Estimates of Improved Productivity and Health from Better Indoor Environments
William J. Fisk
Indoor Environment Program, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, e-mail: [email protected]
Search for more papers by this authorArthur H. Rosenfeld
Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, U.S. Department of Energy
Search for more papers by this authorWilliam J. Fisk
Indoor Environment Program, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, e-mail: [email protected]
Search for more papers by this authorArthur H. Rosenfeld
Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, U.S. Department of Energy
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Abstract The existing literature contains strong evidence that characteristics of buildings and indoor environments significantly influence rates of respiratory disease, allergy and asthma symptoms, sick building symptoms, and worker performance. Theoretical considerations, and limited empirical data, suggest that existing technologies and procedures can improve indoor environments in a manner that significantly increases health and productivity. At present, we can develop only crude estimates of the magnitude of productivity gains that may be obtained by providing better indoor environments; however, the projected gains are very large. For the U.S., we estimate potential annual savings and productivity gains of $6 billion to $19 billion from reduced respiratory disease; $1 billion to $4 billion from reduced allergies and asthma, $10 billion to $20 billion from reduced sick building syndrome symptoms, and $12 billion to $125 billion from direct improvements in worker performance that are unrelated to health. Sample calculations indicate that the potential financial benefits of improving indoor environments exceed costs by a factor of 18 to 47. The policy implications of the findings are discussed and include a recommendation for additional research.
References
- Antonicelli, L., Bilo, M.B., Pucci, S., Schou, C. and Bonifazi, F. (1991) “Efficacy of an air-cleaning device equipped with a high efficiency particulate air filter in house dust mite respiratory allergy”, Allergy, 46, 594–600.
- Arshad, S.H., Matthews, S., Gant, C. and Hide, D.W. (1992) “Effect of allergen avoidance on development of allergic disorders in infancy”, The Lancet, 339(8809), 1493–1497.
- ASHRAE (1989) ASHRAE Standard 62-1989 Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality, Atlanta , GA , American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air Conditioning Engineers, Inc.
- Berman, S.M. (1992) “Energy efficiency consequences of scotopic sensitivity”, Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society, 21(1), 3–14.
- Berman, S.M., Fein, G., Jewett, D.L. and Ashford, F. (1993) “Luminance-controlled pupil size affects Landolt C test performance”, Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society, 22(2), 150–165
- Berman, S.M., Fein, G., Jewett, D.L. and Ashford, F. (1994) “Landolt C recognition in elderly subjects is affected by scotopic intensity of surrounding illuminants”, Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society, 23(2), 123–128.
- Boray, P.P., Gifford, R. and Rosenblood, L. (1989) “Effects of warm white, cool white, and full-spectrum fluorescent lighting on simple cognitive performance, mood and ratings of others”, Journal of Environmental Psychology, 9: 297–308.
- Brundage, J.R., Scott, R.M., Lednar, W.M., Smith, D.W. and Miller, R.N. (1988) “Building-associated risk of febrile acute respiratory diseases in army trainees”, Journal of the American Medical Association, 259(14), 2108–2112.
- Brunekreef, B. (1992) “Damp housing and adult respiratory symptoms”, Allergy, 47, 498–502.
- Clear, R. and Berman, S.M. (1993) “Economics and lighting level recommendations”, Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society, 22(2), 77–86.
- Committee on Health Effects of Indoor Allergens (1993) Indoor Allergens: Assessing and Controlling Adverse Health Effects. In: A.M. Pope, R. Patterson, and H. Burge (eds). Washington , D.C. , National Academy Press.
- Couch, R.B. (1981) “Viruses and indoor air pollution”; Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine, 57(1), 907–921.
- Couch, R.B., Cate, T.R., Douglas, R.G., Gerone, P.J. and Knight, V. (1966) “Effect of route of inoculation on experimental respiratory viral disease in volunteers and evidence for airborne transmission”, Bacteriological Reviews, 30(3), 517–529.
- Dales, R.E. Burnett, R. and Zwanenburg, H. (1991) “Adverse health effects among adults exposed to home dampness and molds”, American Review of Respiratory Disease, 143, 505–509.
- Dick, E.G., Jennings, L.C., Mink, K.A., Wartgow, C.D. and Inhorn, S.L. (1987) “Aerosol transmission of rhinovirus colds”, The Journal of Infectious Diseases, 156(3), 442–448.
- Division of Respiratory Disease Studies, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (1984), “Outbreaks of respiratory illness among employees in large office buildings - Tennessee, District of Columbia”, MMWR, 33(36), 506–513.
- Dixon, R.E. (1985) “Economic costs of respiratory tract infections in the United States”, American Journal of Medicine 78(6B), 45–51.
- EIA (1995) Annual Energy Review 1994, Energy Information Administration, U.S. Department of Energy.
- Eto, J. and Meyer, C. (1988) “The HVAC costs of increased fresh air ventilation rates in office buildings”, ASHRAE Transactions, 94, Pt 2, 331–340.
- Eto, J. (1990) “The HVAC costs of increased fresh air ventilation rates in office buildings, Part 2”. In D.S. Walkinshaw (ed.) Proceedings of Indoor Air '90, Ottawa , Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, Vol. 4, pp. 53–58.
- Evans, D., Levison, M.J., Feldman, C.H. Clark, W.M., Wasilewski, Y., Levin, B. and Mellins, R.B. (1987) “The impact of passive smoking on emergency room visits of urban children with asthma”, American Review of Respiratory Disease, 135(3), 567–572.
-
Fisk, W.J.,
Mendell, M.J.,
Daisey, J.M.,
Faulkner, D.,
Hodgson, A.T.,
Nematollahi, M. and
Macher, J.M. (1993) “Phase 1 of the California healthy building study: a summary”, Indoor Air, 3, 246–254.
10.1111/j.1600-0668.1993.00005.x Google Scholar
- Garibaldi, R.A. (1985) “Epidemiology of community-acquired respiratory tract infections in adults, incidence, etiology, and impact”, American Journal of Medicine, 78(6B), 32–37.
- Gwaltney, J.M. and Hendley, J.O. (1982) “Transmission of experimental rhinovirus infection by contaminated surfaces”, American Journal of Epidemiology, 116(5), 828–833.
- Gwaltney, J.M., Moskalski, P.B. and Hendley, J.O. (1978) “Hand-to-hand transmission of rhinovirus colds”, Annals of Internal Medicine 88, 463–467
- Harving, H., Hansen, L.G., Korsgaard, J., Nielsen, P.A., Olsen, O.F., Romer, J., Svendsen, U.G. and Osterballe, O. (1991) “House dust mite allergy and anti-mite measures in the indoor environment”, Allergy, 46 (supplement 11), 33–38.
- Hedge, A., Sims, W.R. and Becker, F.D. (1995) “Effects of lens-ed-indirect and parabolic lighting in satisfaction, visual health, and productivity of office workers”, Ergonomics, 38(2), 260–280.
- Hoge, C.W. Reichler, M.R., Dominguez, E.A. Bremer, J.C., Mastro, T.D., Hendricks, K.A., Mushev, D.M. Elliott, J.A. Facklam, R.R. and Breiman, R.F. (1994) “An epidemic of pneumococcal disease in an overcrowded, inadequately ventilated jail”, New England Journal of Medicine, 331(10), 643–648.
- Ingram, J.M. and Heymann P.W. (1993) “Environmental controls in the management of asthma”, Asthma: Current Concepts in Management, 13(14), 785–801.
- Jaakkola, J.J.K. and Heinonen, O.P. (1993) “Shared office space and the risk of the common cold”, European Journal of Epidemiology, 11(2), 213–216.
- Jennings, L.C. and Dick, E.G. (1987) “Transmission and control of rhinovirus colds”, European Journal of Epidemiology, 3(4), 327–335.
- Katzev, R. (1992) “The impact of energy-efficient office lighting strategies on employee satisfaction and productivity”, Environment and Behavior, 24(6), 759–778.
- Knight, V. (1980) “Viruses as agents of airborne contagion”, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 353, 147–156.
- Kroner, W.M. and Stark-Martin, J.A. (1992) “ Environmentally responsive workstations and office worker productivity”. In: H. Levin (ed.) Proceedings of Indoor Environment and Productivity, Atlanta , GA , American Society Heating Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers.
- McMenamin, P. (1995) “ The economic toll of allergic rhinitis and associated airway diseases”. In: S.L. Spector (ed.) The Chronic Airway Disease Connection; Redefining Rhinitis, Little Falls , NJ , Health Learning Services.
- Meese, G.B., Kok, R., Lewis, M.I. and Wyon, D.P. (1982) “Effects of moderate cold and heat stress on factory workers in Southern Africa. 2, skill and performance in the cold”, South African Journal of Science, 78, 189–197.
-
Mendell, M.J. (1993) “Non-specific symptoms in office workers: a review and summary of the epidemiologic literature”, Indoor Air, 3, 227–236.
10.1111/j.1600-0668.1993.00003.x Google Scholar
- Mudarri, D.H. and Hall, J.D. (1993) “ Increasing outdoor air flow rates in existing buildings”. In: Proceedings of Indoor Air'93, Helsinki , 6th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, Vol. 5, pp. 21–26.
- Mudarri, D.H. and Hall, J.D. (1996) “ Energy cost and IAQ performance of ventilation systems and controls”. In: Proceedings of IAQ'96, Atlanta , GA , American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, pp. 151–160.
- Nardell, E.A., Keegan, J., Cheney, S.A. and Etkind, S.C. (1991) “Theoretical limits of protection achievable by building ventilation”, American Review of Respiratory Diseases, 144, 302–306.
- Nelson, H.S., Hirsch, S.R., Ohman, J.L., Platts-Mills, T.A.E., Reed, C.E. and Solomon, W.R. (1988) “Recommendations for the use of residential air-cleaning devices in the treatment of allergic respiratory diseases”, Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 82, 661–669.
- Nelson, N.A., Kaufman, J.D., Burt, J. and Karr, C. (1995) “Health symptoms and the work environment in four non-problem United States office buildings”, Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health, 21(1), 51–59.
- NEMA (1989) Lighting and Human Performance, a Review, Washington , D.C. , National Electrical Manufacturers Association.
- New York State Commission on Ventilation (1923) “ The prevalence of respiratory diseases among children in schoolrooms ventilated by various methods”, Chapter XXIII in Ventilation: Report of the New York State Commission on Ventilation, New York , E.P. Dutton & Co.
- Nunes, E, Menzies, R., Tamblyn, R.M., Boehm, E. and Letz, R. (1993) “ The effect of varying level of outside air supply on neurobehavioral performance function during a study of sick building syndrome”. In: Proceedings of Indoor Air'93, Helsinki , 6th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, Vol. 1, pp. 53–58.
- Pepler, R.D. and Warner, R.E. (1968) “Temperature and learning: an experimental study”, ASHRAE Transactions, 74, Pt 2, 211–219.
- Pollart, S.M., Chapman, M.D. and Platts-Mills, T.A.E. (1987) “House dust sensitivity and environmental control”, Primary Care, 14(3), 591–603.
- Preller, L., Zweers, T., Brunekreef, B. and Boleij, J.S.M. (1990) “ Sick leave due to work-related complaints among workers in the Netherlands”. In: D.S. Walkinshaw (ed.) Proceedings of Indoor Air '90, Ottawa , Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, Vol. 1, pp. 227–230.
- Raw, G.J., Roys, M.S. and Leaman, A. (1990) “ Further finding from the office environment survey: productivity”. In: D.S. Walkinshaw (ed.) Proceedings of Indoor Air '90, Ottawa , Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, Vol. 1, pp. 231–236.
- Richards, A.L., Hyams, K.C., Watts, D.M., Rozmajzl, P.J., Woody, J.N. and Merrell, B.R. (1993) “Respiratory disease among military personnel in Saudia Arabia during Operation Desert Shield”, American Journal of Public Health, 83(9), 1326–1329.
- Romm, J.J. (1994) Lean and Clean Management, New York , Kodansha America, Inc.
- Sattar, S.A. and Ijaz, M.K. (1987) “Spread of viral infections by aerosols”, CRC Critical Reviews in Environmental Control, 17(2), 89–131.
- Smedje, G., Norback, D., Wessen, B. and Edling, C. (1996) “ Asthma among school employees in relation to the school environment”. In: S. Yoshizawa, K. Kimura, K. Ikeda, S. Tanabe, Iwata. (eds) Proceedings of Indoor Air'96, Nagoya , 7th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, Vol. 1, pp. 611–616
- Smith, S.W. and Rea, M.S. (1979) “Proofreading under different levels of illumination”, Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society, 8(1), 47–78.
- Smith, S.W. and Rea, M.S. (1982) “Performance of a reading test under different levels of illumination”, Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society, 12(1), 29–33.
- Spengler, J., Neas, L., Nakai, S., Dockery, D., Speizer, F., Ware, J. and Raizenne, M. (1993) “ Respiratory symptoms and housing characteristics”. In: Proceedings of Indoor Air'93, Helsinki , 6th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, Vol. 1, pp. 165–170.
-
Steele, T. and
Brown, M. (1990) ASHRAE Standard 62-1989: Energy, Cost, and Program Implications, DOE/BP-1657,
Portland
OR
, Bonneville Power Administration.
10.2172/5209141 Google Scholar
-
Sundell, J. (1994) “On the association between building ventilation characteristics, some indoor environmental exposures, some allergic manifestations, and subjective symptom reports”, Indoor Air (Supplement 2/94).
10.1111/j.1600-0668.1994.tb00031.x Google Scholar
- Tinker, M.A. (1952) “The effect of intensity of illumination upon speed of reading six-point italic type”, The American Journal of Psychology, 65(4), 600–602.
- Traynor, G.W., Talbott, J.M. and Moses, D.O. (1993) “ The role of the U.S. Department of Energy in indoor air quality and building ventilation policy development”. In: Proceedings of Indoor Air'93, Helsinki , 6th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, Vol. 3, pp. 595–600.
- U.S. Department of Commerce (1995) Statistical Abstract of the United States, 1995.
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (1989) Report to Congress on Indoor Air Quality, Volume II: Assessment and Control of Indoor Air Pollution, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Air and Radiation, EPA/400/1-89?/001C).
- U.S Department of Health and Human Services (1994) Vital and Health Statistics, Current Estimates from the National Health Interview Survey, series 10: data from the National Health Survey No. 189. (DHHS Publication No. 94–1517).
- Veitch, J.A. (1990) “Office noise and illumination effects on reading comprehension”, Journal of Environmental Psychology, 10, 209–217.
- Veitch, J.A., Gifford, R. and Hine, D.W. (1991) “Demand characteristics and full spectrum lighting effects on performance and mood”, Journal of Environmental Psychology, 11, 87–95.
- Ventresca, J.A. (1991) “ Operations and maintenance for indoor air quality: implications from energy simulations of increased ventilation”. In: Proceedings of IAQ'91, Atlanta , GA , American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, pp. 375–378.
- Warshauer, D.M., Dick, E.C., Mandel, A.D., Flynn, T.C. and Jerde, R.S. (1989) “Rhinovirus infections in an isolated Antarctic station, transmission of the viruses and susceptibility of the population”, American Journal of Epidemiology, 129(2), 319–340.
- Weiss, K.B., Gergen, P.J. and Hodgson, T.A. (1992) “An economic evaluation of asthma in the United States”, New England Journal of Medicine, 326(13), 862–866.
- Woods, J.E. (1989) “Cost avoidance and productivity in owning and operating buildings”, Occupational Medicine, 4(4), 753–770.
- Woods, J.E., Drewry, G.M. and Morey, P.R. (1987) “ Office worker perceptions of indoor air quality effects on discomfort and performance”. In: B. Seifert, H. Esdorn, M. Fischer, H. Ruden and J. Wegner (eds) Proceedings of Indoor Air '87, Berlin , (West), Institute of Water, Soil and Air Hygiene, Vol. 2, pp. 464–468.
- Wright, R.N. and Rosenfeld, A.H. (1996) Improved Productivity and Health from Better Indoor Environments: a Research Initiative - $7 million for FY 1998, Washington , DC , Subcommittee on Construction and Building, National Science and Technology Council.
- Wyon, D. P. (1974) “The effects of moderate heat stress on typewriting performance”, Ergonomics, 17(3), 309–318.
- Wyon, D.P. (1976) “ Assessing the effects of moderate heat and cold stress on human efficiency”. In: Proceedings of the Symposium: Factories for Profit - Environmental Design, Pretoria , South Africa , National Building Research Institute, (Paper No. 6).
- Wyon, D.P., Andersen, I.B. and Lundqvist, G.R. (1979) “The effects of moderate heat stress on mental performance Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health, 5, 352–361.
- Wyon, D. P. (1993) “ Healthy buildings and their impact of productivity”. In: Proceedings of Indoor Air '93, Helsinki , 6th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, Vol. 6, pp. 3–13.
- Wyon, D.P. (1996) “ Individual microclimate control: require range, probable benefits, and current feasibility”. In: S. Yoshzawa, K. Kimura, K. Ikeda, S. Tanabe, T. Iwata (eds. Proceedings of Indoor Air '96, Nagoya , 7th International Conference of Indoor Air Quality and climate, Vol. 1, pp. 1067–1072.