Alternative Printing Methods for Cementitious Materials
Arnaud PERROT
IRDL, Université de Bretagne Sud, Lorient, France
Search for more papers by this authorArnaud PERROT
IRDL, Université de Bretagne Sud, Lorient, France
Search for more papers by this authorArnaud Perrot
Search for more papers by this authorYohan Jacquet
Search for more papers by this authorArnaud Perrot
Search for more papers by this authorYohan Jacquet
Search for more papers by this authorSummary
Robotic concrete construction goes beyond the technique of depositing successive layers or filaments, which then solidify. In the field of construction materials, 3D printing technologies are multiple and not limited to extrusion 3D printing. Spatial resolution and absolute freedom of form can be achieved by alternative 3D printing techniques. In their fresh state, cementitious materials are subject to Newton's first law, and all the problems encountered during extrusion stem from the force of gravity. Alternative techniques are suitable for creating honeycomb shapes, but also with reservations (voids in the structure), where ducts can pass through. In particular, these ducts can be used for post-tensioning reinforcement. An alternative technique for achieving functional gradation within the material appears to be already in use with foams. Indeed, graduated porosities are included in concretes by incorporating different quantities of foaming agents. These studies pave the way for exploiting alternative techniques for greater functionality in buildings.
References
- Aghaei Meibodi , M. , Jipa , A. , Giesecke , R. , Shammas , D. , Bernhard , M. , Leschok , M. , Graser , K. , Dillenburger , B. ( 2018 ). Smart slab: Computational design and digital fabrication of a lightweight concrete slab . In Acadia 2018 Recalibration: On Imprecision and Infidelity: Proceedings of the 38th Annual Conference of the Association for Computer Aided Design in Architecture , P. Anzalone , M. Signore , A.J. Wit (eds). Association for Computer Aided Design in Architecture (ACADIA) , Mexico City .
-
Anton , A.
,
Jipa , A.
,
Reiter , L.
,
Dillenburger , B.
(
2020
).
Fast complexity: Additive manufacturing for prefabricated concrete slabs
. In
Second RILEM International Conference on Concrete and Digital Fabrication: Digital Concrete 2020
.
Springer
,
Heidelberg
.
10.1007/978-3-030-49916-7_102 Google Scholar
- Bedarf , P. , Dutto , A. , Zanini , M. , Dillenburger , B. ( 2021 ). Foam 3D printing for construction: A review of applications, materials, and processes . Automation in Construction , 130 , 103861 .
-
Bedarf , P.
,
Calvo-Barentin , C.
,
Schulte , D.M.
,
Şenol , A.
,
Jeoffroy , E.
,
Dillenburger , B.
(
2023
).
Mineral composites: Stay-in-place formwork for concrete using foam 3D printing
.
Archit. Struct. Constr.
,
3
,
251
–
262
. doi:
10.1007/s44150-023-00084-x
.
10.1007/s44150-023-00084-x Google Scholar
-
Benamara , A.
,
Pierre , A.
,
Kaci , A.
,
Melinge , Y.
(
2020
).
3D printing of a cement-based mortar in a complex fluid suspension: Analytical modeling and experimental tests
. In
Second RILEM International Conference on Concrete and Digital Fabrication: Digital Concrete 2020
.
Springer
,
Heidelberg
.
10.1007/978-3-030-49916-7_76 Google Scholar
- Boyd IV , R.P. , Weller , C. , DiSanto , A. , Rees , M. , Hilbert , B. ( 2020 ). Cellular fabrication and apparatus for additive manufacturing . Google Patents, US 2017/0217088 A1.
-
Bruce , M.
,
Clune , G.
,
Xie , R.
,
Mozaffari , S.
,
Adel , A.
(
2022
).
Cocoon: 3D printed clay formwork for concrete casting
. In
Annual Conference of the Association of Computer Aided Design in Architecture, CUMINCAD
,
Cairo
,
400
–
409
. doi:
10.7302/7046
.
10.7302/7046 Google Scholar
-
Buswell , R.A.
,
Bos , F.P.
,
da Silva , W.R.L.
Hack , N.
,
Kloft , H.
,
Lowke , D.
,
Freund , N.
,
Fromm , A.
,
Dini , E.
,
Wangler , T.
(
2022
).
Digital fabrication with cement-based materials: Process classification and case studies
. In
Digital Fabrication with Cement-Based Materials: State-of-the-Art Report of the RILEM TC 276-DFC
,
N. Roussel
and
D. Lowke
(eds).
Springer
,
Cham
,
11
–
48
.
10.1007/978-3-030-90535-4_2 Google Scholar
-
Craveiro , F.
,
Nazarian , S.
,
Bartolo , H.
,
Bartolo , P.J.
,
Duarte , J.P.
(
2020
).
An automated system for 3D printing functionally graded concrete-based materials
.
Additive Manufacturing
,
33
,
101146
.
10.1016/j.addma.2020.101146 Google Scholar
-
El-Galy , I.M.
,
Saleh , B.I.
,
Ahmed , M.H.
(
2019
).
Functionally graded materials classifications and development trends from industrial point of view
.
SN Applied Sciences
,
1
(
11
),
1378
.
10.1007/s42452-019-1413-4 Google Scholar
- Eshkalak , S.K. , Ghomi , E.R. , Dai , Y. , Choudhury , D. , Ramakrishna , S. ( 2020 ). The role of three-dimensional printing in healthcare and medicine . Materials & Design , 194 , 108940 .
- Goyon , J. , Bertrand , F. , Pitois , O. , Ovarlez , G. ( 2010 ). Shear induced drainage in foamy yield-stress fluids . Physical Review Letters , 104 ( 12 ), 128301 .
- Hack , N. and Lauer , W.V. ( 2014 ). Mesh-mould: Robotically fabricated spatial meshes as reinforced concrete formwork . Architectural Design , 84 ( 3 ), 44 – 53 .
-
Hack , N.
,
Dressler , I.
,
Brohmann , L.
,
Gantner , S.
,
Lowke , D.
,
Kloft , H.
(
2020
).
Injection 3D Concrete Printing (I3DCP): Basic principles and case studies
.
Materials
,
13
(
5
). doi:
10.3390/ma13051093
.
10.3390/ma13051093 Google Scholar
- Jipa , A. and Dillenburger , B. ( 2022 ). 3D printed formwork for concrete: State-of-the-art, opportunities, challenges, and applications . 3D Printing and Additive Manufacturing , 9 ( 2 ), 84 – 107 .
-
Jipa , A.
,
Bernhard , M.
,
Meibodi , M.
,
Dillenburger , B.
(
2016
).
3D-printed stay-in-place formwork for topologically optimized concrete slabs
. In
Proceedings of the 2016 TxA Emerging Design+ Technology Conference
.
Texas Society of Architects
,
San Antonio, Texas
. doi:
10.3929/ethz-b000237082
.
10.3929/ethz?b000237082 Google Scholar
-
Jipa , A.
,
Bernhard , M.
,
Ruffray , N.
,
Wangler , T.
,
Flatt , R.J.
,
Dillenburger , B.
(
2019
).
Formwork fabrication freedom for a concrete canoe
.
Gestão & Tecnologia de Projetos
,
14
(
1
),
25
–
44
.
10.11606/gtp.v14i1.148264 Google Scholar
- Jipa , A. , Bürgin , T. , Dillenburger , B. ( 2023 ). 3D-printed formworks for glass fibre reinforced shotcrete . In GRCA 2023 .
-
Keating , S.
and
Oxman , N.
(
2013
).
Compound fabrication: A multi-functional robotic platform for digital design and fabrication
.
Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing
,
29
(
6
),
439
–
448
.
10.1016/j.rcim.2013.05.001 Google Scholar
- Kloft , H. , Krauss , H.-W. , Hack , N. , Herrmann , E. , Neudecker , S. , Varady , P.A. , Lowke , D. ( 2020 ). Influence of process parameters on the interlayer bond strength of concrete elements additive manufactured by Shotcrete 3D Printing (SC3DP) . Cement and Concrete Research , 134 , 106078 .
- Kuzmenko , K. , Ducoulombier , N. , Feraille , A. , Roussel , N. ( 2022 ). Environmental impact of extrusion-based additive manufacturing: Generic model, power measurements and influence of printing resolution . Cement and Concrete Research , 157 , 106807 .
-
Lachmayer , L.
,
Böhler , D.
,
Freund , N.
,
Mai , I.
,
Lowke , D.
,
Raatz , A.
(
2023
).
Modelling the influence of material and process parameters on Shotcrete 3D Printed strands-cross-section adjustment for automatic robotic manufacturing
.
Automation in Construction
,
145
,
104626
.
10.1016/j.autcon.2022.104626 Google Scholar
-
Lindemann , H.
,
Gerbers , R.
,
Ibrahim , S.
,
Dietrich , F.
,
Herrmann , E.
,
Dröder , K.
,
Raatz , A.
,
Kloft , H.
(
2019
).
Development of a shotcrete 3D-printing (SC3DP) technology for additive manufacturing of reinforced freeform concrete structures
. In
First RILEM International Conference on Concrete and Digital Fabrication–Digital Concrete 2018
.
Springer
,
Heidelberg
.
10.1007/978-3-319-99519-9_27 Google Scholar
- Lloret-Fritschi , E. , Reiter , L. , Wangler , T. , Gramazio , F. , Kohler , M. , Flatt , R.J. ( 2017 ). Smart dynamic casting: Slipforming with flexible formwork-inline measurement and control . In HPC/CIC Tromsø 2017 , 27 .
- Lloret-Fritschi , E. , Wangler , T. , Gebhard , L. , Mata-Falcón , J. , Mantellato , S. , Scotto , F. , Burger , J. , Szabo , A. , Ruffray , N. , Reiter , L. ( 2020 ). From smart dynamic casting to a growing family of digital casting systems . Cement and Concrete Research , 134 , 106071 .
-
Lloret-Fritschi , E.
,
Choma , J.
,
Scotto , F.
,
Szabo , A.
,
Gramazio , F.
,
Kohler , M.
,
Flatt , R.J.
(
2022
).
In-crease: Less concrete more paper
.
RILEM Technical Letters
,
7
,
199
–
208
.
10.21809/rilemtechlett.2022.168 Google Scholar
- Lowke , D. , Dini , E. , Perrot , A. , Weger , D. , Gehlen , C. , Dillenburger , B. ( 2018 ). Particle-bed 3D printing in concrete construction – Possibilities and challenges . Cement and Concrete Research , 112 , 50 – 65 .
- Lowke , D. , Talke , D. , Dressler , I. , Weger , D. , Gehlen , C. , Ostertag , C. , Rael , R. ( 2020 ). Particle bed 3D printing by selective cement activation – Applications, material and process technology . Cement and Concrete Research , 134 , 106077 .
- Lowke , D. , Vandenberg , A. , Pierre , A. , Thomas , A. , Kloft , H. , Hack , N. ( 2021 ). Injection 3D concrete printing in a carrier liquid – Underlying physics and applications to lightweight space frame structures . Cement and Concrete Composites , 124 , 104169 .
- Lowke , D. , Mai , I. , Keita , E. , Perrot , A. , Weger , D. , Gehlen , C. , Herding , F. , Zuo , W. , Roussel , N. ( 2022 ). Material-process interactions in particle bed 3D printing and the underlying physics . Cement and Concrete Research , 156 , 106748 .
- Lowke , D. , Anton , A. , Buswell , R. , Jenny , S.E. , Flatt , R.J. , Fritschi , E.L. , Hack , N. , Mai , I. , Popescu , M. , Kloft , H. ( 2024 ). Digital fabrication with concrete beyond horizontal planar layers . Cement and Concrete Research , 186 , 107663 . doi: 10.1016/j.cemconres.2024.107663 .
- Mai , I. , Lowke , D. , Perrot , A. ( 2022 ). Fluid intrusion in powder beds for selective cement activation – An experimental and analytical study . Cement and Concrete Research , 156 , 106771 .
- Mechtcherine , V. , Grafe , J. , Nerella , V.N. , Spaniol , E. , Hertel , M. , Füssel , U. ( 2018 ). 3D-printed steel reinforcement for digital concrete construction – Manufacture, mechanical properties and bond behaviour . Construction and Building Materials , 179 , 125 – 137 .
- Murphy , S.V. and Atala , A. ( 2014 ). 3D bioprinting of tissues and organs . Nature Biotechnology , 32 ( 8 ), 773 – 785 .
-
Oxman , N.
,
Keating , S.
,
Tsai , E.
(
2011
).
Functionally graded rapid prototyping
.
Innovative Developments in Virtual and Physical Prototyping
,
483
–
489
.
10.1201/b11341-78 Google Scholar
-
Perrot , A
. (
2019
).
3D Printing of Concrete: State of the Art and Challenges of the Digital Construction Revolution
.
ISTE Ltd
,
London
, and John Wiley & Sons, New York.
10.1002/9781119610755 Google Scholar
- Perrot , A. , Pierre , A. , Nerella , V.N. , Wolfs , R.J.M. , Keita , E. , Nair , S.A.O. , Neithalath , N. , Roussel , N. , Mechtcherine , V. ( 2021 ). From analytical methods to numerical simulations: A process engineering toolbox for 3D concrete printing . Cement and Concrete Composites , 122 , 104164 .
- Pierre , A. , Weger , D. , Perrot , A. , Lowke , D. ( 2018 ). Penetration of cement pastes into sand packings during 3D printing: Analytical and experimental study . Materials and Structures , 51 , 1 – 12 .
-
Pierre , A.
,
Weger , D.
,
Perrot , A.
,
Lowke , D.
(
2020
).
2D numerical modelling of particle-bed 3D printing by selective paste intrusion
. In
Second RILEM International Conference on Concrete and Digital Fabrication: Digital Concrete 2020
.
Springer
,
Heidelberg
.
10.1007/978-3-030-49916-7_35 Google Scholar
- Pitois , O. , Salamé , A. , Khidas , Y. , Ceccaldi , M. , Langlois , V. , Vincent-Bonnieu , S. ( 2023 ). Daisy-shaped liquid bridges in foam-filled granular packings . Journal of Colloid and Interface Science , 638 , 552 – 560 .
- Popescu , M.A. ( 2019 ). KnitCrete: Stay-in-place knitted formworks for complex concrete structures . PhD Thesis, ETH Zurich .
- Popescu , M.A. , Reiter , L. , Liew , A. , Van Mele , T. , Flatt , R.J. , Block , P. ( 2018 ). Building in concrete with an ultra-lightweight knitted stay-in-place formwork: Prototype of a concrete shell bridge . Structures , 14 , 322 – 332 . doi: 10.1016/j.istruc.2018.03.001 .
- Ranaudo , F. , Van Mele , T. , Block , P. ( 2010 ). A low-carbon, funicular concrete floor system: Design and engineering of the HiLo floors . System , 2012 ( 2016 ), 2016 – 2018 .
-
Rennen , P.
,
Gantner , S.
,
Dielemans , G.
,
Bleker , L.
,
Christidi , N.
,
Dörrie , R.
,
Hojjat , M.
,
Mai , I.
,
Mawas , K.
,
Lowke , D.
et al. (
2023
).
Robotic knitcrete: Computational design and fabrication of a pedestrian bridge using robotic shotcrete on a 3DKnitted formwork
.
Front. Built Environ.
,
9
,
1269000
. doi:
10.3389/fbuil.2023.1269000
.
10.3389/fbuil.2023.1269000 Google Scholar
-
Straßer , A.
,
Weger , D.
,
Matthäus , C.
,
Kränkel , T.
,
Gehlen , C.
(
2022
).
Combining wire and arc additive manufacturing and selective paste intrusion for additively manufactured structural concrete: Fundamental investigations on the effect of heat exposure by WAAM on the rheological and intrusion behavior of cement paste in the particle bed during selective paste intrusion
. In
Open Conference Proceedings
,
1
,
61
–
72
. doi:
10.52825/ocp.v1i.75
.
10.52825/ocp.v1i.75 Google Scholar
-
Straßer , A.
,
Haynack , A.
,
Kränkel , T.
,
Gehlen , C.
(
2024
).
Additive manufacturing by the selective paste intrusion: Effect of the distance of the print nozzle to the particle bed on the print quality
.
Construction and Building Materials
,
449
,
138274
. doi:
10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2024.138274
.
10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2024.138274 Google Scholar
- Szabo , A. ( 2020 ). Design and fabrication of thin folded members with digital concrete processes . PhD Thesis, ETH Zurich .
- Szabo , A. , Lloret-Fritschi , E. , Reiter , L. , Gramazio , F. , Kohler , M. , Flatt , R.J. ( 2019a ). Revisiting folded forms with digital fabrication . In Proceedings of the eCAADe SIGraDi 2019, Architecture in the Age of the 4th Industrial Revolution , J.P. Sousa , G. Castro Henriques , J.P. Xavier (eds). FAUP , Porto .
-
Szabo , A.
,
Reiter , L.
,
Lloret-Fritschi , E.
,
Gramazio , F.
,
Kohler , M.
,
Flatt , R.J.
(
2019b
).
Adapting smart dynamic casting to thin folded geometries
. In
First RILEM International Conference on Concrete and Digital Fabrication–Digital Concrete 2018
.
Springer
,
Heidelberg
.
10.1007/978-3-319-99519-9_8 Google Scholar
-
Szabo , A.
,
Reiter , L.
,
Lloret-Fritschi , E.
,
Wangler , T.
,
Gramazio , F.
,
Kohler , M.
,
Flatt , R.J.
(
2020a
).
ACDC: The admixture controlled digital casting and its application to thin folded concrete structures
. In
Second RILEM International Conference on Concrete and Digital Fabrication: Digital Concrete 2020
.
Springer
,
Cham
. doi:
10.1007/978-3-030-49916-7_93
.
10.1007/978-3-030-49916-7_93 Google Scholar
- Szabo , A. , Reiter , L. , Lloret-Fritschi , E. , Gramazio , F. , Kohler , M. , Flatt , R.J. ( 2020b ). Mastering yield stress evolution and formwork friction for smart dynamic casting . Materials , 13 ( 9 ), 2084 . doi: 10.3390/ma13092084 .
- Taha , N. , Walzer , A.N. , Ruangjun , J. , Bürgin , T. , Dörfler , K. , Lloret-Fritschi , E. , Gramazio , F. , Kohler , M. ( 2019 ). Robotic AeroCrete – A novel robotic spraying and surface treatment technology for the production of slender reinforced concrete elements . In Architecture in the Age of the 4th Industrial Revolution– Proceedings of the 37th eCAADe and 23rd SIGraDi Conference . CumInCAD , Porto .
- Vasilic , K. , Meng , B. , Kühne , H.-C. , Roussel , N. ( 2011 ). Flow of fresh concrete through steel bars: A porous medium analogy . Cement and Concrete Research , 41 ( 5 ), 496 – 503 .
- Vasilic , K. , Schmidt , W. , Kühne , H.-C. , Haamkens , F. , Mechtcherine , V. , Roussel , N. ( 2016 ). Flow of fresh concrete through reinforced elements: Experimental validation of the porous analogy numerical method . Cement and Concrete Research , 88 , 1 – 6 .
-
Weger , D.
,
Baier , D.
,
Straßer , A.
,
Prottung , S.
,
Kränkel , T.
,
Bachmann , A.
,
Gehlen , C.
,
Zäh , M.
(
2020
).
Reinforced particle-bed printing by combination of the selective paste intrusion method with wire and arc additive manufacturing – A first feasibility study
. In
Second RILEM International Conference on Concrete and Digital Fabrication: Digital Concrete 2020
.
Springer
,
Cham
.
10.1007/978-3-030-49916-7_95 Google Scholar
- Weger , D. , Pierre , A. , Perrot , A. , Kränkel , T. , Lowke , D. , Gehlen , C. ( 2021 ). Penetration of cement pastes into particle-beds: A comparison of penetration models . Materials , 14 ( 2 ), 389 .
- Wu , P. , Wang , J. , Wang , X. ( 2016 ). A critical review of the use of 3-D printing in the construction industry . Automation in Construction , 68 , 21 – 31 .
- Zuo , W. , Dong , C. , Belin , P. , Roussel , N. , Keita , E. ( 2022 ). Capillary imbibition depth in particle-bed 3D printing – Physical frame and one-dimensional experiments . Cement and Concrete Research , 156 , 106740 .