A Two-Panel Delphi Study on Risk Factors of Adolescent Suicide in South Korea
Mo Hyun Yang
Department of Education, Traumatic Stress Center, Sungkyunkwan University, Republic of Korea
Search for more papers by this authorSangin Lee
Department of Psychology, Center for Coaching Psychology Research, Jeonbuk National University, Republic of Korea
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Dong Hun Lee
Department of Education, Traumatic Stress Center, Sungkyunkwan University, Republic of Korea
Correspondence: Dong Hun Lee ([email protected])
Search for more papers by this authorYoung-Soon Lee
Department of Psychology, Center for Coaching Psychology Research, Jeonbuk National University, Republic of Korea
Search for more papers by this authorMo Hyun Yang
Department of Education, Traumatic Stress Center, Sungkyunkwan University, Republic of Korea
Search for more papers by this authorSangin Lee
Department of Psychology, Center for Coaching Psychology Research, Jeonbuk National University, Republic of Korea
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Dong Hun Lee
Department of Education, Traumatic Stress Center, Sungkyunkwan University, Republic of Korea
Correspondence: Dong Hun Lee ([email protected])
Search for more papers by this authorYoung-Soon Lee
Department of Psychology, Center for Coaching Psychology Research, Jeonbuk National University, Republic of Korea
Search for more papers by this authorABSTRACT
This study aimed to identify and reach a consensus on factors contributing to adolescent suicidality following biopsychosocial model. The research was conducted in three stages: (1) literature review and school counselor interview on self-harm and suicidal risk factors in the adolescent population; (2) development of a list of risk factors (3) Delphi survey on counselor panel and adolescent panel. Three rounds of the Delphi questionnaire were conducted for each panel. Results discovered that there was consensus between the counselors and adolescents as well as counselor and adolescent exclusive risk factors. Both panels agreed on ‘psychiatric difficulties,’ ‘guilt,’ ‘perceived burdensomeness,’ ‘feeling worthlessness,’ ‘powerlessness,’ ‘hopelessness,’ ‘acquired capability for suicide,’ ‘positive expectations of death,’ ‘lack of meaning in life,’ ‘absence of alternatives to self-harm,’ ‘loneliness,’ ‘impulsivity,’ ‘exposure to problematic parenting,’ ‘family conflict,’ ‘domestic abuse,’ ‘experience of school violence’ ‘bullying or being out casted’, ‘loss of reliance’ and ‘economic hardship.’ Counselor panel exclusive consensus represented the importance of a broad range of risk factors, while adolescents suggested risk factors using expressions that specifically and delicately revealed internal experiences. The consented risk factors could enhance adolescent suicide prevention, as they were validated by the key stakeholders, the adolescents in crisis, and their counselors.
Summary
-
Biopsychosocial model for adolescent suicide allows possible breakdown of the broad suicide risk factors of adolescents.
-
Counselors showed broader perspectives and knowledge of suicide in adolescents than the suicidal adolescents, while the adolescents reported specific and delicate internal experiences during the crisis. However, both panels emphasized the impact of psychological factors such as hopelessness, impulsivity, and guilt and socioenvironmental factors such as family and peer dynamics in suicidal adolescents.
-
This highlights the importance of addressing these internal struggles in suicide prevention efforts as well as the importance of comprehensive, community-based support systems to mitigate these external pressures.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
References
- Abbas, M. J., M. A. Mohanna, T. A. Diab, M. Chikoore, and M. Wang. 2018. “Why Suicide? The Analysis of Motives for Self-Harm.” Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 46, no. 2: 209–225.
- Askew, M., and M. W. Byrne. 2009. “Biopsychosocial Approach to Treating Self-Injurious Behaviors: An Adolescent Case Study.” Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing 22, no. 3: 115–119. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6171.2009.00186.x.
- Auerbach, R. P., J. G. Stewart, and S. L. Johnson. 2016. “Impulsivity and Suicidality in Adolescent Inpatients.” Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology 45, no. 1: 91–103.
10.1007/s10802-016-0146-8 Google Scholar
- Ayer, L., and L. J. Colpe. 2023. “The Key Role of Schools in Youth Suicide Prevention.” Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 62, no. 1: 19–21.
- Ayre, C., and A. J. Scally. 2014. “Critical Values for Lawshe's Content Validity Ratio: Revisiting the Original Methods of Calculation.” Measurement and Evaluation in Counseling and Development 47, no. 1: 79–86.
- Barr, B., D. Taylor-Robinson, A. Scott-Samuel, M. McKee, and D. Stuckler. 2012. “Suicides Associated With the 2008–10 Economic Recession in England: Time Trend Analysis.” BMJ 345: e5142.
- Barrett, L. F., J. Gross, T. C. Christensen, and M. Benvenuto. 2001. “Knowing What You'Re Feeling and Knowing What to do About It: Mapping the Relation Between Emotion Differentiation and Emotion Regulation.” Cognition & Emotion 15, no. 6: 713–724.
- Barzilay, S., D. Feldman, A. Snir, et al. 2015. “The Interpersonal Theory of Suicide and Adolescent Suicidal Behavior.” Journal of Affective Disorders 183: 68–74.
- Bebbington, P. E., S. Minot, C. Cooper, et al. 2010. “Suicidal Ideation, Self-Harm and Attempted Suicide: Results From the British Psychiatric Morbidity Survey 2000.” European Psychiatry 25, no. 7: 427–431. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eurpsy.2009.12.004.
- Beck, A. T., R. A. Steer, J. S. Beck, and C. F. Newman. 1993. “Hopelessness, Depression, Suicidal Ideation, and Clinical Diagnosis of Depression.” Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior 23, no. 2: 139–145.
- Beck, A. T., R. A. Steer, M. Kovacs, and B. Garrison. 1985. “Hopelessness and Eventual Suicide: A 10-year Prospective Study of Patients Hospitalized With Suicidal Ideation.” American Journal of Psychiatry 142, no. 5: 559–563.
- Bertolote, J. M., and A. Fleischmann. 2002. “Suicide and Psychiatric Diagnosis: A Worldwide Perspective.” World Psychiatry 1, no. 3: 181–185.
- Blakeslee, T., J. Snethen, R. F. Schiffman, S. H. Gwon, M. Sapp, and S. Kelber. 2021. “Adolescent Characteristics, Suicide, and Bullying in High School.” Journal of School Nursing 39, no. 6: 463–474.
- Blum, R. W., L. Halcón, T. Beuhring, E. Pate, S. Campell-Forrester, and A. Venema. 2003. “Adolescent Health in the Caribbean: Risk and Protective Factors.” American Journal of Public Health 93, no. 3: 456–460.
- Brezo, J., J. Paris, and G. Turecki. 2006. “Personality Traits as Correlates of, Suicidal Ideation, Suicide Attempts, and Suicide Completions: A Systematic Review.” Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 113, no. 3: 180–206.
- Cao, J., J. Chen, L. Kuang, et al. 2015. “Abnormal Regional Homogeneity in Young Adult Suicide Attempters With No Diagnosable Psychiatric Disorder: A Resting State Functional Magnetic Imaging Study.” Psychiatry Research: Neuroimaging 231, no. 2: 95–102. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pscychresns.2014.10.011.
- Carli, V., C. W. Hoven, C. Wasserman, et al. 2014. “A Newly Identified Group of Adolescents at ‘Invisible’ Risk for Psychopathology and Suicidal Behavior: Findings From the Seyle Study.” World Psychiatry 13, no. 1: 78–86.
- Cha, C. B., P. J. Franz, E. M. Guzmán, C. R. Glenn, E. M. Kleiman, and M. K. Nock. 2018. “Annual Research Review: Suicide Among Youth - Epidemiology, (Potential) Etiology, and Treatment.” Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 59, no. 4: 460–482.
- Chen, V. C. H., J. Y. Chou, T. J. Lai, and C. T. C. Lee. 2010. “Suicide and Unemployment Rate in Taiwan: A Population-Based Study, 1978–2006.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 45: 447–452.
- Choi, Y. 2021. “Death Education on Youth Suicide Problem - Focusing on Bollnow's Existentialistic Consideration.” Korean Journal of Religious Education 66: 137–150.
- Christiansen, E., and B. F. Jensen. 2007. “Risk of Repetition of Suicide Attempt, Suicide or all Deaths After an Episode of Attempted Suicide: A Register-Based Survival Analysis.” Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 41, no. 3: 257–265.
- Classen, T. J., and R. A. Dunn. 2012. “The Effect of Job Loss and Unemployment Duration on Suicide Risk in the United States: a New Look Using Mass-Layoffs and Unemployment Duration.” Health Economics 21: 338–350. https://doi.org/10.1002/hec.1719.
- Colmenero-Navarrete, L., E. García-Sancho, and J. M. Salguero. 2022. “Relationship Between Emotion Regulation and Suicide Ideation and Attempt in Adults and Adolescents: A Systematic Review.” Archives of Suicide Research 26, no. 4: 1702–1735.
- Conger, R. D., K. J. Conger, G. H. Elder, Jr., F. O. Lorenz, R. L. Simons, and L. B. Whitbeck. 1993. “Family Economic Stress and Adjustment of Early Adolescent Girls.” Developmental Psychology 29: 206–219.
- Dougherty, D. M., C. W. Mathias, D. M. Marsh-Richard, et al. 2009. “Impulsivity and Clinical Symptoms Among Adolescents With Non-Suicidal Self-Injury With or Without Attempted Suicide.” Psychiatry Research 169, no. 1: 22–27. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychres.2008.06.011.
- Engel, G. L. 1977. “The Need for a New Medical Model: A Challenge for Biomedicine.” Science 196, no. 4286: 129–136.
- Erikson, E. H. 1968. Identity: Youth and Crisis. Norton & Co.
- Ernst, M., E. E. Nelson, S. Jazbec, et al. 2005. “Amygdala and Nucleus Accumbens in Responses to Receipt and Omission of Gains in Adults and Adolescents.” NeuroImage 25, no. 4: 1279–1291. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2004.12.038.
- Evans, E., K. Hawton, and K. Rodham. 2004. “Factors Associated With Suicidal Phenomena in Adolescents: A Systematic Review of Population-Based Studies.” Clinical Psychology Review 24, no. 8: 957–979. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2004.04.005.
- Fiksenbaum, L., Z. Marjanovic, E. Greenglass, and F. Garcia-Santos. 2017. “Impact of Economic Hardship and Financial Threat on Suicide Ideation and Confusion.” Journal of Psychology 151, no. 5: 477–495.
- Forbes, E. E., and R. E. Dahl. 2005. “Neural Systems of Positive Affect: Relevance to Understanding Child and Adolescent Depression?” Development and Psychopathology 17, no. 3: 827–850.
- Gallagher, M., M. J. Prinstein, V. Simon, and A. Spirito. 2014. “Social Anxiety Symptoms and Suicidal Ideation in a Clinical Sample of Early Adolescents: Examining Loneliness and Social Support as Longitudinal Mediators.” Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology 42: 871–883.
- Gili, M., P. Castellví, M. Vives, et al. 2019. “Mental Disorders as Risk Factors for Suicidal Behavior in Young People: A Meta-Analysis and Systematic Review of Longitudinal Studies.” Journal of Affective Disorders 245: 152–162. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2018.10.115.
- Giner, L., H. Blasco-Fontecilla, D. De La Vega, and P. Courtet. 2016. “Cognitive, Emotional, Temperament, and Personality Trait Correlates of Suicidal Behavior.” Current Psychiatry Reports 18: 102.
- Glenn, C. R., E. M. Kleiman, J. Kellerman, et al. 2020. “Annual Research Review: A Meta-analytic Review of Worldwide Suicide Rates in Adolescents.” Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 61, no. 3: 294–308.
- Gould, M. S., T. Greenberg, D. M. Velting, and D. Shaffer. 2003. “Youth Suicide Risk and Preventive Interventions: A Review of the Past 10 Years.” Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 42, no. 4: 386–405.
- Gvion, Y., and Y. Levi-Belz. 2018. “Serious Suicide Attempts: Systematic Review of Psychological Risk Factors.” Frontiers in Psychiatry 9: 56.
- Haas, B., and F. Popp. 2006. “Why Do People Injure Themselves?” Psychopathology 39, no. 1: 10–18.
- Haw, C., K. Hawton, D. Gunnell, and S. Platt. 2015. “Economic Recession and Suicidal Behaviour: Possible Mechanisms and Ameliorating Factors.” International Journal of Social Psychiatry 61, no. 1: 73–81.
- Jones, A. C., K. C. Schinka, M. H. M. van Dulmen, R. M. Bossarte, and M. H. Swahn. 2011. “Changes in Loneliness During Middle Childhood Predict Risk for Adolescent Suicidality Indirectly Through Mental Health Problems.” Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology 40, no. 6: 818–824.
- Kalokerinos, E. K., Y. Erbas, E. Ceulemans, and P. Kuppens. 2019. “Differentiate to Regulate: Low Negative Emotion Differentiation Is Associated With Ineffective use but Not Selection of Emotion-Regulation Strategies.” Psychological Science 30, no. 6: 863–879.
- Kim, B., D. H. Kim, S. Y. Jang, J. Shin, S. G. Lee, and T. H. Kim. 2022. “Family Economic Hardship and Adolescent Mental Health During the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Frontiers in Public Health 10: 904985.
- Kim, S. Y., M. H. Yang, H. E. Park, J. Y. Kim, and D. H. Lee. 2023. “An Overview of the Meta-Research of Self-Injury and Suicide: Focusing on Risk and Protective Factors.” Jounral of Educational Therapist 15, no. 1: 29–55. https://doi.org/10.35185/KJET.15.1.2.
10.35185/KJET.15.1.2 Google Scholar
- King, P. R., G. P. Beehler, K. Donnelly, J. S. Funderburk, and L. O. Wray. 2021. “A Practical Guide to Applying the Delphi Technique in Mental Health Treatment Adaptation: The Example of Enhanced Problem-Solving Training (E-Pst).” Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 52, no. 4: 376–386. https://doi.org/10.1037/pro0000371.
- Klein, D. N., J. E. Schwartz, S. Rose, and J. B. Leader. 2000. “Five-year Course and Outcome of Dysthymic Disorder: A Prospective, Naturalistic Follow-up Study.” American Journal of Psychiatry 157, no. 6: 931–939.
- Klonsky, E. D., and A. May. 2010. “Rethinking Impulsivity in Suicide.” Suicide & Life-Threatening Behavior 40, no. 6: 612–619. https://doi.org/10.1521/suli.2010.40.6.612.
- Klonsky, E. D., and J. J. Muehlenkamp. 2007. “Self-Injury: A Research Review for the Practitioner.” Journal of Clinical Psychology 63, no. 11: 1045–1056.
- Korean Statistical Information Service. (2022). 2021 Annual Report on the Causes of Death Statistics.
- Kwon, K., and S. Jo. 2015. “Delphi Research to Derive Ethical Elements of Group Counseling.” Korea Journal of Counseling 16, no. 6: 219–240.
10.15703/kjc.16.6.201512.219 Google Scholar
- Lee, T. K., K. A. S. Wickrama, and L. G. Simons. 2013. “Chronic Family Economic Hardship, Family Processes and Progression of Mental and Physical Health Symptoms in Adolescence.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence 42: 821–836.
- Leenaars, A., S. Wenckstern, M. Appleby, et al. 2001. “Current Issues in Dealing With Suicide Prevention in Schools: Perspectives From Some Countries.” Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation 12, no. 4: 365–384.
- Liao, L., K. Zhang, Y. Zhou, and J. Liu. 2024. “The Association Between Negative Emotion Differentiation and Emotion Regulation Flexibility in Daily Life.” Cognition and Emotion: 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1080/02699931.2024.2381079.
- Linehan, M. M., P. Camper, J. A. Chiles, K. Strosahl, and E. Shearin. 1987. “Interpersonal Problem Solving and Parasuicide.” Cognitive Therapy and Research 11: 1–12.
- Linstone, H. A., and M. Turoff. 1975. The Delphi Method, 3–12. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
- Lybbert, R., S. Ryland, and R. Bean. 2019. “Existential Interventions for Adolescent Suicidality: Practical Interventions to Target the Root Causes of Adolescent Distress.” Children and Youth Services Review 100: 98–104. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2019.02.028.
- McClelland, H., J. J. Evans, R. Nowland, E. Ferguson, and R. C. O'Connor. 2020. “Loneliness as a Predictor of Suicidal Ideation and Behaviour: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Prospective Studies.” Journal of Affective Disorders 274: 880–896.
- Miranda, R., M. Gallagher, B. Bauchner, R. Vaysman, and B. Marroquín. 2012. “Cognitive Inflexibility as a Prospective Predictor of Suicidal Ideation Among Young Adults With a Suicide Attempt History.” Depression and Anxiety 29, no. 3: 180–186.
- Miranda-Mendizabal, A., P. Castellví, O. Parés-Badell, et al. 2019. “Gender Differences in Suicidal Behavior in Adolescents and Young Adults: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Longitudinal Studies.” International Journal of Public Health 64, no. 2: 265–283.
- Nock, M. K., J. G. Green, I. Hwang, et al. 2013. “Prevalence, Correlates, and Treatment of Lifetime Suicidal Behavior Among Adolescents: Results From The National Comorbidity Survey Replication Adolescent Supplement.” JAMA Psychiatry 70, no. 3: 300–310.
- Nock, M. K., and A. E. Kazdin. 2002. “Examination of Affective, Cognitive, and Behavioral Factors and Suicide-Related Outcomes in Children and Young Adolescents.” Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology 31, no. 1: 48–58.
- Nock, M. K., M. M. Wedig, E. B. Holmberg, and J. M. Hooley. 2008. “The Emotion Reactivity Scale: Development, Evaluation, and Relation to Self-Injurious Thoughts and Behaviors.” Behavior Therapy 39, no. 2: 107–116.
- Nook, E. C. 2021. “Emotion Differentiation and Youth Mental Health: Current Understanding and Open Questions.” Frontiers in Psychology 12: 700298.
- O'Connor, R. C., R. Smyth, E. Ferguson, C. Ryan, and J. M. G. Williams. 2013. “Psychological Processes and Repeat Suicidal Behavior: A Four-year Prospective Study.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 81, no. 6: 1137–1143.
- Orbach, I. 2007. “ Existentialism and Suicide.” In Existential and Spiritual Issues in Death Attitudes, 307–342. Psychology Press.
- Ougrin, D., T. Tranah, D. Stahl, P. Moran, and J. R. Asarnow. 2015. “Therapeutic Interventions For Suicide Attempts and Self-Harm in Adolescents: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis.” Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 54, no. 2: 97–107.e2.
- Pandey, G. N. 2013. “Biological Basis of Suicide and Suicidal Behavior.” Bipolar Disorders 15, no. 5: 524–541. https://doi.org/10.1111/bdi.12089.
- Parra-Uribe, I., H. Blasco-Fontecilla, G. Garcia-Parés, et al. 2017. “Risk of Re-Attempts and Suicide Death After a Suicide Attempt: A Survival Analysis.” BMC Psychiatry 17, Article : 163.
- Petersen, A. C., P. A. Sarigiani, and R. E. Kennedy. 1991. “Adolescent Depression: Why More Girls?” Journal of Youth and Adolescence 20: 247–271.
- Qin, P., E. Agerbo, N. Westergård-Nielsen, T. Eriksson, and P. B. Mortensen. 2000. “Gender Differences in Risk Factors for Suicide in Denmark.” British Journal of Psychiatry 177, no. 6: 546–550.
- Rigby, K., and P. Slee. 1999. “Suicidal Ideation Among Adolescent School Children, Involvement in Bully—Victim Problems, and Perceived Social Support.” Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior 29, no. 2: 119–130.
- Robila, M., and A. Krishnakumar. 2005. “Effects of Economic Pressure on Marital Conflict in Romania.” Journal of Family Psychology 19, no. 2: 246–251.
- Ross, A. M., C. M. Kelly, and A. F. Jorm. 2014. “Re-Development of Mental Health First aid Guidelines for Suicidal Ideation and Behaviour: A Delphi Study.” BMC Psychiatry 14: 241. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-014-0241-8.
- Saini, P., C. Clements, K. J. Gardner, et al. 2022. “Identifying Suicide and Self-Harm Research Priorities in Northwest England: A Delphi Study.” Crisis 43, no. 1: 35–45.
- Shoib, S., T. W. Amanda, F. Saeed, et al. 2023. “Association Between Loneliness and Suicidal Behaviour: A Scoping Review.” Turk psikiyatri dergisi = Turkish Journal of Psychiatry 34, no. 2: 125–132.
- Simons, L. G., and R. D. Conger. 2007. “Linking Mother–Father Differences in Parenting to a Typology of Family Parenting Styles and Adolescent Outcomes.” Journal of Family Issues 28: 212–241.
- Smith, J. A., and J. E. Rhodes. 2015. “Being Depleted and Being Shaken: An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis of the Experiential Features of a First Episode of Depression.” Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice 88, no. 2: 197–209. https://doi.org/10.1111/papt.12034.
- Stravynski, A., and R. Boyer. 2001. “Loneliness in Relation to Suicide Ideation and Parasuicide: A Population-Wide Study.” Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior 31, no. 1: 32–40.
- Suresh Kumar, P., P. Anish, and B. George. 2015. “Risk Factors for Suicide in Elderly in Comparison to Younger Age Groups.” Indian Journal of Psychiatry 57, no. 3: 249–254.
- Thompson, R. J., T. Springstein, and M. Boden. 2021. “Gaining Clarity About Emotion Differentiation.” Social and Personality Psychology Compass 15, no. 3: e12584.
- A. Tomer, G. T. Eliason, and P. T. Wong, ed. 2008. Existential and Spiritual Issues in Death Attitudes. Mawhaw, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers.
- Victor, S. E., and E. D. Klonsky. 2014. “Correlates of Suicide Attempts Among Self-Injurers: A Meta-Analysis.” Clinical Psychology Review 34, no. 4: 282–297. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2014.03.005.
- Weissman, D. G., E. C. Nook, A. A. Dews, et al. 2020. “Low Emotional Awareness as a Transdiagnostic Mechanism Underlying Psychopathology in Adolescence.” Clinical Psychological Science 8, no. 6: 971–988.
- Wilchek-Aviad, Y., and M. Malka. 2016. “Religiosity, Meaning in Life and Suicidal Tendency Among Jews.” Journal of Religion and Health 55, no. 2: 480–494. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-014-9996-y.
- Zahl, D. L., and K. Hawton. 2004. “Repetition of Deliberate Self-Harm and Subsequent Suicide Risk: Long-Term Follow-up Study of 11583 Patients.” British Journal of Psychiatry 185, no. 1: 70–75.
- Zebhauser, A., L. Hofmann-Xu, J. Baumert, et al. 2014. “How Much Does it Hurt to Be Lonely? Mental and Physical Differences Between Older Men and Women in the Kora-Age Study.” International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 29, no. 3: 245–252.
- Zouk, H., M. Tousignant, M. Seguin, A. Lesage, and G. Turecki. 2006. “Characterization of Impulsivity in Suicide Completers: Clinical, Behavioral and Psychosocial Dimensions.” Journal of Affective Disorders 92, no. 2–3: 195–204.