URBAN AGRICULTURE IN NEO-AUSTERITY TIMES: Reflections on a Contested Policy Domain
Abstract
Urban agriculture (UA) initiatives have become a key area of research, policymaking and activism in reaction to the dominance of global for-profit supply chains that have introduced significant food-related vulnerabilities in urban areas. However, empirical evidence shows that UA initiatives encounter powerful implementation barriers imposed by the neoliberal powers that have established such supply chains. This article proposes that ‘neo-austerity urbanism’ has become a relevant political strategy that supports such barriers. It considers the case of Lisbon and is informed by an interview-based inquiry aimed at identifying the implementation barriers blocking the development of transformative UA initiatives in this city while making such initiatives an integral part of neo-austerity urbanism. Three types of barriers were identified: those derived from the envisioned urban realm; the governance system in place; and the urban agriculture model envisioned. Together, these barriers form an effective mechanism to suppress urban agriculture as an activity with transformative potential in social, environmental and economic terms.
References
- AEMET (2022) Datos climatológicos [Climatological data] [WWW document]. URL www.aemet.es/es/serviciosclimaticos/datosclimatologicos (accessed 22 July 2022).
- Alkon, A. and T. Mares (2012) Food sovereignty in US food movements: radical visions and neoliberal constraints. Agriculture and Human Values 29, 347–59.
- Alonso-Fradejas, A., S.M. Borras Jr, T. Holmes, E. Holt-Giménez and M. Robbins (2015) Food sovereignty: convergence and contradictions, conditions and challenges. Third World Quarterly 36.3, 431–48.
- Amirzadeh, M., S. Sobhaninia, S. Buckman and A. Sharifi (2023) Towards building resilient cities to pandemics: a review of Covid-19 literature. Sustainable Cities and Society, 89.104326, 1–12.
- Armanda, D., J. Guinée and A. Tukker (2019) The second green revolution: innovative urban agriculture's contribution to food security and sustainability—a review. Food Security 22, 13–24.
10.1016/j.gfs.2019.08.002 Google Scholar
- Artmann, M. and K. Sartison(2018) The role of urban agriculture as a nature-based solution: a review for developing a systemic assessment framework. Sustainability 10.6, 1937.
- Ascensão, E. and F. Glinn (2021) Urban gardening and post-austerity in Lisbon. In R. Calvário, M. Kaika and G. Velegrakis (eds.), The political ecology of austerity, Routledge, London.
10.4324/9781003036265-14 Google Scholar
- Banerjee, C. and L. Adenaeuer (2014) Up, up and away! The economics of vertical farming. Journal of Agricultural Studies 2.1, 40–60.
10.5296/jas.v2i1.4526 Google Scholar
- Battersby, J. and V. Watson (2019) The planned ‘city-region’ in the new urban agenda: an appropriate framing for urban food security? Town Planning Review 90.5, 497–518.
10.3828/tpr.2019.32 Google Scholar
- Benke, K. and B. Tomkins (2017) Future food-production systems: vertical farming and controlled-environment agriculture. Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy 13.1, 13–26.
10.1080/15487733.2017.1394054 Google Scholar
- Block, D., N. Chávez, E. Allen and D. Ramirez (2012) Food sovereignty, urban food access, and food activism: contemplating the connections through examples from Chicago. Agriculture and Human Values 29, 203–15.
- Blyth, M. (2013) Austerity: the history of a dangerous idea. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
- Born, B. and M. Purcell (2006) Avoiding the local trap: scale and food systems in planning research. Journal of Planning Education and Research 26.2, 195–207.
- Brenner, N. and N. Theodore (2002) Cities and the geographies of ‘actually existing neoliberalism‘. Antipode 34.3, 349–79.
- Camargo, J. and P. Castro (2018) Portugal em chamas: como resgatar as florestas [Portugal in flames: how to rescue the forests]. Bertrand, Lisbon.
- Carvalho, L., P. Chamusca, J. Fernandes and J. Pinto (2019) Gentrification in Porto: floating city users and internationally-driven urban change. Urban Geography 40.4, 565–72.
- Clapp, J. and W. Moseley (2020) This food crisis is different: Covid-19 and the fragility of the neoliberal food security order. The Journal of Peasant Studies 47.7, 1393–417.
- Cleveland, D., N. Phares, K. Nightingale, R. Weatherby, W. Radis, J. Ballard, M. Campagna, D. Kurtza, K. Livingston, G. Riechers and K. Wilkins (2017) The potential for urban household vegetable gardens to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Landscape and Urban Planning 157, 365–74.
- Coelho, C., F. Veiga and L. Veiga (2006) Political business cycles in local employment: evidence from Portugal. Economic Letters 93.1, 82–87.
- Colson-Fearon, B. and H. Versey (2022) Urban agriculture as a means to food sovereignty? A case study of Baltimore city residents. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 19.19, 12752.
- Correia, A., L. P. Carvalho, M. Campos, R. Salcedas, M. Albuquerque and S. Alves (2022) Residentes de Mariupol chegam a Zaporijia [Residents of Mariupol arrive in Zaporizhzhia] Jornal de Notícias [WWW document]. URL www.jn.pt/mundo/ao-minuto/corredor-humanitario-em-mariupol-e-falta-de-cereais-pode-afetar-o-mundo-14732915.html (accessed 13 May 2022).
- Delgado, C. (2017) Mapping urban agriculture in Portugal: lessons from practice and their relevance for European post-crisis contexts. Moravian Geographical reports 25.3, 13953.
- Delgado, C. (2018) Contrasting practices and perceptions of urban agriculture in Portugal. International Journal of Urban Sustainable Development 10.2, 170–85.
10.1080/19463138.2018.1481069 Google Scholar
- Delgado, C. (2020) Local food policies—their constraints and drivers: insights from Portuguese urban agriculture initiatives. Morovian Geographical Reports 28.3, 223–235.
- Delgado, C. (2023a) Falta capacidade de governança nos sistemas alimentares: lições a partir das iniciativas portuguesas [Governance capacity is lacking in food systems: lessons from Portuguese initiatives]. RIVAR 10.28, 195–214.
- Delgado, C. (2023b) The role of land as the central piece to sustainable food systems: lessons learned from Portugal national food-related policies. Geography and Sustainability 4.1, 84–90.
- Duncan, D., A. Collins, N. Fuhrman, D. Knauff and D. Berle (2016) The Impacts of a school garden program on urban middle school youth. Journal of Agricultural Education 57.4, 174–85.
10.5032/jae.2016.04174 Google Scholar
- E.C. (2017) Social innovation as a trigger for transformations—the role of research. Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg.
- E.C. (2018a) European Commission policy: Open disruptive innovation: European Commission: Start-ups and innovation (unit F.3), Brussels [WWW document]. URL https://research-and-innovation.ec.europa.eu/strategy/support-policy-making/shaping-eu-research-and-innovation-policy/new-european-innovation-agenda_en (accessed 20 March 2023).
- E.C. (2018b) Mission-oriented research and Innovation in the European Union: a problem-solving approach to fuel innovation-led growth. European Commission, Brussels [WWW Document]. URL https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/5b2811d1-16be-11e8-9253-01aa75ed71a1/language-en (accessed 20 March 2023)
- E.C. (2019a) Ensuring EU legislation supports innovation [WWW document]. URL https://research-and-innovation.ec.europa.eu/law-and-regulations/ensuring-eu-legislation-supports-innovation_en (accessed 20 March 2023).
- E.C. (2019b) T he innovation principle, European Commission, Brussels [WWW document]. URL https://research-and-innovation.ec.europa.eu/law-and-regulations/ensuring-eu-legislation-supports-innovation_en (accessed 20 March 2023).
- Ferreira, A. (2020a) O crescimento da mobilidade e turismo em Portugal: solução ou problema? O caso do novo aeroporto de Lisboa [Mobility and tourism growth in Portugal: solution or problem? The case of the new Lisbon airport]. Finisterra 55.113, 195–210.
- Ferreira, A. (2020b) Reconsidering the merit of market-oriented planning innovations: critical insights on transferable development rights from Coimbra, Portugal. Land Use Policy 99, 104977.
- Ferreira, A., R. Guilherme, C. Ferreira and M. Oliveira (2018) Urban agriculture, a tool towards more resilient urban communities? Environmental Science & Health 5, 93–97.
- Ferreira, A., J. Igreja and A. Miranda (2020a) Collaborative governance in Portugal? A critical perspective based on an empirical survey. Revista Portuguesa de Estudos Regionais 55, 109–27.
- Ferreira, A., J. Ribeiro-Santos and I. Breda-Vázquez (2020b) Transcending dilemmas in urban policy-making: envisioning versus adapting, growing versus stabilizing. Planning Theory and Practice 21.1, 76–93.
- Ferreira, A., K. von Schönfeld, F. Augis and P. Conceição (2024) Shrinking cities for economic growth? Insights from the housing sector. Urban Planning 9.2, 1–17.
- FFS (2007) Declaration of Nyéléni, Sélingué, Mali. Forum for Food Sovereignty [WWW document]. URL https://nyeleni.org/en/declaration-of-nyeleni/ (accessed 18 March 2023).
- Fougère, M., B. Segercrantz and H. Seeck (2017) A critical reading of the European Union's social innovation policy discourse: (re)legitimizing neoliberalism. Organization 24.6, 819–43.
- France, M. (2021) Fiche climatologique. Statistiques 1991-2020 et records [Climatological record. Statistics 1991-2020 and Records] [WWW document]. URL https://meteofrance.fr/actualite/publications/les-publications-de-meteo-france (accessed 22 July 2022).
- Garnett, K., G. van Calster and L. Reins (2018) Towards an innovation principle: an industry trump or shortening the odds on environmental protection? Law, Innovation and Technology 10.1, 1–14.
10.1080/17579961.2018.1455023 Google Scholar
- GNAFC (2022) Global report on food crises 2022—joint analysis for better decisions. Global Network against Food Crises and Food Security Information Network [WWW Document] URL https://www.fsinplatform.org/report/global-report-food-crises-2024/ (accessed 20 March 2023)
- Golden, S. (2013) Urban agriculture impacts: social, health, and economic: a literature review. University of California, Davis, CA.
- Gomiero, T. (2018) Agriculture and degrowth: state of the art and assessment of organic and biotech-based agriculture from a degrowth perspective. Journal of Cleaner Production 197.2, 1823–39.
10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.03.237 Google Scholar
- GRP (2020) Estratégia para a inovação e modernização do estado e da administração pública [Strategy for the innovation and modernisation of the state and public administration]. Official Gazette 1st series, No. 148: Government of the Portuguese Republic [WWW Document]. URL https://www.portugal.gov.pt/download-ficheiros/ficheiro.aspx?v=%3d%3dBQAAAB%2bLCAAAAAAABAAzNDCyNAcAwYeeOwUAAAA%3d (accessed 20 March 2023)
- HLPE (2017) Nutrition and food systems. A report by the high level panel of experts on food security and nutrition of the committee on world food security. High Level Panel of Experts on Food Security and Nutrition of the Committee on World Food Security, Rome [WWW Document]. URL https://openknowledge.fao.org/bitstreams/4ac1286e-eef3-4f1d-b5bd-d92f5d1ce738/download (accessed 20 March 2023)
- Holt-Giménez, E. and A. Shattuck (2011) Food crises, food regimes and food movements: rumblings of reform or tides of transformation? Journal of Peasant Studies 38.1, 109–44.
- Hume, I., D. Summers and T. Cavagnaro (2021) Self-sufficiency through urban agriculture: nice idea or plausible reality? Sustainable Cities and Society 68, 102770.
10.1016/j.scs.2021.102770 Google Scholar
- IPMA (2021) Climatologic averages for the municipality of Lisbon 1981–2010. Instituto Português do Mar e da Atmosfera [WWW document]. URL www.ipma.pt/opencms/bin/file.data/climate-normal/cn_81-10_LISBOA_GEOFISICO.pdf (accessed 13 Feb 2022).
- Jessop, B. (2016) The heartlands of neoliberalism and the rise of the austerity state. In S. Springer, K. Birch and J. Macleavy (eds.), Handbook of neoliberalism, Routledge, London.
- Langemeyer, J., C. Madrid-Lopez, A. Beltran and G.Mendez (2021). Urban agriculture—a necessary pathway towards urban resilience and global sustainability? Landscape and Urban Planning 210.104055, 1–8.
- Larsen, K. and J. Gilliland (2008) Mapping the evolution of ‘food deserts’ in a Canadian city: supermarket accessibility in London, Ontario, 1961-2005. International Journal of Health Geographics 7, 1–16.
- Loker, A. and C. Francis (2020) Urban food sovereignty: urgent need for agroecology and systems thinking in a post-Covid-19 future. Agroecology and Sustainable Food System, 44.9, 1118–123.
- Lovell, S. (2010) Multifunctional urban agriculture for sustainable land use planning in the United States. Sustainability 2.8, 2499–522.
10.3390/su2082499 Google Scholar
- Marat-Mendes, T., J. Borges, A. Mélice-Dias and R. Lopes (2021) Planning for a sustainable food system. The potential role of urban agriculture in Lisbon metropolitan area. Journal of Urbanism 14.3, 356–86.
- Marat-Mendes, T., S. Lopes, J. Borges and P. D'Almeida (2022) Atlas of the food system: challenges for a sustainable transition of the Lisbon region. Springer, Cham.
10.1007/978-3-030-94833-7 Google Scholar
- Martins, C. (2020) Covid-19. Pandemia leva fome e desespero às ruas de Lisboa [Covid-19. Pandemic brings hunger and despair to the streets of Lisbon]. Expresso [WWW document]. URL https://expresso.pt/sociedade/coronavirus/2020-03-20-Covid-19.-Pandemia-leva-fome-e-desespero-as-ruas-de-Lisboa (accessed 15 Feb 2022).
- Mcclintock, N. (2014) Radical, reformist, and garden-variety neoliberal: coming to terms with urban agriculture's contradictions. Local Environment: The International Journal of Justice and Sustainability 19.2, 147–71.
10.1080/13549839.2012.752797 Google Scholar
- Mcclintock, N., H. Wooten and A. Brown (2018) Toward a food policy ‘first step’ in Oakland, California: a food policy council's efforts to promote urban agriculture zoning. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 2.4, 15–42.
- Mendes, L. (2018) Tourism gentrification in Lisbon: the panacea of touristification as a scenario of post-capitalist crisis. In I. David (ed.), Crisis, austerity, and transformation: how disciplinary neoliberalism is changing Portugal, Lexington Books, London.
10.5040/9781666993158.ch-002 Google Scholar
- Militare, A. (2021) Climatologia [Climatology] [WWW document]. URL http://clima.meteoam.it/ (accessed 22 July 2022).
- Moragues-Faus, A. and J. Battersby (2021) Urban food policies for a sustainable and just future: concepts and tools for a renewed agenda. Food Policy 103, 102124.
- Moragues-Faus, A. and T. Marsden (2017) The political ecology of food: carving 'spaces of possibility' in a new research agenda. Journal of Rural Studies 55, 275–88.
- Moragues-Faus, A., R. Sonnino and T. Marsden (2017) Exploring European food system vulnerabilities: towards integrated food security governance. Environmental Science & Policy 75, 184–215.
- Moragues-Faus, A. and K. Morgan (2015) Reframing the foodscape: the emergent world of urban food policy. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 47.7, 1558–573.
- Neves, C. (2022) Aviso da Rússia: ‘só vamos fornecer alimentos e produtos agrícolas aos nossos amigos’ [Warning from Russia: 'we will only supply food and agricultural products to our friends']. RTP Notícias [WWW document]. URL www.rtp.pt/noticias/guerra-na-ucrania/aviso-da-russia-so-vamos-fornecer-alimentos-e-produtos-agricolas-aos-nossos-amigos_n1395550 (accessed 10 April 2022).
- Nicholls, E., A. Ely, L. Birkin, P. Basu and D. Goulson (2020) The contribution of small-scale food production in urban areas to the sustainable development goals: a review and case study. Sustainability Science 15.6, 1585–599.
- OECD (2020) Food supply chains and Covid-19: impacts and policy lessons. OECD Publishing, Paris.
- Oliveira, L. (2018) A gestão das terras florestais [Forest land management]. Amigos do Museu Nacional Soares dos Reis, Porto.
- Paddeu, F. (2017) Legalising urban agriculture in Detroit: a contested way of planning for decline. Town Planning Review 88.1, 109–29.
- Patel, R. (2009) Food sovereignty. The Journal of Peasant Studies 36.3, 663–706.
- Pereira, A. (2021) Há listas de espera no programa público de combate à fome [There are waiting lists in the public hunger relief program]. Público [WWW document]. URL www.publico.pt/2021/02/15/sociedade/noticia/ha-listas-espera-programa-publico-combate-fome-1950605 (accessed 3 April 2022).
- Pires, D. (2022) A guerra também se alimenta de cereais [War is also fueled by grains]. TSF [WWW document]. URL www.tsf.pt/mundo/a-guerra-tambem-se-alimenta-de-cereais-14733598.html (accessed 12 July 2023).
- Puma, M., S. Bose, S. Chon and B. Cook (2015) Assessing the evolving fragility of the global food system. Environmental Research Letters 10.2, 1–14.
- Reed, M. and D. Keech (2019) Making the city smart from the grassroots up: the sustainable food networks of Bristol. City, Culture and Society 16, 45–51.
10.1016/j.ccs.2017.07.001 Google Scholar
- Revilla, B. and S. Essbai (2022) Towards a post-growth food system: the community as a cornerstone? Lessons from two Amsterdam community-led food initiatives. In F. Savini, A. Ferreira and K. Schönfeld (eds.), Post-growth planning: cities beyond the market economy, Routldge, New York, NY.
- Robinson, J. (2016) Thinking cities through elsewhere: comparative tactics for a more global urban studies. Progress in Human Geography 40.1, 3–29.
- RUAF (2006) Urban Agriculture Magazine no. 16—Formulating effective policies on urban agriculture. RUAF Foundation [WWW document]. URL https://ruaf.org/document/urban-agriculture-magazine-no-16-formulating-effective-policies-on-urban-agriculture/ (accessed 16 February 2023).
- Salet, W., R. Vermeulen, F. Savini and S. Dembski (2015) Planning for the new European metropolis: functions, politics, and symbols. Planning Theory and Practice, Interface 16.2, 251–75.
- Schilling, J. and J. Logan (2008) Greening the rust belt: a green infrastructure model for right sizing America's shrinking cities. Journal of the American Planning Association 74.4, 451–66.
- Shewfelt, R. (1990) Sources of variation in the nutrient content of agricultural commodities from the farm to the consumer. Journal of Food Quality 13.1, 37–54.
- Siegner, A., J. Sowerwine and C. Acey (2018) Does urban agriculture improve food security? Examining the nexus of food access and distribution of urban produced foods in the United States: a systematic review. Sustainability 10.9, 2988.
- Silva, P. (2017) Political advisers in Portugal: partisanship and loyalty in policy processes. Public Administration 95.2, 378–92.
- Silva, P. and C. Jalali (2016) The many faces of (party) appointments: party government and patronage in Portugal, 1995–2009. Acta Politica 51.4, 539–59.
- Spanier, J. and G. Feola (2022) Nurturing the post-growth city: bringing the rural back in. In F. Savini, A. Ferreira and K. Schönfeld (eds.), Post-growth planning: cities beyond the market economy, Routledge, New York, NY.
10.4324/9781003160984-17 Google Scholar
- Surls, R., G. Feenstra, S. Golden, R. Galt, S. Hardesty, C. Napawan and C. Wilen (2014) Gearing up to support urban farming in California: preliminary results of a needs assessment. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 30.1, 33–42.
10.1017/S1742170514000052 Google Scholar
- Thomas, B. (2010) Food deserts and the sociology of space: distance to food retailers and food insecurity in an urban American neighborhood. International Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences 4.7, 1545–54.
- Tornaghi, C. (2014) Critical geography of urban agriculture. Progress in Human Geography 38.4, 551–67.
- Tornaghi, C. (2017) Urban agriculture in the food-disabling city: (re)defining urban food justice, reimagining a politics of empowerment. Antipode 49.3, 781–801.
- Tulumello, S. (2016) Reconsidering neoliberal urban planning in times of crisis: urban regeneration policy in a ‘dense‘ space in Lisbon. Urban Geography 37.1, 117–40.
- Tulumello, S. (2019) Struggling against entrenched austerity: from the housing crisis toward social movements for housing in post-crisis Lisbon and Portugal. In F. Othengrafen, and K. Serraos (eds.), Urban resilience, changing economy and social trends. Coping with socio-economic consequences of the crisis in Athens, Greece, DruckTeam, Hannover.
- Valley, W. and H. Wittman (2019) Beyond feeding the city: the multifunctionality of urban farming in Vancouver, BC. City, Culture and Society 16, 36–44.
10.1016/j.ccs.2018.03.004 Google Scholar
- Varoufakis, Y. (2018) Austerity. Penguin, London.
- von Schönfeld, K. and A. Ferreira (2021) Urban planning and European innovation policy: achieving sustainability, social inclusion, and economic growth? Sustainability 13.3, 1137.
10.3390/su13031137 Google Scholar
- Wolfram, M. (2016) Conceptualizing urban transformative capacity: a framework for research and policy. Cities, 51, 121–30.
- Wolman, A. (1965) The metabolism of cities. Scientific American 213.3, 179–90.
- Zasada, I., U. Schmutz, D. Wascher, M. Kneafsey, S. Corsi, C. Mazzocchi, F. Monaco, P. Boyce, A. Doernberg, G. Sali and A. Piorr (2019) Food beyond the city—analysing foodsheds and self-sufficiency for different food system scenarios in European metropolitan regions. City, Culture and Society 16, 25–35.
10.1016/j.ccs.2017.06.002 Google Scholar
- Zezza, A. and L. Tasciotti (2010) Urban agriculture, poverty, and food security: empirical evidence from a sample of developing countries. Food policy 35.4, 265–73.