A REASSESSMENT OF THE DISTRIBUTION OF MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS
Part One
Corresponding Author
John F. Kurtzke
Departments of Neurology and Community Medicine, Georgetown University School of Medicine, and Neurology Service, Veterans Administration Hospital, Washington, D. C.
J. F. Kurtzke, M.D. Neurology Service, Veterans Adm. Hospital, Washington, D.C. 20422, USASearch for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
John F. Kurtzke
Departments of Neurology and Community Medicine, Georgetown University School of Medicine, and Neurology Service, Veterans Administration Hospital, Washington, D. C.
J. F. Kurtzke, M.D. Neurology Service, Veterans Adm. Hospital, Washington, D.C. 20422, USASearch for more papers by this authorABSTRACT
When reviewed some 10 years ago, available prevalence studies of multiple sclerosis (MS) seemed to divide the world into three frequency zones for MS: high prevalence at 30 to 60 per 100,000 population; medium at 5 to 15; and low at less than 5 per 100,000. In the last decade the number of the available studies has more than tripled. Their reassessment, including judgments of comparability, still indicates a high-medium-low division for MS frequency world-wide. The high risk areas comprise northern Europe, northern United States, much of southern Canada, New Zealand, and probably southern Australia. Prevalence rates in these regions are mostly 30 to 80 per 100,000 population, centering at about $50. Medium frequency is defined as prevalence of 5 to 25, and is mostly 10 to 15. In Europe, the medium frequency zone bounds that of high frequency to the north, east, and south. The European Mediterranean basin is of medium prevalence with a sharp division from the high zone across France and Switzerland. It is likely that this division continues eastward across Austria, north of Hungary, and across the upper Ukraine to the Caspian Sea, but this is not definite. Medium risk areas of Europe thus include surveyed sites of Spain, Italy, Hungary, Jugoslavia, Bulgaria, and central Ukraine, together with southeastern France and southern Switzerland. Though Romania could be high, it is more likely to be of medium prevalence. Turkey measures low, but from incomplete data. From nationwide prevalence and mortality studies, the west coast of Norway and all Scandinavia above latitude 65° north are of medium frequency. Based on hospital data, northwestern USSR is high, and central and southern USSR medium, in MS risk. Other medium risk areas include southern United States, most of Australia, one ethnic group only in South Africa, and possibly Hawaii. Low risk areas are all surveyed sites of Asia, the Pacific islands, Africa, Latin America, Alaska, and Greenland.
References
- Allison, R. S. 1963: Some neurological aspects of medical geography. Proc. roy. Soc. Med. 56, 71–76.
- Allison, R. S, &, J. H. D. Millar 1954: Prevalence and familial incidence of disseminated sclerosis (A Report to the Northern Ireland Hospitals Authority on the Results of a Three-Year Survey). Prevalence of disseminated sclerosis in Northern Ireland. Ulster med. J. 23, (Suppl. No. 2), 5–27.
- Alter, M., L. Harpern, L. T. Kurland, B. Bornstein, P Tikva, U Leibowitz, &, J Silberstein 1962: Multiple sclerosis in Israel. Prevalence among immigrants and native inhabitants. Arch. Neurol. (Chic.) 7, 253–263.
- Alter, M., M Okihoro, W Rowley, &, T Morris 1971: Multiple sclerosis among Orientals and caucasians in Hawaii. Neurology (Minneap.) 21, 122–130.
- l'Association Française des Sclérosés en Plaques 1967: Une enquête sur la sclérose en plaques en France. Rev. Prat. (Paris) 17, 9–10.
- Bammer, H. 1960: Felduntersuchungen über die Verbreitung der Multiplen Sklerose im Spessart und dem benachbarten Siedlungsraum. Münch. med. Wschr. 102, 1115–1119.
- Bammer, H. 1973: Personal communication.
- Barlow, J. S. 1967: Multiple sclerosis in North Korea and China. Neurology (Minneap.) 17, 802–817.
- Behrend, R. Ch 1969a: A basis for discussion of an MS epidemiological research program in Europe. Ninth International Congress of Neurology, New York . Excerpta Med. Intl. Congress series No. 193, p. 188.
- Behrend, R. Ch 1969b: Multiple sclerosis in Europe. Europ. Neurol. 2, 129–145.
- Behrend, R. Ch 1973: Personal communication.
- Behrend, R. Ch., A. Suhr, J. Rouch, &, J. Roger 1963: Étude statistique sur la sclérose en plaques á Marseille. Rev. neurol. 109, 630–634.
- Bharucha, E. P, &, R. M. Umarji 1961: Disseminated sclerosis in India. Int. J. Neurol. (Montevideo) 2, 182–188.
- Bird, A. V, &, J. E. Kerrich 1969: Multiple sclerosis in South Africa. S. Afr. med. J. 43, 1031–1033.
- Breland, A. E. Jr, &, R. D. Currier 1967: Multiple sclerosis and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis in Mississippi. Neurology (Minneap.) 17, 1011–1016.
- Briskman, A. M. 1969: Rasseiannyi skleroz v Cherkasskoi oblasti [disseminated sclerosis in Cherkasian regions]. Vrach. Delo. 12, 126–127.
- Brody, J. A. 1973: Personal communication.
-
Broman, T.
1960: Multiple sclerosis frequency in Göteborg.
Acta psychiat. neurol. scand. 35 (Suppl. 147), 23–27.
10.1111/j.1600-0447.1960.tb08658.x Google Scholar
- Broman, T., L Bergmann, O Andersen, &, A. M Lindberg-Broman 1972: Multiple sclerosis in Gothenburg. An intensive study during a 20-year period. Progress in Multiple Sclerosis. Research and Treatment, ed. U. Leibowiz, pp. 186–195. Academic Press, New York .
- Caruso, G., A. Uras, &, A Coni 1968: La sclerosi a placche in Sardegna: Sua prevalenza e distribuzione in rapporto alle variazioni altimetriche del suolo. Acta neurol. (Napoli) 23, 381–392.
- Cendrowski, W. S. 1964: Ethnic aspects of multiple sclerosis in Central and Northern Poland. J. neurol. Sci. 1, 390–393.
- Cendrowski, W. S. 1965: Multiple sclerosis in a small urban community in central Poland. J. neurol. Sci. 2, 82–86.
- Cendrowski, W., M. Wender, W. Dominik, Z. Flejsierowicz, M. Owsianowski, &, M Popiel 1969: Epidemiological study of multiple sclerosis in western Poland. Europ. Neurol. 2, 90–108.
- Collard, M, &, F. Boegly 1967: Enquête × Sclérose en plaques × (Aspect fonctionnel) Bas-Rhin-1955–1965. Strasbourg méd. 4, 423–426.
- Collomb, H., M Dumas, P. -L Girard, &, I. -P N'Diaye 1971: Neurologie au Sénégal (bilan de 10 années). Bull. Soc. méd. Afr. noire Langue franç. 16, 575–580.
- Cosnett, J. E. 1964: Neurological disorders in the Zulu. Neurology (Minneap.) 14, 443–454.
- Cruickshank, E. K., R. D. Montgomery, &, J. D Spillane 1961: Obscure neurologic disorders in Jamaica. Wld. Neurol. 2, 199–211.
- Dahl, S. 1971: Über das Auftreten der multiplen Sklerose (MS; Sclerosis disseminata) in verschiedenen Altersstufen. Z. Alternsforsch. 24, 333–342.
- Datta, D. V. 1960: Disseminated sclerosis. Indian Practit. 473–476.
- Deacon, W. E., L Alexander, H. D Siedler, &, L. T Kurland 1959: Multiple sclerosis in a small New England community. New Engl. J. Med. 261, 1059–1061.
- Dean, G. 1949: Disseminated sclerosis in South Africa Its relationship to sway-back disease and suggested treatment. Brit. med. J. 1, 842–845.
- Dean, G. 1967: Annual incidence, prevalence, and mortality of multiple sclerosis in White South-African-born and in White immigrants to South Africa. Brit. med. J. 2, 724–730.
- Dean, G. 1973: Personal communication.
- Dominguez Carmona, M 1961: Esclerosis en placas. Epidemiologia en España. Rev. Sanid. Hig. públ. (Madr.) 35, 113–127.
- Duma, D, &, M. Morariu 1970: Multiple sclerosis in Cluj. Prevalence, geographical and clinical considerations. Rev. Roum. Neurol. 7, 143–151.
- Eastman, R., J. Sheridan, &, D. C Poskanzer 1973: Multiple sclerosis clustering in a small Massachusetts community, with possible common exposure 23 years before onset. New Engl. J. Med. 289, 793–794.
- Fisher, R. A, &, F. Yates 1963: Statistical Tables for Biological, Agricultural and Medical Research, Sixth Ed., Rev. Hafner Publ. Co., New York .
- Foster, R. M, &, J. R. Harrics 1970: Multiple sclerosis in the African. Brit. med. J. 3, 628.
- Grashchenkov, N. I., B. M Hekht, A. B Rogover, &, A. M Vern 1960: Characteristics of the geographical distribution of disseminated sclerosis in the Soviet Union. Acta psychiat. neurol. scand. 35, (Suppl. 147), 148–158.
- Gudmundsson, K. R. 1971: Clinical studies of multiple sclerosis in Iceland. A follow-up of previous survey and reappraisal. Acta neurol. scand. 47, (Suppl. 48), 1–78.
- Hall, P. 1961: Neurologic studies in Ethiopia. Wld. Neurol. 2, 731–739.
- Hargreaves, E. R. 1969: Epidemiological studies in Cornwall. Proc. roy. Soc. Med. 54, 209–216.
- Hung, T. 1970: [Multiple sclerosis in Taiwan]. Clin. neurol. (Tokyo) 10, 33–35.
- Hyllested, K. 1956: Disseminated Sclerosis in Denmark. Prevalence and Geographical Distribution, pp. 141 plus atlas. J. Jørgensen & Co., Copenhagen .
- Hyllested, K. 1960: Discussion on correlation of the geographic distribution of multiple sclerosis with cosmic-ray intensities. Acta psychiat. neurol. scand. 35 (Suppl. 147), 130.
- Iwanowski, W. 1963: Zur Epidemiologie der Multiplen Sklerose (M. S.). Nach Untersuchungen in Berlin. Oeff. Gesundh. -Dienst 25, 262–270.
- Kahana, E, &, M. Alter 1973: Personal communication.
- Khodos, Kh. G 1960: K geographii rasseiannogo sklerosa [The geography of multiple sclerosis]. Zh. Nevropat. Psikhiat. 60, 1435–1443.
- Klein, F, &, K. H. Parnitzke 1963: Geomedizinische Untersuchungen über dic Verbreitung der Multiplen Sklerose in Siedlungsraum um Magdeburg. Dtsch. Gesundh. -Wes. 18, 1677–1682.
- Koch, M. J., D Reed, R Stern, &, J. A Brody 1974: Multiple sclerosis. A cluster in a small northwestern United States community. J. amer. med. Ass. 228, 1555–1557.
- Kreindler, A., C Roşianu, C Bǎlǎceanu, &, E Bicesu 1968: Aspecte epidemiologice ale sclerozei în plǎci [Epidemiology of multiple sclerosis]. Neurologia (Buc.) 13, 481–491.
- Kurland, L. T. 1970: The epidemiologic characteristics of multiple sclerosis. Multiple Sclerosis and Other Demyelinating Diseases, ed. P. J. Vinken, &, G. W. Bruyn, pp. 63–84. North Holland Publ. Co., Amsterdam .
- Kuroiwa, Y, &, M. M. Okihiro 1969: Multiple sclerosis in Hawaii. A preliminary report. Hawaii med. J. 28, 374–376.
- Kurtzke, J. F. 1964: General features of the prevalence of multiple sclerosis. J. Indian. med. Prof. 11, 4896–4901, 4895.
- Kurtzke, J. F. 1966: On statistical testing of prevalence studies. J. chron. Dis. 19, 909–922.
- Kurtzke, J. F. (in press): An overview of the epidemiology of multiple sclerosis. Symposium on the Aetiology and Pathogenesis of Demyelinating Diseases, Kyoto, Japan.
- Kurtzke, J. F, &, Q. H. Bui 1974: Multiple sclerosis in a migrant population. 1. Hospital data. Europ. Neurol. 12, 1–12.
- Kurtzke, J. F., G. Dean, &, D. P. J Botha 1970: A method for estimating the age at immigration of White immigrants to South Africa, with an example of its importance. S. Afr. med. J. 44, 663–669.
- Kurtzke, J. F., C. S. Park, &, S. J Oh 1968: Multiple sclerosis in Korea. Clinical features and prevalence. J. neurol. Sci. 6, 463–481.
- Laha, P. N, &, B. S. Johri 1961: Disseminated sclerosis (A study on sixteen cases). Int. J. Neurol. (Montevideo) 2, 263–270.
- Landy, P. J. 1963: Some aspects of disseminated sclerosis in Queensland. Proc. Aust. Ass. Neurol. 1, 23–26.
- Leibowitz, U., E. Kahana, &, M Alter 1972: Population studies of multiple sclerosis in Israel. Multiple Sclerosis. Progress in Research, eds. E. J. Field, T. M. Bell, &, P. R. Carnegie, pp. 179–196. North-Holland Publ. Co., Amsterdam .
- Lemercier, G., R Virieu, M Dumas, &, H Collomb 1970: Sclérose en plaques au Sénégal. Acta neurol. belg. 70, 309–332.
- Lyons, J. B. 1970: Multiple sclerosis in Ireland. Irish J. med. Sci. 3, 153–162.
- Mapelli, G. 1963: Su di alcuni aspetti geomedici della sclerosi a placche nella Sardegna centro-settentrionale. Riv. Pat. Nerv. Ment. 83, 253–275.
- Mathew, N. T., K. V Mathai, J Abraham, &, G. M Taori 1971: Incidence and pattern of demyelinating disease in India. J. neurol. Sci. 13, 27–38.
- Meunier-Raccaud, M. -Th 1967: La sclérose en plaques en France. Inter-Chefs No. 297, pp. 13–16.
- Millar, J. H. D. 1972: Prevalence of multiple sclerosis in the population of Norther Ireland. International Symposium on Multiple Sclerosis, Göteborg , Sweden .
- Miskolczy, D., K Csiky, P Waitsuk, &, Cs. R Wagner 1962: [The occurrence and forms of appearance of multiple sclerosis at the Tîrgu-Mures clinic of Neurology over a period of 17 years]. Orv. Szle. 8, 134.
- Montanini, R., G. Invernizzi, &, G Escalar 1967: Ricerca epidemiologica sulla Sclerosi Multipla in provincia di Varese. Atti Conv. Int. Sclerosi Multipla, Gallarate 1966, pp. 475–482. La Tipografica Varese, Varese .
- Morariu, M. 1974: Personal communication.
- Morariu, M., M. Alter, &, M Harshe 1974: Multiple sclerosis in Transylvania: A zone of transition in frequency. Neurology (Minneap.) 24, 673–679.
- Moya, G., S. Julian Ramo, &, L Martinez Fuertes 1966: Estudios de neurologia social (Los problemas económíco-sociales en la esclerosis multiple). Rev. Sanid. Hig. pübl. (Madr.) 40, 248–285.
- Mutlu, N. 1954: Multiple sclerosis in Turkey. Etiologic and symptomatologic study of four hundred ten cases. Arch. neurol. psychiat. (Chic.) 71, 511–516.
- Mutlu, M. 1960: The effect of geographical and meteorological factors on incidence of multiple sclerosis in Turkey. Actat psychiat. neurol. scand. 35 (Suppl. 147), 47–54.
- Neme, M. 1956: Estructuracion de Una Enfermedad Neuraxitis - Esclerosis Multiple, pp. 189. Institute of Neurology Investigation, Buenos Aires .
- Oliveras de la Riva, C., J. M. Aragonés Ollé, &, J. Mercadé Sobrequés 1968: Estudio de la incidencia relativa y absolutu de la esclerosis múltiple en nuestra region. An. Med. Cir. (Barcelona) 54, 13.
- Oliveras de la Riva, C 1974: Personal communication.
- Peacock, P. B., F. Schilchter, &, S. C Little 1969: The epidemiology of multiple sclerosis with particular reference to Alabama. Ala. J. med. Sci. 6, 247–258.
- Pernov, K. 1957: [On the distribution and clinical form of multiple sclerosis in the Korean Peoples' Democratic Republic (KPDR)]. Suvr. Med. 8, 55.transl.: J. S. Barlow, Neurology (Minneap.) 21, 353, 1971).
- Ray, R., M. Balmuth, &, F. L Drew 1970: Multiple sclerosis prevalence and mortality in Allegheny County for 1965 and 1966. Amer. J. Publ. Hlth. 60, 2321–2330.
- Rinne, U. K., M. Panelius, E. Kivalo, E. Hokkanen, &, T Meurman 1968: Multiple sclerosis in Finland. Further studies on its distribution and prevalence. Acta neurol. scand. 44, 631–642.
- Saar, Kh. P 1962: Rasseiannyi skleroz v Estonskoi SSR [multiple sclerosis in Estonian SSR]. Vop. Klin. Nevrol. Psikhiat. 2, 69–78.
- Sathe, R. V. 1955: Paraplegia. An analysis of cases at the J. J. Group of hospitals, Bombay, between 1950–1952. J. Ass. Phycns. India 3, 158–162.
- Schumacher, G. A., G. Beebe, R. F. Kibler, L. T. Kurland, J. F. Kurtzke, F. McDowell, B. Nagler, W. A Sibley, W. W Tourtellotte, &, T. L Willmon 1965: Problems of experimental trials of therapy in multiple sclerosis: Report by the panel on the evaluation of experimental trials of therapy in multiple sclerosis. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 122, 552–568.
- Shaby, J. A. 1958: Multiple sclerosis in Iraq. Wien. Z. Nervenheilk. 15, 276–283.
- Spota, B. B, &, Diego Brage 1951: Posición actual en que colocamos a la esclerosis múltiple. Pren. méd. argent. 38, 772–776.
- Stazio, A, &, L. T. Kurland 1962: Multiple sclerosis: its frequency and distribution with special reference to Washington D. C. Neurology (Minneap.) 12, 445–452.
- Steiner, G. 1952: Environmental studies in multiple sclerosis. Neurology (Minneap.) 2, 260–262.
- Sutherland, J. M. 1956: Observations on the prevalence of multiple sclerosis in northern Scotland. Brain 79, 635–654.
- Sutherland, J. M., J. H. Tyrer, &, M. J Eadie 1962: The prevalence of multiple sclerosis in Australia. Brain 85, 149–164.
- Swank, R. L., O Lerstad, A Strøm, &, J Backer 1952: Multiple sclerosis in rural Norway. Its geographic and occupational incidence in relation to nutrition. New Engl. J. Med. 246, 721–728.
- Szego, G, &, R. McD. Anderson 1965: Disseminated sclerosis in Melbourne. Med. J. Aust. 1, 303–305.
- Thiébaut, F., F Rohmer, M Collard, &, F Boegly 1969: A propos d'une enquête sur la S.E.P. (Bas-Rhin 1955–1965). Fréquence et aspects fonctionnels. Rev. Otoneuro-ophtal. 41, 366–368.
- Thong, N. N. 1965: Contribution à l'étude de la sclérose en plaques au Viet-Nam (à propos de deux cas observéà la clinique médicale de Cho-Ray Département de Neurologie du Professeur Agrégé Bui Quoc Huong), pp. 129. Thèse, Univ. Saigon No. 563/42.
- Verhaart, W. J. C. 1951: Multiple and diffuse Sclerosis and related demyelinating diseases in Indonesia. Folia psychiat. neurol. neurochir. neerl. 54, 281–294.
- Westlund, K. 1970: Distribution and mortality time trend of multiple sclerosis and some other diseases in Norway. Acta neurol. scand. 46, 455–483.
- White, D. N, &, L. Wheelan 1959: Disseminated sclerosis. A survey of patients in the Kingston, Ontario area. Neurology (Minneap.) 9, 256–272.