3D Printing in Robotic Urosurgery
Rishabha Malviya
Department of Pharmacy, School of Medical and Allied Sciences, Galgotias University
Search for more papers by this authorRishav Sharma
Department of Pharmacy, School of Medical and Allied Sciences, Galgotias University
Search for more papers by this authorRishabha Malviya
Department of Pharmacy, School of Medical and Allied Sciences, Galgotias University
Search for more papers by this authorRishav Sharma
Department of Pharmacy, School of Medical and Allied Sciences, Galgotias University
Search for more papers by this authorSummary
The use of 3D printing in urology has been the subject of a rapidly expanding corpus of research during the past 5 years. Progress in exciting new fields of study has been made possible by incentives including work-hour restrictions and patient-safety programs, as well as by innovations in biomaterials and quick printing techniques. However, difficulties with its wide usage comprise high prices, unfamiliarity with the technical processes required, as well as absence of potential applications. The investigation of the concept for 3D printing in urological practice depends on robotic surgery to enhance pre-operative planning, update surgeon training, and better educate patients. Models of the prostate are frequently used in the preparation for nerve-sparing surgeries. Early research has shown enough realism and educational effectiveness to warrant continuing the project. Further investigation has shown enhanced surgeon assurance, surgical efficiency, and enhanced patient outcomes, with high levels of patient satisfaction among the highlights. Standard desktop 3D printers now make it possible to produce realistic, precise models in a matter of hours at a price that would not break the bank. Most typically, 3D printing has been utilized to create anatomical replicas of sick organs to replace the haptic feedback that is lost during robotic surgeries. Urologists are rapidly expanding and continuously improving in adaptive mode, and thus the benefits to patients were expected to exceed the diminishing drawbacks, indicating that subsequent transformation in surgical education, robotics techniques, and individualized therapy may occur simultaneously.
References
- Martelli , N. , Serrano , C. , van den Brink , H. , Pineau , J. , Prognon , P. , Borget , I. , El Batti , S. , Advantages and disadvantages of 3-dimensional printing in surgery: A systematic review . Surgery , 159 , 6 , 1485 – 500 , 2016 Jun 1.
- Auricchio , F. and Marconi , S. , 3D printing: Clinical applications in orthopaedics and traumatology . EFORT Open Rev. , 1 , 5 , 121 , 2016 May.
- Parikh , N. and Sharma , P. , Three-dimensional printing in urology: History, current applications, and future directions . Urology , 121 , 3 – 10 , 2018 Nov 1.
- Malik , H.H. , Darwood , A.R. , Shaunak , S. , Kulatilake , P. , Abdulrahman , A. , Mulki , O. , Baskaradas , A. , Three-dimensional printing in surgery: A review of current surgical applications . J. Surg. Res. , 199 , 2 , 512 – 22 , 2015 Dec 1.
- Silberstein , J.L. , Maddox , M.M. , Dorsey , P. , Feibus , A. , Thomas , R. , Lee , B.R. , Physical models of renal malignancies using standard cross-sectional imaging and 3-dimensional printers: A pilot study . Urology , 84 , 2 , 268 – 73 , 2014 Aug 1.
- Silberstein , J.L. , Maddox , M.M. , Dorsey , P. , Feibus , A. , Thomas , R. , Lee , B.R. , Physical models of renal malignancies using standard cross-sectional imaging and 3-dimensional printers: A pilot study . Urology , 84 , 2 , 268 – 73 , 2014 Aug 1.
- Wake , N. , Rude , T. , Kang , S.K. , Stifelman , M.D. , Borin , J.F. , Sodickson , D.K. , Huang , W.C. , Chandarana , H. , 3D printed renal cancer models derived from MRI data: Application in pre-surgical planning . Abdom. Radiol. , 42 , 1501 – 9 , 2017 May.
- Chandak , P. , Byrne , N. , Lynch , H. , Allen , C. , Rottenberg , G. , Chandra , A. , Raison , N. , Ahmed , H.U. , Kasivisvanathan , V. , Elhage , O. , Dasgupta , P. , 3D printing in robotic assisted radical prostatectomy-an IDEAL Phase 2a study . BJU Int. , 122 , 360 – 361 , 2018 Mar 6.
- Westerman , M.E. , Matsumoto , J.M. , Morris , J.M. , Leibovich , B.C. , Three-dimensional printing for renal cancer and surgical planning . Eur. Urol. Focus , 2 , 6 , 574 – 6 , 2016 Dec 15.
- Porpiglia , F. , Bertolo , R. , Checcucci , E. , Amparore , D. , Autorino , R. , Dasgupta , P. , Wiklund , P. , Tewari , A. , Liatsikos , E. , Fiori , C. , ESUT Research Group, Development and validation of 3D printed virtual models for robot-assisted radical prostatectomy and partial nephrectomy: Urologists’ and patients’ perception . World J. Urol. , 36 , 201 – 7 , 2018 Feb.
- Cacciamani , G.E. , Okhunov , Z. , Meneses , A.D. , Rodriguez-Socarras , M.E. , Rivas , J.G. , Porpiglia , F. , Liatsikos , E. , Veneziano , D. , Impact of three-dimensional printing in urology: State of the art and future perspectives. A systematic review by ESUT-YAUWP Group . Eur. Urol. , 76 , 2 , 209 – 21 , 2019 Aug 1.
- Zhang , Y. , Ge , H.W. , Li , N.C. , Yu , C.F. , Guo , H.F. , Jin , S.H. , Liu , J.S. , Na , Y.Q. , Evaluation of three-dimensional printing for laparoscopic partial nephrectomy of renal tumors: A preliminary report . World J. Urol. , 34 , 533 – 7 , 2016 Apr.
- Shin , T. , Ukimura , O. , Gill , I.S. , Three-dimensional printed model of prostate anatomy and targeted biopsy-proven index tumor to facilitate nerve-sparing prostatectomy . Eur. Urol. , 69 , 2 , 377 , 2016 Feb.
- Chandak , P. , Byrne , N. , Lynch , H. , Allen , C. , Rottenberg , G. , Chandra , A. , Raison , N. , Ahmed , H.U. , Kasivisvanathan , V. , Elhage , O. , Dasgupta , P. , 3D printing in robotic assisted radical prostatectomy-an IDEAL Phase 2a study . BJU Int. , 360 – 361 , 2018 Mar 6.
- Hameed , A.M. , Yao , J. , Allen , R.D. , Hawthorne , W.J. , Pleass , H.C. , Lau , H. , The evolution of kidney transplantation surgery into the robotic era and its prospects for obese recipients . Transplantation , 102 , 10 , 1650 – 65 , 2018 Oct 1.
- Smektala , T. , Gołab , A. , Królikowski , M. , Słojewski , M. , Low cost silicone renal replicas for surgical training. Technical note . Arch. Esp. Urol. , 69 , 7 , 434 – 6 , 2016 .
- Kusaka , M. , Sugimoto , M. , Fukami , N. , Sasaki , H. , Takenaka , M. , Anraku , T. , Ito , T. , Kenmochi , T. , Shiroki , R. , Hoshinaga , K. , Initial experience with a tailor-made simulation and navigation program using a 3-D printer model of kidney transplantation surgery . Transplant. Proc. , 47 , 3 , 596 – 599 , 2015 Apr 1. Elsevier .
- Golab , A. , Smektala , T. , Kaczmarek , K. , Stamirowski , R. , Hrab , M. , Slojewski , M. , Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy supported by training involving personalized silicone replica poured in three-dimensional printed casting mold . J. Laparoendosc. Adv. Surg. Tech. , 27 , 4 , 420 – 2 , 2017 Apr 1.
- Ghazi , A.E. and Teplitz , B.A. , Role of 3D printing in surgical education for robotic urology procedures . Transl. Androl. Urol. , 9 , 2 , 931 , 2020 Apr.
- Maddox , M.M. , Feibus , A. , Liu , J. , Wang , J. , Thomas , R. , Silberstein , J.L. , 3D-printed soft-tissue physical models of renal malignancies for individualized surgical simulation: A feasibility study . J. Robot. Surg. , 12 , 27 – 33 , 2018 Mar.
- Reznick , R.K. and MacRae , H. , Teaching surgical skills—Changes in the wind . N. Engl. J. Med. , 355 , 25 , 2664 – 9 , 2006 Dec 21.
-
Badash , I.
,
Burtt , K.
,
Solorzano , C.A.
,
Carey , J.N.
,
Innovations in surgery simulation: A review of past, current and future techniques
.
Ann. Transl. Med.
,
4
,
23
,
1
–
10
,
2016
Dec.
10.21037/atm.2016.12.24 Google Scholar
- Cacciamani , G.E. , Okhunov , Z. , Meneses , A.D. , Rodriguez-Socarras , M.E. , Rivas , J.G. , Porpiglia , F. , Liatsikos , E. , Veneziano , D. , Impact of three-dimensional printing in urology: State of the art and future perspectives. A systematic review by ESUT-YAUWP Group . Eur. Urol. , 76 , 2 , 209 – 21 , 2019 Aug 1.
- Parikh , N. and Sharma , P. , Three-dimensional printing in urology: History, current applications, and future directions . Urology , 121 , 3 – 10 , 2018 Nov 1.
- Malik , H.H. , Darwood , A.R. , Shaunak , S. , Kulatilake , P. , Abdulrahman , A. , Mulki , O. , Baskaradas , A. , Three-dimensional printing in surgery: A review of current surgical applications . J. Surg. Res. , 199 , 2 , 512 – 22 , 2015 Dec 1.
- Uwechue , R. , Gogalniceanu , P. , Kessaris , N. , Byrne , N. , Chandak , P. , Olsburgh , J. , Ahmed , K. , Mamode , N. , Loukopoulos , I. , A novel 3D-printed hybrid simulation model for robotic-assisted kidney transplantation (RAKT) . J. Rob. Surg. , 12 , 541 – 4 , 2018 Sep.
- Ghazi , A. , Stone , J. , Candela , B. , Richards , M. , Joseph , J. , Simulated inanimate model for physical learning experience (simple) for robotic partial nephrectomy using a 3d printed kidney model . J. Urol. , 193 , 4 , e778 , 2015 Apr 1.
- Porpiglia , F. , Bertolo , R. , Checcucci , E. , Amparore , D. , Autorino , R. , Dasgupta , P. , Wiklund , P. , Tewari , A. , Liatsikos , E. , Fiori , C. , ESUT Research Group, Development and validation of 3D printed virtual models for robot-assisted radical prostatectomy and partial nephrectomy: Urologists’ and patients’ perception . World J. Urol. , 36 , 201 – 7 , 2018 Feb.
- Silberstein , J.L. , Maddox , M.M. , Dorsey , P. , Feibus , A. , Thomas , R. , Lee , B.R. , Physical models of renal malignancies using standard cross-sectional imaging and 3-dimensional printers: A pilot study . Urology , 84 , 2 , 268 – 73 , 2014 Aug 1.
- Knoedler , M. , Feibus , A.H. , Lange , A. , Maddox , M.M. , Ledet , E. , Thomas , R. , Silberstein , J.L. , Individualized physical 3-dimensional kidney tumor models constructed from 3-dimensional printers result in improved trainee anatomic understanding . Urology , 85 , 6 , 1257 – 62 , 2015 Jun 1.
- Zhang , Y. , Ge , H.W. , Li , N.C. , Yu , C.F. , Guo , H.F. , Jin , S.H. , Liu , J.S. , Na , Y.Q. , Evaluation of three-dimensional printing for laparoscopic partial nephrectomy of renal tumors: A preliminary report . World J. Urol. , 34 , 533 – 7 , 2016 Apr.