Article
Full Access
Sites and services schemes in Dacca: A critique
Syed Abu Hasnath,
Syed Abu Hasnath
Assistant Professor
Urban and Regional Planning, Faculty of Architecture and Planning, Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology, Dacca 2, Bangladesh
Search for more papers by this authorSyed Abu Hasnath,
Syed Abu Hasnath
Assistant Professor
Urban and Regional Planning, Faculty of Architecture and Planning, Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology, Dacca 2, Bangladesh
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
This paper presents a critical analysis of two sites and services projects in Dacca, in the light of previous studies of low income housing. The analysis demonstrates that resource limitation is not the most important factor preventing resolution of the low-income housing problem, that there is a perverse use of resources which makes the situation worse, and that this use continues because it is in the pecuniary interest of the dominant interest group. The conclusions drawn are far from optimistic: (a) without radical changes in the main direction of resource allocation, there exists little or no possibility for an improvement in the living conditions of poor families; and, (b) the provision of housing for the lowest income group is more a question of political will and social engineering than building technology.
References
- Abrams, C. (1964). Mans Struggle for Shelter in an Urbanising World, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
- Abrams, C. (1966). Squatter Settlements, the Problem and the Opportunity, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Washington D.C.
- Ahmed, M. (1970). Urban Housing Demand Survey in Bangladesh, Dacca University, Dacca.
- Angel, S. and Benjamin, S. (1976). ‘Seventeen reasons why the squatters problems can't be solved’, EKISTICS, 41, (242) 20–26.
- Apte, P. M. (1980). ‘Housing the urban poor’, Science Today, 14, (4) 28–29.
- BRAC (Bangladesh Rural Advancement Committee) (1978). Bashantak Bastuhara Survey, Dacca (Mimeo).
- Bryant, C. (1980). ‘Squatters, collective action and participation: learning from Lusaka’, World Development, 8, 73–85.
- Burgess, R. (1978). ‘Petty commodity housing or dweller control? A critique of John Turner's views on housing policy’, World Development, 6, (9/10).
- Corea, C. (1975). ‘ No cost housing with vernacular technology and space trade-offs’, in P. K. Mutagi (ed.) Urban Development—A Perspective, Tata Inst. of Soc. Sc., Bombay.
- Cornelious, W. (1975). Politics and Migrant Poor, Stanford University Press, Stanford.
- Currie, L. (1976). Taming Megalopolis, Pergamon, Oxford.
- CUS (Centre for Urban Studies) (1975). Survey of Urban Squatters in Dacca, Chinugong and Khulna cities, Dacca University, Dacca.
- CUS (Centre for Urban Studies) (1977). Demra Bastuhara Camp—A Socio-Economic Survey of Squatter Resettlement Area, Dacca University, Dacca (Mimeo).
- Das, S. K. (1980). ‘Delhi squatters resettlement project’, Science Today, 14, (4) 44–45.
- Dwyer, D. J. (1979). People and Housing in Third World Cities, Longman, London.
- Friedmann, J. (1979). ‘ Urban poverty in Latin America—some theoretical considerations’, Development Dialogue.
- GrimesJr., O. F. (1976). Housing for Low Income Urban Families, The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
- Hasnath, S. A. (1977a). ‘ Resquatting in Dacca City; some policy-proposals and techniques’, in R. P. Pama, S. Angel and J. H. De Goede (eds), Low Income Housing—Technology and Policy, AIT, Bangkok.
- Hasnath, S. A. (1977b). ‘Consequences of Squatter Removal’, EKISTICS, 44, (263) 198–201.
- Hasnath, S. A. (1980). Preliminary Situation Report on Low Income Settlement Area (Dacca Metropolitan Area), Shankland Cox Partnership, Dacca/London (Mimeo).
- Hasnath, S. A. (1981). ‘Limitation of self-help in urban low income housing’, Local Government Quarterly, Dacca, 10, (1) 17–30.
- Hosken, F. P. (1975). ‘Urbanisation in Africa: sites and services Programmes’, International Development Review, 1, 20–23.
- Khan, T. A. (1979). ‘ A study of the process of integration of squatter settlements in Greater Dacca’, Unpublished Master's Thesis, Department of Urban and Regional Planning, BUET., Dacca.
- Laquian, A. (1971). Slums Are for People, East-West Centre, Press, Honolulu.
- Lojkine, J. (1976). ‘ Contribution to a Marxist theory of capitalist urbanisation’ in C. G. Pickvance (ed.) Urban Sociology, St. Martin Press, New York.
- Momen, N. (1976). A Study of Tongi Bastuhara (Squatter) and Employment Opportunities within the Area, Department of International Relation, Dacca University, Dacca (Mimeo).
- Norwood, H. C. (1973). ‘Planning sites and services housing’, Town Planning Review, 44, 359.
- Patel, S. (1980). ‘Sites and services’, Science Today, 14, (4) 40–42.
- Peattie, L. R. and Doebele, W. (1976). ‘ Some second thoughts on sites and services’, MIT, Cambridge, Mass, Unpublished manuscript.
- Peattie, L. R. (1979). ‘Housing Policy in Developing Countries’, World Development, 7, 1017–1022.
- Rosser, C. (1971). ‘Housing for the lowest income: the Calcutta experience’, EKISTICS, 31 (183). February.
- Rosser, C. (1972). ‘ Housing and planning change: the Calcutta experience’, in D. J. Dwyer (ed.) The City as a Centre of Change in Asia, Hong Kong University Press.
- Salam, A. (1979). The self-help housing experience in Bangladesh: Mohammedpur and Mirpur Communities, Dacca, Unpublished Master's Thesis, AIT, Bangkok.
- Stepic, A. and Murphy, A. (1979). ‘Housing and government intervention among the urban poor’, EKISTICS, 46 (279).
- The Guardian (1978). ‘ How Gandhi bulldozed a slum into a wasteland’, Monday 6th February, p. 7. London.
- Turner, J. F. C. (1968). ‘ Uncontrolled urban settlement: problems and policy’ in G. Breeze(ed.), The City in Newly Developed Countries: Readings in Urbanism and Urbanisation, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.
- Turner, J. F. C. (1976). Housing by People, Marion Boyars, London.
- Turner, J. F. C. (1978). ‘Housing in three dimensions: terms of reference for housing question redefined’, World Development, 6 (9/10) 1135–1145.
- United Nations (1971). Improvement of Slums and Uncontrolled Settlement, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, New York.
- United Nations (1973). Self-help Practices in Housing: Selected Case Studies, ST/ECA/183, New York.
- Van Huyck, A. P. (1968). ‘ Housing threshold for lowest-income group: the case of India’, in J. D. Herbert and A. P. Van Huyck (eds), Urban Planning in Developing Countries, Praeger Publishers, New York.
- Van Huyck, A. P. (1971). Planning Sites and Services Programmes, Ideas and Methods Exchange No. 68, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Washington D.C. 20410.
- Walton, J. and Portes, A. (1976). Urban Latin America, University of Texas Press, Austin.
- Ward, P. M. (1978). ‘ Self-help housing in Mexico City’, Town Planning Review, January.
- Willcox, D. L. (1980). ‘ Land policies and the draft second five-year plan’, presented at the Seminar on Public Works, Physical Planning and Housing in the Second Five Year Plan (1980-85), Ministry of Public Works & Urban Development, Government of Bangladesh.
- World Bank (1975). Housing Sector Policy Paper, World Bank, Washington D.C.
