktimes.com/
- 9 Anon: HIV contracted from donated blood. CBSNEWS.com. 2002 February 9 [cited 2004 June 3] Available from: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/ 2002/02/09/national/main328872.shtml
- 10 Curiel J: Gay male blood donor ban called unfair – S.F. supervisor wants FDA to change policy. San Francisco Chronicle [ online edition] 2000 January 7 [cited 2004 June 3]. Available from: http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2000/01/07/MN74399.DTL
- 11 AABB: AABB Advocates Change for Policy Regarding Men Who Have Had Sex with Another Man Even One Time Since 1977. American Association Of Blood Banks Press Release 2000 September 14 [cited 2004 May 23 Available from: http://www.aabb.org/Pressroom/Press_Releases/pr091400.htm
- 12
Brittenham GM,
Klein HG,
Kushner JP,
Ajioka RS:
Preserving the national blood supply.
Hematology
2001; 1: 422–432
10.1182/asheducation-2001.1.422 Google Scholar
- 13 Van Der Poel C, Seifried E, Schaasberg W: Paying for blood donations: still a risk? Vox Sang 2002; 83: 285–293
- 14 Anon: International conference demands end to paid blood donations. AABB Weekly Report 2004 April; 16: 3–4
- 15 Titmuss RM: The Gift Relationship. New York, Random House, 1971
- 16 Soldan K, Sinka K. Evaluation of the de-selection of men who have had sex with men from blood donation in England. Vox Sang 2003; 84: 265–273
- 17 Heineman ZR: BOND members urged to participate in blood drive. The Harvard Crimson Online. 2001 September 14 [cited 2003 September 17][about 2 p.]. Available from: http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=120959
- 18 Anon: Blood drive canned due to ‘gay discrimination.’ WorldNetDaily [serial on the Internet] 2003 May 21 [cited 2004 June 3] Available from: http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=32688
- 19 Charton S: Sorority Apologizes After Members Were Urged to Lie for Blood Competition. Associated Press [ online edition]. 2004 April 13 [cited 2004 May 24][about 1 p.]. Available from: http://www.ap.org/
- 20 Semelka S, Smythe C: E-mail calls for lying at blood drive. Columbia Missourian [ online edition][cited 2004 May 22][about 2 p.]. Available from: http://www.jour.missouri.edu/
- 21 Anon: Record blood drive. Columbia Daily Tribune [ online edition] 1997 Apr 11 [cited 2004 May 22] Available from: http://archive.columbiatribune.com//apr/19970411news04.htm
- 22 Anon: Red Cross discards nearly 100 units of blood in wake of sorority snafu. ABC Newsletter 2004 April; 16: 1–2
- 23 Link D: Should gay men be allowed to donate blood? [online article]. The Body: GMHC Treatment Issues [serial on the Internet]. [about 8 p.] 2000 Nov/Dec Dec [cited 2004 May 22]. Available from: http://www.thebody.com/gmhc/issues/novdec00/blood.html
- 24 Germain M, Remis RS, Delage G: The risks and benefits of accepting men who have had sex with men as blood donors. Transfusion 2003; 43: 25–33
- 25 Dumont LJ, AuBuchon JP. Making risk statements stick. Vox Sang 2002; 83: 199–203
- 26 Jackson BR, Busch MP, Stramer SL, AuBuchon JP: The cost-effectiveness of NAT for HIV, HCV, and HBV in whole-blood donations. Transfusion 2003; 43: 721–729
- 27 Marshall DA, Kleinman SH, Wong JP, AuBuchon JP, Grima DT, Kullin NA, Weinstein MC: Cost-effectiveness of nucleic acid test screening of volunteer blood donations for hepatitis B, hepatitis C and human immunodeficiency virus in the United States. Vox Sang 2004; 86: 28–40
- 28 Smith JC: Drive spurs petition. Washington Square News [ online edition][cited 2004 June 2]. [about 1 p.]. Available from: http://www.nyunews.com/news/campus/5958.html
- 29 Klingeberger A: FDA denies blood-drive petition. Washington Square News [ online edition]. 2004 Apr 27 [cited 2004 June 2 [about 1 p.]. Available from: http://www.nyunews.com/news/campus/7409.html
- 30 Anon: FDA denies NYU petition to change ban on blood donation by gay men. ABC Newsletter 2004 May 21: 5–7
- 31 Anon: Blood drives. University of California Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Intersex Association [homepage on the Internet]. [cited 2004 May 4]. Available from: http://www.uclgbtia.org/blood.html
- 32 Anon: School board cancels blood drive. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation [online] 2004 March 18 [cited 2004 May 4]. [about 1 p.]. Available from: http://montreal.cbc.ca/regional/servlet/View?filename=qc_20041803
- 33 Anon: Students at Oregon University cancel blood drive to protest policy on gays. Associated Press [ online edition]. 2003 May 19 [2004 May 14]. [about 1 p.]. Available from: http://www.ap.org/
- 34 Publicover B: York University bans blood donor clinic. The Peak [ online edition]. 1998 October 19 [cited 2004 May 4][about 2 p.]. Available from: http://www.peak.sfu.ca/the-peak/98-3/issue7/blood.html
- 35 Anon: University says blood drive biased against gays. FoxNews.com 2004 March 29 [cited 2004 May 27] Available from: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,115376html
- 36 Grantham C: What's wrong with banning gay blood donors? Outlet Radio Network [serial on the Internet]. [cited 2004 June 3][about 1 p.]. Available from: http://www.christianandvince.com/0702weblog.htm
- 37 Morley C, Power L: Blood Donation Policy. Terrence Higgins Trust [homepage on the Internet][cited 2004 June 3][about 3 p.]. Available from: http://www.tht.org.uk/policy/policy_pdfs/blood.pdf
- 38 Anon: Associated Press: South African gays win right to donate blood. Associated Press [ online edition]. 2000 Mar 24 [cited 2004 June 3][about 1 p.]. Available from: http://www.ap.org/
- 39 Cauvin HE: South Africa in a quandary: should gays donate blood? The New York Times [ online edition]. 2000 Jun 11 [cited 2004 January 13] Available from: http://newyorktimes.com/
- 40 Maartens RW, O'Keefe E, Byrne C: Independent epidemics of heterosexual and homosexual HIV infection in South Africa – survival differences. Q J Med 1997; 90: 449–454
- 41 Anon: Barnes draft. The Research and Documentation Department of the South African Human Rights Commission. 2000 Available from: http://www.sahrc.org.za/section_9_case_2PDF
- 42 Heredia C: Gay blood donations ban may be lifted – FDA panel to study 15-year-old regulation. San Francisco Chronicle [ online edition]. 2000 Sep 12 [cited 2004 June 3 [about 2 p.]. Available from: http://www.sfgate.com
- 43 Green EW, Rock WU: Blood drive policy called homophobic. The Harvard Crimson Online. 2002 December 13 [cited 2004 June 2]. [about 2 p.]. Available from: http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=255880
Citing Literature
