The effects of aftercare on chronic patients and frail elderly patients when discharged from hospital: a systematic review
Gerrie J.J.W. Bours MNS RN
Department of Nursing Science, Universiteit Maastricht,
Search for more papers by this authorCarla M.A. Frederiks PhD RN
Department of General Practice and Social Medicine, Katholieke Universiteit, Nijmegen,
Search for more papers by this authorHuda Huyer Abu-Saad PhD RN
Department of Nursing Science, Universiteit Maastricht,
Search for more papers by this authorEmiel F.M. Wouters PhD MD
Department of Pulmonology, Universiteit Maastrich, Maastricht, The Netherlands
Search for more papers by this authorGerrie J.J.W. Bours MNS RN
Department of Nursing Science, Universiteit Maastricht,
Search for more papers by this authorCarla M.A. Frederiks PhD RN
Department of General Practice and Social Medicine, Katholieke Universiteit, Nijmegen,
Search for more papers by this authorHuda Huyer Abu-Saad PhD RN
Department of Nursing Science, Universiteit Maastricht,
Search for more papers by this authorEmiel F.M. Wouters PhD MD
Department of Pulmonology, Universiteit Maastrich, Maastricht, The Netherlands
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
The purpose of this systematic review was an assessment of the efficacy of aftercare in chronic patients and the frail elderly when discharged from hospital, as regards quality of life, compliance, costs, medical consumption and quality of care. In pursuit of this goal, 17 publications on the effects of aftercare after discharge from hospital were examined. A systematic assessment of methodological quality by two blinded independent reviewers resulted in a consensus score (0–100 points), based on four categories: the study population, description of the interventions, measurement of the outcome and the analysis and presentation of the data. Only three of the 17 studies scored more than 50 points, indicating that most of the studies were of poor methodological quality. The most prevalent methodological problems were that co-interventions were not avoided, a placebo group was lacking, the assessment was not blinded and the analysis was not made on the basis of the intention-to-treat principle. The majority of the studies did not report clear beneficial effects in favour of the intervention group. The positive effects reported were limited to costs and quality of care.
References
- 1 Van Der Windt D.A.W.M., Van Der Heijden G.J.M.G., Scholten R.J.P.M., Koes B.W.,& Bouter L.M. 1995 The efficacy of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs for shoulder complaints. Journal Clinical Epidemiology 48, 691–704
- 2 Bakst J.,& Marra E.F. 1955 Experience with home care for cardiac patients. American Journal of Public Health 45, 444–450
- 3 Barkauskas V.H. 1983 Effectiveness of public health nurse home visits to primiparous mothers and their infants. American Journal of Public Health 73, 573–580
- 4 Bergner M., Hudson L.D., Conrad D.A. 1988 The cost and efficacy of home care for patients with chronic lung diseases. Medical Care 26, 565–579
- 5 Bouter L.M.,& Van Dongen M.C.J.M. 1995 Epidemiologisch onderzoek.. Opzet en interpretatie. (Epidemiologic Research. Principles and methods.) Bohn Stafleu Van Loghum, Houten/Diegem.
- 6 Brootten D., Kumar S., Brown L.P. 1986 A randomized clinical trial of early hospital discharge and home follow-up of very-low-birth-weight infants. The New England Journal of Medicine 315, 934–939
- 7 Bryant N.H., Candland L.,& Loewenstein R. 1974 Comparison of care and cost outcomes for stroke patients with and without home care. Stroke 5, 54–59
- 8 Challis D., Darton R., Johnson L., Stone M.,& Traske K. 1991 An evaluation of an alternative to long-stay hospital care for the frail elderly patients: II. Costs and effectiveness. Age and Ageing 20, 245–254
- 9 Challis D., Darton R., Johnson L., Stone M.,& Traske K. 1991 An evaluation of an alternative to long-stay hospital care for the frail elderly: I. The model of care. Age and Ageing 20, 236–244
- 10 Chalmers T.C., Smith H., Blackburn B. 1981 A method for assessing the quality of a randomized control trial. Controlled Clinical Trials 2, 31–49
- 11 Cockcroft A., Bagnall P., Heslop A.,& .erson N., Heaton R., Batstone J., Allen J., Spencer P.,& Guz A. 1987 Controlled trial of respiratory health worker visiting patients with chronic respiratory disability. British Medical Journal 294, 225–228
- 12 Dickersin K. 1990 The existence of publication bias and risk factors for its occurrence. Journal of American Medical Association 263, 1385–1389
- 13 Donabedian A.,& Rosenfeld L.S. 1968 Criteria and standards for quality assessment and monitoring. Quaterly Review Bulletin 12, 99–108
- 14 Dranove D. 1985 An empirical study of a a hospital based home care program. Inquiry 22, 59–66
- 15 Eelhart J. 1991 Compliance inpatients with chronic non-specific lung diseases literature review. Department of General practice, University of Leiden, Leiden.
- 16 Feinstein A.R. 1985 Clinical epidemiology: the architecture of clinical research. W.B. Saunders, Philadelphia.
- 17 Gerber K.E.,& Nehemkis A.M. 1986 Compliance: The dilemma of the chronically ill. Springer, New York.
- 18 Gortner S.R., Gillis C.L., Shinn J.A. et al. 1988 Improving recovery following cardiac surgery: a randomized clinical trial. Journal of Advanced Nursing 13, 649–661
- 19 Hammond J. 1979 Home health care cost effectiviness: an overview of the literature. Public Health Report 94, 305–311
- 20 Hansen F.R., Spedtsberg K.,& Schroll M. 1992 Geriatric follow-up by home visits after discharge from hospital: a randomized controlled trial. Age and Ageing 21, 445–450
- 21 Hetherington J., Dickersin K., Chalmers I.,& Meinert C.L. 1989 Retrospective and prospective identification of unpublished controlled trials: lessons from a survey of obstetricians and pediatricians. Pediatrics 84, 374–380
- 22 Johnson N.,& Fethke C. 1985 Postdischarge outcomes and care planning for the hospitalised elderly. In Continuity of Care: Advancing the Concept of Discharge Planning. (McClelland E., Kelly K., Buckwater K. ed.), Grune and Stratton, New York, pp. 229–240
- 23 Jowett S.,& Armitage S. 1988 Hospital and community liaison links in nursing: the role of the liaison nurse. Journal of Advanced Nursing 13, 579–587
- 24 Kleijnen J.,& Knipschild P. 1992 Review articles and publication bias. Arzneimittel-Forschung 42, 587–591
- 25 Koes K.W., Assendelft W.J.J., Van Der Heijden G.J.M.G., Bouter L.M.,& Knipschild P.G. 1991 Spinal manipulation and mobilization for back and neck pain: a blinded review. British Medical Journal 303, 1298–1303
- 26 Koes B.W., Bouter L.M., Beckerman H., Van Der Heijden G.J.M.G.,& Knipschild P.G. 1991 Physiotherapie exercises and back pain: a blinded review. British Medical Journal 302, 1572–1576
- 27 Meinert C.L. 1986 Clinical trials: design, conduct and analysis. Oxford University Press, New York.
- 28 Miller P., Wikoff R., McMahon M., Garrat M.J.,& Ringel K. 1988 Influence of a nursing intervention on regimen adherence and societal adjustments postmyocardial infarction. Nursing Research 37, 297–302
- 29 Mitchell A., Van Berkel C., Adam V. et al. 1993 Comparison of liaison and staff nurses in discharge referrals of postpartum patients for public health nursing follow-up. Nursing Research 42, 245–249
- 30 Mor V.,& Sherwood C.C. 1983 Discharged rehabilitation patient: impact of follow-up surveillance by a friendly visitor. Archives of Physical and Medical Rehabilitation 64, 346–353
- 31 Naylor M.D. 1990 Comprehensive discharge planning for hospitalized elderly: a pilot study. Nursing Research 39, 156–161
- 32 Nielsen M., Blenkner M., Bloom M., Downs T.,& Beggs H. 1972 Older persons after hospitalisation: a controlled study of home aide service. American Journal Primary Health 62, 1094–1101
- 33 Oktay J.S.,& Volland P.J. 1987 Foster home care for the frail elderly as an alternative to nursing home care: an experimental evaluation. American Journal of Public Health 77, 1505–1510
- 34 Oktay J.S.,& Volland P.J. 1990 Post-hospital support program for the frail elderly and their caregivers: a quasi-experimental evaluation. American Journal of Public Health 80, 39–46
- 35 Pozen M.W., Stechmiller J.A., Harris W. et al. 1977 A nurse rehabilitator's impact on patients with myocardial infarction. Medical Care 15, 830–837
- 36 Smith D.M., Weinberger M., Katz B.P.,& Moore P.S. 1988 Postdischarge care. Medical Care 26, 699–708
- 37 Stone J.R., Patterson E.,& Felson L. 1968 The effectiveness of home care for general hospital patients. Journal of American Medical Association 205, 145–148
- 38 Townsend J., Piper M., Frank A.O., Dyer S., Northe W.R.S.,& Meade T.W. 1988 Reduction in hospital readmission stay of elderly patients by community based hospital discharge scheme: a randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal 297, 544–547
- 39 Victor C.R.,& Vetter N.J. 1988 Rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic: failure of an augmented home help scheme after discharge to reduce the length of stay in hospital. Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics 7, 83–91
- 40 Weinberger M., Smith D.M., Katz B.P.,& Moore P.S. 1988 The cost-effectiveness of intensive post-discharge care: a randomized trial. Medical Care 26, 1092–1101
- 41 Weissert W.G., Matthews Cready C.,& Pawelak J.E. 1988 The past and future of home and community-based long term care. The Millbank Quarterly 66, 309–387