Introducing Critical Approaches in Health Professions Education Research
Claire Palermo,
Monash University, Clayton, Victoria, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorNicole Redvers
University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada
Search for more papers by this authorGabrielle Brandand
Monash University, Clayton, Victoria, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorClaire Palermo,
Monash University, Clayton, Victoria, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorNicole Redvers
University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada
Search for more papers by this authorGabrielle Brandand
Monash University, Clayton, Victoria, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorCharlotte Rees
The University of Newcastle, Callaghan, New South Wales, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorLynn Monrouxe
The University of Sydney, Camperdown, New South Wales, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorBridget O'Brien
University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, California, USA
Search for more papers by this authorSummary
Collectively, critical approaches aim to: ‘understand and to disrupt notions of truth and the structures of power that come to be taken for granted’. Common critical theories that inform critical approaches include critical theory, critical realism, race, class or cultural theory, gender and queer theory, and feminism theory. Critical analysis leads to the uncovering and dismantling of omissions and invisibilities, paying increased attention to power, privilege, and hierarchy. This chapter explores and discusses the philosophical underpinnings of critical approaches to health professions education research — historical realism ontology, collectivist and subjectivist epistemology, and the emancipatory axiology or values underpinning this approach. It outlines key quality indicators, including guidelines that may support the appraisal of critical research. Key strengths of critical approaches include the potential for reciprocal benefits for researchers and participants in that there is two-way learning through this dual process of trust and reciprocity.
References
- Denzin N . Critical qualitative inquiry . Qual Inq . 2017 ; 23 ( 1 ): 8 – 16 .
- Hodges B . When I say … critical theory . Med Educ . 2014 ; 48 ( 11 ): 1043 – 1044 .
-
Swaminathan R
,
Mulvihill T
.
Critical Approaches to Questions in Qualitative Research
.
New York and London
:
Routledge
;
2017
.
10.4324/9781315629605 Google Scholar
- Patton MQ . Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods: Integrating Theory and Practice . 4th ed. Thousand Oaks, Calif .: SAGE ; 2014 .
- Brand G , Sheers C , Wise S , et al. A research approach for co-designing education with healthcare consumers . Med Educ . 2021 ; 55 ( 5 ): 574 – 581 .
- Redvers N , Schultz C , Vera Prince M , et al. Indigenous perspectives on education for sustainable healthcare . Med Teach . 2020 ; 42 ( 10 ): 1085 – 1090 .
- Palermo C , Allen L , Dart J , et al. Hidden Jedi: a critical qualitative exploration of the fellow credential and advanced expertise . Nutr Diet . 2020 ; 77 ( 1 ): 167 – 176 .
- Rees CE , Monrouxe LV . Theory in medical education research: how do we get there? Med Educ . 2010 ; 44 ( 4 ): 334 – 339 .
-
Scotland J
.
Exploring the philosophical underpinning of research: relating ontology and epistemology to the methodology and methods of the scientific, interpretive and critical research paradigms
.
English Language Teaching
.
2012
;
5
(
9
):
9
–
16
.
10.5539/elt.v5n9p9 Google Scholar
-
Brekke J
,
Anastas J
,
Floersch J
, et al.
The realist frame: scientific realism and critical realism
. In
J Brekke
,
J Anastas
, eds.
Shaping a Science of Social Work: Professional Knowledge and Identity
. Online Edition
New York
:
Oxford University Academic
;
2019
:
22
–
40
.
10.1093/oso/9780190880668.003.0002 Google Scholar
- Palermo C , Reidlinger DP , Rees CE . Internal coherence matters: lessons for nutrition and dietetics research . Nutr Diet . 2021 ; 78 ( 3 ): 252 – 267 .
- Lincoln YS , Lynham SA , Guba EG . Paradigmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences revisited . In NK Denzin , YS Lincoln , eds. The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research . 5th ed. Thousand Oaks, Calif .: SAGE ; 2018 : 108 – 150 .
- Tuhiwai Smith L . Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples . 2nd ed. London : Zed Books ; 2012 .
-
Braun KL
,
Browne CV
,
Ka'opua LS
, et al.
Research on Indigenous elders: from positivistic to decolonizing methodologies
.
Gerontol
.
2014
;
54
(
1
):
117
–
126
.
10.1093/geront/gnt067 Google Scholar
- Freire P . Pedagogy of the Oppressed . 20th Anniversary Ed. New York : Continuum, 1993 .
- Bunniss S , Kelly DR . Research paradigms in medical education research . Med Educ . 2010 ; 44 ( 4 ): 358 – 366 .
- O'Connor S , Zhang M , Trout KK , et al. Co-production in nursing and midwifery education: a systematic review of the literature . Nurs Educ Today . 2021 ; 102 : 104900 .
- Stringer E . Action Research in Education . Upper Saddle River, NJ : Pearson Prentice Hall ; 2008 .
- Jaiswal D , To MJ , Hunter H , et al. Twelve tips for medical students to facilitate a photovoice project . Med Teach . 2016 ; 38 ( 10 ): 981 – 986 .
- Rees C . Drawing on drawings: moving beyond text in health professions education research . Perspect Med Educ . 2018 ; 7 ( 3 ): 166 – 173 .
- Gordon L , Rees C , Ker J , et al. Using video-reflexive ethnography to capture the complexity of leadership enactment in the healthcare workplace . Adv Health Sci Educ . 2017 ; 22 ( 5 ): 1101 – 1121 .
- Smith JL . Critical discourse analysis for nursing research . Nurs Inquiry . 2007 ; 14 ( 1 ): 60 – 70 .
- McGaghie WC , Issenberg SB , Barsuk JH , et al. A critical review of simulation-based mastery learning with translational outcomes . Med Educ . 2014 ; 48 ( 4 ): 375 – 385 .
- Cook KE . Using critical ethnography to explore issues in health promotion . Qual Health Res . 2005 ; 15 ( 1 ): 129 – 138 .
-
Tuhiwai Smith L
.
Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples
,
3rd
ed.
London
:
Bloomsbury
;
2021
.
10.5040/9781350225282 Google Scholar
- Jackson CL , Greenhalgh T . Co-creation: a new approach to optimising research impact . Med J Aust . 2015 ; 203 ( 7 ): 283 – 284 .
- Towle A , Farrell C , Gaines ME , et al. The patient's voice in health and social care professional education: the Vancouver Statement . Int J of Hth Gov . 2016 ; 21 ( 1 ): 18 – 25 .
- Nhemachena A , Mlambo N , Kaundjua M . The notion of the “field” and the practices of researching and writing Africa: towards decolonial praxis . Africology: The J Pan Afr Studies . 2016 ; 9 ( 7 ): 15 – 36 .
-
Khupe C
,
Keane M
.
Towards an African education research methodology: decolonising new knowledge
.
Educ Res Soc Change
.
2017
;
6
(
1
):
25
–
37
.
10.17159/2221-4070/2017/v6i1a3 Google Scholar
-
Redvers N
,
Wilkinson M
,
Fischer C
.
Colorectal cancer community engagement: a qualitative exploration of American Indian voices from North Dakota
.
BMC Cancer
.
2022
;
9
(
1
):
158
.
10.1186/s12885-021-09119-2 Google Scholar
- Geia LK , Hayes B , Usher K . Yarning/Aboriginal storytelling: towards an understanding of an Indigenous perspective and its implications for research practice . Contemp Nurse . 2013 ; 46 ( 1 ): 13 – 17 .
- Ungunmerr-Baumann MR , Brennan F . Reverencing the earth in the Australia dreaming . The Way . 1989 ; 29 : 38 – 45 .
- Ferrazzi P , Tagalik S , Christie P , et al. Aajiiqatigiingniq: an Inuit consensus methodology in qualitative health research . Int J Qual Meth . 2019 ; 18 : 1 – 9
- Wexler L , White J , Trainor B . Why an alternative to suicide prevention gatekeeper training is needed for rural Indigenous communities: presenting an empowering community storytelling approach . Critical Public Health . 2015 ; 25 ( 2 ): 205 – 217 .
- Redvers N , Yellow Bird M , Quinn D , et al. Molecular decolonization: an Indigenous microcosm perspective of planetary health . Int J Environ Res Pub Hlth . 2020 ; 17 ( 12 ): 4586 .
- Walker M , Fredericks B , Mills K , et al. “Yarning” as a method for community-based health research with Indigenous women: the Indigenous Women's Wellness Research Program . Health Care Women Int . 2014 ; 35 ( 10 ): 1216 – 1226 .
- Brearley L . Deep listening and leadership: an Indigenous model of leadership and community development in Australia . In C Voyageur , L Brearley , B Calliou , eds. Restorying Indigenous Leadership: Wise Practices in Community Development , 2nd ed. Banff : Banff Centre Press ; 2015 : 91 – 127 .
- Rees CE . Identities as performances: encouraging visual methodologies in medical education research . Med Educ . 2010 ; 44 ( 1 ): 5 – 7 .
- Iedema R , Mesman J , Carroll K . Visualising Health Care Practice Improvement: Innovation from Within . London : Radcliffe Publishing ; 2013 .
-
Mesman J
,
Walsh K
,
Kinsman L
, et al.
Blending video-reflexive ethnography with solution-focused approach: a strengths-based approach to practice improvement in health care
.
Int J Qual Meth
.
2019
;
18
:
1
–
10
.
10.1177/1609406919875277 Google Scholar
- Ajjawi R , Hilder J , Noble C , et al. Using video-reflexive ethnography to understand complexity and change practice . Med Educ . 2020 ; 54 ( 10 ): 908 – 914 .
- Iedema R . Research paradigm that tackles the complexity of in situ care: video reflexivity . BMJ Qual Safe . 2019 ; 28 ( 2 ): 89 – 90 .
-
Carroll K
.
Outsider, insider, alongsider: examining reflexivity in hospital-based video research
.
Int J Mult Res Approaches
.
2009
;
3
(
3
):
246
–
263
.
10.5172/mra.3.3.246 Google Scholar
- Carroll K , Mesman J . Multiple researcher roles in video-reflexive ethnography . Qual Health Res . 2018 ; 28 ( 7 ): 1145 – 1156 .
- Ellis C , Adams T , Bochner AP . Autoethnography: an overview . Histor Soc Res . 2011 ; 12 ( 4 ): 273 – 290 .
-
Adams T
,
Ellis C
,
Jones S
.
Autoethnography
. In
J Matthes
,
CS Davis
,
RF Potter
, eds.
The International Encyclopedia of Communication Research Methods
.
Hoboken
:
John Wiley & Sons, Inc
;
2017
:
1
–
11
.
10.1002/9781118901731.iecrm0011 Google Scholar
-
Tachine AR
,
Yellow Bird E
,
Cabrera NL
.
Sharing circles: an Indigenous methodological approach for researching with groups of Indigenous peoples
.
Int Rev Qual Res
.
2016
;
9
(
3
):
277
–
295
.
10.1525/irqr.2016.9.3.277 Google Scholar
-
Foot KA
.
Cultural-historical activity theory: exploring a theory to inform practice and research
.
J Hum Behav Soc Environ
.
2013
;
24
(
3
):
329
–
347
.
10.1080/10911359.2013.831011 Google Scholar
- Liamputtong P . Qualitative Research Methods , 5th ed. Melbourne : Oxford University Press ; 2019 .
-
Strydom P
.
Contemporary Critical Theory and Methodology
.
London and New York
:
Routledge
;
2011
.
10.4324/9780203875568 Google Scholar
- Kitto SC , Chesters J , Grbich C . Quality in qualitative research . Med J Aust . 2008 ; 188 ( 4 ): 243 – 246 .
- Cassell C , Radcliffe LS , Malik F . Participant reflexivity in organizational research design . Org Res Meth . 2020 ; 23 ( 4 ): 750 – 773 .
- Barry CA , Britten N , Barber N , et al. Using reflexivity to optimize teamwork in qualitative research . Qual Health Res . 1999 ; 9 ( 1 ): 26 – 44 .
-
Carroll KF
,
Mesman J
.
Ethnographic context meets ethnographic biography: a challenge for the mores of doing fieldwork
.
Int J Mult Res Approaches
.
2011
;
5
(
2
):
155
–
168
.
10.5172/mra.2011.5.2.155 Google Scholar
-
Horsfall D
,
Higgs J
.
Boundary riding and shaping research spaces
. In
J Higgs
,
A Titchen
,
D, Horsfall
et al., eds.
Creative Spaces for Qualitative Researching
.
Rotterdam
:
Sense Publishers
;
2011
:
45
–
54
.
10.1007/978-94-6091-761-5_5 Google Scholar
-
McCartan J
,
Brimblecombe J
,
Adams K
.
Methodological tensions for non-Indigenous people in Indigenous research: a critique of critical discourse analysis in the Australian context
.
Soc Sci Hum Open
.
2022
;
6
(
1
):
100282
.
10.1016/j.ssaho.2022.100282 Google Scholar
- Enosh G , Ben-Ari A . Reflexivity: the creation of liminal spaces – researchers, participants, and research encounters . Qual Health Res . 2016 ; 26 ( 4 ): 578 – 584 .
- Gordon L . Making space for relational reflexivity in longitudinal qualitative research . Med Educ . 2021 ; 55 ( 11 ): 1223 – 1224 .
- Buus N , Agdal R . Can the use of reporting guidelines in peer-review damage the quality and contribution of qualitative health care research? Int J Nurs Stand . 2013 ; 50 ( 10 ): 1289 – 1291 .
- Goodman D , Ogrinc G , Davies L , et al. Explanation and elaboration of the SQUIRE (Standards for QUality Improvement Reporting Excellence) Guidelines V.2.0: examples of SQUIRE elements in the healthcare improvement literature . BMJ Qual Safe . 2016 ; 25 ( 12 ): e7 .
- Ogrinc G , Armstrong GE , Dolansky MA , et al. SQUIRE-EDU (Standards for QUality Improvement Reporting Excellence in Education): publication guidelines for educational improvement . Acad Med . 2019 ; 94 ( 10 ): 1461 – 1470 .
- Abelson J , Li K , Wilson G , et al. Supporting quality public and patient engagement in health system organizations: development and usability testing of the Public and Patient Engagement Evaluation Tool . Health Exp . 2016 ; 19 ( 4 ): 817 – 827 .
- Staniszewska S , Brett J , Simera I , et al. GRIPP2 reporting checklists: tools to improve reporting of patient and public involvement in research . BMJ . 2017 ; 358 : j3453 .
- National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) . Statement on consumer and community involvement in health and medical research. 2016 . https://www.nhmrc.gov.au/about-us/publications/statement-consumer-and-community-involvement-health-and-medical-research (accessed 3 September 2022 ).
- Australian Commission of Safety and Quality in Health Care . National Safety and Quality Health Service (NSQHS) Standards: Partnering with Consumers Standard . Sydney, NSW : 2022 .
- Halman M , Baker L , Ng S . Using critical consciousness to inform health professions education . Perspect Med Educ . 2017 ; 6 ( 1 ): 12 – 20 .
- Baum F , MacDougall C , Smith D . Participatory action research . J Epidemiol Community Health . 2006 ; 60 ( 10 ): 854 – 857 .
- Crampton PES , McLachlan JC , Illing JC . A systematic literature review of undergraduate clinical placements in underserved areas . Med Educ . 2013 ; 47 ( 10 ): 969 – 978 .
- Hudon C , Loignon C , Grabovschi C , et al. Medical education for equity in health: a participatory action research involving persons living in poverty and healthcare professionals . BMC Med Educ . 2016 ; 16 : 106 .
- Mitchell P , Nightingale J . Sonography culture: power and protectionism . Radiography . 2019 ; 25 ( 3 ): 227 – 234 .
- Finn GM , Brown MEL . Ova-looking feminist theory: a call for consideration within health professions education and research . Adv Health Sci Educ . 2022 ; 27 ( 3 ): 893 – 913 .
- Grumbach K , Mendoza R . Disparities in human resources: addressing the lack of diversity in the health professions . Health Aff (Millwood) . 2008 ; 27 ( 2 ): 413 – 422 .
-
Matias CE
.
The Handbook of Critical Theoretical Research Methods in Education
.
London and New York
:
Routledge
;
2021
.
10.4324/9780429056963 Google Scholar
- Paradis EL , Nimmon L , Wondimagegn D , et al. Critical theory: broadening our thinking to explore the structural factors at play in health professions education . Acad Med . 2020 ; 95 ( 6 ): 842 – 845 .
- Cleland J , Razack S . When I say … privilege . Med Educ . 2021 ; 55 ( 12 ): 1347 – 1349 .