The spectrum of primary blastomycotic meningitis: A review of central nervous system blastomycosis
Corresponding Author
Dr Edward F. Gonyea MD
Neurology Service, Veterans Administration Hospital, Memphis, TN
Department of Neurology, University of Tennessee Center for the Health Sciences, Memphis, TN
Neurology Service, Veterans Administration Hospital, 1030 Jefferson Ave, Memphis, TN 38104Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Dr Edward F. Gonyea MD
Neurology Service, Veterans Administration Hospital, Memphis, TN
Department of Neurology, University of Tennessee Center for the Health Sciences, Memphis, TN
Neurology Service, Veterans Administration Hospital, 1030 Jefferson Ave, Memphis, TN 38104Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Three cases of meningitis with initial and exclusive neurological involvement prompted a review of the clinical, cerebrospinal fluid, and pathological findings in an additional 78 patients with central nervous system blastomycosis. The first patient of the 3 had progressive cerebellar dysfunction as the result of chronic basilar meningitis. The second had a C8-T1 radiculopathy without other evidence of superior sulcus syndrome, and subsequent acute fatal meningitis. The third had aseptic, benign, self-limited meningitis followed by clinically obvios systemic blastomycosis.
Diagnosis is difficult, and it is likely that other cases have been presumptively treated for tuberculous meningitis. A more aggressive approach to diagnosis is proposed that takes into account the condition of the patient, the likelihood of dissemination at necropsy, and the frequent meningeal infections that are negative on culture of lumbar CSF.
References
- 1 Aszkanazy CL, Barrie HJ, Crookston JH: Systemic blastomycosis. Can Med Assoc J 65: 55–56, 1951
- 2
Badham C:
Preliminary report on the causal organisms of blastomycotic meningitis.
Med J Aust
2: 385,
1922
10.5694/j.1326-5377.1922.tb61810.x Google Scholar
- 3
Barlow DL:
Primary blastomycotic meningitis occurring in a child.
Med J Aust
2: 302–304,
1923
10.5694/j.1326-5377.1923.tb118942.x Google Scholar
- 4 Barrett-Connor E: Tuberculous meningitis in adults. South Med J 60: 1061–1067, 1967
- 5 Beaver DC, Furrer ED: Pathogenic yeasts and yeast-like organisms: report of a case in Minnesota simulating coccidioidal granuloma. J Lab Clin Med 18: 329–348, 1933
- 6 Bechtel RE, LeCount ER: A case of systemic blastomycosis with necropsy. Arch Intern Med 13: 609–613, 1914
- 7 Berger MP, Paz J: Diagnosis of cryptococcal meningitis. JAMA 236: 2517–2518, 1976
- 8 Bonoff CP: Acute primary pulmonary blastomycosis. Radiology A 54: 157–164, 1950
- 9 Boughton TH, Clark SN: A case of blastomycosis. Arch Intern Med 13: 594–598, 1914
- 10 Buechner HA, Clawson CM: Blastomycosis of the central nervous system: II. A report of nine cases from the Veterans Administration Cooperative Study. Am Rev Respir Dis 95: 820–826, 1967
- 11 Buechner HA, Seabury JH, Campbell CC, et al: The current status of serologic, immunologic and skin tests in the diagnosis of pulmonary mycoses. Chest 63: 259–270, 1973
- 12 Busey JF: Blastomycosis: III. A comparative study of 2-hydroxystilbamidine and amphotericin B therapy. Am Rev Respir Dis 105: 812–818, 1972
- 13 Busey JF, Baker R, Birch L, et al: Blastomycosis: I. A review of 198 collected cases in Veterans Administration hospitals (Blastomycosis Cooperative Study of the Veterans Administration). Am Rev Respir Dis 89: 659–672, 1964
- 14 Cabot Case Report No. 25292: Generalized blastomycosis with meningitis. N Engl J Med 221: 111–115, 1939
- 15 Carmody EJ, Tappen W: Blastomycosis meningitis: a report of a case successfully treated with amphotericin B. Ann Intern Med 51: 780–791, 1959
- 16 Cherniss EI, Waisbren BA: North American blastomycosis: a clinical study of 40 cases. Ann Intern Med 44: 105–123, 1956
- 17 Chick EW, Sutliff WD, Rakich JH, et al: Epidemiological aspects of cases of blastomycosis admitted to Memphis, Tennessee, hospitals during the period 1922–1954: a review of 86 cases. Am J Med Sci 231: 253–262, 1956
- 18 Christensen C, Hektoen L: Generalized blastomycosis. JAMA 47: 247, 1906
- 19 Churchill T, Stober AM: A case of systemic blastomycosis. Arch Intern Med 13: 568–574, 1914
- 20 Conant NF, Smith DT, Baker RD, et al: Cryptococcosis, in Manual of Clinical Mycology. Third edition. Philadelphia, WB Saunders Company, 1971, p 296
- 21 Cooper CN: The clinical history and pathologic observations in a case of systemic blastomycosis. J Iowa Med Soc 21: 119–122, 1931
- 22 Craig WMcK, Carmichael FA Jr.: Blastomycoma of the cerebellum: report of a case. Mayo Clin Proc 13: 347–351, 1938
- 23 Craig WMck, Dockerty MB, Harrington SW: Intravertebral and intrathoracic blastomycoma simulating dumb-bell tumor. South Surg 9: 759–766, 1940
- 24 D'Aunoy R, Beven JL: Systemic blastomycosis. J Lab Clin Med 16: 124–130, 1930
- 25 DeJong RN: Spinal puncture, in The Neurologic Examination. Third edition. New York, Harper & Row, 1967, p 1042
- 26 Drutz DJ, Spickard A, Rogers DE, et al: Treatment of disseminated mycotic infections: a new approach to amphotericin B therapy. Am J Med 45: 405–418, 1968
- 27 Duttera MJ, Osterhout S: North American blastomycosis: a survey of 63 cases. South Med J 62: 295–301, 1969
- 28 Eickenberg H-U, Amin M, Lich R Jr.: Blastomycosis of the genitourinary tract. J Urol 113: 650–652, 1975
- 29 Eisendrath DN, Ormsby OS: A case of systemic blastomycosis, with blastomycetes in the sputum. JAMA 45: 1045–1048, 1905
- 30 Ellner JJ, Bennett JE: Chronic meningitis. Medicine (Baltimore) 55: 341–370, 1976
- 31 Farnell FJ, Starr S: Systemic oidiomycosis: with manifestations in central nervous system. Boston Med Surg J 176: 771–773, 1917
- 32 Feld DD, Cadden AV: Systemic blastomycosis. Dis Chest 16: 473–482, 1949
- 33 Fetter BF, Klintworth GK, Hendry WS: Mycoses of the Central Nervous System. Baltimore, The Williams & Wilkins Company, 1967, pp 38–52, 89–123
- 34 Fish RG, Takaro T, Lovell M: Coexistent Addison's disease and North American blastomycosis. Am J Med 28: 152–155, 1960
- 35 Fountain FF: Acute blastomycotic arthritis. Arch Intern Med 132: 684–688, 1973
- 36
Franks AG,
Taylor HG:
Cutaneous blastomycosis complicated by meningitis.
Arch Dermatol Syph
48: 88–90,
1943
10.1001/archderm.1943.01510010092015 Google Scholar
- 37 Friedman LL, Signorelli JJ: Blastomycosis: a brief review of the literature and a report of a case involving the meninges. Ann Intern Med 24: 385–400, 1946
- 38 Furcolow ML, Smith CD: A new hypothesis on the epidemiology of blastomycosis and the ecology of Blastomyces dermatitidis. Trans NY Acad Sci 35: 421–430, 1973
- 39
Furcolow ML,
Watson KA,
Tisdall OF, et al:
Some factors affecting survival in systemic blastomycosis.
Dis Chest 54 Suppl
1: 285–291,
1968
10.1378/chest.54.Supplement_1.285 Google Scholar
- 40 Gaspar I: Blastomycotic meningo-encephalitis. Arch Neurol Psychiatry 22: 475–486, 1929
- 41
Gaspar I,
Fenstermacher WA,
Lingeman LR:
Systemic blastomycosis, with report of a fatal case.
Radiology
18: 305–315,
1931
10.1148/18.2.305 Google Scholar
- 42 Gonyea EF: Cisternal puncture and cryptococcal meningitis. Arch Neurol 28: 200–201, 1973
- 43 Gonyea EF: Site vs. quantity of cerebrospinal fluid in detecting cryptococcal meningitis. N Engl J Med 289: 272, 1973
- 44 Gonyea EF, Heilman KM: Neuro-ophthalmic aspects of central nervous system cryptococcosis. Arch Ophthalmol 87: 164–168, 1972
- 45 Goto K: Ueber Blastomycetenmeningitis. Mitt Med Fak Tokyo 15: 75–101, 1915
- 46 Greenfield JG: Blastomycotic infection of the nervous system. Med Sci 10: 267–273, 1924
- 47 Greenwood RC, Voris HC: Systemic blastomycosis with spinal cord involvement: case report. J Neurosurg 7: 450–454, 1950
- 48 Habte-Gahr E, Smith IM: North American blastomycosis in Iowa: review of 34 cases. J Chronic Dis 26: 585–594, 1973
- 49 Hodges GR, Fass RJ, Saslaw S: Central nervous system disease associated with Mycoplasma pneumoniae infection. Arch Intern Med 130: 277–282, 1972
- 50 Hurley TD: An unique lesion of the heart in systemic blastomycosis. J Med Res 33: 499–502, 1916
- 51 Jones TB: Localized infection caused by yeast-like fungi: with special reference to the spinal involvement. Surg Gynecol Obstet 50: 972–984, 1930
- 52 Kaufmann GE, Clark K: Continuous simultaneous monitoring of intraventricular and cervical subarachnoid cerebrospinal fluid pressure to indicate development of cerebral or tonsillar herniation. J Neurosurg 33: 145–150, 1970
- 53 Kepron MW, Schoemperlen CB, Hershfield ES, et al: North American blastomycosis in Central Canada: a review of 36 cases. Can Med Assoc J 106: 243–246, 1972
- 54 Krost RA, Moes MJ, Stober AM: A case of systemic blastomycosis. JAMA 50: 184–188, 1908
- 55 Krost RA, Stober AM, Moes MJ: A case of systemic blastomycosis. Arch Intern Med 13: 557–567, 1914
- 56 Kunkel WM Jr, Weed LA, McDonald JR, et al: Collective review: North American blastomycosis: Gilchrist's disease: a clinicopathologic study of ninety cases. Int Abstr Surg 99: 1–26, 1954
- 57 Larkin JC, Young JM, Sutliff WD: Clinicopathologic conference: systemic blastomycosis involving genitourinary tract and skin. J Tenn Med Assoc 66: 1141–1142, 1973
- 58
LeCount ER:
Blastomycotic lesions of the brain.
J Nerv Ment Dis
36: 144–149,
1909
10.1097/00005053-190903000-00002 Google Scholar
- 59 LeCount ER, Myers J: Systemic blastomycosis: final report of the case described by Eisendrath and Ormsby in 1905. J Infect Dis 4: 187–200, 1907
- 60 Leers W-D, Russell NA, Laroye G: Cerebellar abscess due to Blastomyces dermatitidis. Can Med Assoc J 107: 657–660, 1972
- 61 Levitas JR, Baum GL: Surgical aspects of blastomycosis. Surgery 33: 93–101, 1953
- 62 Lewison M, Jackson H: A case of systemic blastomycosis. Arch Intern Med 13: 575–584, 1914
- 63 Littman ML, Wicker EH, Warren AS: Systemic North American blastomycosis: report of a case with cultural studies of the etiologic agent and observations on the effect of streptomycin and penicillin in vitro. Am J Pathol 24: 339–365, 1948
- 64 Lockwood WR, Allison F Jr, Batson BE, et al: The treatment of North American blastomycosis: ten years'experience. Am Rev Respir Dis 100: 314–320, 1969
- 65 Lockwood WR, Busey JF, Batson BE, et al: Experiences in the treatment of North American blastomycosis with 2-hydroxystilbamidine. Ann Intern Med 57: 553–562, 1962
- 66 Loudon RG, Lawson RA Jr: Systemic blastomycosis: recurrent neurological relapse in a case treated with amphotericin B. Ann Intern Med 55: 139–147, 1961
- 67 MacBryde CM, Thompson El: Meningitis and dermatitis caused by a new variety of blastomycete (endomycete). Arch Dermatol Syph 27: 49–69, 1933
- 68 Martin DS, Smith DT: Blastomycosis (American blastomycosis, Gilchrist's disease): I. A review of the literature. Am Rev Tuberc 39: 275–304, 1939
- 69 Martin DS, Smith DT: Blastomycosis (American blastomycosis, Gilchrist's disease): II. A report of thirteen new cases. Am Rev Tuberc 39: 488–515, 1939
- 70 McKenty FE, Morgan D: Blastomycosis. Ann Surg 61: 513–518, 1915
- 71 Montgomery FH, Ormsby OS: Systemic blastomycosis. Arch Intern Med 2: 1–41, 1909
- 72 Montgomery H: Systemic blastomycosis. Med Clin North Am 14: 651–662, 1930
- 73 Moore JT: Blastomycosis: with report of a case dying from abscess of the brain. Surg Gynecol Obstet 31: 590–594, 1920
- 74 Myers HJ, Stober AM: A case of systemic blastomycosis. Arch Intern Med 13: 585–593, 1914
- 75 Osmond JD, Schweitzer G, Dunbar JM, et al: Blastomycosis of the spine with paraplegia. S Afr Med J 45: 431–434, 1971
- 76 Palmer PE, McFadden SW: Blastomycosis: report of an unusual case. N Engl J Med 279: 979–983, 1968
- 77 Parker CA: Actinomycosis and blastomycosis of the spine. J Bone Joint Surg [Am] 5: 759–777, 1923
- 78 Parker JD, Doto IL, Tosh FE: A decade of experience with blastomycosis and its treatment with ampbotericin B. Am Rev Respir Dis 99: 895–902, 1969
- 79 Rabinowitz JG, Busch J, Buttram WR: Pulmonary manifestations of blastomycosis: radiological support of a new concept. Radiology 120: 25–32, 1976
- 80 Rainey RL, Harris TR: Disseminated blastomycosis with meningeal involvement. Arch Intern Med 117: 744–747, 1966
- 81 Rewbridge AG, Dodge CW, Ayers TT: A case of meningitis due to Endomyces capsulatus (new species). Am J Pathol 5: 349–364, 1929
- 82 Riley FB, LeCount ER: A case of systemic blastomycosis. Arch Intern Med 13: 614–616, 1914
- 83 Rusk GY: A case of pulmonary, cerebral, and meningeal blastomycosis. Proc NY Pathol Soc 10: 48–50, 1910–1911
- 84 Sayk J: The cerebrospinal fluid in brain tumors, in PJ Vinken, GW Bruyn (eds): Handbook of Clinical Neurology, vol 16, Tumors of the Brain and Skull, Part I. New York, American Elsevier, 1974, p 360
- 85 Schwarz J, Baum GL: Blastomycosis. Am J Clin Pathol 21: 999–1029, 1951
- 86 Seabury JH, Dascomb HE: Results of the treatment of systemic mycoses. JAMA 188: 509–513, 1964
- 87 Sinskey RM, Anderson WB: Miliary blastomycosis with metastatic spread to posterior uvea of both eyes. AMA Arch Ophthalmol 54: 602–604, 1955
- 88 Solway LJ, Kohan M, Pritzker HG: A case of disseminated blastomycosis. Can Med Assoc J 41: 331–336, 1939
- 89 Stober AM: Systemic blastomycosis: a report of its pathological, bacteriological and clinical features. Arch Intern Med 13: 509–556, 1914
- 90 Sutliff WD, Cruthirds TP: Blastomyces dermatitidis in cytologic preparations. Am Rev Respir Dis 108: 149–151, 1973
- 91 Sutliff WD, Kyle JW, Hobson JL: North American blastomycosis: clinical forms of disease and treatment with stilbamidine and 2-hydroxystilbamidine. Ann Intern Med 41: 89–107, 1954
- 92
Swift H,
Bull LB:
Notes on a case of systemic blastomycosis: blastomycotic cerebrospinal meningitis.
Med J Aust
2: 265–267,
1917
10.5694/j.1326-5377.1917.tb104808.x Google Scholar
- 93 Titrud LA: Blastomycosis of the cervical spine. Minn Med 58: 729–732, 1975
- 94 Türk W: Ein Fall von Hefeinfektion (Saccharomykose) der Meningen. Dtsch Arch Klin Med 90: 335–366, 1907
- 95 Tuttle JG, Lichtwardt HE, Altshuler CH: Systemic North American blastomycosis: report of a case with small forms of blastomycetes. Am J Clin Pathol 23: 890–897, 1953
- 96 Utz JP: Histoplasma and cryptococcus meningitis. Res Publ Assoc Res Nerv Ment Dis 44: 378–392, 1968
- 97 Utz JP: Current and future chemotherapy of central nervous system fungal infections. Adv Neurol 6: 127–132, 1974
- 98 von Hansemann D: Ueber eine bisher nicht beobachtete Gehirnerkrankung durch Hefen. Verhandl Dtsch Gesamte Pathol 9: 21–24, 1905
- 99 Wade HW, Bel GS: A critical consideration of blastomycosis: with notes on certain special features and report of five cases. Arch Intern Med 18: 103–130, 1916
- 100 Waisbren BA, Ullrich D: An isolated blastomycetoma of the posterior cranial fossa treated successfully with surgery and amphotericin B. Am J Med 32: 621–624, 1962
- 101 Whitaker HW: North American blastomycosis: report of a case in which a patient with meningeal involvement was treated with streptomycin and promin. Arch Pathol 48: 212–217, 1949
- 102 Wilhelmj CM: The primary meningeal form of systemic blastomycosis. Am J Med Sci 169: 712–721, 1925
- 103 Williams JR: A case of systemic blastomycosis. Med J Aust 2: 185–187, 1922
- 104 Witorsch P, Utz JP: North American blastomycosis: a study of 40 patients. Medicine (Baltimore) 47: 169–200, 1968