Residential care for older people: job satisfaction and psychological health in care staff
Corresponding Author
Esme Moniz-Cook BSc (Hons)
Department of Clinical Psychology, Hull & Holderness Community Health NHS Trust, Hull
Esme Moniz-Cook Consultant Clinical Psychologist Clinical Psychology Department Hull & Holderness Community Health NHS Trust Coltman Street Day Hospital Coltman Street Hull HU3 2SG UKSearch for more papers by this authorDip Clin ABPsS, Psy C Psychol
Department of Clinical Psychology, Hull & Holderness Community Health NHS Trust, Hull
Search for more papers by this authorDawn Millington BSc (Hons)
Department of Clinical Psychology, Hull & Holderness Community Health NHS Trust, Hull
Search for more papers by this authorMiriam Silver BSc (Hons)
Department of Clinical Psychology, Hull & Holderness Community Health NHS Trust, Hull
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Esme Moniz-Cook BSc (Hons)
Department of Clinical Psychology, Hull & Holderness Community Health NHS Trust, Hull
Esme Moniz-Cook Consultant Clinical Psychologist Clinical Psychology Department Hull & Holderness Community Health NHS Trust Coltman Street Day Hospital Coltman Street Hull HU3 2SG UKSearch for more papers by this authorDip Clin ABPsS, Psy C Psychol
Department of Clinical Psychology, Hull & Holderness Community Health NHS Trust, Hull
Search for more papers by this authorDawn Millington BSc (Hons)
Department of Clinical Psychology, Hull & Holderness Community Health NHS Trust, Hull
Search for more papers by this authorMiriam Silver BSc (Hons)
Department of Clinical Psychology, Hull & Holderness Community Health NHS Trust, Hull
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Staff in local authority residential homes for older people care for dependent and demanding residents. Recent research has linked resident aggression to psychological disturbance in these staff. Despite this, little is known about the experiences of staff, many of whom are facing significant changes in the residents they care for. This paper examines psychological well-being, perceptions of the work environment and job satisfaction in 48 members of staff from two local authority homes. Results indicate that these staff experience equivalent stress to professional nurses in an NHS setting. Moderate levels of emotional exhaustion are associated with poor clarity about the job they are now required to perform. There is also a poor sense of personal accomplishment. Differences in the needs of staff, and the implications for staff development programs within individual homes are discussed. Given reports of high illness figures for care staff in public sector homes for older people, we argue that carefully targeted staff development programs have the potential for reducing burnout and days lost through illness. Such programs can also improve ‘therapeutic reciprocity’ which in turn might enhance psychological well-being in care staff, and the quality of life for residents.
References
- Age Concern (1994) National Policies for Local Action. Age Concern, London .
- Ames D., Ashby D., Mann A.H. & Graham N. (1988) Psychiatric illness in elderly residents of Part III homes in one London borough: Prognoses and review. Age and Aging 17 (4), 249–256.
- Banks M.H., Clegg C.W., Jackson P.R., Kemp N.J., Stafford F.M. & Wall T. D (1980) The use of the General Health Questionnaire as an indicator of mental health in occupational studies. Journal of Occupational Psychology 53 (3), 187–194.
- Challis D., Darton R., Johnson L., Stone M. & Traske K. (1995) Care Management and the Health Care of Older People. The Darlington Community Care Project. Arena, Aldershot .
- Chappell N.L. & Novak M. (1994) Caring for institutionalized elders: Stress among nursing assistants. Journal of Applied Gerontology 13 (3), 299–315.
-
Darton R. &
Wright K. G. (1993) Changes in the provision of long stay care 1970–1990.
Health and Social Care in the Community
1 (1), 11–25.
10.1111/j.1365-2524.1993.tb00191.x Google Scholar
- Department of Health & Social Security (1981a) Growing Older. HMSO, London .
- Department of Health (1990a) Caring for People: Community Care in the Next Decade and Beyond. Cm849. HMSO, London .
- Department of Health. (1990b) Working for Patients. Cm 555. HMSO, London .
- Department of Health & Social Security (1981b) Care in Action: a Handbook of Policies for the Health and Personal Social Services in England. HMSO, London .
- Dunn L., Rout U., Carson J. & Ritter S. (1994) Occupational stress amongst care staff working in nursing homes: An empirical investigation. Journal of Clinical Nursing 3 (3), 177–183.
- Fielding J. & Weaver S.M. (1994) A comparison of hospital and community- based nurses: perceptions of their work environment and psychological health. Journal of Advanced Nursing 19 (6), 1196–1204.
- Firth-Cozens J. & Hardy G.E. (1992) Occupational stress, clinical treatment and changes in job perceptions. Journal of Occupational and Organisational Psychology 65 (2), 81–88.
- Firth H., McIntee J., McKeown P. & Britton P. (1986) Burnout and professional depression: Related concepts Journal of Advanced Nursing 11 (6), 633–664.
- Firth H., McKeown P., McIntee J. & Britton P. (1987) Professional depression, ‘burnout’ and personality in longstay nursing. International Journal of Nursing Studies 24 (3), 227–237.
-
Gilleard C.J. &
Brunston A. (1984) Nurses' typification of nursing home patients.
Ageing and Society
4 (1), 45–67.
10.1017/S0144686X00010448 Google Scholar
- Goldberg D. (1978) Manual of the General Health Questionnaire. NFER-NELSON, Windsor .
- Goldberg D. & Williams P. (1988) GHQ a Users Guide to the General Health Questionnaire. NFER-NELSON, Windsor .
- Griffiths R. (1988) Community Care: Agenda for Action. HMSO, London .
- Grimley Evans J. (1983) Towards 2001: Population changes: Implications for care, the Health Service. Journal of the Royal Society of Health 103 (6), 200–201 & 238.
- Hingley P. & Cooper C.L. (1986) Stress and the Nurse Manager. Wiley, Chichester .
- Ineichen B. (1987) Measuring the rising tide: How many dementia cases will there be by 2001 British Journal of Psychiatry 50 (2), 193–200.
- Ineichen B. (1990) The extent of dementia among old people in residential care. International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 5 (5), 327–335.
- Jenkinson M.L., Potter J.M. & Hildick-Smith M. (1992) The decline in geriatric longstay beds: Who remains Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of London 26 (1), 56–60.
- Kitwood T & Bredin K (1992) Towards a theory of dementia care: Personhood and wellbeing. Ageing and Society 12 (3), 269–287.
- Kuremyr D., Kihlgren M., Norberg A., Astrom S. & Karlsson I. (1994) Emotional experiences, empathy and burnout among staff caring for patients at a collective living unit and a nursing home. Journal of Advanced Nursing 19 (4), 670–679.
- N.L. Mace (Ed) (1990) The management of problem behaviours. In Dementia Care. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore .
- Macpherson R., Eastley R.J., Richards H. & Mian I.H. (1994) Psychological distress among workers caring for the elderly. International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 9 (5), 381–386.
- Mann A.H., Graham N. & Ashby D. (1984) Psychiatric illness in residential homes for the elderly: A survey in one London Borough. Age & Ageing 13 (4), 257–265.
- Marck P. (1990) Therapeutic reciprocity: a caring phenomenon. Advances in Nursing Science 13 (1), 49–59.
- Maslach C. & Jackson S. (1986) The Maslach Burnout Inventory Manual, 2nd edn. Consulting Psychologists Press, Palo Alto .
- Moos R.H. (1981) Manual of the Work Environment Scale. Consulting Psychologists Press, Palo Alto .
- Moos R.H. & Lemke S. (1992) Manual of the Sheltered Care Environment Scale. Center for Health Care Evalutation, Department of Veterans Affairs and Stanford University Medical Centers, Palo Alto .
- Nolan M. & Grant G. (1993) Rust out and therapeutic reciprocity: concepts to advance the nursing care of older people. Journal of Advanced Nursing 18 (8), 1305–1314.
- Novak M. & Chappell N.L. (1994) Nursing assistant burnout and the cognitively impaired elderly. International Journal of Aging and Human Development 39 (2), 105–120.
- Pattie A.H. (1988) Measuring levels of difficulty - the clifton assessment procedures for the elderly. In J. Wattis and I. Hindmarch (Eds). Psychological Assessment of the Elderly. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh .
- Pattie A.H. & Gilleard C.J. (1979) Manual of the Clifton Assessment Procedures for the Elderly (CAPE). Hodder and Stoughton, Sevenoaks .
- Payne C. (1991) Training for care staff development programme: Some initial findings. Journal of Training and Development 2 (2), 7–24.
- Pennington R.E. & Pierce W.L. (1985) Observations of empathy of nursing-home staff: a predictive study. International Journal of Aging and Human Development, 21 (4), 281–290.
- Rickford F. (1994) The system grows frail. The Guardian November 30th.
- Teri L., Rabins P., Whitehouse P., Berg L., Reisberg B., Sunderland T., Eichelman B. & Phelps C. (1992) Management of behavioural disturbance in Alzheimer's Disease. Current knowledge and future directions. Alzheimer's Disease and Associated Disorders 6 (2), 77–88.
- Wilber K.H. & Specht C.V. (1994) Prevalence and predictors of burnout among adult day care providers. Journal of Applied Gerontology 13 (3), 282–98.
- Willcocks D., Peace S. & Kellaher L. (1987) Public Places. Tavistock, London .
- Wistow G. (1995) Coming apart at the seams. Health Service Journal 105 (5442), 2 March, 24–25.
- Wood P.C. & Castleden C.M. (1993) Dependency, quality and staffing of institutions for the elderly. Health Trends 25 (3), 97–101.