INTEGRATING SPACES OF RELEGATION AND VALUE: Examining the Governance of Threat and Urban Social Inequality in the Brussels Capital Region
Both authors contributed equally in the empirical findings, conceptualization and writing of the article. We would like to acknowledge and thank Nadia Fadil and Maarten Loopmans for their guidance and feedback as well as to Hamza Esmili, Patrick Govers and the three anonymous reviewers for their comments on earlier drafts of this work. This article had the support of the ‘Deradicalizing the City’ Project funded by the KU Leuven (IDN/20/004) and FWO (G0D8521N).
Abstract
While critical security and urban studies have been attentive to the effects of counterterrorism and radicalization policies by looking at the militarization of urban environments and the securitization of social policies, less attention has been paid to how these policies reconfigure urban governance in Western European cities. Taking the case study of the Brussels capital region, this article examines the intertwinement of the management of the terrorist threat and urban governance to make the following contributions. First, we argue that threat management builds from geographies of urban social inequality by targeting spaces of relegation and spaces of value. Secondly, we examine how the management of threat draws upon existing logics of integration as a mode of urban governance. Spaces of relegation are integrated through exercising control and influence over the conduct of its population considered at risk of radicalization. Spaces of value, considered as vulnerable to terrorist attacks, are to be integrated through infrastructural interventions. Finally, we observe that the management of threat results in the securitization of integration by harnessing existing socio-economic inequalities. This creates a paradox: while integration aims to mitigate the effects of urban uneven development, its securitization further confines these spaces by reproducing exclusionary techniques.
References
- Aalbers, M. and E. van Beckhoven (2010) The integrated approach in neighbourhood renewal: more than just a philosophy? Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie 101.4, 449–61.
10.1111/j.1467-9663.2009.00574.x Google Scholar
- Alber, A., J. Cabalion and V. Cohen (2020) Un impossible travail de déradicalisation [An impossible work of deradicalization]. Editions Érès, France.
10.3917/eres.alber.2020.01 Google Scholar
- Amir-Moazami, S. (2023) Interrogating Muslims: the liberal-secular matrix of integration. Bloomsbury, London.
- Baeten, G. (2001) Clichés of urban doom: the dystopian politics of metaphors for the unequal city—a view from Brussels. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 25.1, 55–69.
10.1111/1468-2427.00297 Google Scholar
- Baker-Beall, C., C. Heath-Kelly and L. Jarvis (2015) Counter-radicalisation: critical perspectives. Routledge, Abingdon.
- Bousetta, H., A. Favell and M. Martiniello (2018) Governing multicultural Brussels: paradoxes of a multi-level, multi-cultural, multinational urban anomaly. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 44.12, 2070–85.
10.1080/1369183X.2017.1341712 Google Scholar
- Brand, R. and S. Fregonese (2013) The radicals’ city: urban environment, polarisation, cohesion. Routledge, Abingdon.
- Brown, K.E. and T. Saeed (2015) Radicalization and counter-radicalization at British universities: Muslim encounters and alternatives. Ethnic and Racial Studies 38.11, 1952–68.
10.1080/01419870.2014.911343 Google Scholar
- Brown, S. (1985) Central Belfast's security segment: an urban phenomenon. Area 17.1, 1–9.
- Busby, A. (2013) ‘Bursting the Brussels bubble’: using ethnography to explore the European Parliament as a transnational political field. Perspectives on European Politics and Society 14.2, 203–22.
10.1080/15705854.2013.785260 Google Scholar
- Chambers, P. and T. Andrews (2019) Never mind the bollards: the politics of policing car attacks through the securitisation of crowded urban places. EPD: Society and Space 37.6, 1025–44.
- Coaffee, J. (2013a) Rescaling and responsibilising the politics of urban resilience: from national security to local place-making. Politics 33.4, 240–52.
10.1111/1467-9256.12011 Google Scholar
- Coaffee, J. (2013b) Towards next-generation urban resilience in planning practice: from securitization to integrated place making. Planning Practice and Research 28.3, 323–39.
10.1080/02697459.2013.787693 Google Scholar
- Coaffee, J. and P. Fussey (2015) Constructing resilience through security and surveillance: the politics, practices and tensions of security-driven resilience. Security & Dialogue 46.1, 86–105.
10.1177/0967010614557884 Google Scholar
- Coaffee, J., P. O'Hare and M. Hawkesworth (2009) The visibility of (in)security: the aesthetics of planning urban defences against terrorism. Security Dialogue 40.4/5, 489–511.
10.1177/0967010609343299 Google Scholar
- Coolsaet, R. (2019) Radicalization: The origins and limits of a contested concept. In N. Fadil, M. Koning and F. Ragazzi (eds.), Radicalization in Belgium and the Netherlands: critical perspectives on violence and security, I.B. Tauris, London.
10.5040/9781788316187.ch-001 Google Scholar
- Cowden, S. and G. Singh (2017) Community cohesion, communitarianism and neoliberalism. Critical Social Policy 37.2, 268–86.
10.1177/0261018316670252 Google Scholar
- Croft, S. (2012) Securitizing Islam: identity and the search for security. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
10.1017/CBO9781139104142 Google Scholar
- De Cannière, A., M.-L. Roggemans and Y. Rouet (2013) The development of the European Quarter. In E. Corijn and J. Ven (eds.), The Brussels reader: a small world city to become the capital of Europe, VUB Press, Brussels.
- Dikeç, M. (2007) Badlands of the republic: space, politics and urban policy. Blackwell Publishing, Oxford.
- Edmunds, J. (2012) The ‘new’ barbarians: governmentality, securitization and Islam in Western Europe. Contemporary Islam 6.1, 67–84.
10.1007/s11562-011-0159-6 Google Scholar
- Fadil, N. (2014) Brussels as a landscape of fear: containing ‘otherness’, In F. Peter and R. Ortega (eds.), Islamic movements in Europe. Public religion and Islamophobia in the modern world, I.B. Tauris, London.
- N. Fadil, F. Ragazzi and M. Koning (eds.) (2019) Radicalization in Belgium and in the Netherlands: critical perspectives on violence and security. I.B. Tauris, London.
10.5040/9781788316187 Google Scholar
- Fadil, N., A. Snijders, K. Boustani Dahan and L. Janssens (2022) Entre droits fondamentaux et surveillance. Les effets secondaires de la lutte contre la radicalisation sur les musulmans belges. [Between fondamental rights and surveillance. Secondary effects of the fight against radicalisation on Belgian Muslims]. Rapport de Recherche, KU Leuven, Belgium.
- Favell, A. (2022) The integration nation: immigration and colonial power in liberal democracies. Polity Press, Cambridge.
- Feldman, G. (2012) The migration apparatus. Security, labor, and policymaking in the European Union. Stanford University Press, California, CA.
- Foret, F. (2022) Si loin, si proches? La perception par les citoyens de la présence des institutions internationales à Bruxelles [So far, so close? Citizens’ perception of the presence of international institutions in Brussels]. Brussels Studies 170, 1–12.
- Glück, Z. (2017) Security urbanism and the counterterror state in Kenya. Anthropological Theory 17.3, 297–321.
10.1177/1463499617729295 Google Scholar
- Graham, S. (2010) Cities under siege: the new military urbanism. Verso Books, London.
- Husband, C. and Y. Alam (2011) Social cohesion and counter-terrorism: a policy contradiction? The Policy Press, Bristol.
10.1332/policypress/9781847428011.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Jacobs, J. (1969) The economy of cities. Random House, New York, NY.
- Jaminé, S. and N. Fadil (2019) (De-)radicalization as a negotiated practice: an ethnographic case study in Flanders. In N. Fadil, F. Ragazzi and M. Koning (eds.), Radicalization in Belgium and in the Netherlands: critical perspectives on violence and security, I.B. Tauris, London.
10.5040/9781788316187.ch-007 Google Scholar
- Janssens, L. and N. Fadil (2022) Entre secret et le partage d'information. Les négociations du secret professionel et le partage d'information dans la lutte contre la radicalisation violente. [Between secret and share of information. Negotiations of professional secrecy and sharing of information in the fight against violent radicalisation]. Rapport de Recherche, KU Leuven, Belgium.
- Jensen, M.T. and O.B. Jensen (2021) The social life of a barrier: a material ethnography of urban counter-terrorism. Space and Culture 26.1, 74–88.
- Johansen, M.-L. (2020) Epidemic policing: the spreading of counterradicalization in Denmark. EPD: Society and Space 38.3, 472–89.
- Joint Research Center (2022) Security by design Protection of public spaces from terrorist attacks. Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg.
- Kesteloot, C. (1994) Three levels of socio-spatial polarization in Brussels. Built Environment 20.3, 204–17.
- Kundnani, A. (2012) Radicalisation: the journey of a concept. Race & Class 54.2, 3–25.
10.1177/0306396812454984 Google Scholar
- Kundnani, A. and B. Hayes (2018) The globalisation of countering violent extremism policies. Undermining human rights, instrumentalising civil society. Transnational Institute, Amsterdam.
- Lemaire, P. (2019). Guide to the integration of security systems in public spaces. Brussels-Capital Region. perspective.brussels [WWW Document]. URL: https://perspective.brussels/sites/default/files/documents/bbp_guidesecu_fr_v06.pdf (accessed 26 January 2025).
- Lenel, E. (2013). La mixité sociale dans l'action publique urbaine à Bruxelles: projet ou langage politique? [Social mixity in urban public action in Brussels: project or political language?]. Brussels Studies 65.
- Lewicki, P.M. (2017) EU-Space and the Euroclass. Modernity, Nationality and Lifestyle among Eurocrats in Brussels. Transcript publishing, Bielefeld.
- Loopmans, M. (2008) Relevance, gentrification and the development of a new hegemony on urban policies in Antwerp, Belgium. Urban Studies 45.12, 2499–519.
10.1177/0042098008097107 Google Scholar
- Newman, O. (1972) Defensible space; crime prevention through urban design. Macmillan, New York, NY.
- Pasquetti, S. (2019) Experiences of urban militarism: spatial stigma, ruins and everyday life. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 43.5, 848–69.
10.1111/1468-2427.12797 Google Scholar
- Ragazzi, F. (2017) Countering terrorism and radicalisation: securitizing social policy? Critical Social Policy 37.2, 163–79.
10.1177/0261018316683472 Google Scholar
- Ragazzi, F. (2023) Counter-radicalization, Islam and Laicité: policed multiculturalism in France's banlieues. Ethnic & Racial Studies 46.4, 707–27.
10.1080/01419870.2022.2032248 Google Scholar
- Rea, A. (2001) Jeunes immigrés dans la cité. Protestation collective, acteurs locaux et politiques publiques [Youth immigrants in the cité. Collective protests, local actors and public policies]. Éditions Labor, Brussels.
- Romańczyk, K.M. (2012) Transforming Brussels into an international city—reflections on ‘Brusselization’. Cities 29, 126–32.
- Romańczyk, K.M. (2015) Towards urban governance: twenty years of neighbourhood contracts in the Brussels-Capital Region. Cities 44, 1–8.
- Rouyet, Y. (2014) Rock the canal! A history of cultural life in the canal area of Brussels. Brussels Studies 75, 1–13.
- Saberi, P. (2019) Preventing radicalization in European cities: an urban geopolitical question. Political Geography 74, 1–10.
- Saberi, P. (2022). Fearing the immigrant: racialization and urban policy in Toronto. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN.
- Schinkel, W. (2017) Imagined societies: a critique of immigrant integration in Western Europe. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
10.1017/9781316424230 Google Scholar
- Swyngedouw, E. and J. Moyersoen (2006) Brussels: a world city? In: M. Amen, K. Archer and M. Bosman (eds.), Relocating global cities: from the center to the margins, Rowman & Littlefield, London.
- Shore, C. and S. Wright (1997) Policy: a new field of anthropology. In C. Shore and S. Wright (eds.), Anthropology of policy: critical perspectives on governance and power, Routledge, London.
- Statbel (2021) Poverty risks in Belgium in 2020 [WWW document]. URL: https://statbel.fgov.be/en/news/poverty-risks-belgium-2020 (accessed 12 June 2024).
- Taleb, A. (2021) Europe in focus: imperial formations in the fabric of the European Union. Ethnic & Racial Studies 44.10, 1755–78.
10.1080/01419870.2021.1921234 Google Scholar
- Tissot, S. (2018) Categorizing neighborhoods: the invention of ‘sensitive areas’ in France and ‘historic districts’ in the United States. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 42.1, 150–8.
10.1111/1468-2427.12530 Google Scholar
- Uitermark, J. (2014) Integration and control: the governing of urban marginality in Western Europe. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 38.4, 1418–36.
10.1111/1468-2427.12069 Google Scholar
- Van Criekingen, M. (2021) Contre la gentrification [Against Gentrification]. La Dispute, Paris.
- Vermeulen, F. (2014) Suspect communities—targeting violent extremism at the local level: policies of engagement in Amsterdam, Berlin, and London. Terrorism and Political Violence 26.2, 286–306.
10.1080/09546553.2012.705254 Google Scholar
- Vermeulen, S. (2015) The Brussels Canal Zone: negotiating visions for urban planning. VUB Press, Brussels.
- Vermeulen, S. and E. Corijn (2013) Gentrification or upward social mobility: the Canal Zone. In E. Corijn and J. Ven (eds.), The Brussels reader: a small world city to become the capital of Europe, VUB Press, Brussels.
- Vloeberghs, E. and E. Corijn (2013). Brussels, a small world city. In E. Corijn and J. Ven (eds.), The Brussels reader: a small world city to become the capital of Europe, VUB Press, Brussels.
- Wacquant, L. (2009) Punishing the poor: the neoliberal government of social insecurity. Duke University Press, Durham, NC.
10.1215/9780822392255 Google Scholar
- Wacquant, L. (2012) Three steps to a historical anthropology of actually existing neoliberalism. Social Anthropology/Anthropologie Sociale 20.1, 66–79.
10.1111/j.1469-8676.2011.00189.x Google Scholar
- Wacquant, L. (2016). Revisiting territories of relegation: class, ethnicity and state in the making of advanced marginality. Urban Studies 53.6, 1077–88.
10.1177/0042098015613259 Google Scholar