Late Quaternary Biogeography of Small Carnivores in Europe
Robert S. Sommer
Department of Landscape Sciences and Geomatics, Neubrandenburg University of Applied Sciences, Neubrandenburg, Germany
Search for more papers by this authorJennifer J. Crees
Institute of Zoology, Zoological Society of London, London, UK
Search for more papers by this authorRobert S. Sommer
Department of Landscape Sciences and Geomatics, Neubrandenburg University of Applied Sciences, Neubrandenburg, Germany
Search for more papers by this authorJennifer J. Crees
Institute of Zoology, Zoological Society of London, London, UK
Search for more papers by this authorEmmanuel Do Linh San
University of Fort Hare, Alice, South Africa
Search for more papers by this authorJerrold L. Belant
Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, USA
Search for more papers by this authorMichael J. Somers
University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa
Search for more papers by this authorSummary
The Late Quaternary distribution history of small carnivores in Europe was strongly influenced by climate and humans. Subfossil records from geological or archaeological excavations can be used to reconstruct spatio-temporal dynamics of species for the Pleistocene and Holocene Epochs. During full glacial conditions, around 60–15 thousand years ago (kya), Central European regions were only permanently colonized by the wolverine, Gulo gulo , and both stoat, Mustela erminea , and least weasel, M. nivalis . From around 14 kya, the European polecat, M. putorius , European badger, Meles meles , pine marten, Martes martes , red fox, Vulpes vulpes , and European wild cat, Felis silvestris , spread into northern regions due to climate warming (Greenland Interstadial 1) and associated stepwise reforestation of those regions. The Eurasian otter, Lutra lutra , colonized Central Europe for the first time during the Early Holocene. In contrast to several other small carnivore species from temperate regions that survived and recolonized Central Europe from refugial regions such as Iberia, the Apennine peninsula, the Carpathians or the Balkans, the otter was restricted to the Apennine peninsula and its low genetic diversity as well as its late arrival may be a consequence of this. The stone marten, Martes foina , probably followed Neolithic settlers out of Asia Minor, whereas the origin and colonization pattern of the European mink, Mustela lutreola , remains enigmatic. Small carnivores experienced limited distributional shifts during the Holocene in comparison to larger carnivores, probably due to their ecological plasticity and relative resilience to human impacts. The European wild cat disappeared from northern regions after the Holocene thermal optimum and both the pine marten and the European polecat may have experienced some range contraction during the Medieval, but most species broadly maintained their Holocene distributions to the present day.
References
- Barron , E. , van Andel , T.H. & Pollard , D. ( 2003 ) Glacial environments II. Reconstructing the climate of Europe in the Last Glaciation . In: Neanderthals and Modern Humans in the European Landscape during the Last Glaciation: Archaeological Results of the Stage 3 Project (eds T.H. Andel & W. Davies ), pp. 57 – 78 . McDonald Institute Monographs , Cambridge .
- Benecke , N. ( 1999 ) The project “The holocene history of the European vertebrate fauna” . Archäologie in Eurasien 6 , 151 – 161 .
- Björck , S. , Walker , M.J.C. , Cwynar , L.C. , Johnsen , S. , Knudsen , K.-L. , Lowe , J.J. & Wohlfarth , B. ( 1998 ) An event stratigraphy for the Last Termination in the North Atlantic region based on the Greenland ice core record: a proposal by the INTIMATE group . Journal of Quaternary Science 13 , 283 – 292 .
- Blockley , S.P.E. , Lane , C.S. , Hardiman , M. , Rasmussen , S.O. , Seierstad , I.K. , Steffensen , J.P. , Svensson , A. , Lotter , A.F. , Turney , C.S.M. , Bronk Ramsey , C. & INTIMATE members ( 2012 ) Synchronisation of palaeoenvironmental records over the last 60,000 years, and extended INTIMATE event stratigraphy to 48,000 b2k . Quaternary Science Reviews 36 , 2 – 10 .
- Crees , J.J. ( 2013 ) Dynamics of Large Mammal Range Shifts and Extinction: Evidence from the Holocene of Europe . PhD thesis, Imperial College London and Institute of Zoology, ZSL .
- Crees , J.J. & Turvey , S.T. ( 2014 ) Holocene extinction dynamics of Equus hydruntinus , a late-surviving European megafaunal mammal . Quaternary Science Reviews 91 , 16 – 29 .
- Crees , J.J. , Carbone , C. , Sommer , R.S. , Benecke , N. & Turvey , S.T. ( 2016 ) Millennial-scale faunal record reveals differential resilience of European large mammals to human impacts across the Holocene . Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 283 , 20152152 .
- Dansgaard , W. , Johnsen , S.J. , Clausen , H.B. , Dahl-Jensen , D. , Gundestrup , N.S. , Hammer , C.U. , Hvidberg , C.S. , Steffensen , J.P. , Sveinbjörnsdottir , A.E. , Jouzel , J. & Bond , G. ( 1993 ) Evidence for general instability of past climate from a 250-kyr ice-core record . Nature 364 , 218 – 220 .
- Davis , B.A.S. , Brewer , S. , Stevenson , A.C. & Guiot , J. ( 2003 ) The temperature of Europe during the Holocene reconstructed from pollen data . Quaternary Science Reviews 22 , 1701 – 1716 .
- Deffontaine , V. , Libois , R. , Kotlik , P. , Sommer , R. , Nieberding , C. , Searle , J.B. & Michaux , J.R. ( 2005 ) Beyond the Mediterranean peninsulas: evidence of central European glacial refugia for a temperate forest mammal species, the bank vole ( Clethrionomys glareolus ) . Molecular Ecology 14 , 1727 – 1739 .
-
Fortin , M.J.
&
Dale , M.R.T.
(
2005
)
Spatial Analysis: A Guide for Ecologists
.
Cambridge University Press
,
Cambridge
.
10.1017/CBO9780511542039 Google Scholar
- Gaston , K. ( 2009 ) Geographic range limits of species . Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 276 , 1391 – 1393 .
- Hewitt , G.M. ( 1996 ) Some genetic consequences of ice ages, and their role in divergence and speciation . Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 58 , 247 – 276 .
- Hewitt , G.M. ( 2000 ) The genetic legacy of the Quaternary ice ages . Nature 405 , 907 – 913 .
- Honnen , A.-C. , Petersen , B. , Kaßler , L. , Elmeros , M. , Roos , A. , Sommer , R.S. & Zachos , F.E. ( 2011 ) Genetic structure of Eurasian otter ( Lutra lutra , Carnivora: Mustelidae) populations from the western Baltic sea region and its implications for the recolonisation of northwestern Germany . Journal of Zoological Systematics and Evolutionary Research 48 , 169 – 175 .
- Hubberten , H.W. , Andrev , A. , Astakhov , V.I. , Demikov , I. , Dowdeswell , J.A. et al . ( 2004 ) The periglacial climate and environment in northern Eurasia during the Last Glaciation . Quaternary Science Reviews 23 , 1333 – 1357 .
- Huijzer , B. & Vandenberghe , J. ( 1998 ) Climatic reconstruction of the Weichselian Pleniglacial in northwestern and Central Europe . Journal of Quaternary Science 13 , 391 – 417 .
- Huntley , B. & Allen , J.R.M. ( 2003 ) Glacial environments III: palaeo-vegetation patterns in Late Glacial Europe . In: Neanderthals and Modern Humans in the European Landscape during the Last Glaciation: Archaeological Results of the Stage 3 Project (eds T.H. Andel & W. Davies ), pp. 79 – 102 . McDonald Institute Monographs , Cambridge .
- Huntley , B. & Birks , H.J.B. ( 1983 ) An Atlas of Past and Present Pollen Maps of Europe: 0–13,000 years ago . Cambridge University Press , Cambridge .
- Huntley , B. , Alfano , M.J. , Allen , J.R.M. , Pollard , D. , Tzedakis , P.C. , de Beaulieu , J.-L. , Grüger , E. & Watts , B. ( 2003 ) European vegetation during Marine Oxygen Isotope Stage-3 . Quaternary Research 59 , 159 – 212 .
- IUCN [International Union for Conservation of Nature] ( 2001 ) IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria, Version 3.1 . IUCN , Gland and Cambridge .
- Kleinen , T. , Tarasov , P. , Brovkin , V. , Andreev , A. & Stebich , M. ( 2011 ) Comparison of modeled and reconstructed changes in forest cover through the past 8000 years: Eurasian perspective . The Holocene 21 , 723 – 734 .
- Koby , F.E. ( 1951 ) Le putois d'Eversmann fossile en Suisse et en France . Eclogae Geologicae Helvetiae 44 , 394 – 398 .
- Kosintsev , P. ( 2007 ) Late Pleistocene large mammal faunas from the Urals . Quaternary International 160 , 112 – 120 .
- Kosintsev , P. & Bachura , O.P. ( 2013 ) Late Pleistocene and Holocene mammal fauna of the southern Urals . Quaternary International 284 , 161 – 170 .
- Kotlík , P. , Deffontaine , V. , Mascheretti , S. , Zima , J. , Michaux , J.R. & Searle , J.B. ( 2006 ) A northern glacial refugium for bank voles ( Clethrionomys glareolus ) . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 103 , 14860 – 14864 .
- Krajcarz , M.T. , Krajcarz , M. , Goslar , T. & Nadachowski , A. ( 2015 ) The first radiocarbon dated steppe polecat ( Mustela eversmanii ) from the Pleistocene of Poland . Quaternary International 357 , 237 – 244 .
- Kuemmerle , T. , Hickler , T. , Olofsson , J. , Schurgers , G. & Radeloff , V.C. ( 2012 ) Refugee species: which historic baseline should inform conservation planning? Diversity and Distributions 18 , 1258 – 1261 .
- Kutschera , V.E. , Lecomte , N. , Janke , A. , Selva , N. , Sokolov , A.A. , Haun , T. , Steyer , K. , Nowak , C. & Hailer , F. ( 2013 ) A range-wide synthesis and timeline for phylogeographic events in the red fox ( Vulpes vulpes ) . BMC Evolutionary Biology 13 , 1 – 15 .
- Lepiksaar , J. ( 1986 ) The Holocene history of theriofauna in Fennoscandia and Baltic countries . Striae 24 , 51 – 70 .
- Litt , T. , Brauer , A. , Goslar , T. , Merkt , J. , Balaga , K. , Müller , H. , Ralska-Jasiewiczowa , M. , Stebich , M. & Negendank , J.F.W. ( 2001 ) Correlation and syncronisation of Lateglacial continental sequences in northern central Europe based on annually laminated lacustrine sediments . Quaternary Science Reviews 20 , 1233 – 1249 .
- Litt , T. , Schminke , H.U. & Kromer , B. ( 2003 ) Environmental response to climatic and volcanic events in central Eurpoe during the Weichselian Lateglacial . Quaternary Science Reviews 22 , 7 – 32 .
- Loehr , J. , Worley , K. , Grapputo , A. , Carey , J. , Veitch , A. & Coltman , D.W. ( 2006 ) Evidence for cryptic glacial refugia from North American mountain sheep mitochondrial DNA . Journal of Evolutionary Biology 19 , 419 – 430 .
- McCormick , F. ( 1999 ) Early evidence for wild animals in Ireland . In: The Holocene History of the European Vertebrate Fauna: Modern Aspects of Research (ed. N. Benecke ), pp. 355 – 372 . Verlag Marie Leidorf , Rahden .
- McDevitt , A.D. , Zub , K. , Kawałko , A. , Oliver , M.K. , Herman , J.S. & Wójcik , J.M. ( 2012 ) Climate and refugial origin influence the mitochondrial lineage distribution of weasels ( Mustela nivalis ) in a phylogeographic suture zone . Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 106 , 57 – 69 .
- Mecozzi , B. , Coppola , D. , Iurino , D.A. , Sardella , R. & De Marinis , A.M. ( 2019 ) The Late Pleistocene European badger Meles meles from Grotta Laceduzza (Brindisi, Apulia, Southern Italy): the analysis of the morphological and biometric variability . The Science of Nature 106 , 13 .
-
Mitchell-Jones , A.J.
,
Amori , G.
,
Bogdanowicz , W.
,
Kryštufek , B.
,
Reijnder , P.J.H.
,
Spitzenberger , F.
,
Stubbe , M.
,
Thissen , J.B.M.
,
Vohralik , V.
&
Zima , J.
(
1999
)
The Atlas of European Mammals
.
T. & A.D. Poyser
,
London
.
10.1111/j.1461-0248.2004.00624.x Google Scholar
- Mooney , C.Z. & Duval , R.D. ( 1993 ) Bootstrapping: a nonparametric approach to statistical inference . Sage University Paper Series on Quantative Applications in the Social Sciences , 07-095. Sage , Newbury Park .
- Mucci , N. , Arrendal , J. , Ansorge , H. , Bailey , M. , Bodner , M. , et al . ( 2010 ) Genetic diversity and landscape genetic structure of otter ( Lutra lutra ) populations in Europe . Conservation Genetics 11 , 583 – 599 .
- Münzel , S. , Langguth , K. , Conard , N. & Uerpmann , H.P. ( 2001 ) Höhlenbärenjagd auf der Schwäbischen Alb vor 30.000 Jahren . Archäologisches Korrespondenzblatt 31 , 317 – 328 .
- Normand , S. , Ricklefs , R.E. , Skov , F. , Bladt , J. , Tackenberg , O. & Svenning , J-C . ( 2011 ) Postglacial migration supplements climate in determining plant species ranges in Europe . Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 278 , 3644 – 3653 .
- Ponomarev , D. , Puzachenko , A. , Bachura , O. , Kosintsev , P. & von der Plicht , J. ( 2013 ) Mammal fauna during the Late Pleistocene and Holocene in the far northeast of Europe . Boreas 42 , 779 – 797 .
- Prost , S. , Klietmann , J. , van Kolfschoten , T. , Vrieling , K. , Stiller , M. , Nagel , D. , Rabeder , G. , Guralnick , R. , Waltari , E. , Hofreiter , M. & Sommer , R.S. ( 2013 ) Effects of Late Quaternary climate change on Palearctic shrews . Global Change Biology 19 , 1865 – 1874 .
- Renssen , H. , Seppä , H. , Heiri , O. , Roche , D.M. , Goosse , H. & Fichtfet , T. ( 2009 ) The spatial and temporal complexity of the Holocene thermal maximum . Nature Geoscience 2 , 411 – 414 .
- Roberts , N. ( 1998 ) The Holocene: An Environmental History . 2 nd edition . Blackwell , Oxford .
- Schmitt , T. & Krauss , J. ( 2004 ) Reconstruction of the colonization route from glacial refugium to the northern distribution range of the European butterfly Polyommatus coridon (Lepidoptera: Lycaenidae) . Diversity and Distributions 10 , 271 – 274 .
- Schönswetter , P. , Stehlik , I. , Holderegger , R. & Triebsch , A. ( 2005 ) Molecular evidence for glacial refugia of mountain plants in the European Alps . Molecular Ecology 14 , 3547 – 3555 .
- Sickenberg , O. ( 1968 ) Der Steppeniltis ( Mustela [Putorius] eversmanii soergeli Éhik) in der Niederterrasse der Leine und seine klimageschichtliche Bedeutung . Eiszeitalter Gegenwart 19 , 147 – 163 . (In German).
- Sommer , R.S. ( 2007 ) When East met West: the sub-fossil footprints of the west European hedgehog and the northern white-breasted hedgehog during the Late Quaternary in Europe . Journal of Zoology 271 , 82 – 89 .
-
Sommer , R.S.
(
2020
)
Late Pleistocene and Holocene history of mammals in Europe
. In:
Handbook of the Mammals of Europe
(eds
K. Hackländer
&
F.E. Zachos
), 16 pp.
Springer
,
Cham
.
10.1007/978-3-319-65038-8_3-1 Google Scholar
- Sommer , R. & Benecke , N. ( 2004 ) Late- and Post-Glacial history of the Mustelidae in Europe (Mustelidae) . Mammal Review 34 , 249 – 284 .
- Sommer , R.S. & Benecke , N. ( 2005a ) The recolonisation of Europe by brown bears Ursus arctos Linnaeus, 1758 after the Last Glacial Maximum . Mammal Review 35 , 156 – 164 .
- Sommer , R.S. & Benecke , N. ( 2005b ) Late-Pleistocene and early Holocene history of the canid fauna of Europe (Canidae) . Mammalian Biology 70 , 227 – 241 .
- Sommer , R.S. & Benecke , N. ( 2006 ) Late-Glacial and early Holocene colonisation history of felids in Europe (Felidae): a review . Journal of Zoology 269 , 7 – 20 .
- Sommer , R.S. & Nadachowski , A. ( 2006 ) Glacial refugia of mammals in Europe: evidence from fossil records . Mammal Review 36 , 251 – 266 .
- Sommer , R.S. & Zachos , F.E. ( 2009 ) Fossil evidence and phylogeography of temperate species: “glacial refugia” and postglacial recolonization . Journal of Biogeography 36 , 2013 – 2020 .
- Sommer , R.S. , Persson , A. , Wiesecke , N. & Fritz , U. ( 2007 ) Holocene recolonization and extinction history of the pond turtle, Emys orbicularis (L., 1758) in Europe . Quaternary Sciences Reviews 26 , 3099 – 3107 .
- Sommer , R.S. , Zachos , F.E. , Street , M. , Jöris , O. , Skog , A. & Benecke , N. ( 2008 ) Late Quaternary distribution dynamics and phylogeography of the red deer ( Cervus elaphus ) in Europe . Quaternary Science Reviews 27 , 714 – 733 .
- Sommer , R.S. , Fahlke , J. , Schmölcke , U. , Benecke , N. & Zachos , F.E. ( 2009a ) Quaternary history of the European roe deer ( Capreolus capreolus ) . Mammal Review 38 , 1 – 16 .
- Sommer , R.S. , Lindqvist , C. , Persson , A. , Bringsøe , H. , Rhodin , A.G.J. , Schneeweiß , N. , Široký , P. , Bachmann , L. & Fritz , U. ( 2009b ) Unexpected early extinction of the European pond turtle ( Emys orbicularis ) in Sweden and climatic impact on its Holocene range . Molecular Ecology 18 , 1252 – 1262 .
- Sommer , R.S. , Kalbe , J. , Ekström , J. , Benecke , N. & Liljegren , R. ( 2014 ) Range dynamics of the reindeer in Europe during the last 25,000 years . Journal of Biogeography 41 , 298 – 306 .
- Statham , M.J. , Edwards , C.J. , Norén , K. , Soulsbury , C.D. & Sacks , B.N. ( 2018 ) Genetic analysis of European red foxes reveals multiple distinct peripheral populations and central continental admixture . Quaternary Science Reviews 197 , 257 – 266 .
- Steffensen , J.P. , Andersen , K.K. , Bigler , M. , Clausen , H.B. , Dahl-Jensen , D. , et al . ( 2008 ) High-resolution Greenland ice core data show abrupt climate change happens in few years . Science 321 , 680 – 684 .
- Stewart , J.R. ( 2008 ) The progressive effect of the individualistic response of species to Quaternary climate change: an analysis of British mammalian faunas . Quaternary Science Reviews 27 , 2499 – 2508 .
- Stewart , J.R. , Lister , A.M. , Barnes , I. & Dalen , L. ( 2010 ) Refugia revisited: individualistic responses of species in space and time . Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 277 , 661 – 671 .
- Street , M. & Baales , M. ( 1999 ) Pleistocene/Holocene changes in the Rhineland fauna in a northwest European context . Archäologie in Eurasien 6 , 9 – 38 .
- Stuart , A.J. ( 2015 ) Late Quaternary megafaunal extinctions on the continents: a short review . Geological Journal 50 , 338 – 363 .
- Stuart , A.J. & Lister , A.M. ( 2012 ) Extinction chronology of the woolly rhinoceros Coelodonta antiquitatis in the context of late Quaternary megafaunal extinctions in northern Eurasia . Quaternary Science Reviews 51 , 1 – 17 .
- Taberlet , P. , Fumagalli , L. , Wust-Saucy , A.G. & Cosson , J.F. ( 1998 ) Comparative phylogeography and postglacial colonization routes in Europe . Molecular Ecology 7 , 453 – 464 .
- Theuerkauf , M. & Joosten , H. ( 2012 ) Younger Dryas cold stage vegetation pattern of central Europe-climate, soil and relief controls . Boreas 41 , 391 – 407 .
- Vinther , B.M. , Buchardt , S.L. , Clausen , H.B. , Dahl-Jensen , D. , Johnsen , S.J. , Fisher , D.A. , Koerner , R.M. , Raynaud , D. , Lipenkov , V. , Andersen , K.K. , Blunier , T. , Rasmussen , S.O. , Steffensen , J.P. & Svensson , A.M. ( 2009 ) Holocene thinning of the Greenland ice sheet . Nature 461 , 385 – 388 .
- von Koenigswald , W. , Müller-Beck , H. & Pressmar , E. ( 1974 ) Die Archäologie und Paläontologie in den Weinberghöhlen bei Mauern (Bayern): Grabungen 1937–1967 . Selbstverlag, Institut für Urgeschichte , Tübingen . (In German).
- Weninger , B. , Jöris , O. & Danzeglocke , U. ( 2008 ) CalPal 2007. Cologne Radiocarbon Calibration & Palaeoclimate Research Package . http://www.calpal.de . Accessed on 3 May 2014.
- Willis , K.J. & Whittaker , R.J. ( 2000 ) The refugial debate . Science 287 , 1406 – 1407 .
- Wohlfarth , B. , Veres , D. , Ampel , L. , Lacourse , T. , Blaauw , M. , et al . ( 2008 ) Rapid ecosystem response to abrupt climate changes during the last glacial period in Western Europe, 40–16 kyr BP . Geology 36 , 407 – 410 .
- Yalden , D.W. 1999 . The History of British Mammals . T. & A.D. Poyser , London .