THE DARK SIDE OF PLANETARY URBANIZATION: Operational Landscapes, Crisis and the ‘Peripheral Condition’
I am grateful to Rodrigo Castriota for his close reading and insightful comments on the very first version of this article. I also wish to express my gratitude to the IJURR editors and reviewers for their engagement with the text, which deeply improved it.
Abstract
In this article I present the concept of the ‘peripheral condition’ in the context of theoretical discussion on planetary urbanization. Inspired by Neil Brenner and Christian Schmid's interpretation of urbanization, which draws from Lefebvre's oeuvre, I suggest taking into consideration Robert Kurz's key insights about the internal contradiction of capital. In this study I seek to integrate the ‘critique of value’ theory's crisis-centric approach into the literature on planetary urbanization, as it allows us to move beyond accounts that focus on extensive urbanization through operational landscapes and instead encompass the social relations that accompany it. Consequently, I argue that this comprehension reveals the periphery-form as a relevant idea to qualify discussions on planetary urbanization once an ever-growing population faces situations of precarity that were previously considered restricted to the peripheries. Hence, I suggest that planetary urbanization cannot be fully understood without considering its dark side, the peripheral condition.
References
- Addie, J.-P. (2020) Stuck inside the urban with the dialectical blues again: abstraction and generality in urban theory. USI Publications 45, 1–36.
- Addie, J.-P. (2021) Urban life in the shadows of infrastructural death: from people as infrastructure to dead labour and back again. USI Publications 53, 1–22.
- Arantes, P. (2004) Zero à esquerda [Left zero]. Conrad, São Paulo.
- Arantes, P. (2014) O novo tempo do mundo: e outros estudos sobre a era de emergências [New time of the world: and other studies on the era of emergencies]. Boitempo, São Paulo.
- Arboleda, M. (2015) Spaces of extraction, metropolitan explosions: planetary urbanization and the commodity boom in Latin America. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 40.1, 96–112.
- Arboleda, M. (2020) Planetary mine: territories of extraction under late capitalism. Verso, London.
- Arnold, D. and J. Pickles (2011) Global work, surplus labor and the precarious economies of the border. Antipode 43.5, 1598–624.
- Arzuaga, F. (2019) Socially necessary superfluity: Adorno and Marx on the crisis of labor. Philosophy & Social Criticism 45.7, 819–43.
- Asevedo, M. (2017) Petrobras: notícias sobre uma crise nada particular—a Petrobras e o pré-sal brasileiro no contexto de crise mundial da indústria do petróleo e de financeirização da economia [Petrobras: news about a crisis that is nothing special—Petrobras and Brazilian pre-salt in the context of the global crisis in the oil industry and the financialization of the economy]. Master's thesis, Department of Engineering, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro.
- Askenazy, P. and B. Palier (2018) Rising precariousness supported by the welfare state. Working paper 74. Sciences Po LIEPP, Paris.
- Beck, U. (1999) The brave new world of work. Polity, Cambridge.
- Bernt, M. and H. Liebmann (2013) Peripherisierung, Stigmatisierung, Abhänkigkeit [Peripheralization, stigmatization, dependency]. Springer, Berlin.
10.1007/978-3-531-19130-0 Google Scholar
- Bivar, V. (2018) Organic resistance: the struggle over industrial farming in postwar France. The University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill, NC.
10.5149/northcarolina/9781469641188.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Boechat, C. (2014) O colono que virou suco: terra, trabalho, estado e capital na modernização da citricultura paulista [The settler who became juice: land, work, state and capital in the modernization of São Paulo's citrus industry]. PhD dissertation, Department of Geography, University of São Paulo, São Paulo.
- Brenner, N. (2009) What is critical urban theory? City 3.2/3, 198–207.
10.1080/13604810902996466 Google Scholar
- Brenner, N. (2013) Theses on urbanization. Public Culture 25.1, 85–114.
- Brenner, N. (2014) Introduction. Urban theory without an outside. In N. Brenner (ed.), Implosions/explosions: towards a study of planetary urbanization, Jovis, Berlin.
- Brenner, N. (2016) Critique of urbanization: selected essays. Birkhhäuser/Bauwelt Fundamente Series, Basel and Boston, MA.
10.1515/9783035607956 Google Scholar
- Brenner, N. (2018) Debating planetary urbanization: for an engaged pluralism. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 36.3, 570–90.
- Brenner, N. (2019) New urban spaces: urban theory and the scale question. Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
10.1093/oso/9780190627188.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Brenner, N. and N. Katsikis (2020a) Operational landscape: hinterlands of the capitalocene. In E. Wall (ed.), The landscapists: redefining landscape relations, Wiley, Hoboken, NJ.
10.1002/ad.2521 Google Scholar
- Brenner, N. and N. Katsikis (2020b) Operational landscapes: hinterlands of the Capitalocene. Architectural Design 90.1, 22–31.
- Brenner, N. and C. Schmid (2011) Planetary urbanization. In M. Gandy (ed.), Urban constellations, Jovis, Berlin.
- Brenner, N. and C. Schmid (2014) The ‘urban age’ in question. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 38.3, 731–55.
- Brenner, N. and C. Schmid (2015) Towards a new epistemology of the urban. City 19.2/3, 151–82.
10.1080/13604813.2015.1014712 Google Scholar
- Caldeira, T. (2017) Peripheral urbanization: autoconstruction, transversal logics and politics in cities of the global South. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 35.1, 3–20.
- Canettieri, T. (2020) A condição periférica [The peripheral condition]. Consequência, Rio de Janeiro.
- Canettieri, T. (2021) The cities of the global South as global references of collapse. Revista Virus 23, 1–8.
- Canettieri, T. (2023) Ordem, progresso e catástrofe: sobre a pertinência do ensaio ‘A fratura brasileira do mundo’ de Paulo Eduardo Arantes [Order, progress and catastrophe: on the relevance of the essay ‘The Brazilian fracture of the world’ by Paulo Eduardo Arantes]. Passagens de Paris 22/23, 57–79.
- Castel, R. (1995) Les métamorphoses de la question sociale: une chronique du salariat [The metamorphoses of the social question: a chronicle of wage employment]. Librarie Arthème Fayard, Mesnil-sur-L'Estrée.
10.3406/agora.1995.1517 Google Scholar
- Castel, R. (2003) L'insécurité sociale: qu'est-ce qu’être protégé? [Social insecurity: what does it mean to be protected?]. Seuil, Paris.
- Castriota, R. (2021) Urbanização extensiva na Amazônia oriental: escavando a não-cidade em Carajás [Extensive urbanization in eastern Amazonia: excavating the non-city in Carajás]. PhD dissertation, Faculty of Economic Sciences, Federal University of Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte.
- Comaroff, J. and J. Comaroff (2012) Theory from the South: or, how Euro-America is evolving toward Africa. Anthropological Forum 22.2, 113–31.
- COS (Centre d'Observation de la Société) (2023) La précarité du travail a été multipliée par deux en quarante ans [Job insecurity has doubled over 40 years] [WWW document]. URL https://www.observationsociete.fr/travail/statuts/evolution-precarite/ (accessed 30 April 2024).
- Damon, J. (2017) Un monde de bidonvilles: migrations et urbanisme informel [A world of slums: migration and informal urbanism]. Seuil, Paris.
- Davis, M. (2005) Planet of slums. Verso, New York, NY.
- Denning, M. (2010) Wageless life. New Left Review 66 (November/December), 79–97.
- Faier, L. (2021) Planetary urban involution in the Tokyo suburbs. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 45.4, 630–42.
- Goonewardena, K. (2018) Planetary urbanization and totality. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 36.3, 456–73.
- Graham, S. (2010) Cities under siege: the new military urbanism. Verso, London.
- Guilluy, C. (2014) La France périphérique: comment on a sacrifié les classes populaires [Peripheral France: how the working classes were sacrificed]. Flammarion, Paris.
- Guilluy, C. (2019) Twilight of the elites: prosperity, the periphery and the future of France. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT, and London.
10.2307/j.ctv8jp0fm Google Scholar
- Harvey, D. (1978) The urban process under capitalism: a framework for analysis. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 2.1–3, 101–31.
10.1111/j.1468-2427.1978.tb00738.x Google Scholar
- Harvey, D. (1989) The condition of postmodernity. Blackwell, Oxford.
- Harvey, D. (2001) Spaces of capital: towards a critical geography. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh.
- Harvey, D. (2003) The new imperialism. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
10.1093/oso/9780199264315.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Harvey, D. (2019) Spaces of global capitalism: a theory of uneven geographical development. Verso, London.
10.1515/9781474468954 Google Scholar
- Hélardot, V. (2005) Précarisation du travail et de l'emploi: quelles résonances dans la construction des expériences sociales? [Precarious work and employment: what resonates in the construction of social experiences?] EMPAN 60.4, 30–37.
- Howe, L.B. (2022) Processes of peripheralization: toehold and aspirational urbanization in GCR. Antipode 54.1, 1803–28.
10.1111/anti.12844 Google Scholar
- ILO (International Labour Organization) (2020) Global employment trends 2020. Report. United Nations, Geneva.
- Katsikis, N. (2020) Agglomeration landscapes and operational landscapes: towards a new conceptualization of the planetary urbanization fabric [WWW document]. URL terraurbis.com/?page_id=206 (no longer available online).
- Katz, C. (2021) Splanetary urbanization. Symposium, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 45.4, 597–611.
- Khan, D. and A. Karak (2019) Urban development by dispossession: planetary urbanization and primitive accumulation. Studies in Political Economy 99.3, 307–30.
10.1080/07078552.2018.1536366 Google Scholar
- Kockelkorn, A., C. Schmid, M. Streule and K. Wong (2023) Peripherialization through mass housing urbanization in Hong Kong, Mexico City, and Paris. Planning Perspectives 38.3, 603–41.
10.1080/02665433.2022.2126997 Google Scholar
- Kokoreff, M. and D. Lapeyronnie (2013) Refair la cité: l'avenir des banlieues [Rebuild the city: the future of the suburbs]. Seuil, Paris.
- Koolhaas, R. and E. Cleijne (2001) Lagos: how it works. Lars Müller Publishers, Baden.
- Kowarick, L. (1979) A espoliação urbana [The urban dispossession]. Paz e Terra, Rio de Janeiro.
- Kurz, R. (1986) The crisis of exchange value: science as productive force, productive labor and capitalist reproduction. Mediations: Journal of Marxist Literary Group 27.1/2, npn.
- Kurz, R. (1991) Der Kollaps der Modernisierung [The collapse of modernization]. Reclam, Leipzig.
- Kurz, R. (2012) Geld ohne Wert [Money without value]. Horlemann Verlag, Leipzig.
- le Bourdellès, M. (2022) Peripheralization in the ‘heart’ of cities? A perspective from the French mid-sized cities’ historic neighbourhoods [WWW document]. URL https://hal.science/hal-03690990 (accessed 30 April 2024).
- Lefebvre, H. (1970) La revolution urbaine [The urban revolution]. Gallimard, Paris.
- Lefebvre, H. (1974) La production de l'espace [The production of space]. Anthropos, Paris.
- Maricato, E. (1979) A produção capitalista da casa (e da cidade) no Brasil industrial [The capitalist production of the house (and the city) in industrial Brazil]. Alfa-Omega, São Paulo.
- Marini, R.M. (2005) Dialética da dependência [Dialectics of dependency]. Expressão Popular, São Paulo.
- Marx, K. (1857–1861) Grundrisse: foundations of the critique of political economy [WWW document]. URL https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ (accessed 12 December 2021).
- Marx, K. (1867) Capital: critique of political economy, volume I [WWW document]. URL https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ (accessed 12 December 2021).
- Marx, K. (1894) Capital: critique of political economy, volume III [WWW document]. URL https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1894-c3/ (accessed 26 December 2021).
- Mbembe, A. (2020) Brutalisme [Brutalism]. La Découverte, Paris.
10.3917/dec.mbemb.2020.01 Google Scholar
- Merrifield, A. (2013) The planetary urbanization of non-work. City 17.1, 20–36.
10.1080/13604813.2012.754176 Google Scholar
- Milanez, B. (2017) Boom ou bolha? A influência do mercado financeiro sobre o preço do minério de ferro no período 2000–2016 [Boom or bubble? The influence of the financial market on the price of iron ore in the period 2000–2016]. Versus Jornal 1.2, 1–18.
- Oliveira, F. (1972) Economia brasileira: crítica à razão dualista [The Brazilian economy: a critique of dualistic reason]. Estudos CEBRAP 2, 5–82.
- Oliveira, F. (1981) Anos 70: hostes errantes [The 1970s: wandering hosts]. Novos Estudos CEBRAP 1.1, 25–38.
- Oliveira, F. (2003) Crítica da razão dualista: o ornitorrinco [Critique of dualistic reason: the platypus]. Boitempo, São Paulo.
- Oswin, N. (2018) Planetary urbanization: a view from outside. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 36.3, 540–46.
- Oswin, N. and G. Pratt (2021) Critical urban theory in the urban age: ruptures, tensions and messy solidarities. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 45.4, 585–96.
- Peake, L., D. Patrick, R. Reddy, G. Tanyldiz, S. Ruddick and R. Tchoukaleyska (2018) Placing planetary urbanization in other fields of vision. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 36.3, 374–86.
- Petrillo, A. (2021) La periferia non è più quella di un tempo [The peripheries are not what they used to be]. Bordeaux Edizioni, Rome.
- Pitta, F. (2017) As transformações na reprodução fictícia do capital na agroindústria canavieira paulista: do Proálcool à crise de 2008 [Transformations in the fictitious reproduction of capital in São Paulo's sugarcane agroindustry: from Proálcool to the 2008 crisis]. PhD dissertation, Faculty of Philophy, Languages and Human Sciences, University of São Paulo, São Paulo.
- Pitta, F. (2020) O crescimento e a crise da economia brasileira no século XXI como crise da sociedade do trabalho: bolha das commodities, capital fictício e crítica do valor-dissociação [The growth and crisis of the Brazilian economy in the twenty-first century as a crisis of the labour society: commodity bubble, fictitious capital and the critique of value-dissociation]. Sinal de Menos 14.1, 138–145.
- Pitta, F., C. Boechat and M. Mendonça (2017) A produção do espaço na região do MATOPIBA: violência transnacionais, imobiliárias agrícolas e capital fictício [The production of space in the MATOPIBA region: transnational violence, agricultural real estate and fictitious capital]. Revista de Estudos Internacionais 5.2, 155–79.
10.5752/P.2317-773X.2017v5n2p155 Google Scholar
- Postone, M. (1993) Time, labor and social domination: a reinterpretation of Marx's critical theory. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
- Randolph, G. and M. Storper (2022) Is urbanization in the global South fundamentally different? Comparative global urban analysis for the 21st century. Urban Studies 60.1, 1–28.
- Rannila, P. (2021) Housing violence in the post-welfare context. Housing, Theory and Society 38.3, 2–17.
- Rolnik, R. (2019) Urban warfare: housing and cities in an age of finance. Verso, London.
- Roy, A. (2005) Urban informality: towards an epistemology of planning. Journal of the American Planning Association 71.2, 147–58.
- Roy, A. (2016) What is urban about critical urban theory? Urban Geography 37.6, 810–23.
- Schmid, C. (2018) Journeys through planetary urbanization: decentering perspectives on the urban. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 36.3, 591–610.
- Secchi, B. (2013) La città dei ricchi e la città dei poveri [The city of the rich and the city of the poor]. Laterza, Bari.
- Sevilla-Buitrago, A. (2014) Urbs in rure: historical enclosure and the extended urbanization of the countryside. In N. Brenner (ed.), Implosions/explosions: towards a study of planetary urbanization, Jovis, Berlin.
- Silva, A. (2013) Imigrantes afro-islâmicos na indústria avícola brasileira [Afro-Islamic immigrants in the Brazilian poultry industry]. PhD dissertation, Department of Geography, University of São Paulo, São Paulo.
10.11606/D.8.2013.tde-08112013-100320 Google Scholar
- Simone, A. (2017) The urban majority and provisional recompositions in Yangon. Antipode 50.1, 23–40.
10.1111/anti.12344 Google Scholar
- Standing, G. (2011) The precariat: the new dangerous class. Bloomsbury, Oxford.
10.5040/9781849664554 Google Scholar
- Strauss, K. (2017) Labour geography 1: towards a geography of precarity. Progress in Human Geography 42.4, 622–30.
- Streule, M., O. Karaman, L. Sawyer and C. Schmid (2020) Popular urbanization: conceptualizing urbanization processes beyond informality. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 44.2, 652–72.
10.1111/1468-2427.12872 Google Scholar
- Svampa, M. (2019) Neo-extractivism in Latin America. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
10.1017/9781108752589 Google Scholar
- Truong, F. (2022) Banlieues [Peripheries]. In D. Fassin (ed.), La société qui vient [The society to come]. Seuil, Paris.
- Tupinambá, G. (2017) The unemployable and the generic: rethinking the commons in the communist hypothesis. Palgrave Communications 3, 158–73.
10.1057/palcomms.2017.73 Google Scholar
- Vegliò, S. (2021) Postcolonizing planetary urbanization: Aníbal Quijano and an alternative genealogy of the urban. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 45.4, 663–78.
- Waite, L. (2009) A place and space for critical geography of precarity? Geography Compass 3.1, 412–33.
10.1111/j.1749-8198.2008.00184.x Google Scholar
- Wallerstein, I. (2004) World-system analysis: an introduction. Duke University Press, Durham, NC, and London.