Issues surrounding the participation of adolescents with cancer in clinical trials in the UK
Corresponding Author
A. McTIERNAN RN , BSC
The Meyerstein Institute of Oncology, The Middlesex Hospital, London, UK
address: Anne McTiernan, Oncology Research Office, 3rd Floor Jules Thorn, The Middlesex Hospital, Mortimer Street, London W1T 3AA, UK (e-mail: [email protected]).Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
A. McTIERNAN RN , BSC
The Meyerstein Institute of Oncology, The Middlesex Hospital, London, UK
address: Anne McTiernan, Oncology Research Office, 3rd Floor Jules Thorn, The Middlesex Hospital, Mortimer Street, London W1T 3AA, UK (e-mail: [email protected]).Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Cancer in adolescents is rare with approximately 600 adolescents being diagnosed with cancer in the UK each year. With such small numbers, clinical trials are imperative if improvements in treatment and prognosis are to be achieved. However, the availability of such trials and the issues surrounding clinical trials in adolescents with cancer has rarely been reviewed. There are a number of issues regarding clinical trials that are particularly pertinent to this group. Primarily, despite evidence that adolescents with cancer fare better when treated on clinical trials, it would appear that adolescents do not have equal access to trials because of the fragmentation of adolescent cancer care between adult and paediatric oncology. For those who are treated within clinical trials, issues of informed consent need to be addressed, such as who should give consent and the provision of age-appropriate information. Finally, it has been suggested that adolescents are less compliant with treatment than both their adult and paediatric counterparts. As many adolescents with cancer can now been cured, this should be an area of great concern and more research is needed to ascertain the full extent of the problem and ways of overcoming it. The availability of clinical trials, along with the issues surrounding clinical trials in adolescents, need to be addressed if continued improvements in the outcome of this group of patients are to be seen.
REFERENCES
- Bleyer W.A. (1997) The U.S. Pediatric Cancer Clinical Trials Programmes: international implications and the way forward. European Journal of Cancer 33, 1439 – 1447.
- Bleyer W.A., Tejeda H., Murphy S.B., Robinson L.L., Ross J.A., Pollock B.H., Severson R.K., Brawley O.W., Smith M.A. & Ungerleider R.S. (1997) National cancer clinical trials: children have equal access; adolescents do not. Journal of Adolescent Health 21, 366 – 373.
- British Paediatric Association: Ethics Advisory Committee August 1992 (1992) Guidelines for the Ethical Conduct of Medical Research Involving Children. British Paediatric Association, London.
- Daugherty C.K. (1999) Impact on therapeutic research on informed consent and the ethics of clinical trials: a medical oncology perspective. Journal of Clinical Oncology 17, 1601 – 1617.
- Daugherty C.K., Ratain M.K., Grochowski E., Stocking C., Kodish E., Mick R. & Siegler M. (1995) Perceptions of cancer patients and their physicians involved in Phase I trials. Journal of Clinical Oncology 13, 1062 – 1072.
- Decoster G., Stein G. & Holdener E.E. (1990) Responses and toxic deaths in phase I clinical trials. Annals of Oncology 1, 175 – 181.
- Department of Health (1992) A Policy Framework for Commissioning Cancer Services. HMSO, London.
- Department of Health (2000) The NHS Cancer Plan. HMSO, London.
- Dimond B. (1996) The Legal Aspects of Child Health Care. Mosby, London.
- Dolgin M.J., Katz E.R., Doctors S.R. & Siegel S.E. (1986) Caregivers’ perceptions of medical compliance in adolescents with cancer. Journal of Adolescent Health Care 7, 22 – 27.
- Dorn L.D., Susman E.J. & Fletcher J.C. (1995) Informed consent in children and adolescents: age, maturation and psychological state. Journal of Adolescent Health 16, 185 – 190.
- The Family Law Reform Act (1969) Cited in: Dimond B. (1996) The Legal Aspects of Child Health Care. Mosby, London.
- Gillis C.R., Hole D.J., Still R.M., Davis J. & Kaye S.B. (1991) Medical audit, cancer registration and survival on ovarian cancer. Lancet 337, 611 – 612.
- Grossman S.A., Piantadosi S. & Covahey C. (1994) Are informed consent forms that describe clinical oncology research proposals readable by most patients and their families? Journal of Clinical Oncology 12, 2211 – 2215.
- Gulliford M.C., Petruckevitch A. & Burney P.G.J. (1991) Survival with bladder cancer, evaluation of delay in treatment, type of surgeon, and modality of treatment. British Medical Journal 303, 437 – 440.
-
Gurney J.G.,
Davis S.,
Severson R.K.,
Fang J.Y.,
Ross J.A. &
Robison L.L. (1996) Trends in cancer incidence among children in the U.S.
Cancer
78, 532
–
541.
10.1002/(SICI)1097-0142(19960801)78:3<532::AID-CNCR22>3.0.CO;2-Z PubMed Web of Science® Google Scholar
- Harding P.J., Paul J., Gillis C.R. & Kaye S.B. (1993) Management of malignant teratoma: does referral to specialist unit matter? Lancet 341, 999 – 1002.
- International Conference on Harmonisation (1996). Guideline for Good Clinical Practice. International Conference on Harmonisation, Geneva.
- Karjalainen S. & Palva I. (1989) Do treatment protocols improve end results? A study of survival of patients with multiple myeloma in Finland. British Medical Journal 299, 1069 – 1072.
- Kramer S., Meadows A., Patore G., Jarrett P. & Bruce D. (1984) Influence of place on diagnosis, treatment, and survival in three pediatric solid tumors. Journal of Clinical Oncology 2, 917 – 923.
- Lennox E.L., Stiller C.A., Morris Jones P.H. & Kinner Wilson L.M. (1979) Nephroblastoma: treatment during 1970–3 and the effect on survival of inclusion in the first MRC trial. British Medical Journal 2, 567 – 569.
- Levi F., La Vecchia C., Negri E. & Lucchini F. (2001) Childhood cancer mortality in Europe, 1955–1995. European Journal of Cancer 37, 785 – 809.
- LoVerde M.E., Prochazka A.V. & Byyny R.L. (1989) Research consent forms: continued unreadability and increasing length. Journal of General Internal Medicine 4, 410 – 412.
- Meadows A.T., Kramer S., Hopson R., Lustbader E., Jarrett P. & Evans A.E. (1983) Survival in childhood acute lymphocytic leukemia: effect of protocol and place of treatment. Cancer Investigation 1, 49 – 55.
- Office for National Statistics (2000) 1994 Cancer Statistics Registrations: England and Wales (Series MB1 No. 27). The Stationery Office, London.
- Reaman G.H., Sposto R., Sensel M.G., Lange B.J., Feusner J.H., Heerema N.A., Leonard M., Holmes E.J., Sather H.N., Pendergrass T.W., Johnstone H.S., O'Brien R.T., Steinherz P.G., Zeltzer P.M., Gaynon P.S., Trigg M.E. & Uckun F.M. (1999) Treatment outcome and prognostic factors for infants with acute lymphoblastic leukemia treated on two consecutive trials of the Children's Cancer Group. Journal of Clinical Oncology 17, 445 – 455.
- Royal College of Nursing (1993) Ethics Related to Research in Nursing. Scutari Press, London.
- Ruccione K., Kramer R.F., Moore I.K. & Perin G. (1991) Informed consent for treatment of childhood cancer: factors affecting parents’ decision making. Journal of Pediatric Oncology Nursing 8, 112 – 121.
- Smith T.L., Lee J.J., Kantarjian H.M., Legha S.S. & Raber M.N. (1996) Design and results of phase I cancer clinical trials: three-year experience at M.D. Anderson Cancer Center. Journal of Clinical Oncology 14, 287 – 295.
-
Smith S.D.,
Rosen D.,
Trueworthy R.C. &
Lowman J.T. (1979) A reliable method for evaluating drug compliance in children with cancer.
Cancer
43, 169
–
173.
10.1002/1097-0142(197901)43:1<169::AID-CNCR2820430125>3.0.CO;2-F CAS PubMed Web of Science® Google Scholar
- Stiller C.A. & Draper G.J. (1989) Treatment centre size, entry to trials and survival in acute lymphoblastic leukaemia. Archives of Disease in Childhood 64, 657 – 661.
- Tamaroff M.H., Festa R.S., Adesman A.R. & Walco G.A. (1992) Therapeutic adherence to oral medication regimens by adolescents with cancer. II. Clinical and psychologic correlates. Journal of Pediatrics 120, 812 – 817.
-
Tebbi C.K. (1993) Treatment compliance in childhood and adolescence.
Cancer
71, 3441
–
3449.
10.1002/1097-0142(19930515)71:10+<3441::AID-CNCR2820711751>3.0.CO;2-P CAS PubMed Web of Science® Google Scholar
-
Tebbi C.K.,
Cummings K.M.,
Zeyon M.A.,
Smith L.,
Richards M. &
Mallon J. (1986) Compliance of pediatric and adolescent cancer patients.
Cancer
58, 1179
–
1184.
10.1002/1097-0142(19860901)58:5<1179::AID-CNCR2820580534>3.0.CO;2-E CAS PubMed Web of Science® Google Scholar
- Tebbi C.K. & Koren B.G. (1983) A specialized unit for adolescent oncology patients. Is it worth it? Journal of Medicine 14, 161 – 184.
- United Kingdom Children's Cancer Study Group (2000) UKCCSG website http://www.ukccsg.org/
- Wagner H.P., Dingeldein-Bettler I., Berchthold W., Luthy A.R., Hirt A., Pluss H.J., Beck D., Wyss M., Signer E., Imbach P., Feldges A., Bleher E.A., Plaschkes J., Briner J., Leibundgut K. & Von Der Weid N. for the Swiss Pediatric Oncology Group (1995) Childhood NHL in Switzerland: incidence and survival of 120 study and 42 non-study patients. Medical and Pediatric Oncology 24, 281 – 286.
- Watson R. (2001) EU harmonises rules for trials. British Medical Journal 322, 68.