Discharge communications between hospital and community health care staff: a selective review
Corresponding Author
S. J. Closs BSc
School of Health, University of Hull, UK
S.J. Closs Senior Lecturer in Nursing Research School of Health University of Hull Hull HU6 7RX UKSearch for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
S. J. Closs BSc
School of Health, University of Hull, UK
S.J. Closs Senior Lecturer in Nursing Research School of Health University of Hull Hull HU6 7RX UKSearch for more papers by this authorAbstract
The rate of turnover of NHS hospital patients is rising, while lengths of stay are becoming shorter. This means that newly discharged patients are increasingly dependent and many are in need of carefully planned and immediate care in the community. The appropriate provision of such care requires effective communications across the hospital-community interface. This review was undertaken in order to determine the current research base for effective discharge information exchange across the primary—secondary interface. It examines six aspects of communications between nursing and medical staff based in the hospital and the community. These include the timing of dispatch and receipt of discharge information, its content, format and mode of transmission, as well as the contributors to, and direction of, communications. Recommendations are made for improving communications across the interface, as well as for further research.
References
- Adams D.C.R., Poskitt K.R. & Bristol J.B. (1993) Surgical discharge summaries: improving the record. Annals of the Royal College of Surgeons of England 75, 96–99.
- Anderson M.A. & Helms L. (1993) An assessment of discharge planning models: communication in referrals for home care. Orthopaedic Nursing 12 (4), 41–49.
- Anderson M.A. & Helms L. (1994) Quality improvement in discharge planning: an evaluation of factors in communication between health care providers. Journal of Nursing Care Quality 8 (2), 62–72.
- Anderson M.A. & Helms L. (1995) Communication between continuing care organizations. Research in Nursing and Health 18, 49–57.
- Armitage S. (1990) Liaison and Continuity of Nursing Care: Executive Summary. Welsh Office, Cardiff .
- Bado W. & Williams C.J. (1984) Usefulness of letters from hospitals to general practitioners. British Medical Journal 288, 1813–1814.
- Barnett D. (1985) The information exchange. Nursing Times 81 (9), 27–29.
- Boyle C.M., Young R.E. & Stevenson J.G. (1974) General Practitioners' opinions of a new hospital-discharge letter. (Letter) The Lancet, 2 (878), 466–467.
- Brazy J.E., Langkamp D.L., Brazy N.D. & De Luna R.F. (1993) Do primary care physicians prefer dictated or computer-generated discharge summaries American Journal of Diseases of Children 147, 986–988.
- Castleden W.M., Stacey M.C., Norman P.E., Lawrence-Brown M.M.D. & Brooks J.G. (1992) General practitioners' attitudes to computer-generated surgical discharge letters. The Medical Journal of Australia 157, 380–382.
- Cole D.R., Johnson M.S., Heaton C.J. & Petti M. (1994) Fax/modem board communications decrease preceptor communication costs. Family Medicine 26 (7), 418–420.
- Colledge N.R., Smith R.G. & Lewis S.J. (1992) The delivery of interim discharge summaries to general practitioners by the elderly. Health Bulletin 50 (3), 219–222.
- Curran P., Gilmore D.H. & Beringer T.R.O. (1992) Communication of discharge information for elderly patients in hospital. The Ulster Medical Journal 61 (1), 56–58.
- Davies M. & Connolly J. (1995) The social worker's role in the hospital: seen through the eyes of other healthcare professionals. Health and Social Care in the Community 3 (5), 301–309.
- Department of Health (1989) Discharge of Patients from Hospital (and accompanying booklet). DH Circular HC (89)5. HMSO, London .
- Department of Health (1994) R&D Priorities in Relation to the Interface Between Primary and Secondary Care. Report to the NHS Central Research and Development Committee. HMSO, London .
- Dickersin K., Scherer R. & Lefebvre C. (1995) Identifying relevant studies for systematic reviews. Chapter 3 In I. Chalmers & D. G. Altman (Eds) Systematic Reviews. BMJ Publishing Group, London .
- Dover S.B. & Low-Beer T.S. (1984) The initial hospital discharge note: send out with the patient or post Health Trends 16, 48.
- Dunn D.C. & Dale R.F. (1986) Combined computer generated discharge documents and surgical audit. British Medical Journal 292, 816–818.
- Fair J.F. (1989) Hospital discharge and death communications. British Journal of Hospital Medicine 42, 59–61.
- Gooder P. & Charny M. (1992) Consultants' views of a district's services. Journal of Public Health Medicine. 14 (4), 393–398.
- Harding J. (1987) Study of discharge communications from hospital doctors to an inner London practice. Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners 37, 494–495.
- Holyoake T.I. & D'A Semple P. (1990) Comparison of acceptability by General Practitioners of word processor and conventional discharge letters. Health Bulletin 48 (1) 29–35.
- Howard D.J. (1986) Structured discharge letter in a department of geriatric medicine. Health Trends 18, 12–13.
- Jackson M.F. (1994) Discharge planning: issues and challenges for gerontological nursing. A critique of the literature. Journal of Advanced Nursing 19, 492–502.
- Kendrick A.R. & Hindmarsh D.J. (1989) Which type of hospital discharge report reaches general practitioners most quickly British Medical Journal 298, 362–363.
- King M.H. & Barber S.G. (1991) Towards better discharge summaries: brevity and structure. West of England Medical Journal, 106 (ii) 40–41, 55.
- Lenhard R.E., Buchman J.P., Achuff S.C., Kahane S.N. & Macmanus C.J. (1991) AUTRES—The Johns Hopkins Hospital Automated Resume. Journal of Medical Systems 15 (3), 237–247.
- Lewis P.V. (1987) Organizational communication: the essence of effective management In M.A. Anderson & L. Helms (Eds) 3rd edn Communication Between Continuing Care Organizations. Research in Nursing and Health 18, 49–57. Grid Publishing, Columbus , OH .
- Llewelyn D.E.H., Ewins D.L., Horn J., Evans T.G.R. & McGregor A.M. (1988) Computerised updating of clinical summaries: new opportunities for clinical practice and research British Medical Journal 297, 1504–1506.
- Long A. & Atkins J.B. (1974) Communications between general practitioners and consultants. British Medical Journal 4, 456–459.
- Macey A., Murphy J.S.G. & Mollan R.A.B. (1989) How to dictate a discharge summary. British Medical Journal 298, 1646.
- Macmillan M.S., Tierney A.J., Atkinson F.I., King C. & Worth A. (1993) A national survey of general practitioners' experience and views relating to discharge of elderly people following acute hospital care. (3rd supplementary report to the report on ‘Discharge of Patients from Hospital’). Nursing Research Unit, Department of Nursing Studies, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh.
- Mageean R.G. (1986) Study of ‘discharge communications’ from hospital. British Medical Journal 293, 1283–1284.
- McCormick I.R. & Boyd M.A. (1994) Primary and secondary care integration. New Zealand Medical Journal 107, 425–427.
- Meara J.R., Wood, J.L. Wilson M.A. & Hart M.C. (1992) Home from hospital: a survey of hospital discharge arrangements in Northamptonshire. Journal of Public Health Medicine, 14 (2) 145–150.
- Nangle B. & Keane M.T. (1994) Effective retrieval in hospital information systems: the use of context in answering queries to patient discharge summaries. Artificial Intelligence in Medicine 6, 207–227.
- Naylor M., Brooten D., Jones R., Lavizzo-Mourey R., Mezey M. & Pauly M. (1994) Comprehensive discharge planning for the hospitalized elderly. A randomized clinical trial. Annals of Internal Medicine 120 (12), 999–1006.
- Oetgen W.J., Steinweg D.L. & Kimball D.B. (1982) The hospital discharge summary: a new format. Military Medicine 147, 1054–1055.
- Parnell J. (1982) Occasional Paper. Continuity and communication-1. Nursing Times 78 (9), 33–36.
- Penney T.M. (1988) Delayed communication between hospitals and general practitioners. British Medical Journal 297, 28–29.
- Pheby D.F.H. & Thorne P. (1994) The Medical Data Index (MDI) dependency module: a shared database to assist discharge planning and audit. Journal of Advanced Nursing 20, 361–367.
- Prophet C.M. (1993) Patient discharge referral: interdisciplinary collaboration. Proceedings of the Annual Symposium on Computer Applications in Medical Care, 332–336.
- Sandler D.A., Heaton C., Garner S.T. & Mitchell J.R.A. (1989) Patients' and general practitioners' satisfaction with information given on discharge from hospital: audit of a new information card. British Medical Journal 299, 1511–1513.
- Sandler D.A. & Mitchell J.R.A. (1987) Interim discharge summaries: how are they best delivered to general practitioners British Medical Journal 295, 1523–1525.
- Siders A.M. & Peterson M. (1992) Inceasing patient satisfaction and nursing productivity through implementation of an automated discharge summary. Proceedings of the Annual Symposium of Computer Applications in Medical Care, 136–140.
- Sollitt L. (1992) Preventing problems after hospital discharge. Primary Health Care 2 (10), 6–8.
- Temple J. (1988) General practice follow-up of patients discharged from hospital. The Practitioner 232, 148–151.
- A. J. Tierney (Ed.) (1993) Discharge of patients from hospital: report of a survey of current practice in acute hospital wards in Scotland and concurrent national surveys of the experiences and views of community nursing staff and general practitioners. Nursing Research Unit, Department of Nursing studies, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh .
- Tierney A.J., Macmillan M.S., Worth A. & King C. (1994) Discharge of patients from hospital—current practice and perceptions of hospital and community staff in Scotland. Health Bulletin, 52 (6) 479–491.
- Tulloch A.J., Fowler G.H., McMullan J.J. & Spence J. (1975) Hospital discharge reports: content and design. British Medical Journal 4, 443–446.
- Waters K.R. (1987) Discharge planning: an exploratory study of the process of discharge planning on geriatric wards. Journal of Advanced Nursing 12, 71–83.
- Wertheimer D.S. & Kleinman L.S. (1990) A model for interdisciplinary discharge planning in a university hospital. The Gerontologist 30 (6), 837–840.
- Williams E.I. & Fitton F. (1990) General practitioner response to elderly patients discharged from hospital. British Medical Journal 300, 159–161.
- Williams J.G., Roberts R. & Rigby M.J. (1993) Integrated patient records: another move towards quality for patients Quality in Health Care 2, 73–74.
- Willmott M. (1995) Nursing and therapy audit: survey of projects. CASPE Research Newsletter Summer, 2.
- Worth A., Tierney A.J., Macmillan M.S., King C. & Atkinson F.I. (1993) A national survey of community nursing staffs experience and views relating to discharge of elderly people following acute hospital care. (2nd Supplementary Report to the Report on ‘Discharge of Patients from Hospital’.), Nursing Research Unit, Department of Nursing Studies, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh.