Informal caregivers’ experiences of formal support in a changing context
Corresponding Author
Janine Wiles
Health Geography, School of Geography and Geosciences, University of St Andrews, St Andrews, UK
Correspondence Janine Wiles Lecturer Health Geography School of Geography and Geosciences University of St Andrews St Andrews KY16 9AL UK E-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Janine Wiles
Health Geography, School of Geography and Geosciences, University of St Andrews, St Andrews, UK
Correspondence Janine Wiles Lecturer Health Geography School of Geography and Geosciences University of St Andrews St Andrews KY16 9AL UK E-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
As the location of long-term care of elderly people moves to homes and communities, and responsibility for care shifts to families, understanding the experience of people in this situation is necessary to ensure that support is appropriate, accessible and effective. The present paper explores informal caregivers’ and recipients’ relationships with formal support, drawing on thematic and narrative analysis of 30 in-depth interviews with self-identified family caregivers conducted over a year in a mid-size city in Ontario, Canada. All but six of these caregivers had had some interaction with formal support. The semistructured interviews explored caregivers’ knowledge about, and perceptions and experiences of accessing and using formal support. Interpretation reveals how confusion and lack of knowledge about services, the inflexibility and lack of availability of services, and increasing pressure on the quantity and quality of publicly funded community-based resources combine to impact negatively on the experience of accessing and using formal support. Different ideas about the relative roles and responsibilities of seniors, informal caregivers and ‘family’ in general, and the state both shape and are shaped by policies and the situated realities of the provision of formal support. Providing care at home creates both opportunities and constraints for caregivers in their interactions with formal support. Lastly, this paper highlights the difficulties of interacting with publicly funded formal support as the costs of care are moved away from the state and onto families and individuals.
References
- Abel E.K. (1990) Informal care for the disabled elderly: a critique of recent literature. Research on Aging 12, 139–157.
- Adamek M.E. (1992) Should the government pay? Caregiver views of government responsibility and feelings of stigma about financial support. Journal of Applied Gerontology 11, 283–297.
-
Aronson J. (1990) Women's perspectives on informal care of the elderly: public ideology and personal experience of giving and receiving care.
Ageing and Society
10, 61–84.
10.1017/S0144686X00007856 Google Scholar
- Atkinson J.M. & John H. (Eds) (1984) Structures of Social Action: Studies in Conversation Analysis. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
- Ayres L. (2000) Narratives of family caregiving: the process of making meaning. Research in Nursing and Health 23, 424–434.
- Bailey P.H. & Tilley S. (2002) Storytelling and the interpretation of meaning in qualitative research. Journal of Advanced Nursing 38, 574–583.
- Barlow M. (2001) The last frontier. The Ecologist February, http://www.theecologist.org/archive_article.html?article151./
- Bass D., Noelker L. & Rechlin L. (1996) The moderating influence of service use on negative caregiving consequences. Journal of Gerontology 51 (Suppl.), S121–S131.
- Bolmsjö I. & Hermerén G. (2001) Interviews with patients, family, and caregivers in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: comparing needs. Journal of Palliative Care 17, 236–240.
- Brotman S.L. & Yaffe M.J. (1994) Are physicians meeting the needs of family caregivers of the frail elderly? Canadian Family Physician 40, 679–685.
- Canadian Home Care Association (1998) Portrait of Canada: An Overview of Public Home Care Programs. Canadian Home Care Association in collaboration with l’Association des CLSC et des DHSLD du Quebec, Quebec City.
-
Chappell N. &
Blandford A. (1991) Informal and formal care: exploring the complementarity.
Ageing and Society
11, 299–317.
10.1017/S0144686X00004189 Google Scholar
- Clarke C. (1999) Commentary (on Lyons and Zarit 1999 ‘Formal and informal support: the great divide’). International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 14, 194–196.
- Clarke N. (2001) Training as a vehicle to empower carers in the community: more than a question of information sharing. Health and Social Care in the Community 9, 79–88.
- Clifford J. (1983) On ethnographic authority. Representations 1, 118–146.
- Cloutier-Fisher D. (2000) Long-term care restructuring in rural Ontario: retrieving community service user and provider narratives. Social Science and Medicine 50, 1037–1045.
- Coe M. & Neufeld A. (1999) Male caregivers’ use of formal support. Western Journal of Nursing Research 21, 568–588.
- Cortazzi M. (1993) Narrative Analysis. The Falmer Press, London.
- Coyte P.C. & McKeever P. (2001) Home care in Canada: passing the buck. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 33, 11–25.
- Deber R.B. & Williams A.P.. (1995) Policy, payment, and participation: long-term care reform in Ontario. Canadian Journal on Aging 14, 294–318.
- Department of Health (1999) Caring About Carers: A National Strategy for Carers. Department of Health, London.
- Doty P., Jackson M. & Crown W. (1998) The impact of female caregivers’ employment status on patterns of formal and informal eldercare. Gerontologist 38.
- Edelman P. & Hughes S. (1990) The impact of community care on the provision of informal care to home bound elderly persons. Journals of Gerontology 45 (Suppl.), S74–S84.
-
Finch J. &
Mason J. (1990) Filial obligations and kin support for elderly people.
Ageing and Society
10, 151–175.
10.1017/S0144686X00008059 Google Scholar
- Frederiks C.M.A., Te Wierik M.J.M., Visser A. & Sturmans F. (1990) The functional status and utilisation of care by elderly people living at home. Journal of Community Health 15, 307–317.
-
Gee J.P. (1986) Units in the production of narrative discourse.
Discourse Processes
9, 381–422.
10.1080/01638538609544650 Google Scholar
- Gesler W.M. & Kearns R.A. (2002) Culture/Place/Health. Routledge, London.
- Grant G., Ramcharan P., McGrath M., Nolan M. & Keady J. (1998) Rewards and gratifications among family caregivers: towards a refined model of caring and coping. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research 42, 58–71.
- Greene V. (1983) Substitution between formally and informally provided care for the impaired elderly in the community. Medical Care 21, 609–619.
- Greenwood R. (2002) Aging in place: What do people want? Comments from PACE focus groups on long-term care. Nursing Homes: Long Term Care Management 51, 26–30.
- Guberman N. & Maheu P. (2002) Conceptions of family caregivers: implications for professional practice. Canadian Journal on Aging 21, 27–37.
- Hanlon N. & Rosenberg M.W. (1998) Not-so-new public management and the denial of geography: Ontario health-care reform in the 1990s. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 16, 1021–1034.
- Hardy B., Ruth Y. & Wistow G. (1999) Dimensions of choice in the assessment and care management process: the views of older people, carers and care managers. Health and Social Care in the Community 7, 483–491.
- Hasselkus B.R. (1988) Meaning in family caregiving: perspectives on caregiver/professional relationships. Gerontologist 28, 686–691.
- Health Canada (1984, 2000) Canada Health Act. [WWW document.] URL http://canada.justice.gc.ca/en/laws/C-6/text/text.html.HealthCanada
- Health Canada (1997) The future of caregiving. Seniors Info Exchange Winter, 1–6 .
-
Johansson L. (1991) Informal care of dependent elderly at home – some Swedish experiences.
Ageing and Society
11, 41–58.
10.1017/S0144686X00003822 Google Scholar
-
Keating N.,
Fast J.,
Ingrid C.,
Penning M. &
Keefe J. (1997) Bridging policy and research in eldercare.
Canadian Journal on Aging/Canadian Public Policy
(Suppl.), 22–41.
10.2307/3551539 Google Scholar
- Keating N., Fast J., Frederick J., Cranswick K. & Perrier C. (1999) Eldercare in Canada: Context, Content and Consequences. Statistics Canada, Ottawa.
- Kelsey J. (1993) Rolling Back the State: Privatisation of Power in Aotearoa/New Zealand. Bridget Williams Books, Auckland.
- Kersten P., McLellan L., George S., Mullee M.A. & Smith J.A.E. (2001) Needs of carers of severely disabled people: Are they identified and met adequately? Health and Social Care in the Community 9, 235–243.
- Kingston, Frontenac, Lennox and Addington County Community Care Access Centre (2000) Bringing Health Care Home: Backgrounder. Kingston, Frontenac, Lennox and Addington County Community Care Access Centre, Kingston.
- Killeen J. (1999) Commentary (on Lyons and Zarit 1999 ‘Formal and informal support: the great divide’). International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 14, 192–194.
- Kodadek S.M. & Haylor M.J. (1990) Using interpretive methods to understand family caregiving when a child is blind. Journal of Pediatric Nursing 5, 42–49.
- Labov W. (1972) Language in the Inner City: Studies in the Black English Vernacular. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, PA.
- Labov W. (1982) Speech actions and reactions in personal narrative. In: D. Tannen (Ed.) Analyzing Discourse: Text and Talk, pp. 219–247 . Georgetown University Press, Washington, DC.
- Lankshear G., Giarchi G.G. & Hodges V. (1999) The placement of a social service care manager in a GP surgery as a way to improve caregiver access to services and improve liaison between statutory agencies. Health and Social Care in the Community 7, 206–215.
- Larragy J.F. (1993) Formal service provision and the care of the elderly at home in Ireland. Journal of Cross Cultural Gerontology 8, 361–374.
- Levine C. (1999) Home sweet hospital: the nature and limits of private responsibilities for home health care. Journal of Aging and Health 11, 341–359.
- Litwak E. (1985) Helping the Elderly: The Complementary Roles of Informal Networks and Formal Systems. Guildford Press, New York, NY.
-
Litwak E.
Messeri P. &
Silverstein M. (1990) The role of formal and informal groups in providing help to older people.
Marriage and Family Review
15, 171–193.
10.1300/J002v15n01_09 Google Scholar
-
Litwin H. &
Auslander G.K. (1988) Between social networks and formal social services.
Ageing and Society
8, 269–285.
10.1017/S0144686X00006942 Google Scholar
- Luk W.S.-C. (2002) The home care experience as perceived by the caregivers of Chinese dialysis patients. International Journal of Nursing Studies 39, 269–277.
-
Lyons K.S. &
Zarit S.H. (1999) Formal and informal support: the great divide.
International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry
14, 183–192.
10.1002/(SICI)1099-1166(199903)14:3<183::AID-GPS969>3.0.CO;2-J CAS PubMed Web of Science® Google Scholar
-
Lyons K.S.,
Zarit S.H.,
Aline S.G. &
Whitlach C.J. (2002) Caregiving as a dyadic process: perspectives from caregiver and receiver.
Journals of Gerontology: Social Sciences
57B, P195–P204.
10.1093/geronb/57.3.P195 Google Scholar
- Massey D. (1999) Spaces of politics. In: D. Massey, J. Allen & P. Sarre (Eds) Human Geography Today, pp. 279–294 . The Polity Press, Brighton.
- May J., Ellis-Hill C. & Payne S. (2001) Gatekeeping and legitimization: how informal carers’ relationship with health care workers is revealed in their everyday interactions. Journal of Advanced Nursing 36, 364–375.
- McKeever P. (1999) Between women: nurses and family caregivers. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 30, 185–191.
- McKeganey N. (1989) The role of home help organisers. Social Policy and Administration 23, 171–188.
- Moore E., Rosenberg M., W. & McGuinness D. (1997) Growing Old in Canada: Demographic and Geographic Perspectives. ITP Nelson, Toronto.
- Morris S.M. & Thomas C. (2001) The carer's place in the cancer situation: Where does the carer stand in the medical setting?. European Journal of Cancer Care 10, 87–95.
- New Zealand/Aotearoa Ministry of Health (2002) Health of Older People Strategy. New Zealand Ministry of Health/Manatu Hauora, Wellington.
- Older Women's Network & Registered Nurses Association of Ontario (1998) Joint Statement: The Impact of Health Care Restructuring on Older Women. Registered Nurses Association of Ontario, Toronto.
- Ontario Health Coalition (2000) Secrets in the House: Homecare Reform in Ontario 1997–2000. Ontario Health Coalition, Toronto.
- Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-term Care (2000) Ontario Is Already Reforming Health Care. Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-term Care, Toronto.
- Ontario Ministry of Health Long-term Care Division (1996) Community Care Access Centres: Board Orientation. Ontario Ministry of Health, Toronto.
- Ontario Ministry of Health Long-term Care Division (1999) Service Directions for CCACs and Other LTC Community Agencies. Ontario Ministry of Health, Toronto.
- Parker G. (1992) Counting care: numbers and types of informal caregivers. In: J. Twigg (Ed.) Carers: Research and Practice, pp. 6–29 . HMSO, London.
- Payne B.J., Grant K.R., Christian C. & Gregory D.M. (2002) Blurring the boundaries: women's caring work and Manitoba health care reform. Centres of Excellence for Women's Health Research Bulletin 3, 11–13.
- Pederson A. & Beattie-Huggan P. (2002) The Charlottetown Declaration on the Right to Care (2001). Centres of Excellence for Women's Health Research Bulletin 3, 18–20.
- Pinch S. (1989) The restructuring Thesis and the study of public services. Environment and Planning A 21, 905–926.
- Ploeg J., Biehler L. Willison K., Hutchison B. & Blythe J. (2001) Perceived support needs of family caregivers and implications for a telephone support service. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 33, 43–61.
- Polanyi L. (1985) Telling the American Story: A Structural and Cultural Analysis of Conversational Storytelling. Ablex, Norwood, NJ.
- Policy and Consultation Branch (1998) Public Home Care Expenditures in Canada 1975–1976 to 1997–1998. Health Canada, Ottawa.
- Provincial and Territorial Ministers of Health (2000) Understanding Canada's Health Care Costs: Final Report. Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-term Care, Toronto.
-
Qureshi H. (1990) A research note on the hierarchy of obligations among informal caregivers – a response to Finch and Mason.
Ageing and Society
10, 455–458.
10.1017/S0144686X00007418 Google Scholar
-
Qureshi H. &
Walker A. (1989) The Caring Relationship: Elderly People and Their Families. MacMillan, Basingstoke.
10.1007/978-1-349-20264-5 Google Scholar
- Riessman C.K. (1993) Narrative Analysis. Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA.
- Robinson C. & Williams V. (2002) Carers of people with learning disabilities, and their experience of the 1995 Carers Act. British Journal of Social Work 32, 169–183.
- Rolls E. (1992) Do the health visitor's professional training and bureaucratic responsibilities separate her from the women she is serving? Women's Studies International Forum 15, 397–404.
- Rosenberg M.W. & James A. (1994) The end of the second most expensive health care system in the world: some geographical implications. Social Science and Medicine 39, 967–981.
- Rosenberg M.W. & James A. (2000) Medical services utilization patterns by seniors. Canadian Journal on Aging 19 (Suppl. 1), 125–142.
- Soothill K., Morris S.M., Harman J.C., Francis B., Thomas C. & McIllmurray M.B. (2001) Informal carers of cancer patients: What are their unmet psychosocial needs? Health and Social Care in the Community 9, 464–475.
- Steele R.G. & Fitch M.I. (1996) Needs of family caregivers of patients receiving home hospice care for cancer. Oncology Nursing Forum 23, 823–828.
-
Straw L.B.,
O'Bryant S.L. &
Meddaugh D.I. (1991) Support system participation in spousal caregiving: Alzheimer's disease versus other illnesses.
Journal of Applied Gerontology
10, 359–371.
10.1177/073346489101000309 Google Scholar
- Tennstedt S., Crawford S. & McKinlay J. (1993) Is family care on the decline? A longitudinal investigation of the substitution of formal long-term care services for informal care. Milbank Quarterly 71, 601–624.
-
Tester S. (1999) Commentary (on Zarit et al.
1999 ‘Useful services for families: research findings and directions’).
International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry
14, 165–181.
10.1002/(SICI)1099-1166(199903)14:3<178::AID-GPS967>3.0.CO;2-B PubMed Web of Science® Google Scholar
- Twigg J. & Atkin K. (1994) Carers Perceived: Policy and Practice in Informal Care. Open University Press, Milton Keynes.
- Valentine G. (2001) Social Geographies: Space and Society. Prentice Hall/Pearson Education, Harlow.
- Wackerbarth S.B. & Johnson M.M.S. (2002) Essential information and support needs of family caregivers. Patient Education and Counselling 47, 95–100.
- Walker E. & Dewar B.J. (2001) How do we facilitate carers’ involvement in decision making? Journal of Advanced Nursing 34, 329–337.
- Ward-Griffin C. (2001) Negotiating care of frail elders: relationships between community nurses and family caregivers. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 33, 63–81.
- Wenger G.C., Scott A. & Seddon D. (2002) The experience of caring for older people with dementia in a rural area: using services. Aging and Mental Health 6, 30–38.
- Williams A., Wagner S. & Buettner M. (2002) Labour process change: women's paid home care work in Saskatoon. Centres of Excellence for Women's Health Research Bulletin 3, 13–15.
-
Zarit S.H.,
Gaugler J.E. &
Jarrott S.E. (1999) Useful services for families: research findings and directions.
International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry
14, 165–178
10.1002/(SICI)1099-1166(199903)14:3<165::AID-GPS966>3.0.CO;2-O CAS PubMed Web of Science® Google Scholar