Evidence for neuropsychological effects of PCBs in environmental studies: Getting better all the time
Deborah C. Rice,
Corresponding Author
Deborah C. Rice
Maine Bureau of Health, Department of Human Services
Maine Bureau of Health, State House Station 11, Augusta, ME 04333–0017. E-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorDeborah C. Rice,
Corresponding Author
Deborah C. Rice
Maine Bureau of Health, Department of Human Services
Maine Bureau of Health, State House Station 11, Augusta, ME 04333–0017. E-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
This invited response to the paper by D.V. Cicchetti, A.S. Kaufman, and S.S. Sparrow (CKS), and the responses by the investigative teams of the studies criticized by them, addresses specific errors of logic and interpretation by CKS, and integrates comments made by the study investigators. CKS provide a flawed analysis of the literature on the neuropsychological effects of PCBs identified in epidemiological studies. Arguments regarding the inadequacy of study design and data analysis are for the most part factually in error, unimportant, superceded by later testing or analysis within a study, or if true, would bias results toward the null rather than finding spurious effects. They also fail to differentiate between small effects in an individual and the societal consequences of such effects, and fail to recognize the overall consistency of effects among studies. In fact, the literature is remarkably consistent in documenting adverse consequences of developmental exposure to PCBs in humans. In addition, contrary to assertions by CKS, developmental studies in monkeys documented cognitive effects at body burdens observed in human studies. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Psychol Schs 41: 693–707, 2004.
REFERENCES
- Baghurst, P.A., McMichael, A.J., Wigg, N.R., Vimpani, G.V., Robertson, E.J., Roberts, R.J., et al. ( 1992). Environmental exposure to lead and children's intelligence at the age of seven years. The Port Pirie cohort study. New England Journal of Medicine, 327, 1279–1284.
- Bellinger, D.C. ( 1995). Interpreting the literature on lead and child development: The neglected role of the “Experimental System.” Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 17, 201–212.
- Bellinger, D.C. ( 2000). Effect modification in epidemiologic studies of low-level neurotoxicant exposures and health outcomes. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 22, 133–140.
- Bellinger, D.C., Stiles, K.M., & Needleman, H.L. ( 1992). Low-level lead exposure, intelligence and academic achievement: A long-term follow-up study. Pediatrics, 90, 855–861.
- Canfield, R.L., Henderson, C.R., Cory-Slechta, D.A., Cox, C., Jusko, T.A., & Lanphear, B.P. ( 2003). Intellectual impairment in children with blood lead concentrations below 10 micrograms per deciliter. New England Journal of Medicine, 348, 1517–1526.
- Cicchetti, D.V., Kaufman, A.S., & Sparrow, S.S. ( 2004). The relationship between prenatal and postnatal exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and cognitive, neuropsychological, and behavioral deficits: A critical appraisal. Psychology in the Schools, 41, 589–624.
- Darvill, T., Lonky, E., Reihman, J., Stewart, P., & Pagano, J. ( 2000). Prenatal exposure to PCBs and infant performance on the Fagan Test of Infant Intelligence. Neurotoxicology, 21, 1029–1038.
- Davidson, P.W., Kost, J., Myers, G.J., Cox, C., Clarkson, T.W., & Shamlaye, C.F. ( 2001). Methylmercury and neurodevelopment: Reanalysis of the Seychelles Child Development Study outcomes at 66 months of age. Journal of the American Medical Association, 285, 1291–1293.
- Dietrich, K.N., Berger, O.G., Succop, P.A., Hammond, P.B., & Bornschein, R.L. ( 1993). The developmental consequences of low to moderate prenatal and postnatal lead exposure: Intellectual attainment in the Cincinnati Lead Study Cohort following school entry. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 15, 37–44.
- Environmental Protection Agency. ( 1985). Costs and benefits of reducing lead in gasoline: Final regulatory impact analysis (EPA-230–05–85–006). Washington, DC: Author.
- Gladen, B., & Rogan, W. ( 1991). Effects of perinatal polychlorinated biphenyls and dichlorodiphenyl dichloroethane on later development. Journal of Pediatrics, 119, 58–63.
- Gladen, B.C., & Rogan, W.J. ( 2004). Relationship of perinatal PCB exposure to neurodevelopmental outcomes: Reply to appraisal. Psychology in the Schools, 41, 687–691.
- Gladen, B.C., Rogan, W.J., Hardy, P., Thullen, J., Tingelstad, J., & Tully, M. ( 1988). Development after exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls and dichlorodiphenyl dichloroethene transplacentally and through human milk. Journal of Pediatrics, 113, 991–995.
- Grandjean, P., Weihe, P., Burse, V.W., Needham, L.L., Storr-Hansen, E., Heinzow, B., et al. ( 2001). Neurobehavioral deficits associated with PCB in 7-year-old children prenatally exposed to seafood neurotoxicants. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 23, 305–317.
- Grandjean, P., Weihe, P., White, R.F., Debes, F., Araki, S., Yokoyama, K., et al. ( 1997). Cognitive deficit in 7-year-old children with prenatal exposure to methylmercury. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 19, 417–428.
- Grosse, S.D., Matte, T.D., Schwartz, J., & Jackson, R.J. ( 2002). Economic gains resulting from the reduction in children's exposure to lead in the United States. Environmental Health Perspectives, 110, 563–569.
- Huisman, M., Koopman-Esseboom, C., Fidler, V., Hadders-Algra, M., van der Paauw, C.G., Tuinstra, L.G.M.Th., et al. ( 1995). Perinatal exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls and dioxins and its effect on neonatal neurological development. Early Human Development, 41, 111–127.
- Jacobson, J.L., & Jacobson, S.W. ( 1996). Intellectual impairment in children exposed to polychlorinated biphenyls in utero. New England Journal of Medicine, 335, 783–789.
- Jacobson, J.L., & Jacobson, S.W. ( 2002). Breast-feeding and gender as moderators of teratologic effects on cognitive development. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 24, 348–358.
- Jacobson, J.L., & Jacobson, S.W. ( 2004). Prospective studies of exposure to an environmental contaminant: The challenge of hypothesis testing in a multivariate correlational context. Psychology in the Schools, 41, 625–637.
- Jacobson, J.L., Jacobson, S.W., & Humphrey, H.E. ( 1990). Effects of exposure to PCBs and related compounds on growth and activity in children. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 12, 319–326.
- Jacobson, J.L., Jacobson, S.W., Padgett, R.J., Brummit, G.A., & Billings, R.L. ( 1992). Effects of prenatal PCB exposure on cognitive processing efficiency and sustained attention. Developmental Psychology, 28, 297–306.
- Jacobson, J.L., Schwartz, P.M., Fein, G.G., & Dowler, J.K. ( 1984). Prenatal exposure to an environmental toxin: A test of the multiple effects model. Developmental Psychology, 20, 523–532.
- Jacobson, S.W., Fein, G.G., Jacobson, J.L., Schwartz, P.M., & Dowler, J.K. ( 1985). The effect of PCB exposure on visual recognition memory. Child Development, 56, 853–860.
- Jacobson, S.W., Jacobson, J.L., & Fein, G.G. ( 1986). Environmental toxins and infant development. In H.E. Fitzgerald, B.M. Lester, & M.W. Yogman (Eds.), Theory and research in behavioral pediatrics (Vol. 3, pp. 96–146). New York: Plenum Press.
- Kaufman, A.S. ( 2001). Do low levels of lead produce IQ loss in children? A careful examination of the literature. Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology, 16, 303–341.
- Ko, H., Yao, B., Chang, F.-M., Hsu, C.-C., Jacobson, S.W., & Jacobson, J.L. ( 1994). Preliminary evidence of recognition memory deficits in infants born to Yucheng exposed women. In H. Fiedler, O. Hutzinger, L. Birnbaum, G. Lambert, L. Needham, & S. Safe (Eds.), Dioxin '94. Kyoto, Japan: Kyoto University.
- Koopman-Esseboom, C., Weisglas-Kuperus, N., de Ridder, M.A.J., Van der Paauw, C.G., Tuinstra, L.G.M.Th., & Sauer, P.J.J. ( 1996). Effects of polychlorinated biphenyl/dioxin exposure and feeding type on infants' mental and psychomotor development. Pediatrics, 97, 700–706.
- Kopp, C., & McCall, R. ( 1982). Predicting later mental performance for normal, at risk, and handicapped infants. In P. Baltes & O. Brim (Eds.), Life-span development and behavior (Vol. 4, pp. 33–61). New York: Academic Press.
- Landrigan, P.J., Schechter, C.B., Lipton, J.M., Fahs, M.C., & Schwartz, J. ( 2002). Environmental pollutants and disease in American children: Estimates of morbidity, mortality, and costs for lead poisoning, asthma, cancer, and developmental disabilities. Environmental Health Perspectives, 110, 721–728.
- Leviton, A., Bellinger, D., Allred, E.N., Rabinowitz, M., Needleman, H., & Schoenbaum, S. ( 1993). Pre- and postnatal low-level lead exposure and children's dysfunction in school. Environmental Research, 60, 30–43.
- Longnecker, M.P., Gladen, B.C., Patterson, D.G., Jr., & Rogan, W.J. ( 2000). Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB) exposure in relation to thyroid hormone levels in neonates. Epidemiology, 11, 249–254.
- Longnecker, M.P., Wolff, M.S., Gladen, B.C., Brock, J.W., Grandjean, P., Jacobson, J.L., et al. ( 2003). Comparison of polychlorinated biphenyl levels across studies of human neurodevelopment. Environmental Health Perspectives, 111, 65–70.
- Lonky, E., Reihman, J., Darvill, T., Mather, J., & Daly, H. ( 1996). Neonatal behavioral assessment scale performance in humans influenced by maternal consumption of environmentally contaminated Lake Ontario fish. Journal of Great Lakes Research, 22, 198–212.
- McCall, R.B., & Carriger, M.S. ( 1993). A meta-analysis of infant habituation and recognition memory performance as predictors of later IQ. Child Development, 64, 57–79.
- Muckle, G., Jacobson, S.W., Ayotte, P., Dewaily, E., & Jacobson, J.L. ( 2003). Environmental contaminants and infant development in Nunavik. Paper presented at the northern contaminants program symposium: Canadian arctic contaminants assessment, Ottawa, Canada.
- Muir, T., & Zegarac, M. ( 2001). Societal costs of exposure to toxic substances: Economic and health costs of four case studies that are candidates for environmental causation. Environmental Health Perspectives, 109, 885–903.
- National Academy of Sciences Institute of Medicine. ( 2003). Dioxins and dioxin-like compounds in the food supply: Strategies to decrease exposure. Washington, DC: Author.
- National Institutes of Environmental Health Sciences. ( 1998). Scientific issues relevant to assessment of health effects from exposure to methylmercury. Workshop organized by Committee on Environment and Natural Resources (CENR). Washington, DC: Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP).
- Patandin, S., Koot, H.M., Sauer, P.J.J., & Weisglas-Kuperus, N. ( 1999a). Problem behavior in Dutch preschool children in relation to background polychlorinated biphenyl and dioxin exposure. Effects of environmental exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls and dioxins on growth and development in young children (pp. 143–156). Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Erasmus University, Rotterdam.
- Patandin, S., Lanting, C.I., Mulder, P.G.H., Boersma, E.R., Sauer, P.J.J., & Weisglas-Kuperus, N. ( 1999b). Effects of environmental exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls and dioxins on cognitive abilities in Dutch children at 42 months of age. Journal of Pediatrics, 134, 33–41.
- Patandin, S., Veenstra, J., Mulder, P.G.H., Sewnaik, A., Sauer, P.J.J., & Weisglas-Kuperus, N. ( 1999c). Attention and activity in 42-month-old Dutch children with environmental exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls and dioxins. Effects of environmental exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls and dioxins on growth and development in young children (pp. 123–142). Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Erasmus University, Rotterdam.
- Rice, D.C. ( 1996). PCBs and behavioral impairment: Are there lessons we can learn from lead? Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 18, 229–232.
- Rice, D.C. ( 1997). Effect of postnatal exposure to a PCB mixture in monkeys on multiple fixed interval-fixed ratio performance. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 19, 429–434.
- Rice, D.C. ( 1998). Effects of postnatal exposure of monkeys to a PCB mixture on spatial discrimination reversal and DRL performance. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 20, 391–400.
- Rice, D.C. ( 1999). Behavioral impairment produced by low-level postnatal PCB exposure in monkeys. Environmental Research 80, S113–S121.
- Rice, D.C., & Hayward, S. ( 1997). Effects of postnatal exposure to a PCB mixture in monkeys on nonspatial discrimination reversal and delayed alternation performance. Neurotoxicology, 18, 479–494.
- Rice, D.C., & Hayward, S. ( 1999). Effects of postnatal exposure of monkeys to a PCB mixture on concurrent random interval-random interval and progressive ratio performance. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 21, 47–58.
- Rogan, W.J., & Gladen, B.C. ( 1991). PCBs, DDE, and Child Development at 18 and 24 Months. Annals of Epidemiology, 1, 407–413.
- Rogan, W.J., Gladen, B.C., McKinney, J.D., Carreras, N., Hardy, P., Thullen, J., et al. ( 1986a). Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and dichlorodiphenyl dichloroethane (DDE) in human milk: Effects of maternal factors and previous lactation. American Journal of Public Health, 76, 172–177.
- Rogan, W.J., Gladen, B.C., McKinney, J.D., Carreras, N., Hardy, P., Thullen, J., et al. ( 1986b). Neonatal effects of transplacental exposure to PCBs and DDE. Journal of Pediatrics, 109, 335–341.
- Salkever, D.S. ( 1995). Updated estimates of earnings benefits from reduced exposure of children to environmental lead. Environmental Research, 70, 1–6.
- Schantz, S.L. ( 1996). Developmental neurotoxicity of PCBs in humans: What do we know and where do we go from here? Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 18, 217–228.
- Schantz, S.L., Gardiner, J.C., Gasior, D.M., McCaffrey, R.J., Sweeney, A.M., & Humphrey, H.E.B. ( 2004). Much ado about something: The weight of evidence for PCB effects on neuropsychological function. Psychology in the Schools, 41, 669–679.
- Schantz, S.L., Gasior, D.M., Plverejan, E., Humphrey, H.E.B., Gardiner, J.C., McCaffrey, R.J., et al. ( 2002). PCB-induced impairments in older adults: Schantz et al.'s response. Environmental Health Perspectives, 110, 71–72.
- Schantz, S.L., Widholm, J.J., & Rice, D.C. ( 2003). Effects of PCB exposure on neuropsychological function in children. Environmental Health Perspectives, 111, 357–376.
- Schwartz, J. ( 1994). Societal benefits of reducing lead exposure. Environmental Research, 66, 105–124.
- Stewart, P., Fitzgerald, B., Reihman, J., Gump, B., Lonky, E., Darvill, T., et al. ( 2003a). Prenatal PCB exposure, the corpus collosum, and response inhibition. Environmental Health Perspectives, 111, 1670–1677.
- Stewart, P., Reihman, J., Lonky, E., Darvill, T., & Pagano, J. ( 2000). Prenatal PCB exposure and neonatal behavioral assessment scale (NBAS) performance. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 22, 21–29.
- Stewart, P., Reihman, J., Lonky, E., Darvill, T., & Pagano, J. ( 2004). Prenatal PCB exposure and neurobehavioral development in infants and children: Can the Oswego study inform the current debate? Psychology in the Schools, 41, 639–653.
- Stewart, P.W., Reihman, J., Lonky, E.I., Darvill, T.J., & Pagano, J. ( 2003b). Cognitive development in preschool children prenatally exposed to PCBs and MeHg. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 5525, 1–12.
- Vreugdenhil, H.J.I., Lanting, C.I., Mulder, P.G.H., Boersma, E.R., & Weisglas-Kuperus, N. ( 2002a). Effects of prenatal PCB and dioxin exposure on cognitive and motor abilities in Dutch children at school age. Journal of Pediatrics, 140, 48–56.
- Vreugdenhil, H.J.I., Slijper, F.M.E., Mulder, P.G.H., & Weisglas-Kuperus, N. ( 2002b). Effects of perinatal exposure to PCBs and dioxins on play behavior in Dutch children at school age. Environmental Health Perspectives, 110, A593–A598.
- Walkowiak, J., Wiener, J.-A., Fastabend, A., Heinzow, B., Krämer, U., Schmidt, E., et al. ( 2001). Environmental exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls and quality of the home environment: Effects on psychodevelopment in early childhood. The Lancet, 358, 1602–1607.
- Weisglas-Kuperus, N., Vreugdenhil, H.J.I., & Mulder, P.G.H. ( 2004). Reply to Cicchetti, Kaufman, and Sparrow. Psychology in the Schools, 41, 665–668.
- Weiss, B. ( 1990). Risk assessment: The insidious nature of neurotoxicity and the aging brain. Neurotoxicology, 11, 305–314.
- Weiss, B. ( 2000). Vulnerability of children and the developing brain to neurotoxic hazards. Environmental Health Perspectives, 108, 375–381.
- Wigg, N.R., Vimpani, C.V., McMichael, A.J., Baghurst, P.A., Robertson, E.F., Roberts, R.J. ( 1988) Port Pirie cohort study: Childhood blood lead and neuropsychological development at two years of age. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 42, 213–219.
- Winneke, G., Bucholski, A., Heinzow, B., Kraemer, U., Schmidt, E., Walkowiak, J., et al. ( 1998). Developmental neurotoxicity of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs): Cognitive and psychomotor functions in 7-month old children. Toxicology Letters, 102–103, 423–428.
- Winneke, G., Kraemer, U., Walkowiak, J., Fastabend, A., Heinzow, B., Borte, M., et al. ( 2002). Delay of neurobehavioral development following pre- and postnatal PCB exposure: Persistent or reversible? Paper presented at the second PCB workshop—Recent advances in the environmental toxicology and health effects of PCBs, Brno, Czech Republic. Abstract published in Naunyn-Schmiedeberg's Archives of Pharmacolgy (2002), Vol. 365 Suppl. Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.
- Winneke, G., Walkowiak, J., & Krämer, U. ( 2004). Strong opinions are no substitute for balanced arguments: Comments on Cicchetti, Kaufman, and Sparrow's critical appraisal of PCB cohort studies. Psychology in the Schools, 41, 655–663.
