Review
Full Access
Not all predators are equal: a continent-scale analysis of the effects of predator control on Australian mammals
Daniel O. Hunter,
Malgorzata Lagisz,
Viyanna Leo,
Shinichi Nakagawa,
Mike Letnic,
Corresponding Author
Daniel O. Hunter
Centre for Ecosystem Science, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052 Sydney, Australia.
Correspondence author.Search for more papers by this authorMalgorzata Lagisz
Evolution & Ecology Research Centre and School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052 Sydney, Australia.
Search for more papers by this authorViyanna Leo
Centre for Ecosystem Science, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052 Sydney, Australia.
Search for more papers by this authorShinichi Nakagawa
Evolution & Ecology Research Centre and School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052 Sydney, Australia.
Search for more papers by this authorMike Letnic
Centre for Ecosystem Science, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052 Sydney, Australia.
Search for more papers by this authorDaniel O. Hunter,
Malgorzata Lagisz,
Viyanna Leo,
Shinichi Nakagawa,
Mike Letnic,
Corresponding Author
Daniel O. Hunter
Centre for Ecosystem Science, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052 Sydney, Australia.
Correspondence author.Search for more papers by this authorMalgorzata Lagisz
Evolution & Ecology Research Centre and School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052 Sydney, Australia.
Search for more papers by this authorViyanna Leo
Centre for Ecosystem Science, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052 Sydney, Australia.
Search for more papers by this authorShinichi Nakagawa
Evolution & Ecology Research Centre and School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052 Sydney, Australia.
Search for more papers by this authorMike Letnic
Centre for Ecosystem Science, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052 Sydney, Australia.
Search for more papers by this authorEditor: DRdoi: 10.1111/mam.12115
Abstract
- Introduced predators pose threats to biodiversity and are implicated in the extinction of many native species. In Australia, considerable effort is spent controlling populations of introduced predators, including the dingo Canis dingo and the red fox Vulpes vulpes, to reduce their effects on native species and livestock. Studies describe different outcomes of controlling dingo and fox populations on native species, making biodiversity management decisions difficult for conservation managers.
- We conduct a meta-analysis to compare the impacts that control programmes targeted towards dingoes and foxes in Australia have on introduced predators and on other mammal species, including native species and prey species.
- Our results provide evidence that lethal control of dingoes and foxes has different outcomes for different mammalian species. Dingo removal had a negative effect on the abundance of native mammals weighing less than the critical weight range (CWR) of 30–5500 g, and a positive effect on the abundance of mammals above the CWR. Fox abundance increased in response to dingo control, but confidence intervals were large. Fox removal had strong positive effects on ground-dwelling and arboreal mammals. Lethal control of dingoes did not have a significant effect on cats, but where dingoes were removed there was a tendency for foxes to increase, and where foxes were removed there was a tendency for cats to increase.
- Our results highlight unintended and perverse outcomes of lethal predator control on Australian mammals. Lethal control of dingoes significantly increases abundances of above CWR mammals and significantly decreases abundances of under CWR mammals. Lethal control of foxes significantly increases the abundances of CWR mammals. These findings show how removing dingoes and foxes alters mammal assemblages and provide comprehensive and objective information for conservation managers.
- We recommend that land management agencies take the results of this study into consideration when planning lethal control programmes targeting dingoes and foxes because, depending on the target canid, these programmes result in different outcomes for other mammal species. Removal programmes targeting dingoes and/or foxes can result in increased abundances of introduced predators and, ultimately, have far-reaching effects on many mammal species.
Supporting Information
| Filename | Description |
|---|---|
| mam12115-sup-0001-AppendixS1-S4.docxWord document, 529.5 KB |
Appendix S1. PRISMA diagram showing the process of discovery and elimination of publications for the fox removal dataset. Appendix S2. PRISMA diagram showing the process of discovery and elimination of publications for the dingo removal dataset. Appendix S3. Excluded full-text studies – fox removal dataset. Appendix S4. Dingo distribution in Australia and locations of study sites. |
Please note: The publisher is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.
References
- Algar DA, Burbidge AA, Angus GJ (2002) Cat eradication on Hermite Island, Montebello Islands, Western Australia. Turning the Tide: the Eradication of Invasive Species: 14–18.
- Allen LR (2015) Demographic and functional responses of wild dogs to poison baiting. Ecological Management & Restoration 16: 58–66.
- Allen BL, Allen LR, Engeman RM, Leung LP (2013) Intraguild relationships between sympatric predators exposed to lethal control: predator manipulation experiments. Frontiers in Zoology 10: 39.
- Allen BL, Allen LR, Engeman RM, Leung LP (2014) Sympatric prey responses to lethal top-predator control: predator manipulation experiments. Frontiers in Zoology 11: 56.
- Banks PB (1999) Predation by introduced foxes on native bush rats in Australia: do foxes take the doomed surplus? Journal of Applied Ecology 36: 1063–1071.
- Banks PB (2000) Can foxes regulate rabbit populations? The Journal of Wildlife Management 64: 401–406.
- Biggins DE, Vargas A, Godbey JL, Anderson SH (1999) Influence of pre-release experience on reintroduced black-footed ferrets (Mustela nigripes). Biological Conservation 89: 121–129.
- Bininda-Emonds ORP, Cardillo M, Jones KE, MacPhee RDE, Beck RMD, Grenyer R et al. (2007) The delayed rise of present-day mammals. Nature 446: 507–512.
- Brook LA, Johnson CN, Ritchie EG (2012) Effects of predator control on behaviour of an apex predator and indirect consequences for mesopredator suppression. Journal of Applied Ecology 49: 1278–1286.
- Burrows ND, Algar D, Robinson AD, Sinagra J, Ward B, Liddelow G (2003) Controlling introduced predators in the Gibson Desert of Western Australia. Journal of Arid Environments 55: 691–713.
- Carthey AJR, Banks PB (2012) When does an alien become a native species? A vulnerable native mammal recognizes and responds to its long-term alien predator. PLoS ONE 7: e31804.
- Caughley G (1987) Ecological relationships. In: G Caughley, N Shephed, J Short (eds) Kangaroos: Their Ecology and Management in the Sheep Rangelands of Australia, 159–187. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
- Caughley G, Grigg GC, Caughley J, Hill GJE (1980) Does dingo predation control the densities of kangaroos and emus? Wildlife Research 7: 1–12.
- Claridge AW, Cunningham RB, Catling PC, Reid AM (2010) Trends in the activity levels of forest-dwelling vertebrate fauna against a background of intensive baiting for foxes. Forest Ecology and Management 260: 822–832.
- Coates TD (2008) The effect of fox control on mammal populations in an outer urban conservation reserve. Australian Mammalogy 30: 51–64.
- Colman NJ, Gordon CE, Crowther MS, Letnic M (2014) Lethal control of an apex predator has unintended cascading effects on forest mammal assemblages. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 281: 20133094.
- Crowther MS, Fillios M, Colman N, Letnic M (2014) An updated description of the Australian dingo (Canis dingo Meyer, 1793). Journal of Zoology 293: 192–203.
- Cupples JB, Crowther MS, Story G, Letnic M (2011) Dietary overlap and prey selectivity among sympatric carnivores: could dingoes suppress foxes through competition for prey? Journal of Mammalogy 92: 590–600.
- Davey C, Sinclair A, Pech R, Arthur A, Krebs C, Newsome A, Allcock K (2006) Do exotic vertebrates structure the biota of Australia? An experimental test in New South Wales. Ecosystems 9: 992–1008.
- Davis NE, Forsyth DM, Triggs B, Pascoe C, Benshemesh J, Robley A, Lumsden LF (2015) Interspecific and geographic variation in the diets of sympatric carnivores: dingoes/wild dogs and red foxes in south-eastern Australia. PLoS ONE 10: e0120975.
- Dexter N, Murray A (2009) The impact of fox control on the relative abundance of forest mammals in East Gippsland, Victoria. Wildlife Research 36: 252.
- Dexter N, Meek P, Moore S, Hudson M, Richardson H (2007) Population responses of small and medium sized mammals to fox control at Jervis Bay, southeastern Australia. Pacific Conservation Biology 13: 283.
- Doherty TS, Glen AS, Nimmo DG, Ritchie EG, Dickman CR (2016) Invasive predators and global biodiversity loss. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 113: 11261–11265.
- Donadio E, Buskirk SW (2006) Diet, morphology, and interspecific killing in Carnivora. The American Naturalist 167: 524–536.
- Duval S, Tweedie R (2000) Trim and fill: a simple funnel-plot–based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics 56: 455–463.
- Egger M, Smith GD, Schneider M, Minder C (1997) Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. British Biomedical Journal 315: 629–634.
- Fillios M, Gordon C, Koch F, Letnic M (2010) The effect of a top predator on kangaroo abundance in arid Australia and its implications for archaeological faunal assemblages. Journal of Archaeological Science 37: 986–993.
- Fisher DO, Johnson CN, Lawes MJ, Fritz SA, McCallum H, Blomberg SP et al. (2014) The current decline of tropical marsupials in Australia: is history repeating? Global Ecology and Biogeography 23: 181–190.
- Fleming PJS (1996) Ground-placed baits for the control of wild dogs: evaluation of a replacement-baiting strategy in north-eastern New South Wales. Wildlife Research 23: 729–740.
- Friedrich JO, Adhikari NKJ, Beyene J (2008) The ratio of means method as an alternative to mean differences for analyzing continuous outcome variables in meta-analysis: a simulation study. BMC Medical Research Methodology 8: 32.
- Gentle MN, Saunders GR, Dickman CR (2007) Poisoning for production: how effective is fox baiting in south-eastern Australia? Mammal Review 37: 177–190.
- Gillies CA, Pierce RJ (1999) Secondary poisoning of mammalian predators during possum and rodent control operations at Trounson Kauri Park, Northland, New Zealand. New Zealand Journal of Ecology 23: 183–192.
- Gilroy J (1999) Kangaroo monitoring in relation to kangaroo management in New South Wales. Australian Zoologist 31: 306–308.
- Gordon CE, Feit A, Grüber J, Letnic M (2015) Mesopredator suppression by an apex predator alleviates the risk of predation perceived by small prey. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences 282: 20142870.
- Gordon CE, Moore BD, Letnic M (2017) Temporal and spatial trends in the abundances of an apex predator, introduced mesopredator and ground-nesting bird are consistent with the mesopredator release hypothesis. Biodiversity and Conservation 26: 1445–1462.
- Hadfield JD, Nakagawa S (2010) General quantitative genetic methods for comparative biology: phylogenies, taxonomies and multi-trait models for continuous and categorical characters. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 23: 494–508.
- Hayward MW, Kerley GIH (2009) Fencing for conservation: restriction of evolutionary potential or a riposte to threatening processes? Biological Conservation 142: 1–13.
- Hedges LV, Gurevitch J, Curtis PS (1999) The meta-analysis of response ratios in experimental ecology. Ecology 80: 1150–1156.
- Higgins JPT, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG (2003) Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. British Biomedical Journal 327: 557–560.
- Holbrook CM, Bergstedt RA, Barber J, Bravener GA, Jones ML, Krueger CC (2016) Evaluating harvest-based control of invasive fish with telemetry: performance of sea lamprey traps in the Great Lakes. Ecological Applications 26: 1595–1609.
- Johnson C (2006) Australia's Mammal Extinctions: a 50000 Year History. Cambridge University Press, Melbourne, Australia.
- Johnson CN, VanDerWal J (2009) Evidence that dingoes limit abundance of a mesopredator in eastern Australian forests. Journal of Applied Ecology 46: 641–646.
- Johnson CN, Isaac JL, Fisher DO (2007) Rarity of a top predator triggers continent-wide collapse of mammal prey: dingoes and marsupials in Australia. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Science 274: 341–346.
- King CM (1984) Immigrant Killers: Introduced Predators and the Conservation of Birds in New Zealand. Oxford University Press, Auckland, New Zealand.
- Kinnear JE, Onus ML, Bromilow RN (1988) Fox control and rock-wallaby population dynamics. Wildlife Research 15: 435–450.
- Kinnear JE, Onus ML, Sumner NR (1998) Fox control and rock-wallaby population dynamics — II. an update. Wildlife Research 25: 81.
- Kinnear JE, Summer NR, Onus ML (2002) The red fox in Australia—an exotic predator turned biocontrol agent. Biological Conservation 108: 335–359.
- Kovacs EK, Crowther MS, Webb JK, Dickman CR (2012) Population and behavioural responses of native prey to alien predation. Oecologia 168: 947–957.
- Legge S, Murphy BP, McGregor H, Woinarski JCZ, Augusteyn J, Ballard G et al. (2017) Enumerating a continental-scale threat: how many feral cats are in Australia? Biological Conservation 206: 293–303.
- Letnic M, Dworjanyn SA (2011) Does a top predator reduce the predatory impact of an invasive mesopredator on an endangered rodent? Ecography 34: 827–835.
- Letnic M, Crowther MS, Koch F (2009a) Does a top-predator provide an endangered rodent with refuge from an invasive mesopredator? Animal Conservation 12: 302–312.
- Letnic M, Koch F, Gordon C, Crowther MS, Dickman CR (2009b) Keystone effects of an alien top-predator stem extinctions of native mammals. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 276: 3249–3256.
- Letnic M, Ritchie EG, Dickman CR (2012) Top predators as biodiversity regulators: the dingo Canis lupus dingo as a case study. Biological Reviews 87: 390–413.
- Letnic M, Feit A, Forsyth DM (2017) Strength of a trophic cascade between an apex predator, mammalian herbivore and grasses in a desert ecosystem does not vary with temporal fluctuations in primary productivity. Ecosystems 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10021-017-0141-0.
- MacDonald DW, Harrington LA (2003) The American mink: the triumph and tragedy of adaptation out of context. New Zealand Journal of Zoology 30: 421–441.
- Marlow NJ, Thomas ND, Williams AAE, Macmahon B, Lawson J, Hitchen Y et al. (2015a) Cats (Felis catus) are more abundant and are the dominant predator of woylies (Bettongia penicillata) after sustained fox (Vulpes vulpes) control. Australian Journal of Zoology 63: 18–27.
- Marlow NJ, Thomas ND, Williams AAE, Macmahon B, Lawson J, Hitchen Y et al. (2015b) Lethal 1080 baiting continues to reduce European red fox (Vulpes vulpes) abundance after more than 25 years of continuous use in south-west Western Australia. Ecological Management & Restoration 16: 131–141.
- Menkhorst P, Knight F (2001) Field Guide to the Mammals of Australia. Oxford University Press, Melbourne, Australia.
- Miller CJ, Miller TK (1995) Population dynamics and diet of rodents on Rangitoto Island, New Zealand, including the effect of a 1080 poison operation. New Zealand Journal of Ecology 19: 19–27.
- Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG (2009) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Annals of Internal Medicine 151: 264–269.
- Molsher R, Newsome AE, Newsome TM, Dickman CR (2017) Mesopredator management: effects of red fox control on the abundance, diet and use of space by feral cats. PLoS ONE 12: e0168460.
- Morris T, Letnic M (2017) Removal of an apex predator initiates a trophic cascade that extends from herbivores to vegetation and the soil nutrient pool. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 284: 20170111.
- Moseby K, Hill BM, Read JL (2009) Arid recovery – a comparison of reptile and small mammal populations inside and outside a large rabbit, cat, and fox-proof exclosure in arid South Australia. Austral Ecology 34: 156–169.
- Moseby K, Carthey A, Schroeder T (2015) The influence of predators and prey naivety on reintroduction success: current and future directions. In: DP Armstrong, MW Hayward, D Moro and PJ Seddon (eds) Advances in Reintroduction Biology of Australian and New Zealand Fauna: 29–42. CSIRO, Melbourne.
- Nakagawa S, Santos ES (2012) Methodological issues and advances in biological meta-analysis. Evolutionary Ecology 26: 1253–1274.
- Newsome AE, Catling PC, Corbett LK (1983) The feeding ecology of the dingo II. dietary and numerical relationships with fluctuating prey populations in south-eastern Australia. Australian Journal of Ecology 8: 345–366.
- Newsome AE, Catling PC, Cooke BD, Smyth R (2001) Two ecological universes separated by the dingo barrier fence in semi-arid Australia: interactions between landscapes, herbivory and carnivory, with and without dingoes. The Rangeland Journal 23: 71–98.
- Paradis E, Claude J, Strimmer K (2004) APE: analyses of phylogenetics and evolution in R language. Bioinformatics 20: 289–290.
- Pickett KN, Hik DS, Newsome AE, Pech RP (2005) The influence of predation risk on foraging behaviour of brushtail possums in Australian woodlands. Wildlife Research 32: 121–130.
- Pople AR, Grigg GC, Cairns SC, Beard LA, Alexander P (2000) Trends in the numbers of red kangaroos and emus on either side of the South Australian dingo fence: evidence for predator regulation? Wildlife Research 27: 269–276.
- Prowse TAA, Johnson CN, Cassey P, Bradshaw CJA, Brook BW (2015) Ecological and economic benefits to cattle rangelands of restoring an apex predator. Journal of Applied Ecology 52: 455–466.
- R Core Team (2013) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. http://www.R-project.org/.
- Read JL, Scoleri V (2015) Ecological implications of reptile mesopredator release in arid South Australia. Journal of Herpetology 49: 64–69.
- Rees JD, Kingsford RT, Letnic M (2017) In the absence of an apex predator, irruptive herbivores suppress grass seed production: implications for small granivores. Biological Conservation 213: 13–18.
- Reynolds JC, Tapper SC (1996) Control of mammalian predators in game management and conservation. Mammal Review 26: 127–155.
- Ripple WJ, Estes JA, Beschta RL, Wilmers CC, Ritchie EG, Hebblewhite M et al. (2014) Status and ecological effects of the world's largest carnivores. Science 343: 1241484.
- Risbey DA, Calver MC, Short J, Bradley JS, Wright IW (2000) The impact of cats and foxes on the small vertebrate fauna of Heirisson Prong, Western Australia. II. a field experiment. Wildlife Research 27: 223–235.
- Ritchie EG, Johnson CN (2009) Predator interactions, mesopredator release and biodiversity conservation. Ecology Letters 12: 982–998.
- Robertshaw J, Harden R (1986) The ecology of the dingo in northeastern New-South-Wales 4. Prey selection by dingoes, and its effect on the major prey species, the swamp wallaby, Wallabia bicolor (Desmarest). Wildlife Research 13: 141–163.
- Robley A, Gormley AM, Forsyth DM, Triggs B (2014) Long-term and large-scale control of the introduced red fox increases native mammal occupancy in Australian forests. Biological Conservation 180: 262–269.
- Rothstein HR, Sutton AJ, Borenstein M (2006) Publication Bias in Meta-Analysis: Prevention, Assessment and Adjustments. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK.
- Ruscoe WA, Ramsey DSL, Pech RP, Sweetapple PJ, Yockney I, Barron MC et al. (2011) Unexpected consequences of control: competitive vs. predator release in a four-species assemblage of invasive mammals. Ecology Letters 14: 1035–1042.
- Salo P, Korpimäki E, Banks PB, Nordström M, Dickman CR (2007) Alien predators are more dangerous than native predators to prey populations. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 274: 1237–1243.
- Saunders GR, Gentle MN, Dickman CR (2010) The impacts and management of foxes Vulpes vulpes in Australia. Mammal Review 40: 181–211.
- Savidge JA (1987) Extinction of an island forest avifauna by an introduced snake. Ecology 68: 660–668.
- Sih A, Bolnick DI, Luttbeg B, Orrock JL, Peacor SD, Pintor LM et al. (2010) Predator–prey naïveté, antipredator behavior, and the ecology of predator invasions. Oikos 119: 610–621.
- Sinclair ARE, Pech RP, Dickman CR, Hik D, Mahon P, Newsome AE (1998) Predicting effects of predation on conservation of endangered prey. Conservation Biology 12: 564–575.
- Sinclair ARE, Mduma S, Brashares JS (2003) Patterns of predation in a diverse predator–prey system. Nature 425: 288–290.
- Spencer EE, Crowther MS, Dickman CR (2014) Diet and prey selectivity of three species of sympatric mammalian predators in central Australia. Journal of Mammalogy 95: 1278–1288.
- Towerton AL, Penman TD, Kavanagh RP, Dickman CR (2011) Detecting pest and prey responses to fox control across the landscape using remote cameras. Wildlife Research 38: 208–220.
- Twigg LE, Eldridge SR, Edwards GP, Shakeshaft BJ, Adams N (2000) The longevity and efficacy of 1080 meat baits used for dingo control in central Australia. Wildlife Research 27: 473–481.
- Viechtbauer W (2010) Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package. Journal of Statistical Software 36: 1–48.
- Wallach AD, Johnson CN, Ritchie EG, O'Neill AJ (2010) Predator control promotes invasive dominated ecological states. Ecology Letters 13: 1008–1018.
- Wayne A, Maxwell MA, Ward CG, Wayne JC, Vellios CV, Wilson IJ (2017) Recoveries and cascading declines of native mammals associated with control of an introduced predator. Journal of Mammalogy 98: 489–501.
- Woinarski JCZ, Burbidge AA, Harrison PL (2015) Ongoing unraveling of a continental fauna: decline and extinction of Australian mammals since European settlement. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 112: 4531–4540.
Citing Literature
